A lot of the toy look is the texturing though don't forget.
Well, it's also the shape. The older DReim Z-95 had an organic flow to it which made it look like something you'd see in the Clone Wars while still acting as a bridge to the designs seen in use during the Galactic Civil War.
Also, there's quite a bit of consitent Z-95 stuff out there (as well as a lot of inconsistent stuff). The older model takes the well known and accepted looks while blending in a truly good representation of what I'd like to see the Z-95 looking like. That model does... or at least lays the groundwork for... doing the ship justice.
Now, the new ship is good as always - I've never seen Brand do poor work - but it does look very much like those ships "made to make toys" as seen in the new films. There's just something campy and cartoonish about it...
Indeed. It's not fair to judge either models since neither are finished yet.
Again, I hate to be a pain, but I do get the impression that Brand posts his work here so as to get constructive feedback. I'm citing that I'm not convinced the re-re-design of this fairly well known ship is the best decision and for which reasons I don't quite care for it. Brand's proven me wrong on my initial judgements before, and if he can make a case for this new one, he might do it again. Until then...