Site Management > Site Support / Feedback

Author Topic: important wiki matter: please post thoughts 2

<< < (3/7) > >>

General Battuta:

--- Quote from: TopAce on February 05, 2021, 12:46:01 pm ---Okay, for some reason I remembered as if I had removed the comment before protecting. Seeing the page's history, it's a false memory, apparently. Sorry about that.

Just please tell me this stuff is now over. For real.

--- End quote ---

No, comrade premiere. It has only begun

Mobius:

--- Quote from: General Battuta on February 05, 2021, 12:07:15 pm ---there was a clear consensus

--- End quote ---

Again, nope - many members, including myself, did not agree with it. And my opinion on the matter hasn't changed.

While "most" people who posted on that thread claimed "to be fine" with it, phrases such as "we all agreed" and "there was a clear consensus" do not genuinely describe what happened during the debate.


I can't apply any vetos of course (I'm no FS Wiki authority and I absolutely don't want to be one), but you can't just pretend my voiced opinion doesn't exist. Just my 0.02€.

TopAce:
Okay, phrasing it as "we all agreed" is factually untrue, and "clear consensus" is debatable, too, but there were more who either did not care or approved the comment. I was with you when it came to explaining the reference, and tried to came up with a compromise but it was quickly reverted and the edit war continued.

Clearly there's no solution that would please everyone.

Andreas Rybak:
We could leave it off as pretty much no one cares at this point, and leave the veteran comments for actual comments intended to be made about the performance or characteristics of the Aeolus.

The E:

--- Quote from: Andreas Rybak on February 05, 2021, 04:41:23 pm ---We could leave it off as pretty much no one cares at this point, and leave the veteran comments for actual comments intended to be made about the performance or characteristics of the Aeolus.

--- End quote ---

If "noone cares", which is entirely untrue as there are people who do care and they outnumber the people who don't, then there's nothing wrong with this one line, which is both a funny reference and entirely true to stay in there.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

Go to full version