For what games do you fail to understand why everyone thinks they are great? I'd have to say Age of Empires II (blows starcraft away in terms of micromanagement) and Chrono Trigger.
i dunno, i disagree. don't get me wrong, me and my buddies will still get together every 3 or 4 months to play a game or two of AOE2, but i think they tried to make it too in-depth, too complicated. it took wayyyy too long to learn how to really play it. i mean you're managing lumber, gold, stone, and food. starcraft's just minerals and vespene.
i liked starcraft better
but maybe that's just cause i was better at it