No, you're in the right place, at least generally-speaking. It may have been some time ago; I really haven't been on very frequently for a good 3 or 4 months. Do your logs reach back that far? I do distinctly remember at least some of the stuff still being there the last time I was playing, since I would have been in and out of those chests. I don't mind posting the coords, since my base is on the warp list anyway (though maybe I should reconsider that...), so let's see if I can be more specific:
--Tools chest (3298,1532): At least two enchanted diamond pickaxes, though I know you said you wouldn't bother with enchantments.
--Books chest (3294,1532): Pretty sure I had some enchanted books, but I'm not really concerned about those.
--Buckets & Bowls chest (3287,1532): I know I had several lava/water buckets, obviously not a huge deal. I feel like I may have had a few saddles in the chest below it too.
--Glowstone chest: I know it's not showing up there, but I'm also just about positive that I had a bunch of glowstone dust squared away, if not a stack of glowstone blocks as well.
--Mined ores: (3298,1534): This is the biggie. Probably two full stacks of iron blocks, at least half a stack of gold blocks plus some ingots, and I don't recall exactly how many diamonds, but I think it was at least several blocks and some miscellaneous loose ones.
That's as much as I can remember, anyway. Out of curiosity, is anything like that old private chest plugin we used to have on the old setup still out there today? It'd at least prevent us having to worry about the item-stealing side of things.
(Also I'd like to thank whatever asshole did all this for also removing a few random torches. I got ganked by a creeper in my own basement while I was going through my chests, which meant I had to do a bunch of emergency chest construction and tedious sorting.)