Hard Light Productions Forums

General FreeSpace => FreeSpace Discussion => Topic started by: Androgeos Exeunt on December 22, 2008, 08:37:03 pm

Title: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on December 22, 2008, 08:37:03 pm
Hey, all. Quite recently, there has been a small conflict on FSWiki because it is never explicitly stated in the game that the GTVA Colossus is a juggernaut (http://www.hard-light.net/wiki/index.php/Talk:GTVA_Colossus#Semantics), nor does it really classify as either a superdestroyer (the Colossus is twelve times the size of the Lucifer), or a destroyer (the Colossus has five times the firepower of an Orion). Super capital ship might apply, because the Colossus has the -supercap flag in its ship table (but so does the Sathanas), and Alpha 3 called it a massive warship in The Sixth Wonder (although anything of cruiser size or larger is also called a warship).

So the question is: Given that the GTVA Colossus is never explicitly given a ship type in the game, what do you think it is closest to?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Polpolion on December 22, 2008, 08:40:23 pm
It's definitely not a warship; we know that much.  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on December 22, 2008, 08:41:45 pm
Personally, I regard it as a juggernaut, even though 'GTJ Colossus' sounds weird to me.

However, since there is only one canonically, it is a 'flagship' and yet does not need a class designation, strictly. (Hence, 'GTVA Colossus')
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Darius on December 22, 2008, 08:46:13 pm
It's a colossus.  :nervous:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on December 22, 2008, 08:49:32 pm
Juggernaut.

The Hecate has **** firepower compared to a Ravana and its still a destroyer because of its size and HP.
Therefore...
Even though the Colly has less firepower than the Sath, they have the same HP, and same size therefore same class.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: FUBAR-BDHR on December 22, 2008, 08:53:12 pm
Does it have less firepower or is the firepower just not all forward like the Sath?  Off to look at the tables........
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on December 22, 2008, 09:08:11 pm
SATH
BFRED = 4756 sustained dps x 4
LRED = 1359 sustained dps x 1
TOTAL = 20383

COLLY
BGREEN = 776 sustained dps x 6
TERSLASH = 321 sustained dps x 7
TOTAL = 6903

(this is just pure anti-cap beam, didn't calculate all the puny turrets)

Ok that's quite a big gap, but the colly can ramp up its beams to BFGreen.
Both will do the same thing to destroyers - that is, chew them up beyond measure.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aurora Paradox on December 22, 2008, 09:11:33 pm
I would say super destroyer but that is just my opinion.

Aurora Paradox
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Kie99 on December 22, 2008, 09:20:17 pm
Wiki should just say "none stated", the only mention is the "TSoup" in FRED, and God only knows what that was meant to mean.  Its obviously larger than a destroyer or superdestroyer, and its size is similar to that of a Juggernaut.  Having said that, Juggernaut always struck me as a specific designation of the Sathanas - references to "A Shivan Juggernaut" rather than actually mentioning its actual class, perhaps it was a personal thing.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on December 22, 2008, 09:21:47 pm
Terran Soup
made with headz
?

I recall some of its textures being called TSoupTileXX or something too...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: eliex on December 22, 2008, 09:22:57 pm
I'll say juggernaut class, and in addition to the points that Droid has made, the Colossus has comparable size to the Sathanas too.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: FUBAR-BDHR on December 22, 2008, 09:26:08 pm
Maybe Campbell won the contract to make it. 


Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on December 22, 2008, 09:32:34 pm
It was probably an in-joke or something, I think Soup = Sup.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mongoose on December 23, 2008, 12:22:18 am
Its designation is GTVA...which quite obviously stands for Galactic Terran-Vasudan Awesomesauce.  QED.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on December 23, 2008, 12:25:25 am
It's the Terran/Vasudan Navy's version of 'our reproductive mechanisms are bigger than your reproductive mechanisms'
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Akalabeth Angel on December 23, 2008, 02:28:45 am
It's "the Colossus". It doesn't need a designation.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Reprobator on December 23, 2008, 02:42:18 am
i think it s fit more flagship than else as it's a quite unique ship type in the gtva fleet...
it would have a class when a second ship similar to the colossus would be built.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on December 23, 2008, 07:16:27 am
Looks like "Juggernaut" is winning.

If this is the designation that we'll be using in the Wiki, its non-canonicity should be made explicit in a way.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Stormkeeper on December 23, 2008, 07:18:26 am
Baseball bat. :nervous:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: nvsblmnc on December 23, 2008, 07:28:12 am
I personally agree with the idea that the Colossus is a flagship.

The Sath and the Collie aren't the same type of ship.  The Sath is a straightforward steamroller, and the Juggernaught term fits it well.

The Collie is more of a symbol and seems to me to be very much a one-off.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Rodo on December 23, 2008, 07:28:36 am
Dreadnought maybe?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ShadowGorrath on December 23, 2008, 07:32:34 am
The Colossus is a juggernaut. Class of ships is determined by size and armour. If it was determined by firepower, then the Lilith would be a corvette or destroyer, and the Moloch would be a cruiser. 5-6km long ships are juggernauts just like 1.5-2.5km ships are destroyers, and 3-4.5km ships are superdestroyers. Or something close.

The reason the Colossus was not called as a juggernaut by the GTVA, is because when the Sath arrived, only then the juggernaut classification appeared. Before, the GTVA didn't need a new class, as there was only 1 ship of that size. Only the Colossus.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Kie99 on December 23, 2008, 10:15:48 am
I repeat that if no designation is given in the game, nor can one be inferred from the prefix of the ship then it is merely one's opinion, and non-canonical, so the Wiki should say "none stated" rather than anyone's guess or the result of a poll.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: castor on December 23, 2008, 12:37:54 pm
Quote from: Webster
2: a massive inexorable force, campaign, movement, or object that crushes whatever is in its path
As far as GTVA goes, thats exactly what it is.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: lefkos on December 23, 2008, 01:03:56 pm
Dreadnought maybe?
its to big imo
juggernaught fits the col perfect
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on December 23, 2008, 01:07:45 pm
It's a None specified.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: BS403 on December 23, 2008, 01:59:22 pm
I'm going to have to agree with snail and the others and say none specified.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Vip on December 23, 2008, 02:04:21 pm
I say it's a Destroyer Destroyer - after all, it was meant to kill Destroyers and possibly even Super Destroyers like the Lucifer ;)

But seriously, although it was one-in-a-kind ship meant as a symbol (thus GTVA instead of GTD/GTSD/GTJ/GTC(huck)N(orris)), I'd go for the Juggernaut. It fits nicely there, being nearly as huge as the Sathanas and not being much worse in weaponry.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: jakeslogan on December 29, 2008, 01:22:25 am
Quote
Personally, I regard it as a juggernaut, even though 'GTJ Colossus' sounds weird to me.
lol, the Colossus was made by both Terran and Vasudan, so "IF" they put it juggernaut, they'd have named it GTVJ Colossus(Galactic Terran-Vasudan Juggernaut).
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aardwolf on December 29, 2008, 01:51:52 am
/me votes for "largest spacefaring warship ever constructed"

So the acronym should be GTVLSWEC Colossus.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: jakeslogan on December 29, 2008, 09:47:30 pm
I don't know, but this remind me of TV JVC.  :lol:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Grizzly on December 31, 2008, 12:33:39 pm
The 'A' stands for Amphibious Assault Ship.

On a more serious note, I would just call it a "Battleship (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battleship)" Since that is the official term of a ship more powerfull then a Destroyer.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on December 31, 2008, 12:39:39 pm
A is AWACS. As in...GTA Charybdis.
But that means that the Colly is a big AWACS (which it isn't), and that the Iceni is a massive fighter (lol).
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on December 31, 2008, 12:41:53 pm
The F in Iceni either stands for 'Frigate' or it's the faction name, 'Front'. In the Boadicea's case I'm pretty sure it's the latter.

I'm inclined to believe that the affix 'GTVA' is the faction name, nothing to do with the ship class.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aardwolf on January 02, 2009, 12:34:25 am
/me agrees with Snail.

Also, has anyone ever noticed that the Sathanas has AWACS?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 02, 2009, 02:01:47 am
:eek2:

Really?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on January 02, 2009, 03:07:55 am
I've heard that before, and probably seen it in the tables earlier...

Which makes the stealth fighter in 'Monster in the Mist' ineffective. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 02, 2009, 03:21:48 am
No wonder I was killed once by the Sathanas' SAAA... :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: jakeslogan on January 04, 2009, 09:59:55 pm
In the game, they said that there was nothing in Gama Draconis, but in the Colossus' cutscene, I can still see a planet.  :D
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on January 04, 2009, 10:28:22 pm
Where did it say that that part of the cutscene was in Gamma Draconis? The voiceover was only saying that the Colossus would be used to fight the Shivans in 'the mysterious nebula beyond Gamma Draconis'. It's in a different system when you see it come past the camera.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aardwolf on January 05, 2009, 06:35:54 am
If you set a Sath as friendly, when it takes damage it sends the Terran AWACS damaged and critical messages.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on January 05, 2009, 06:59:15 am
Really? :eek2:

I should try that.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: jakeslogan on January 05, 2009, 07:39:46 am
Quote
Where did it say that that part of the cutscene was in Gamma Draconis? The voiceover was only saying that the Colossus would be used to fight the Shivans in 'the mysterious nebula beyond Gamma Draconis'. It's in a different system when you see it come past the camera.
Well :D, maybe they shouldn't zoom-in Gamma Draconis then show the Colossus after that, it might lead to misunderstanding. :confused:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 05, 2009, 08:44:38 am
If you set a Sath as friendly, when it takes damage it sends the Terran AWACS damaged and critical messages.
Whoah, really?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on January 05, 2009, 08:52:08 am
Juggernaut. Simply because the next size up from Destroyer for the Shivans was a Juggernaut according to the GTVA, since the Sath was referred to as such, so I am assuming they would use the same class references as they use for their own ships, since they do up to that point.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 05, 2009, 08:56:01 am
Hey Flipside has exactly 5000 posts. Funneh.


I agree with Flipside, but some pedantic people always claim that it wasn't ever said that it was a juggernaut, in the same way the Ulysses is never specifically called 'a ship', so really it should be a 'unspecified space-faring combat vehicle'.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on January 05, 2009, 09:09:24 am
Except that ship is a very generic term, and it can be used to refer to any spacefaring... vehicle. Juggernaut and destroyer are one level below in categorization.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 05, 2009, 11:31:57 am
The Colossus didn't have a "pure" designation, it simply was the product of the T-V Alliance's efforts in creating an extremely powerful and big warship.

:v:TM never called it a Juggernaut so I don't understand why we should.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 05, 2009, 11:41:58 am
:v:TM never called it a Juggernaut so I don't understand why we should.
Because it's the logical designation.

But of course, if you're a purist...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 05, 2009, 11:47:04 am
Juggernaut is not a conventional word like destroyer or cruiser. It appears to be a reference to something unconventional and evil so using it to designate good guys' assets would be a bad idea.

Remember the difference between "submarines" and "u-boats"?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: FreeSpaceFreak on January 05, 2009, 01:50:33 pm
U-boats are German, that's all. Today's German Navy submarines are still called "U-boats". Germany also sold some to Israel, and these are just called "submarines".

So yes, you may be right somehow. The Colossus was GTVA, which is why it has the special designation <nothing> (U-boats), as opposed to other ships of that magnitude which are called "juggernauts" (submarines). But that's not what you meant, I know :P
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 05, 2009, 01:59:12 pm
I remember a speech by Winston Churchill in which he said pretty much this: "We, the good guys, use submarines while them, the bad guys, use U-boats...". This happened even if submarines and U-boats were basically the same thing.

In FS2 the Colossus would be a joint endeavor, a massive ship symbolizing the Alliance the good guys use to defeat the bad guys. The Sathanas, however, would be a "Juggernaut", a big evil warship the bad guys(Shivans) use to threaten the good guys.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 05, 2009, 02:01:55 pm
I remember a speech by Winston Churchill in which he said pretty much this: "We, the good guys, use submarines while them, the bad guys, use U-boats...". This happened even if submarines and U-boats were basically the same thing.
Doesn't sound very Churchillian.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 05, 2009, 02:24:28 pm
That's not a quote from him ("pretty much this") but what I posted is the meaning of his speech.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 05, 2009, 09:22:03 pm
And here I sit, wondering why the GTVA thinks "None specified" sounds better than "Juggernaut".
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on January 05, 2009, 09:35:10 pm
I'm wondering why, if the GTVA have used the same class-names for equally sized ships on both sides throughout Freespace 1 & 2, they would suddenly change their mind when it came to the Colossus.

Calling it 'undesignated' would be silly, there's a difference between non-canon and nonsensical.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aardwolf on January 05, 2009, 09:44:20 pm
Juggernaut is a -bad- name. It'd be like naming it the GTSD Manslaughter.

It's not a matter of changing something, it's that they didn't have a classification for the colossus, and didn't encounter the Sath until later.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on January 05, 2009, 09:46:46 pm
Well, you could say the same for the Moloch, the tech description even states that it isn't 'strictly' a Corvette class vessel, but is named that way because it is the closest class to it.

So, if that reasoning can work in one direction, it should be able to work in the other.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 06, 2009, 01:21:37 am
I believe :v: could have called the Moloch a "Light Carrier" or SLCa Moloch, but they wanted to simplify things.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Stormkeeper on January 06, 2009, 02:50:41 am
I still think it should be GTBB; Galactic Terran Baseball Bat.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 06, 2009, 02:58:38 am
I still think it should be GTBB; Galactic Terran Baseball Bat.
Seconded. ;7
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 06, 2009, 03:20:45 am
Juggernaut is a -bad- name. It'd be like naming it the GTSD Manslaughter.

 :lol:


well if we're talking about -bad- names

then i submit

GTSD Assrape

which was SO not significant of my immaturity
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on January 06, 2009, 04:25:14 am
GTVBB, you mean. :lol:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 12:00:46 pm
And here I sit, wondering why the GTVA thinks "None specified" sounds better than "Juggernaut".

The Colossus was THE Colossus. I'm amazed of the fact that so many still don't get it, why would you need a designation such a ship?


Oh, I'd like someone to delete the useless posts above mine.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on January 06, 2009, 01:25:25 pm
The Lucifer was also one in a kind. Yet it received a designation (superdestroyer).
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 06, 2009, 01:28:53 pm
The Sathanas was also (probably) thought to have been one of a kind, yet it was designated as a juggernaut.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on January 06, 2009, 01:36:04 pm
I blame V for that. Obviously by the time they started FREDding, they had already known there would be 80 of them, and assigned a designation to it.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 01:39:34 pm
The Lucifer was also one in a kind. Yet it received a designation (superdestroyer).

The GTA/PVE didn't know it? And it was a fearsome Shivan vessel, not a joint endeavor.

The Sathanas was also (probably) thought to have been one of a kind, yet it was designated as a juggernaut.

But, as you said, it was Shivan...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aardwolf on January 06, 2009, 02:03:44 pm
The Lucifer was also one in a kind. Yet it received a designation (superdestroyer).

No, the Lucifer was just SD Lucifer, not SSD Lucifer.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 02:06:10 pm
Another thing: who said that the Lucifer was one in kind if the Colossus was built with the specific purpose of handling such threat?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 06, 2009, 02:09:06 pm
I'd interpret it so that during the Great War the Lucifer was considered (and hoped) to be unique. Only later did they start to think otherwise and consequently Khonsu II announced his insane plans.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 06, 2009, 02:14:37 pm
Another thing: who said that the Lucifer was one in kind if the Colossus was built with the specific purpose of handling such threat?
If they had such a ship they would be bound to have much worse in store?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 02:21:37 pm
I don't think so.

They knew that there was only one Lucifer in the Shivan fleet attacking them but they couldn't give for sure that there was only one Lucifer in the Shivan fleet: what the Terrans and the Vasudans faced was, in fact, was nothing more than an assault force. It's impossible to judge a Species by seeing a small(because it was VERY small, for Shivan standards) fleet.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on January 06, 2009, 02:32:17 pm
No, the Lucifer was just SD Lucifer, not SSD Lucifer.

Yes, it was SD Lucifer, but it was called a superdestroyer somewhere.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 02:48:01 pm
"S" as "Super" isn't valid in canon prefixes. We have GTSDs and SSDs only in custom made ships.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on January 06, 2009, 03:07:42 pm
The Collosus was it's hull name though, not it's Designation, just as the first Orion Class Destroyer was, in all likelihood, called Orion, only one Orion, but every ship based on that hull was still a Destroyer.

The fact there is only one of them wouldn't change the class of ship, it might make it unique, it might only have to be referred to as 'The Colossus' to be known, but that's like saying the 'Ark Royal' is the 'Ark Royal', not an Aircraft Carrier, or (to use a sci-fi reference) the USS Enterprise is 'The Enterprise' and not a Federation Heavy Cruiser.

To my mind, it is the Colossus, the first Colossus-Class Juggernaut, and, most likely, the last.

Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 03:12:08 pm
The Colossus is unique, it wasn't a one of a kind ship and nothing else. It was a symbol of the Alliance and was hence designated GTVA Colossus. Juggernaut is a name used for massive Shivan ships, only.

Also, we may or may not consider the fact that :v:'s plan might have changed in the past. Maybe, at the beginning, the Colossus and the Sathanas weren't supposed to be two direct adversaries(meaning that each one was the counterpart of the other). Just a thought, anyway.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on January 06, 2009, 03:16:55 pm
Well, in truth, it doesn't say that in the tables or cutscenes any more definitely than it says that the Colossus is a Juggernaut.

We are really both just expressing opinions now, since neither of our views can really be justified by any empirical evidence.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 03:31:03 pm
The "symbol of the Alliance" thing is a logic consequence of thoughts based on canon. The Colossus indeedly was a symbol of the Alliance and the Colossus cutscene doesn't leave any choices in terms of ship designations.

The point is that, in any case, it's not appropriate to consider the Colossus a Juggernaut. In the FreeSpace Demo the term "juggernaut" wasn't used to define a ship class(proof: no capitalization)...it was simply used as a reference to "big stuff" in general.

EDIT: Not voting until I see Snuffleupagus and/or "The Colossus doesn't need a designation". :p
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on January 06, 2009, 03:38:16 pm
So are mine a logical sequence of thoughts based on Canon, that's exactly what I'm saying, they are both acceptable answers, but neither are, from a 'canon' point of speaking 'True', they are both based on our own interpretation of canon, not on canon itself.

I find it perfectly acceptable to consider the Colossus a Juggernaut vessel, even if it is the Colossus, after all, the Sathanas was designated a Juggernaut whilst it was still only the Sathanas, but it really boils down to personal opinion.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 06, 2009, 03:39:22 pm
Open-minded guy at work... :D
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 06, 2009, 03:49:09 pm
Suddenly the word "dreadnought" popped into my mind. If we interpret some dictionary information, a juggernaut is "unstoppable", like the Sathanas seemed to be at first, with its awesome forward beam cannons. But the Colossus could be a dreadnought, as in "One that is the largest or the most powerful of its kind". Sort of. no canon base whatsoever, but sounds distantly appropriate.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Flipside on January 06, 2009, 03:55:48 pm
Open-minded guy at work... :D

:lol: Well, you're just as entitled to your opinion as me, and we both have good reasons for thinking as we do ;)

Suddenly the word "dreadnought" popped into my mind. If we interpret some dictionary information, a juggernaut is "unstoppable", like the Sathanas seemed to be at first, with its awesome forward beam cannons. But the Colossus could be a dreadnought, as in "One that is the largest or the most powerful of its kind". Sort of. no canon base whatsoever, but sounds distantly appropriate.


Actually, to my mind, the Moloch should have been a Dreadnought, since I've always visualized them as being ships designed more for taking punishment than giving it.

Edit: I suppose that comes from a rough interpretation of the word itself - Dreadnaught = Fears Nothing.
Edit 2 : On second thoughts, maybe the Moloch wasn't such a good suggestion, since they tend to fear pretty much anything that can target subsystems...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 06, 2009, 08:51:09 pm
Even then, for a Moloch to be a pure Dreadnought it would need more than what...three SReds?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Rick James on January 07, 2009, 12:49:47 am
Even then, for a Moloch to be a pure Dreadnought it would need more than what...three SReds?

That always confused me. Terran and Vasudan vessels fill the gap between small beams and large ones with "slash" type beams. Why didn't the Shivan's do something similar?--if not a slash beam, then a medium-strength direct-fire beam.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 07, 2009, 01:37:39 am
Well in terms of SRed, LRed, and BFRed, the LRed would be that "medium" strength beam. Some mods add an HRed to the Shivan arsenal, probably as a way to give the LRed more of a use as a standard beam cannon.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: eliex on January 07, 2009, 02:49:20 am
I think the mods added HRed as a super-destroyer class beam, as there's a MRed for corvettes.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 07, 2009, 03:07:47 am
Right, I remember Ghost Revenants adds an MRed.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Grizzly on January 07, 2009, 04:13:25 am
Even then, for a Moloch to be a pure Dreadnought it would need more than what...three SReds?

That always confused me. Terran and Vasudan vessels fill the gap between small beams and large ones with "slash" type beams. Why didn't the Shivan's do something similar?--if not a slash beam, then a medium-strength direct-fire beam.

Because the Shivans are not the GTVA. They do not show any similarities either (oh well, they fly spaceships, but that's really it).
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 07, 2009, 05:17:35 am
Even then, for a Moloch to be a pure Dreadnought it would need more than what...three SReds?

That always confused me. Terran and Vasudan vessels fill the gap between small beams and large ones with "slash" type beams. Why didn't the Shivan's do something similar?--if not a slash beam, then a medium-strength direct-fire beam.

Because the Shivans are not the GTVA. They do not show any similarities either (oh well, they fly spaceships, but that's really it).

GTVA Ships are basically more defence/broadside attack minded, pretty much can take attacks on both sides and will make an attack broadside first rather than using their forward beam cannons (this is especially true with ships such as the Orion, whose port and starboard BGreens will rip you to shreds), while Shivans are CLEARLY much more offensive minded (have you ever looked at the Sathanas before?). Shivan Destroyers generally are heavier on their forward beam cannon array, and use it to great effect to decimate ships of smaller size, regardless of armour/anti-fighter compliment. Putting a Sathanas next to a Hecate will achieve next to nothing, as it only has a single LRed (I think) mounted aft. IMO, this translates to me as the Sathanas coming across as Purely Offensive, its purpose is ONLY to decimate other ships, while Terran Ships may carry Marines/other non pilots. If the Shivans made a people carrier, they would go easy on the forward BFReds and learn something from the Orion and discover the rectangle.

Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 07, 2009, 05:23:54 am
If the Shivans made a people carrier, they would go easy on the forward BFReds and learn something from the Orion and discover the rectangle.
Nah, the next Transport / Freighter they make will have a BFRed somewhere. ;)

Come to think of it, if the Dis had better armor and the token beam cannon spikes, would anyone else see it as a Sathanas-style mini-Cruiser? ;7
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 07, 2009, 05:38:05 am
Putting a Sathanas next to a Hecate will achieve next to nothing, as it only has a single LRed (I think) mounted aft. IMO, this translates to me as the Sathanas coming across as Purely Offensive, its purpose is ONLY to decimate other ships
Well, that and the whole "Let's blow up that ****ing star" feature.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 07, 2009, 05:49:17 am
Putting a Sathanas next to a Hecate will achieve next to nothing, as it only has a single LRed (I think) mounted aft. IMO, this translates to me as the Sathanas coming across as Purely Offensive, its purpose is ONLY to decimate other ships
Well, that and the whole "Let's blow up that ****ing star" feature.

Oh yeahh, forget about that
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 07, 2009, 08:26:27 am

EDIT: Not voting until I see Snuffleupagus and/or "The Colossus doesn't need a designation". :p


:rolleyes:

Then don't. Read the first post in this thread.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 09, 2009, 09:16:44 pm
The Colossus can be clearely classified as a jugg class warship. However we MUST pay attention to its original pourpose and who actualy built the ship.

It is a GTVA jugg class warship and not a shivan jugg class warship .

While it does have some rather good offensive capabilaties it is more of a defensive/attack stile ship much like the Orion. (Im not comparing it to the Hattie since the Hattie is more offensive orientated IMO and the Hecate is in a class of its own. decent in all areas but not really really good at anything ).

If you want you can think of the Collie as a cross bread between a Hattie and an Orion supersized .

If the GTVA was hell bent on making a pure offensive class of jugg's then im pretty sure you would have seen several MJolnir's mounted in such a way as to provide maximum offensive capabilaties coupled with default LRBG or BFG .

However you can afford to build such ships when you outnumber the enemy by at least 2/1 and you are convinced that one shot or a couple of them max would ensure that you win the battle hands down.

So before anyone think's about placing the Collie in a specific class they should consider these simple fact's first .

The Collie was designed to hold the fort and win against several ship's which were known to be the most powerfull ones ever encountered. While it would have a very difficult time at this on its own it would of been supported by the C&C of the Hecate class as well as the more offensive Hattie Sobek and Deimos.

All of these ship's when formed into a single defensive or even offensive line against even a Sath ,if properly used would be sure to win or at least severely dammage the enemy so that it would no longer pose such a dire threat.

I've come to this conclusion after carefully watching the way different ship classes are presented in game and in the tech room as well as the ani's . They were all meant to work toghether in order to ensure the safes and fastest way to neutralize Lucifer class SD and of course any other ship the shivans might have nearby (meaning Demon class and such) .

Also while i do not want this to turn into another Iceni debate i can not help but feel that somehow the Iceni at least at some point should or rather was supposed to be an integral part of the GTVA's arsenal.(It's just a feeling i cant shake loose )
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 09, 2009, 10:22:25 pm
Also while i do not want this to turn into another Iceni debate i can not help but feel that somehow the Iceni at least at some point should or rather was supposed to be an integral part of the GTVA's arsenal.(It's just a feeling i cant shake loose )

It's easy to see why. The Colossus and Iceni look like siblings. ;)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Akalabeth Angel on January 10, 2009, 01:12:02 am
I agree with Flipside, but some pedantic people always claim that it wasn't ever said that it was a juggernaut, in the same way the Ulysses is never specifically called 'a ship', so really it should be a 'unspecified space-faring combat vehicle'.

      Incidentally the Ulysses is also supposed to be a joint project fighter yet the Vasudans never use it.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 10, 2009, 01:46:51 am
The Ulysses now has a ship type in the ship selection screen, so it doesn't count.

      Incidentally the Ulysses is also supposed to be a joint project fighter yet the Vasudans never use it.

No wonder I found "PVF Ulysses" in FSPort to be a bit out of place.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: nostro_pl on January 10, 2009, 06:35:58 am
I think that Colossus is a juggernaut - class warship. From Shivan's perspective this ship can only be stopped by SJ Sathanas, so it's almost "unstoppable". And GTVA calls SJ Sathanas a "juggernaut", because only Colossus can beat him.

BTW: Hello everyone, I'm new here  :)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 10, 2009, 06:41:22 am
One on one, the Colossus can't do squat to the Sathanas unless it's facing away from the Colossus in any 90 degree angle. :doubt:

Considering its size, firepower, and ability to house ships, would Battlecarrier be a good term for it?
In fact, any Destroyer in FreeSpace is a Battlecarrier when you look at their ability to destroy other warships with little support while having carrier capability.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: nostro_pl on January 10, 2009, 06:56:15 am
Yup, to win the Colossus have 2 be behind, under or over the Sathanas, but for example Orion doesn't have a chance against rear LRed placed on the juggernaut.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 10, 2009, 07:01:01 am
Actually head-on the Lucifer's two LReds that replace its Super Shivan Lasers destroy an Orion in three salvos (As seen on Blue Planet), it would take six pulses from the Sathanas's rear cannon, the Orion would have a decent chance of destroying that cannon before it goes down.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 10, 2009, 07:26:52 am
Ideally, the Colossus will probably win in a broadside battle against the Sathanas.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: nostro_pl on January 10, 2009, 08:03:09 am
I agree.  :nod:

BTW it's shame that in FS_Open 3.6.9 there aren't a Lucifer's forward beams from FS 1 or FSPort (SSLBeam or something like that)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 10, 2009, 08:07:17 am
Shivan Super Lasers. Since FreeSpace 2 came out they were swapped out with LReds. Table editing can give you them back.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Stormkeeper on January 10, 2009, 09:18:33 am
Shivan Super Lasers. Since FreeSpace 2 came out they were swapped out with LReds. Table editing can give you them back.
In FS2 its SReds by default. Which turned into a very very very large and heavily armoured cruiser.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 10, 2009, 10:36:41 am
Shivan Super Lasers. Since FreeSpace 2 came out they were swapped out with LReds. Table editing can give you them back.
In FS2 its SReds by default. Which turned into a very very very large and heavily armoured cruiser.

Unfortunately, if you replace them with the SLaser (no not the Spartan Laser... you play too much halo 3 hehe), the AI treats it like a laser turret (which is what it really is) and you suddenly have a mothe****ing unstoppable SOB crawling through the system, with constant pulses of 'Uber Ray' obliterating everything in it's path. So if you are willing to replace it, you have to lock that turret and use sexps only to fire it, or you are going to have to have some genius idea to beat that thing
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 10, 2009, 11:07:18 am
Shivan Super Lasers. Since FreeSpace 2 came out they were swapped out with LReds. Table editing can give you them back.
In FS2 its SReds by default. Which turned into a very very very large and heavily armoured cruiser.

Unfortunately, if you replace them with the SLaser (no not the Spartan Laser... you play too much halo 3 hehe), the AI treats it like a laser turret (which is what it really is) and you suddenly have a mothe****ing unstoppable SOB crawling through the system, with constant pulses of 'Uber Ray' obliterating everything in it's path. So if you are willing to replace it, you have to lock that turret and use sexps only to fire it, or you are going to have to have some genius idea to beat that thing
--Steve-O--'s Federal Fightersâ„¢  ;7
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: nostro_pl on January 10, 2009, 11:25:29 am
In FSPort Shivan Super Laser on the forward 2 turrets of the Lucifer was replaced by SSLBeam. It's shame that SSLBeam isn't in 3.6.9 Open. Now, if we want to have beams similar (in damage) to this from FSPort, we have 2 replace it to LRed's
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 11, 2009, 08:46:48 am
Shivan Super Lasers are good at disabling and/or disarming stuff. Have you guys seen TSM-69? When I saved my first incarnation of it and tested it, the Lucifer's SSLs kept disarming the Colossus' portside beams.

On a side note, LReds are stronger than SSLs, although I think I've mentioned that before. :nervous:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 11, 2009, 09:24:02 am
Considering its size, firepower, and ability to house ships, would Battlecarrier be a good term for it?
In fact, any Destroyer in FreeSpace is a Battlecarrier when you look at their ability to destroy other warships with little support while having carrier capability.

Battlecarrier has never been used by :v:?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aardwolf on January 11, 2009, 10:44:02 am
Battlecarrier afaik has never been used by any real navies, and it is never used in canon FreeSpace. My Battlecarrier model was ... not originally intended for FreeSpace anyway.

Battlecruiser, although used in real navies (but not recently), is also not used in canon FreeSpace.

The GTVA Colossus was a warship. It's a broad category that encompasses all of these other stupid things, and definitely applies to the Colossus.

And I should remind anyone who thinks it should be called a juggernaut that a 'juggernaut' is basically tantamount to a steamroller. IIRC the name comes from the Latin transliteration of some Hindu altar-on-wheels contraption that was notorious for running people over.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 11, 2009, 07:08:40 pm
In the FS Universe, Destroyers have been kind of merged with Carriers, as Destroyers have a sizeable Fighter compliment
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 12, 2009, 09:18:34 am
Someone said before that the Collie can not take the Sath head on. Or rather it is useless unless the Sath if facing off by at least 90 degrees.

I believe you are correct . Bu then again why dont we try something out. Moving ALL of the Collies beam cannons to the front and have all of the what 10 or 12 beam cannons fire at the Sath. For that matter you might as well equip the forward part with Mjolnirs since they are the most powerfull beam cannon the GTVA has and the big C has more then enough room for lets say 8 or 9 ???
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 12, 2009, 09:21:57 am
Bu then again why dont we try something out. Moving ALL of the Collies beam cannons to the front and have all of the what 10 or 12 beam cannons fire at the Sath.
Concidering the dialogue of High Noon, I'd speculate that with such a weapons layout the Collie could fire one decisive beam salvo before it melted into an unidentified puddle of metal and paint.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 12, 2009, 09:30:09 am
Umm yeah forgot about that. Nevertheless hearing such a discussion in the said mission i was like WTF??? Build bigger heatsink's you fraking idiots. But such is the word of Volition and who are we to debate such things even if the said thing is at least idiotic to say the least.

All hail the campaign plot god's !




Hold up didn't the said reactor overheat happen because the Collie was using its beams overloaded for a very long period of time. If so using all of the overloaded for a much shorter time span in theory should cause no significant problems ? In fact such a thing wont even cause the severe damage the Collie sustained in that mission ! ?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 12, 2009, 09:46:07 am
Umm yeah forgot about that. Nevertheless hearing such a discussion in the said mission i was like WTF??? Build bigger heatsink's you fraking idiots. But such is the word of Volition and who are we to debate such things even if the said thing is at least idiotic to say the least.

All hail the campaign plot god's !




Hold up didn't the said reactor overheat happen because the Collie was using its beams overloaded for a very long period of time. If so using all of the overloaded for a much shorter time span in theory should cause no significant problems ? In fact such a thing wont even cause the severe damage the Collie sustained in that mission ! ?

it would slowly start to wear down the beam cannons and stress the reactor much faster, meaning it would have to b replaced more often
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 15, 2009, 09:27:13 pm
Hold up you are telling me that 13 overloaded beam cannons don't stand a chance against the 4 BF Red's of the Sath ???

I mean you have 6 Green's on the Collie and 7 Slasher beams (why in the name of all that is holy would you put slashers on a ship this size is beyond me logic doesn't even factor here its been tossed out the window a long time ago ) .

So as far as i know the Green's can be overloaded to fire either LRBgreens so as to take the fight to the Sath or BF-Green which  is basically the same thing with shorter range .

I don't know abut the slashers but i assume they can be overloaded to.

So all these beams wont cut it for the Collie ???

i mean you have a total damage potential per pulse from the Green's alone (overloaded of course) of about 250.800 points of damage !

Add to this 80.850 points of damage in 30 secs which is about the recharge time for the BF-Green is I'm not mistaken .

So we have here a grand total of 331650 points of damage every 30 seconds. So in less the 1 minute and about 40 seconds the Sath should be history.

In the mean time the Sath has about 320k points of damage to bout per pulse every 10 seconds correct ??

Assuming and this is a huge assumption the Sath can somehow manage to keep its 4 beam's intact ...err...wait a sec...that would mean it would take the Sath about 1 minute to finish off the Collie!

Damn never mind i think i just answered my own question if I'm correct . Damn that huge sustained fire rate !

In that case the Mjolnir would in theory prove a much more usefull solution as it is much more powerfull. Having at least 7 of those should make up for this wouldn't it ???


Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on January 15, 2009, 09:38:43 pm
7 Mjolnirs?
7 x 1500 sustained = 10500

4 BFreds?
4 x 4756 sustained = 19024

Both of the beams pratically fire non-stop, so sustained is a good measure for them.
The BFreds still have the advantage.
Now, thirteen Mjolnirs are required to beat the Sath's primary BFRed firepower. Certainly, the Colly does have 13 beams, but it can only ever bring 5 or 6 of them to bear. Not to mention that MjolnirBeams only have half the targeting range.
And yes, this is all assuming that al the beams remain intact, which probably will, as beams rarely target the tips of spikes like that.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 15, 2009, 09:45:16 pm
Hey wait thats not true I remember the Collie opening fire at least 3 times on the tip's of the Sath's arms  during the mission with the first Sath when it's taken down.


Also ...WHY IN THE NAME OF ALL THAT IS HOLY TO A HLP'er and FS FAN are the god damn GTVA beam cannon's so god damn useless, weak , good for nothing pieces of frak....!!!!!

*alphaone  has had too much cofeene this morning so now hes going to go cool of a bit *

Sorry its the math that drives me like this . And those good for nothin' beams  !
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on January 15, 2009, 10:07:19 pm
Naw, the GTVA beams aren't useless. Its more of that BFReds are freaking powerful.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 15, 2009, 10:09:01 pm
oh RLY ?? Then what about the LRed ???

In fact the only beam i believe is somewhat normal for the shivans is the Sred which if i remember corectly is rather weak when compared to a GTVA beam .
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 15, 2009, 11:19:20 pm
Colossus has thirteen beams, eh? So the odd one out is the one at the top... :wtf:

In a broadside battle against the Sathanas with the Colossus overdriving all its beam cannons, the Sathanas will probably lose.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on January 15, 2009, 11:21:42 pm
The Colly wins in a broadside battle regardless :P
Neither the Sath's four main beams not its LRed can hit the Colly when broadsiding.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 15, 2009, 11:33:31 pm
The Colly wins in a broadside battle regardless :P
Neither the Sath's four main beams not its LRed can hit the Colly when broadsiding.

However if the Colly overtakes it it's in for some hurt, the Sath's main beams have quite an arc
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: eliex on January 16, 2009, 01:19:01 am
You get the Colossus anywhere but the front of the Sathanas and with overloaded beams - clear winner.
Same goes for the Rakshasha. The Sathanas is just an oversized Rakshasha tactical wise.   ;)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 16, 2009, 02:10:44 am
And with everyone talking about overloading EVERY SINGLE BEAM CANNON THE COLOSSUS HAS everyone must have forgot that it did so with one cannon and melted the reactor.

Okay then. Do it with five or six beams on one side all at once. Watch it explode right afterwards. Go ahead.
That would have to be in a real-life scenario though at best.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Ziame on January 16, 2009, 12:37:30 pm
What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?

GTVA is an abbreviation of two things:
a) organization Galactic Terran-Vasudan Alliance, military-civilian pact consisting of both Terrans and Vasudans
b) ship class, represented by one, (Rest in Pieces), ship GTVA Colossus, which means Galactic Terran-Vasudan Armageddon.

Thanks for listening

And, Zane, you're right, one uber cannon almost destroyed colossus instead of sathanas, so if we make it two cannons, colossus probably dies.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 16, 2009, 01:04:32 pm
Hey people...what do you think about the Iceni, then? :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 16, 2009, 01:05:29 pm
Galactic Terran-Vasudan Armageddon? BS.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Ziame on January 16, 2009, 02:32:33 pm
Galactic Terran-Vasudan Armageddon? BS.

BS? Does it mean BattleShip?

Well I thought Armageddon was funny  :(
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 16, 2009, 03:09:28 pm
BS = Bullsh!t :P

That said, TrashMan's GTVBS Archangel Mk 2 must stand for Galactic Terran-Vasudan Bull ****. :nervous:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Aardwolf on January 16, 2009, 03:09:41 pm
The one-of-a-kind ship prefixes are just the faction abbreviations. Sheesh.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 17, 2009, 03:53:22 am
WTF are you ppl talking here. Overloading ONE beam cannon almost destroyed the Collie ???!!! The Collie overloaded ALL of its side beam cannon's at least the ones facing the Sath.

And it was not even that that damaged the Collie since from the said discussion the Collie and apparently every other ship out there has a possibility to overload its beam cannon's .

However the discussion said specifically that or rather left me with the clear idea that they used the overloaded beam cannon's for far too much time and so they did not have the ability to cool them down .

Basically if they had the choice of firing the overloaded beam once every minute or so I'm sure the same problem's would not have occurred since they would of had much more time to cool down .
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 17, 2009, 04:03:42 am
The Righteous went boom. n00b at overclocking.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 17, 2009, 04:06:38 am
WTF are you ppl talking here. Overloading ONE beam cannon almost destroyed the Collie ???!!! The Collie overloaded ALL of its side beam cannon's at least the ones facing the Sath.

And it was not even that that damaged the Collie since from the said discussion the Collie and apparently every other ship out there has a possibility to overload its beam cannon's .

However the discussion said specifically that or rather left me with the clear idea that they used the overloaded beam cannon's for far too much time and so they did not have the ability to cool them down .

Basically if they had the choice of firing the overloaded beam once every minute or so I'm sure the same problem's would not have occurred since they would of had much more time to cool down .


Put simply

Beam Cannons are not made to be overdriven, just like your car wasn't made to run on an empty tank.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mars on January 17, 2009, 04:30:11 am
It's more like taking the govenor device off your car and pushing it past the limit
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Kie99 on January 17, 2009, 04:36:29 am
Hey people...what do you think about the Iceni, then? :rolleyes:

Referred to as a Corvette by your Wingman at one point.  "We're 5 Clicks from that Corvette!"
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 17, 2009, 04:38:47 am
Referred to also as a frigate.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 17, 2009, 04:39:53 am
Referred to also as a frigate.

...in the Techroom, yeah.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 17, 2009, 04:46:12 am
Hey people...what do you think about the Iceni, then? :rolleyes:

Referred to as a Corvette by your Wingman at one point.  "We're 5 Clicks from that Corvette!"
In the same manner the SD Nebiros is referred to as a cruiser, and the GVCv Thebes is referred to as a destroyer.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 17, 2009, 04:51:44 am
Hey people...what do you think about the Iceni, then? :rolleyes:

Referred to as a Corvette by your Wingman at one point.  "We're 5 Clicks from that Corvette!"
In the same manner the SD Nebiros is referred to as a cruiser, and the GVCv Thebes is referred to as a destroyer.
lol...face it...the whole game's rubbish under its own naming system, or else Voilition intentionally planned that the GTA / GTVA (Let's just say the humans) militaries consisted of retards that didn't go through any type of "Know your enemy and your friend, and what to expect to see in the field" training... :rolleyes:

Might as well say again, Cruisers are AAA platforms with rave lights, Corvettes bigger AAA platforms with ravier rave lights, and Destroyers carriers with ravey rave lights.

This, I believe is as accurate as it can get. :p
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 17, 2009, 04:52:07 am
In the same manner the SD Nebiros is referred to as a cruiser, and the GVCv Thebes is referred to as a destroyer.

:wtf:

...wha-...oh yeah, Snipes said:

Spoiler:
Alpha 2: We got incoming, a Ravana-class CRUISER, designation Nebiros.

Which persona said that the Thebes was a destroyer?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 17, 2009, 04:54:12 am
Which persona said that the Thebes was a destroyer?
It's in the Bearbaiting debriefing if you happen to lose the Thebes:

"The destroyer Thebes, however, did not survive the engagement."
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on January 17, 2009, 05:02:56 am
Hey people...what do you think about the Iceni, then? :rolleyes:

Referred to as a Corvette by your Wingman at one point.  "We're 5 Clicks from that Corvette!"
In the same manner the SD Nebiros is referred to as a cruiser, and the GVCv Thebes is referred to as a destroyer.

Yeah, but a wingman calling the Iceni a 'corvette' just after they've discovered the thing is more forgivable than these other two examples. Yes, Loukakis did say that it was a 'frigate', but at least the Iceni is corvette-sized.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: eliex on January 17, 2009, 07:14:23 pm

In the same manner the SD Nebiros is referred to as a cruiser, and the GVCv Thebes is referred to as a destroyer.

Into the Lion's Den there's a Rakshasha cruiser that doesn't have a unique name too.

Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on January 17, 2009, 07:16:49 pm
Everything in Into the Lion's Den (except the Nebiros) doesn't have a name...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 17, 2009, 09:34:54 pm
Everything in Into the Lion's Den (except the Nebiros) doesn't have a name...

True. I never really gave much thought to the magnitude of the whole name problem in Into the Lion's Den until now. ;)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Ziame on January 18, 2009, 09:25:22 am
Well, I think it's forgivable. IMO it gives this feeling of "OMGWTFBBQ our computerz can't compute namez! NOOOOEES!"
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 18, 2009, 09:32:31 am
In the same manner the SD Nebiros is referred to as a cruiser, and the GVCv Thebes is referred to as a destroyer.

:v: probably changed its class to Sobek after realizing that a destroyer could easily survive a direct engagement against the Beleth - maybe its hitpoints and the main beam cannon were too much to turn the second part of Bearbaiting into a worth challenge.

Even the name suggests that the Thebes was a destroyer - it was the name of an ancient city. Except for Alexandria, most(all?) names of that kind are used for destroyers(Carthage, Cyrene, Phoenicia, Aquitaine). Afterall, names of cities and regions work fine.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 18, 2009, 09:38:01 am
Psamtik (I), on the other hand, was an Egyptian king who united his people freed his land from Assyrian control in under ten years. The Memphis, on the other hand, is named after an Egyptian city.

I think it is hence safe to assume that modern Vasudan ship names are taken from very good Egyptian kings/Pharaohs and Egyptian cities.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 18, 2009, 10:26:07 am
Psamtik (I), on the other hand, was an Egyptian king who united his people freed his land from Assyrian control in under ten years. The Memphis, on the other hand, is named after an Egyptian city.

I think it is hence safe to assume that modern Vasudan ship names are taken from very good Egyptian kings/Pharaohs and Egyptian cities.

In short, something

A) Egyptian

and

B) Notable for some good reason
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 20, 2009, 06:38:32 am
The Colossus is a Battle Ship.

Look at the cutscene where it talks about its weapons capability, around the top right of the screen the exact words:
TVA Battle Ship.

There's your Canon evidence. :P
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 20, 2009, 11:35:11 am
:wtf:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 20, 2009, 02:03:20 pm
If I had something that would play the blasted thing so I can screen it I would, you'll just have to watch it a couple times yourself.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 20, 2009, 02:14:10 pm
something that would play the blasted thing so I can screen it
You mean like... a media player of some sort?

Picture related (http://koti.mbnet.fi/reiler/FunkyFreeSpaceStuff/wtfnooblol.png).
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 20, 2009, 02:18:28 pm
No Windows Media Player will not display the video. WinAmp will not display videos either.
But that's the screen I was going for.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 20, 2009, 02:20:55 pm
No Windows Media Player will not display the video. WinAmp will not display videos either.
Ever thought about installing codecs? Actually, the easier option is to get a media player that plays videos without any hassle. VLC Media Player will accomplish this task, but personally I prefer The KMPlayer nowadays since it looks cooler and crashes far less often. Or never, to be precise.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Rodo on January 20, 2009, 04:05:36 pm
I have the VLC and also real player plays it, I think he's right... the vid defines the Colossus as a "XXX" battle ship of massive proportions ( don't know what says on the XXX part), well that's what says in 3 different shots, the other descriptions are just the same text written over and over :P... something like "math is cool Im preety deamed... and I can't read any further.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 20, 2009, 04:07:55 pm
the vid defines the Colossus as a "XXX" battle ship of massive proportions ( don't know what says on the XXX part)
It looks a lot like TVA, as Commander Zane said. Which could naturally stand for Terran-Vasudan Alliance.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 21, 2009, 03:05:14 am
So you mean the Collie actualy had a designation already in place as a TVA Battleship.

However such a thing implies that it is somewhat standard to both terran's and vasudans. Namely a ship class that is built for both races with no differences whatsoever?

Also such a thing would imply that the Collie was intended for mass production at some point or another.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: eliex on January 21, 2009, 03:13:38 am
Also such a thing would imply that the Collie was intended for mass production at some point or another.

That won't happen due to the massive costs and time required just to build one. One would wonder how the 80 Sathanai got constructed in a short time span (if the construction exceed more than 50 years radically newer technology would have been developed.)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Narvi on January 21, 2009, 03:22:40 am
Also such a thing would imply that the Collie was intended for mass production at some point or another.

That won't happen due to the massive costs and time required just to build one. One would wonder how the 80 Sathanai got constructed in a short time span (if the construction exceed more than 50 years radically newer technology would have been developed.)

Not necessarily. It probably wouldn't take twenty years to build the next one. Remember that the Colossus was a secret project, and construction began around the time period of reconstruction, so it probably wasn't allocated too many resources. Not to mention that Sol, the primary human industrial hub has been cut off, so a lot of resources were needed just to rebuild the infrastructure at the time.

The first Colossus was the prototype. The next model will come out faster.

As to the 80 Sathanas class juggernaughts; the Shivans have like, a lot of systems. And have been around for thousands of years.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 21, 2009, 03:34:28 am
One would wonder how the 80 Sathanai got constructed in a short time span (if the construction exceed more than 50 years radically newer technology would have been developed.)
Nothing implies directly that the Sathanases were constructed between the events of FS1 and FS2. It is completely possible that the Shivans had their Sathanas armada, as well as god-kowns-what other ships. They just didn't see any reason to use them during the Great War. Or the Sathanases had other tasks at the time (like blowing up other stars perhaps?).
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 21, 2009, 03:43:31 am
Agreed the first one takes ages to build that is a rule you can not get passed. New tech had to be developed and tested then retested before final assembly . Then the whole thing had to be tested as a whole different modification and corrections made to it before it was completed.



Also the GTVA had to start from almost 0 infrastructure .  Just imagine they had to build the shipyards the research and development infrastructure gather enough res. while at the same time divert a huge amount of rest to rebuilding the fleets. And the economical infrastructure.

Sure the GTVA lost quite a hand full of ships this time and an entire sistem but all in all they are a LOT better off then they were at the end of the last war when they had almost nothing to go on.

At least this time they have the infrastructure in place the shipyards the res gathering in place the R&D etc. Also this time around they do not have to develop new tech for everything.

Even if they wanted modifications to be done to the Collie they know how and where to do it .

So should they start building another one half the time would be required if not less. That is usually how it goes. By the time they get to the third one and so on they could build them, should they allocate enough res. ,in as little as 2 to 3 years per ship.


Im using modern day equivalents for this . I mean im looking at how different production of various military assets went after the first one was developed tried and tested.


To give you an example the development of a APC over here a new one i mean took about 2 -3 years of testing designing etc. This is how much it took for the first one to be developed and built and a assembly line put in place.

Now at just 20% work capacity they can ship out about 50 per month.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: castor on January 21, 2009, 12:25:30 pm
Though, after seeing the Saths, I doubt they'd ever want to build something like Collie again :)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Ziame on January 21, 2009, 01:47:16 pm
And after three hundred years, some scientist will discover this forum and say "Holy crap! They thought we'd be stupid enough to build a ship that can be ripped in half by a stray asteroid!" Then he will stand on the grave of HLP (HLP LIVE FOREVUH!) and smile "Thiz iz real life!" And then, Shivanz attack.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 22, 2009, 03:06:40 am
And after three hundred years, some scientist will discover this forum and say "Holy crap! They thought we'd be stupid enough to build a ship that can be ripped in half by a stray asteroid!" Then he will stand on the grave of HLP (HLP LIVE FOREVUH!) and smile "Thiz iz real life!" And then, Shivanz attack.


 :wtf:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Grizzly on January 22, 2009, 04:09:50 am
And after three hundred years, some scientist will discover this forum and say "Holy crap! They thought we'd be stupid enough to build a ship that can be ripped in half by a stray asteroid!" Then he will stand on the grave of HLP (HLP LIVE FOREVUH!) and smile "Thiz iz real life!" And then, Shivanz attack.


 :wtf:

 
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 22, 2009, 04:35:26 am
Yeah I'm lost on that one too.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Excalibur on January 22, 2009, 05:46:08 am
.pihs elttaB

Although I think that it should just be "GTVA Colossus", since it is a one and only prototype test model - that actually does the job it was designed and built for.

Also, GTJ or GTCJ sounds wierd.

.rubilaxcE

Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 22, 2009, 07:02:56 am
Well like others have said, the fact that it's called a Battle Ship implies that it would be further produced, the GTVA Colossus would be the name given to the maiden ship of its class before it was produced with a GTBB title or something.

The first of the Victory Heavy Destroyers was named the IAS Victory to state a possibly similar note.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Narvi on January 22, 2009, 09:21:09 am
Well like others have said, the fact that it's called a Battle Ship implies that it would be further produced, the GTVA Colossus would be the name given to the maiden ship of its class before it was produced with a GTBB title or something.

The first of the Victory Heavy Destroyers was named the IAS Victory to state a possibly similar note.

GTBB...? Galactic Terran Battle Barge? Not quite yet, I think. :P

It's a joint venture, don't forget. The symbol of the unity of the GTVA.

So, it would be either GTVABS or (more likely) GTVBS. Possibly GTVBs.

"The Colossus-class GTVBs Vindicator is leading the thrust into the warm depths of the inner system."
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 22, 2009, 09:23:48 am
GTBB...? Galactic Terran Battle Barge? Not quite yet, I think. :P
Quote from: The mother****ing Wikipedia after searching for "BB"
Battleship, US Navy hull classification symbol
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: azile0 on January 22, 2009, 10:36:10 am
The Colossus was THE COLOSSUS of the GTVA. It meets both Juggernaut and Superdestroyer classes, because it's got the size of a juggernaut, and the firepower of a Superdestoyer. I'm honestly disappointed how weak the Colly is, really. If it didn't have some badass fighter cover, it would have been obliterated by the Sath's beams in seconds, like in that.. one mission where the Sath kills the Colly because it didn't have fighter cover. I just wish that I could fly fast enough over the the Sath and kill it's beams before it killed the Colly. Take THAT, canon storyline!
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Narvi on January 22, 2009, 11:49:22 am
GTBB...? Galactic Terran Battle Barge? Not quite yet, I think. :P
Quote from: The mother****ing Wikipedia after searching for "BB"
Battleship, US Navy hull classification symbol

What.

How does that work?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 22, 2009, 12:39:12 pm
What.

How does that work?
The same way Frigate (Ff) works.

Magic.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Grizzly on January 22, 2009, 01:42:28 pm
The Colossus was THE COLOSSUS of the GTVA. It meets both Juggernaut and Superdestroyer classes, because it's got the size of a juggernaut, and the firepower of a Superdestoyer. I'm honestly disappointed how weak the Colly is, really. If it didn't have some badass fighter cover, it would have been obliterated by the Sath's beams in seconds, like in that.. one mission where the Sath kills the Colly because it didn't have fighter cover. I just wish that I could fly fast enough over the the Sath and kill it's beams before it killed the Colly. Take THAT, canon storyline!

The Collusses was killed that easy because of an oversight / bug. The disabled engines thingy. Along that, that mission was just fairly badly coded.

With that said, where is Their Finest Hour: Reborn?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: nostro_pl on January 22, 2009, 01:47:21 pm
Propably also with fighter cover the Colossus doesn't have a chance against the Sathanas in Finest Hour.
 Joshua, captain of the Colossus said, that he wants to give Bastion a time to reach the jump node. It's possible, that even with all engines on-line, Colo would not escape.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Rodo on January 22, 2009, 04:19:08 pm
well what can you do, the sath is obviously unstopable, unless you play it right, and well you always need an "invincible" foe to keep the player at the edge of the chair... is that right? m
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: eliex on January 22, 2009, 04:41:09 pm
You always need an "invincible" foe to keep the player at the edge of the chair... is that right? m

Certainly for Inferno - the SH Gargant if it's still going to be in the upcoming INF SCP.  :P
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 23, 2009, 02:09:09 am
Remove that last e from "Gargante", elie. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 23, 2009, 03:16:47 am
Well for a ship of its size the Collie much like the Hecate class destroyer is so poorly armed.

I mean the Orion has 4 BG  an 2 slashers i believe or something like that.

While all mighty Colossus has 6 or 7 BG and just as many slashers ?????? WTF is with that combo ???

I henestly dont get it ! Why the hell did they put so many slashes on the Collie for that matter why the hell does the Collie have so few beams ???

I mean its many times the size and volume of a Hecate or Orion or Hattie so if we take the Orion as an example it should have at least 12 BG and 8 or so slashers not to mention a few dozen aaaf defence batteries.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on January 23, 2009, 05:34:31 am
...While all mighty Colossus has 6 or 7 BG and just as many slashers ?????? WTF is with that combo ???

I henestly dont get it ! Why the hell did they put so many slashes on the Collie for that matter why the hell does the Collie have so few beams ???..

Because it's enough. Have you seen how easily the Colossus took down a Ravana in Clash of the Titans II?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Excalibur on January 23, 2009, 06:01:46 am
Yes, but it still took whatever it took minus about 15 seconds...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Rodo on January 23, 2009, 06:26:14 am
I had the impresion that the collie should have had a new kind of beam, a powerfull one, every flag ship has it's own distinctive characteristics... like the sath... it forward beam cannons are the punch, the collie just seems to be a bigger warship... no real improvements on any field... a new powerfull and dreadfull beam would have been nice not a bunch of those, just one, one new powerfull beam and that's it.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 23, 2009, 07:03:55 am
Rodo you seem to be stepping into Inferno mod right about now ! :))

Loved that campaign !

Sure it might be enough to dispatch a couple of destroyers at once but even so it just seems like the Collie is a victim of its own long development period.

Thats just how it seems to me .

I mean what was cutting edge 5 or 10 years before would be standard now.


The Hattie on the other hand is a brand new state of the art destroyer ! And it shows.

The Orion is a victim of its age yet even so it is the most feared Destroyer in game from a capship vs capship combat i mean . The most powerfull ones inclueding fighter bays aaaf defences would have to be Hecate then Hattie then Ravana then Orion then Demon .
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Rodo on January 23, 2009, 11:01:03 am
what's the Hattie? I thought you ment the Hecate with that but
The most powerfull ones inclueding fighter bays aaaf defences would have to be Hecate then Hattie then Ravana then Orion then Demon .
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 23, 2009, 11:02:39 am
Hatshepsut
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: azile0 on January 23, 2009, 11:04:53 am
I agree. I really wanted to see a DNA-shaped beam cannon. That would be AWESOME on the Collie.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Rodo on January 23, 2009, 11:08:29 am
well too bad the retail script was done this way... it's got his moments anyway.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 23, 2009, 11:32:59 am
well too bad the retail script was done this way... it's got his moments anyway.

mmm, I suppose, but High Noon IMO should have been some great epik battle in which the entire 3rd Fleet mounts a flank attack while the Colly takes the brunt of the 4 BFReds and dishes out its own punishment while Alpha Wing take out the remaining cannons and have the rest of the 33rd in Bakhas and some bombers from the Colossus with some kind of FIGHTER ESCORT! DAMMIT VOLITION! try to get in close to the Sath, while it throws its own fighters at the GTVA Ships and this huge climax battle takes place and ends in a cutscene similar in scale to the fs2 intro where triumphant music plays as the Sath goes down in a flurry of fighters, beams, and debris


But that's just my Opinion
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: nostro_pl on January 23, 2009, 03:12:06 pm
Exactly, it would be great.
Destruction of the Sathanas was a great success of a GTVA, and it should be rewarded by a movie  :)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 23, 2009, 03:25:53 pm
Well, with FSO and the Media VPs such a cutscene would be very bad if compared to the in-game event.

:p
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 23, 2009, 04:49:56 pm
Exactly, it would be great.
Destruction of the Sathanas was a great success of a GTVA, and it should be rewarded by a movie  :)
Like the rest of the GTVA should get credit from what the Colossus and a single bomber wing did. :P
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on January 23, 2009, 04:58:45 pm
Are posts in General FreeSpace supposed to miss the differences between the FreeSpace Universe and what we see ingame? It's quite obvious that in a Universe point of view the engagement didn't involve only two ships and two wings. Other notable examples are Apocalypse, Bearbaiting and Evangelist.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 23, 2009, 05:05:33 pm
Are posts in General FreeSpace supposed to miss the differences between the FreeSpace Universe and what we see ingame? It's quite obvious that in a Universe point of view the engagement didn't involve only two ships and two wings. Other notable examples are Apocalypse, Bearbaiting and Evangelist.
Honestly I can understand this argument but others, like "FS2 overrides all FS1 aspects" is complete bollocks.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 23, 2009, 06:18:25 pm
Are posts in General FreeSpace supposed to miss the differences between the FreeSpace Universe and what we see ingame? It's quite obvious that in a Universe point of view the engagement didn't involve only two ships and two wings. Other notable examples are Apocalypse, Bearbaiting and Evangelist.
As true as that is the Colossus and bomber wings are really the only things that could've made enough of a difference to turn the tide of battle in such a situation though. Like how the only thing that made a difference between a dead Earth and victory for the GTA was a surgical strike against the Lucifer.
That's just probably the game though. Perhaps in a real-life scenario things would be way different.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 23, 2009, 11:02:51 pm
Exactly, it would be great.
Destruction of the Sathanas was a great success of a GTVA, and it should be rewarded by a movie  :)
Like the rest of the GTVA should get credit from what the Colossus and a single bomber wing did. :P

Hmmm, I think I might just *attempt* FRED-ing that  :nervous:

At least it'll put this new soundtrack I've been working on to good use
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 24, 2009, 09:34:52 am
Are posts in General FreeSpace supposed to miss the differences between the FreeSpace Universe and what we see ingame? It's quite obvious that in a Universe point of view the engagement didn't involve only two ships and two wings. Other notable examples are Apocalypse, Bearbaiting and Evangelist.
As true as that is the Colossus and bomber wings are really the only things that could've made enough of a difference to turn the tide of battle in such a situation though. Like how the only thing that made a difference between a dead Earth and victory for the GTA was a surgical strike against the Lucifer.
That's just probably the game though. Perhaps in a real-life scenario things would be way different.
In a real-life scenario there wouldn't be a GTVA.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 24, 2009, 09:40:29 am
And in real life we would have lazors to snipe targets a few hundred km away :)))
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 24, 2009, 04:47:46 pm
ffs...
It's speculation of what would happen on FreeSpace's part had the events taken place in real-time.
Seriously, would anyone actually sortie a single ship with two bomber wings to take down another ship as large and magnitudes of power stronger than your carrier vessel?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 24, 2009, 05:15:06 pm
IF i was desperate enough i would. I mean if you wanna take it close to real time then ffs lets talk combat deployment of the GTVA fleet's combat engagements and such...!

I mean heres one example ! You have the flagship of the 5'th fleet the Aquitane and one of the most proeminent admirals and posibly influencial ones in all the GTVA on board as its commander . The Aquitane could very well be considered some sort of flag ship for the GTVA . And yet the Aquitane is left unguarded almost all of the time. At best you have one fraking wing of fighters providing CAP in the fraking middle of the nebula.


I mean come on get real.

I'd freaking sortie at least 6 wing's of fighter's,bombers and interceptors. 2 bombers wings 1 fighter wing and 3 interceptor wings. That is an actual adequate CAP in the middle of the freaking war with a species that is superior in both numbers and weapons. And since you cant freaking see anithin' in the god damn nebula id say keeping at least 1 or 2 cruisers or a corvette close by would be a really good idea.

Also let's not forget the all mighty Collie with its sh** for brain weapons configuration . Powerfull indeed but ever so weak at the same time.

You have THE flagship of the entire GTVA armed forces and a simbol of GTVA pride and so on ...and yet the bloody thing is left unguarded all the time. I dont care how much firepower it has i will never let that ship go anywhere without an Orion and a Hecate or Hattie less then a 1 short jump away.

Oh and dont even get me started on the absolute stupidity of fracking blocading nodes by placing your ships in front of the enemy cannons cuz that just made my head explode .  I mean what kind of an absolute idiot do you have to be to place yourself in the lion's mouth like that .


Fraking move to the side you fraking idiots for the love of god.

Oh yeah not to mention the favorite of us all "uu lets send 1 wing of bombers to take out the enemy fleet cuz..err they can do it ..hoorayyyy....." "so what about the rest of the ships "

"aaa well why dont we try to play tag with the enemy beam canons that sounds like fun right ....??!!"

Phew vented off some steam here but i think ppl should understand that while it is appealing to try and debate all these things in real time and such one has to disregard a host of other game elements that are there top be taken a laws or something.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 24, 2009, 06:08:07 pm
So the game itself is concentrated on the player's viewpoint of being a combat pilot for a given flagship, I can deal with that, piloting small things is fun, but it's too concentrated on the point that such a pilot can change the entire tide of battle in any situation. For the battles against the Sathanas, there'd probably be more large ships and even more small ships, it's not like we can do that with ground troops in reality "Okay, our objectives are to clear this city, this tank will provide assistance for Fireteam (Four men) Alpha, expect heavy resistance, good luck." and somehow win.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 24, 2009, 06:16:05 pm
well thats exactly mi point. I mean before ppl start stating and debating real time stuf they shoul concentrate on the fact that the game is made is such a way that the pilot in this case the player of Alpha 1 is MEANT  to win the war all by himself.

and he probably could too with a few cheats ;))
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 24, 2009, 11:45:47 pm
In that sense, FS2 sounds like Pokemon, Freelancer, Duke Nukem and Prey. ;)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Charismatic on January 30, 2009, 12:01:05 pm
The Collie was built to defeat a Lucifer. Lucifer was a superdestroyer, so shouldent the Collie be one as well?

Sathi's are Juggernauts but the Collie could not really take one on without the help of Alpha 1. So how can it be a Jugernaut?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Jeff Vader on January 30, 2009, 12:05:51 pm
The Collie was built to defeat a Lucifer. Lucifer was a superdestroyer, so shouldent the Collie be one as well?
Bombers weren't built to defeat other bombers.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Charismatic on January 30, 2009, 12:09:10 pm
Fighters are built to defeat other fighters as well as other ships. But this is cap ships were talking about. The Collie took out destroyers just fine. Had a hard time taking out a Sathi.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 30, 2009, 12:43:45 pm
Ursae are designed to destroy destroyers... So does that mean they're destroyers too? :confused:

This train of thought has to be the worst argument set forward for any candidate so far.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Charismatic on January 30, 2009, 12:59:04 pm
Screw off. I said fighters in general. Exceptions always apply. Like when lag bombing or tab loading.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: SpardaSon21 on January 30, 2009, 06:38:37 pm
I used to think Juggernaut, but then I saw the .ani that talks about the Colossus after you first encounter it.  It pretty clearly stated "TVA Battle Ship".  So therefore we can conclude that the class of the Colossus is battleship.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: AlphaOne on January 30, 2009, 07:36:19 pm
You're all wrong the collie is in fact a stealth fighter with beams ! The whole 6 km long thing is just its disguise ! Thats how it goes about unnoticed. The GTVA scientists and most brilliant minds decided that this top secret project was best hidden in a 6 km long thing.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on January 30, 2009, 10:04:17 pm
You're all wrong the collie is in fact a stealth fighter with beams ! The whole 6 km long thing is just its disguise ! Thats how it goes about unnoticed. The GTVA scientists and most brilliant minds decided that this top secret project was best hidden in a 6 km long thing.

I think I'll hand my rank slides in now thanks. Oh- and my Officers Commission and everything I have to do with the GTVA.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Killer Whale on January 31, 2009, 06:13:43 am
I think it's a supercapitol  :blah:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 31, 2009, 07:09:51 am
I think it's a supercapitol  :blah:
We've already pointed it out...it's a "Battle Ship." :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on January 31, 2009, 10:19:01 am
Article modified to reflect http://koti.mbnet.fi/reiler/FunkyFreeSpaceStuff/wtfnooblol.png and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrKMw6JHgFA.

http://www.hard-light.net/wiki/index.php?title=GTVA_Colossus&diff=20541&oldid=19924

This thread may now be spammed and subsequently locked. Thanks for the evidence, Commander Zane and Lobo. Much obliged.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 31, 2009, 11:03:00 am
Are you serious?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Droid803 on January 31, 2009, 11:31:15 am
Please drop the 'of massive proportions'. That just sounds...unprofessional. 'Battle ship' would be a good enough designation.
We all know the Colossus was made by the (Galactic) Terran-Vasudan Alliance, and that it's big.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on January 31, 2009, 11:51:45 am
What about writing an article about this issue, and instead of giving a designation, there would be a link there?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Narvi on January 31, 2009, 12:41:10 pm
You could always put the "giant battleship of massive proportions" in quotes.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: TopAce on January 31, 2009, 01:16:26 pm
http://www.hard-light.net/wiki/index.php/GTVA_Colossus_ship_type_debate

I wrote something about this issue. Perhaps this article could be linked to and expanded accordingly. (I think linking to this is a wee bit better than simply giving "Ship" as the ship type)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Charismatic on January 31, 2009, 03:21:51 pm
Why in all the years, did we find this out Now?
This thread deserves some credit.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Kie99 on January 31, 2009, 04:06:50 pm
Article modified to reflect http://koti.mbnet.fi/reiler/FunkyFreeSpaceStuff/wtfnooblol.png and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrKMw6JHgFA.

http://www.hard-light.net/wiki/index.php?title=GTVA_Colossus&diff=20541&oldid=19924

This thread may now be spammed and subsequently locked. Thanks for the evidence, Commander Zane and Lobo. Much obliged.

It is a joke. "TVA Battle Ship of Massive Proportions" is not a ship class, and the Colossus is not 'inaccurately referred to as a warship', as it is quite obviously a ship of war, so these references are accurate.  Please do not scrawl this type of bollocks on the Wiki in future.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on January 31, 2009, 04:54:30 pm
Honestly I'm thinking of starting my own Wiki without this stuff...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on January 31, 2009, 07:13:10 pm
GTD Colossus
GTJ Colossus
GTPwnz j00-lossus.

I voted Superdestroyer...Juggernaut doesn't seem to fit...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Scotty on January 31, 2009, 07:37:53 pm
I'm pretty sure it's superdestroyer.  In the mission where you first meet the Sathanas, the corvette you are with says that it "...exceeds superdestroyer specifications..."  What else could you compare that too other than the Collosus? (I'm fairly certain it is larger, or the whole idea just dies.)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 31, 2009, 08:09:23 pm
Oh my god...

Come on, look at the Colossus cinematic, it's hinted that it was to be designated as a Battle Ship.
It's not a Superdestroyer, it's not a Juggernaut, it's not a Giant Baseball Bat of Doom (Though it functions like one nicely it wouldn't be given that designation), it's a Battle Ship.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Scotty on January 31, 2009, 08:11:34 pm
Oh my god...
"TVA Battle Ship of epic proportions."

OF COURSE!  Or Battle Ship could mean a SHIP THAT BATTLES!   :blah:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on January 31, 2009, 08:14:40 pm
Almost every ship is capable of battling or destroying to an extent, though Fighters and Bombers aren't called Battleships or Destroyers, nor are Cruisers or Corvettes.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on February 01, 2009, 02:56:26 am
You can't definitely call it a Battle Ship, since it appears in a tiny corner of one cutscene for a few moments. Hardly conclusive evidence.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on February 01, 2009, 03:04:59 am
You can't definitely call it a Battle Ship, since it appears in a tiny corner of one cutscene for a few moments. Hardly conclusive evidence.

Well it's the only 'real' thing we have to go on regarding this.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on February 01, 2009, 03:07:20 am
I still fail to see how ONE instance of Battle Ship in-game can overrule ALL the instances of Supercap EVERYWHERE ELSE.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on February 01, 2009, 03:27:12 am
Well in-game evidence suggests that the Colossus is also CANNON FODDER. :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on February 01, 2009, 03:37:11 am
Well in-game evidence suggests that the Colossus is also CANNON FODDER. :rolleyes:

Hey! I tried to change that stereotype!  :D
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Commander Zane on February 01, 2009, 04:20:31 am
And you did a damn good job at it too. :D
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on February 01, 2009, 04:40:24 am
And you did a damn good job at it too. :D

Why Thank-You  :)
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on February 01, 2009, 05:04:19 am
/me checks TopAce's article and tweaks it a little.

Good job. If I wasn't scared of Goober banning mebeams aren't prohibitively restrictive to use, I would fire a BABeam at you. :nervous:

Well in-game evidence suggests that the Colossus is also CANNON FODDER. :rolleyes:

Really?
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on February 01, 2009, 05:15:19 am
/me checks TopAce's article and tweaks it a little.

Good job. If I wasn't scared of Goober banning mebeams aren't prohibitively restrictive to use, I would fire a BABeam at you. :nervous:

Well in-game evidence suggests that the Colossus is also CANNON FODDER. :rolleyes:

Really?

It went against everything the CO of the Colly learned at GTVA Officer Academy and stayed in the way of a rolling Sathanas for no real reason, when the Alliance could've deployed other assets to occupy the Sath rather than sacrificing the single largest expenditure in the GTVA in the space of 3 minutes.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: ssmit132 on February 01, 2009, 05:52:43 am
Who says it would have got out of Capella to escape the supernova, though? And we don't know what would have happened if the Colossus had jumped out, but let's not open that can of worms again.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on February 01, 2009, 06:08:49 am
If Command had more resources, they would definitely have been deployed. The problem is that they didn't. Remember Exodus?

Spoiler:
You had no reinforcements there. Three fighters sortied to protect a convoy of four large ships against...fifty-over Shivan small craft and a Cain? Add a Moloch if you don't destroy the Abraxis fast enough. It's asking for trouble if the Shivans weren't stupid enough to attack only one target.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Dilmah G on February 01, 2009, 06:21:49 am
If Command had more resources, they would definitely have been deployed. The problem is that they didn't. Remember Exodus?

Spoiler:
You had no reinforcements there. Three fighters sortied to protect a convoy of four large ships against...fifty-over Shivan small craft and a Cain? Add a Moloch if you don't destroy the Abraxis fast enough. It's asking for trouble if the Shivans weren't stupid enough to attack only one target.

Yeah I suppose you're right, and counting the fact V kept in mind the computers of the day when they planned the mission.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: SpardaSon21 on February 01, 2009, 10:33:19 am
Hmmm.

We need a WWVD (What Would Volition Do) thread where we debate all sorts of pointless nonsense about what Volition would do if they were designing Freespace 2 with the tech of today's computers.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on February 01, 2009, 10:44:16 am
Today's culture is more of a Console-Gaming culture, so likely FS2 were it made in 2009 would be for the XBox360 or PS3 or something.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on February 01, 2009, 10:47:32 am
Today's culture is more of a Console-Gaming culture, so likely FS2 were it made in 2009 would be for the XBox360 or PS3 or something.

PC games still are being produced, so FS2 would also be released in PC. Wouldn't it become clumsy to play it on a console.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on February 01, 2009, 10:49:19 am
It'd become stupid if it were on a console.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on February 01, 2009, 10:49:43 am
It'd become stupid if it were on a console.

'ZACTLY.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on February 01, 2009, 10:54:25 am
May I know why? :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on February 01, 2009, 10:54:55 am
May I know why? :rolleyes:
Simplification.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on February 01, 2009, 10:55:58 am
Hmm...I can think of the commands...how a keyboard uses ALMOST every key on the BOARD to play the game..while a console controller would have MAX 8-10 keys..How do you expect to play the game. You're better off playing Starfox...XD
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on February 01, 2009, 11:04:54 am
Say whatever you want about the simplification of commands but you can say nothing regarding the level of plot development and graphics.

Another bad thing is be the lack of mods, which would be very bad.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on February 01, 2009, 11:09:10 am
Lol...yeah :o
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on February 01, 2009, 11:14:09 am
Another bad thing is be the lack of mods, which would be very bad.
That would be the worst point.
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mobius on February 01, 2009, 11:17:15 am
Yeah, true, but your first posts led me to think that you were somewhat accusing console games of n00bness and stupidity, which isn't necessarily true. :nod:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on February 01, 2009, 11:49:40 am
I don't think so...Console games rock! CRASH BANDICOOT FOREVER!
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Grizzly on February 01, 2009, 12:16:43 pm
I don't think so...Console games rock! CRASH BANDICOOT FOREVER!

You have volunteered for a training assignment with the GTVA. This specific training will cover shooting the pilot of the ship, in order to get the ship in one piece. This technique is also known as "headshooting".

Your assignment in this specific training will be to pilot a modified version of the Amazon drone...
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Snail on February 01, 2009, 12:36:57 pm
Now the barrel roll [Press Z twice]. Do a barrel roll!
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on February 01, 2009, 12:48:19 pm
CRAP.... :eek:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Romanmolf on February 01, 2009, 12:58:03 pm
Hmm...I can think of the commands...how a keyboard uses ALMOST every key on the BOARD to play the game..while a console controller would have MAX 81-0 keys..How do you expect to play the game. You're better off playing Starfox...XD

I agree.  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: GTSVA on February 01, 2009, 01:07:56 pm
Cool...someone agreed with me. I feel special. :nod:
Title: Re: What Ship Type is the GTVA Colossus?
Post by: Mongoose on February 01, 2009, 01:26:32 pm
I'm gonna say that this thread has run its course.

(And just because I get the last word here, the Colossus is the Colossus.  It has no class because it needs no class.  It's a one-off.  So meh. :p)