I have FS2 installed elsewhere, and as I said above, I have over 11 gb of harddrive space left. I'm fairly certain new pilots don't take up that much space to make.
Why think I should running it as a mod instead of a standalone? Not sure on how to do that...
UPDATE:
Good news! I can now create a pilot and...
... the game CTD's when I try to load up either campaign (the EM campaign from the site and the raiders campaigns here on the forum).
Going to see about running the map pack too just to see if that CTD's as well.
UPDATE 2:
On the off chance the files I downloaded were corrupted during download (had the problem a long long time ago), I'm going to try redownloading them from FP and reinstalling, just to be sure.
UPDATE 3:
It's works! I guess i did have a crappy installation and reinstalling it did work out fine. Missions are working fine (although it's neat how the ship handles). Game is working fine now, playing through some of the EM campaign, not running into any problems, tried some single player missons, all working fine for me.