Hard Light Productions Forums

Off-Topic Discussion => General Discussion => Topic started by: Stealth on November 04, 2003, 05:27:44 pm

Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 04, 2003, 05:27:44 pm
damn what an awesome movie.  what'd you guys think of it?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 04, 2003, 05:31:37 pm
It's out already?!
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: DragonClaw on November 04, 2003, 05:32:30 pm
Its out tomorrow. Stealth probably got some ripped version, or bribed the theatre. Newbie.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 04, 2003, 05:32:33 pm
It is there, still Nov 4th here :(

Still, I'll probs go see it this weekend :)

Flipside :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 04, 2003, 05:44:24 pm
Newbie.  or you could just be jealous.

yeah, i think you're just jealous :D


Anyway, there's always screeners, for almost every movie, which is usually a one time show where they show the movie, before it comes out.  most times movie theater employees get to see it then.


Pffftttt, bribed the theater?  hahahaha
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Blue Lion on November 04, 2003, 06:49:41 pm
Details?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 04, 2003, 07:23:16 pm
Currently getting a 22% positive ranking at Rotten Tomatoes (http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/MatrixRevolutions-1127201/). Ouch.

Still gonna see it though.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: DragonClaw on November 04, 2003, 07:26:06 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stealth
Newbie.  or you could just be jealous.

yeah, i think you're just jealous :D


Possibly... :cool:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 04, 2003, 08:27:14 pm
you've got to walk into the movie expecting non-stop action... badass action.

seraph is awesome.  he looks, talks, and everyone knows that he's a badass...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sandwich on November 05, 2003, 01:18:12 am
Seeing it 10pm tonight, GMT +2.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 01:24:24 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stealth
Newbie.  or you could just be jealous.

yeah, i think you're just jealous :D


Anyway, there's always screeners, for almost every movie, which is usually a one time show where they show the movie, before it comes out.  most times movie theater employees get to see it then.


Pffftttt, bribed the theater?  hahahaha


Yeah I suppose they are really just that jellous. Heh I allready saw it last friday. ;7 :D Yeah you are right. The movie rocked. Totally awesome.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 05, 2003, 02:55:44 am
Rotten Tomatoes is up to 38%. Yeah, I'm still gonna see it too, ZB.

Did you say Seraph? Hell ya, I was hoping something like that would happen with him. :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Gloriano on November 05, 2003, 03:37:43 am
yeah matrix revolution is awesome film Seraph rocks
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 04:27:40 am
Yeah totally. If you ask me...he's way better than Neo.
Trinity....meh
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 05, 2003, 09:32:57 am
Quote
Originally posted by Razor
Yeah totally. If you ask me...he's way better than Neo.
Trinity....meh


but he is way better than Neo.  he's from the first version of the matrix, therefore he's perfect, and undefeatable ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: J3Vr6 on November 05, 2003, 10:01:46 am
Some guy at work is gonna go see revolutions at the Imax theater.  Some people here have already seen it and they say it sucked.  I hope that's not true.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Ashrak on November 05, 2003, 10:31:43 am
iv got it the ticket for the 8th :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: J3Vr6 on November 05, 2003, 10:44:12 am
Let me ask this, does it tie up all the loose sends that were left in the 2nd movie?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 11:10:54 am
Mostly yes!
Now that the official premier is over (about 40 minutes ago) I may as well post a few spoilers. ;7
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 05, 2003, 11:21:30 am
Just got back. It was good, but not great. The action scenes were really well done.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 05, 2003, 11:31:53 am
If you guys want some spoilers for the ending:

Spoiler:

The machines are about to defeat the humans on the docks of Zion, when Morpheus arrives on the Hammer and triggers an EMP, killing all robots. The EMP deactivates all human equipment too, so they retreat to the main city and destroy all tunnels, but the machines are digging in.

Neo, meanwhile, got to the machine city (they imply there's only one, which is kind of stupid) and convinces the guy there (don't know who it is, some machine ruler or something) to end the hostilities if he can defeat Smith, who now has almost the whole matrix under control and will soon attack the machine city. Neo fights Smith, loses, but when Smith absorbs him something happens, and Smith is destroyed.

The machines leave Zion, everyone is happy, everyone who had been captured by Smith is restored, and the Oracle mentions that Neo (who apparently died and was taken somewhere by the machines) might be back.

The end.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 05, 2003, 11:39:12 am
JESUS CHRIST!

What a bunch of crap.

I regret paying $4 to see this movie.
I regret spending an hour in the bus stop afterwards.
I regret making my way through the camera man, the policemen and 800 fans to my seat.

Put it this way:
What we know will happen from the trailers and Reloaded:
Zion is attacked by machines. Neo encounters a big computer head, and battles Smith. Due to hollywood logic, the machines are defeated, and at least one main characters dies.

What happens: Zion is attacked by machines. Neo encounters a big computer head, and battles Smith. Due to hollywood logic, the machines are defeated, and at least one main characters dies.

Where's the revolution? Nope. No revolution. No actual plot. No character developement AT ALL. The SFX were lame. The action was drawn out. I actually cried "DIE ALREADY *****!" when a main character died.

Also, it was full of flaws. Most notably: It is established in the Matrix and also in Revolutions that whoever is posessed by an agent, dies. We learn that the Matrix has been conquered by Smiths. Everyone is Smith. Every Smith is killed. Ergo, everyone in the Matrix is killed.

Jeez. I want my two hours back.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 11:58:11 am
The movie was great.
What is the point of revolution. There is a revolution. Neo ends the war...he saves the humanity and establishes peace. The Matrix is destroyed and noone in it has died. We saw that Oracle was possesed by Smith...she returned. There is no Matrix in the matrix. It was a totally stupid idea and who ever thought of it doesn't even understand the Matrix at all. Neo's sacrifice saved both Machines from Smith and Humans from machines. There is no One. Neo and Smith are the One. As Oracle said, Neo is the positive, Smith is the negative of an equation. There is one equation and that is The One.
Smith+Neo=0 Why?
When Neo "destroyed" Smith in Matrix 1 his code got coppied onto Smith causing countless errors and flaws which enabled Smith to ALTER THE MATRIX THE WAY HE SAW FIT. The way he saw fit was to enslave everyone in the Matrix. Smith is a virus program...he took abilities from Neo (or Neo gave abilities to him) to fly, make enormous dammage and be able to copy himself.

Spoilers:

Trinity dies, We see the architech again, The oracle Seriph and that girl still live...The Architect promisses to free everyone from the matrix, Bane (Smith in the real world) fryes Neo's eyes so he is blind, Neo is able to see Bane and kills him
____________________________________________________
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 11:59:39 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
JESUS CHRIST!

What a bunch of crap.

I regret paying $4 to see this movie.
I regret spending an hour in the bus stop afterwards.
I regret making my way through the camera man, the policemen and 800 fans to my seat.

Put it this way:
What we know will happen from the trailers and Reloaded:
Zion is attacked by machines. Neo encounters a big computer head, and battles Smith. Due to hollywood logic, the machines are defeated, and at least one main characters dies.

What happens: Zion is attacked by machines. Neo encounters a big computer head, and battles Smith. Due to hollywood logic, the machines are defeated, and at least one main characters dies.

Where's the revolution? Nope. No revolution. No actual plot. No character developement AT ALL. The SFX were lame. The action was drawn out. I actually cried "DIE ALREADY *****!" when a main character died.

Also, it was full of flaws. Most notably: It is established in the Matrix and also in Revolutions that whoever is posessed by an agent, dies. We learn that the Matrix has been conquered by Smiths. Everyone is Smith. Every Smith is killed. Ergo, everyone in the Matrix is killed.

Jeez. I want my two hours back.


By the way...if you were unsatisfied with Reloaded you shouldn't have seen the Revolutions. Noone forced you to see it. You made your own CHOICE
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 05, 2003, 12:06:14 pm
who said I was unsatisfied with Reloaded?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 12:11:32 pm
Quote
No character developement AT ALL


Characters don't need development. We know what they all can do what are their strengths and weaknesses. Sound effects were awesome. The epic battle between Smith and Neo is the best part in the movie. Very intense and fantastically done. I am deffinetly gonna see this again.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 05, 2003, 12:15:15 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Razor


Characters don't need development.


And at this moment, Razor died.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 05, 2003, 12:28:45 pm
Hmmmmm.... shades of Dune (the book) here?

Flipside :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 12:28:58 pm
There is a difference between reality (this real world) and fiction (the film world). Obviously...you do not know the difference. Ok if you think that characters needed development lets see what kind of developments did you expect.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: neo_hermes on November 05, 2003, 12:32:19 pm
....
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 05, 2003, 12:34:35 pm
Razor. You're dead. You can't talk. You've already made clear that you've never seen real cinema. So shut up and be dead like you have to.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 12:37:45 pm
Quote
Razor. You're dead. You can't talk.  So shut up and be dead like you have to.

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

Quote
You've already made clear that you've never seen real cinema.


:wtf: :lol: :doubt:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Blue Lion on November 05, 2003, 12:53:54 pm
I thought it was alright....
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 05, 2003, 01:09:14 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
Also, it was full of flaws. Most notably: It is established in the Matrix and also in Revolutions that whoever is posessed by an agent, dies.
It established no such thing. The only people who died as a result of Agentification were the ones Our Heroes killed.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 05, 2003, 01:15:43 pm
ah.... all right, I misunderstood that part. But the smiths died anyway. Neo is (presumably) dead, and so should be everyone else whose bodies Smith inhabited.

Or Neo is not dead and we'll get a sequel.

He better be dead.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 01:25:30 pm
There will probably be no sequel. Unfortunately.
Well I wish there were.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: 01010 on November 05, 2003, 01:26:54 pm
Well, I've saved myself a fiver and/or a lengthy download using this here thread right here.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 05, 2003, 01:32:11 pm
I'm glad someone got something out of the thread.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 05, 2003, 01:32:14 pm
Actually, there is a sequel, in the form of The Matrix Online. :p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 05, 2003, 02:30:32 pm
yeah, my theories were wrong (for the most part... they had some truth though ;) )... i think the movie was overall excellent (just got back from seeing it again).

the movie was non-stop action, and i enjoyed it.  it did tie up all the loose ends, and while the ending wasn't what most people had hoped it would be, all loose ends were tied up and explained.

Also you have to remember, from what i heard they had a purpose in making three Matrix movies...  movie:

1)  Matrix - BIRTH - (Neo's beginning, he's freed and in essense is "born")

2)  Matrix Reloaded - LIFE - (Neo's life outside of the Matrix, and his life in general (recall that no main characters died in Reloaded, it was pretty much about his life)

3)  Matrix Revolutions - DEATH - (Neo dies)

it was a very good movie i think... the only reason not many of you like (or will like) it is because it's not what you expected ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 05, 2003, 02:39:58 pm
Ugh. I just came back from watching it. Nothing special IMHO. I mean, it doesen't stand on its own two feet as an independent movie. So I have to think of it as the end of Reloaded. But still...

The action was good. Lots of eye candy. But come on... It was a rather lame concluding "episode" to the whole thing...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Splinter on November 05, 2003, 02:42:10 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
JESUS CHRIST!

What a bunch of crap.

I regret paying $4 to see this movie.
I regret spending an hour in the bus stop afterwards.
I regret making my way through the camera man, the policemen and 800 fans to my seat.

Put it this way:
What we know will happen from the trailers and Reloaded:
Zion is attacked by machines. Neo encounters a big computer head, and battles Smith. Due to hollywood logic, the machines are defeated, and at least one main characters dies.

What happens: Zion is attacked by machines. Neo encounters a big computer head, and battles Smith. Due to hollywood logic, the machines are defeated, and at least one main characters dies.

Where's the revolution? Nope. No revolution. No actual plot. No character developement AT ALL. The SFX were lame. The action was drawn out. I actually cried "DIE ALREADY *****!" when a main character died.

Also, it was full of flaws. Most notably: It is established in the Matrix and also in Revolutions that whoever is posessed by an agent, dies. We learn that the Matrix has been conquered by Smiths. Everyone is Smith. Every Smith is killed. Ergo, everyone in the Matrix is killed.

Jeez. I want my two hours back.


EXACTLY! times X9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 9999999999999999999999999999

ARGH! Im going to murder the whicshkkoowzski (dont care how you spell it) brothers! :hopping:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 05, 2003, 02:45:28 pm
Though I have to say that I enjoyed the action and the movie. Its just that it was... lame. I can't explain why. Maybe its partly because it didn't end the way I wanted it to, perhaps it was because they suddenly threw all the dialogue out the window, maybe even because nothing really changed in the end.  I dunno. I just felt cheated.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 05, 2003, 03:53:02 pm
As of now, I think it could have been better. There's a good chance I'll change my opinion after watching it again.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sandwich on November 05, 2003, 05:14:30 pm
Lame, with some cool scenes (of course).

Plotwise the movie stunk to high heaven. I don't know how or why they pulled the Train Master out of their butts, but he was pointless. So was that whole thing with the "you're nowhere" non-location. Bleh.

They don't tell you who the french guy is, who Seraph is, who the ghosts from #2 were - nothing. And in the end, the only additional information you really have about the whole situation is what you got from the second movie, about Zion being wiped out and remade 7 times. Whoop-dee-doo. :rolleyes:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Windrunner on November 05, 2003, 05:20:55 pm
i have to agree with stunaep. the movie was in my point of view just OK. not more. the thing i liked the most was the battle in zion and the battle between neo and smith. thats all
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 05, 2003, 05:27:55 pm
I didn't really expect that Smith would overpower Neo. I belive that Smith was too powerfull because as he enslaves people by copying him slef...he takes their life force thus that makes him more powerfull. Even though Neo kicked his ass in the previous two movies Smith grew very very very strong. The battle was an epic scenario. Two sides...good and evil...battleing it out. The future of the world in the hands of either of them. Yeah! I bet that not even Volition could think of a such a great epic battle.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: 01010 on November 05, 2003, 05:30:14 pm
I think part of the problem lies with the potential the story has over what film decides to do with it.  I think that they'd make better books where the characters could stand to be developed more. Good action scenes though.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 05, 2003, 05:37:45 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Sandwich
I don't know how or why they pulled the Train Master out of their butts,


They don't tell you who the french guy is, who Seraph is, who the ghosts from #2 were - nothing.


Yeah the whole Train Master thing was pretty lame... but it brought out some funny scenes though, (like Neo trying to run through the tunnel ;) )

That was easy to figure out man!  "French Guy" - Former "One". Ghosts were programs.  Seraph is a program from the first Matrix.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Grey Wolf on November 05, 2003, 07:47:13 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Razor
:wtf: :lol: :doubt:
A bit OT, but can someone explain to me what the hell is up with the triple contradictory smile thing?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Charmande on November 05, 2003, 08:11:29 pm
Well... the war for Zion was great IMO.  It could have been a little more grand though, i mean they only had one of those "command towers', the one with the four or five big turret guns.  Also... they need something other than bullets... i didn't see a single missile or bomb or even a laser while they were fending off those sentinals.  don't the sentinals remind you of the Shivans?  it doesn't matter how many you kill cuz there's always a bajillion more.

Anyhow, the end was just pathetic, and neo's battle with agent smith wasn't nearly as great or as long as i would have liked.  Neo knocked smith into a wall, smith knocked neo into a wall, NOTHING NEW! :ick

But like reloaded, this movie was worth watching just for the action scenes, specifically the battle at Zion.

Quote
Posted by Razor...

Yeah! I bet that not even Volition could think of a such a great epic battle.


Volition already thought of a greater, epiccer battle, and it's called Freespace! :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 05, 2003, 08:20:36 pm
****
LALALALALALALALALALALALALALALALALALALA
****

I'm not reading this until I watch the movin on IMAX on friday...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Deepblue on November 06, 2003, 12:15:01 am
Quote
Originally posted by Charmande
Well... the war for Zion was great IMO.  It could have been a little more grand though, i mean they only had one of those "command towers', the one with the four or five big turret guns.  Also... they need something other than bullets... i didn't see a single missile or bomb or even a laser while they were fending off those sentinals.  don't the sentinals remind you of the Shivans?  it doesn't matter how many you kill cuz there's always a bajillion more.

Anyhow, the end was just pathetic, and neo's battle with agent smith wasn't nearly as great or as long as i would have liked.  Neo knocked smith into a wall, smith knocked neo into a wall, NOTHING NEW! :ick

But like reloaded, this movie was worth watching just for the action scenes, specifically the battle at Zion.

 

Volition already thought of a greater, epiccer battle, and it's called Freespace! :)

That is the funniest thing I have read all day.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sandwich on November 06, 2003, 02:12:48 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stealth
That was easy to figure out man!  "French Guy" - Former "One". Ghosts were programs.  Seraph is a program from the first Matrix.


Merv is a former one. Right. Convince me. :doubt:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 06, 2003, 02:53:59 am
Just got back from watching Revolutions earlier tonight. I really liked this movie. It played like a morality play: Neo is "Everyman" fighting against the Devil (aka Smith) who is his polar opposite. Neo and Smith fight, but it is only when Neo surrenders, stops fighting and gets "absorbed" by Smith that Neo wins the day and saves Zion. Neo still carried the original code the Architect mentioned in Reloaded, so when Smith absorbed him, the code spread to all the Smiths, then reasserted itself and "rebooted" the Matrix, thus freeing it from Smith's control.

What people might have missed is that Neo made a deal with Deus ex Machina (aka the big machine head in the Machine City aka the Original AI). Smith had absorbed EVERYONE in the Matrix and thus became a danger to even his fellow machines/programs. If Neo hadn't fought Smith, Smith would have eventually absorbed the machines in the real world. Smith proved that he could absorb humans in the real world when he took over Bane. It stands to reason that Smith might have also eventually found a way to absorb machines in the real world, thus even posing a threat to all the other AIs, including Deus ex Machina. So Neo bargained with Deus: Neo would kill Smith, thus ending the threat to the machines (and returing everyone still in the Matrix to normal) and in return, Deus would spare Zion.

The movie made sense to me...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Splinter on November 06, 2003, 03:03:58 am
Quote
Originally posted by Su-tehp What people might have missed is that Neo made a deal with Deus ex Machina (aka the big machine head in the Machine City aka the Original AI). Smith had absorbed EVERYONE in the Matrix and thus became a danger to even his fellow machines/programs. If Neo hadn't fought Smith, Smith would have eventually absorbed the machines in the real world. Smith proved that he could absorb humans in the real world when he took over Bane. It stands to reason that Smith might have also eventually found a way to absorb machines in the real world, thus even posing a threat to all the other AIs, including Deus ex Machina. So Neo bargained with Deus: Neo would kill Smith, thus ending the threat to the machines (and returing everyone still in the Matrix to normal) and in return, Deus would spare Zion.

The movie made sense to me...


you rirght i didnt get that part... wow and considering they mentioned it like 5 times in the movie itself i must be an idiot :lol:

the battle between neo and smith in the end was the greatest joke of the matrix series... there was not ONE cool move... flying bashing into each other OH WAIT! the rain exploding! WOW!!!! :doubt: so they fly he did that in the 2nd one... so they have huge strong punches... yeah thats whaat we want to see... the hulk, which by the way was better then this movie. they had crap in this movie for the "epic" battle they had big booms when they colided and thats it they fights were lame the flying was fine but it should be special like in the 2nd one where he does that crouch thing you know? that sends a tingle up my spine hehe. it should have been more like the fight seen in no.1 in the train station or in no.2 with 100 smiths

total let down. yes zion fight was cool.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 06, 2003, 03:32:36 am
After sleeping over this, I still come to the same conclusion. Its that nothing changed in the end that bothers me. I mean, in the first film NEO comes around and basically sets Smith free in the process. This creates a mess. A smith mess, that is adressed in the second film with Smith copying himself. Though its still only second to the danger posed by the machines on Zion. But I was still thinking from the first film that the ULTIMATE goal is to free all the people from the matrix. Anyway...

In the third movie, Smith's little escapades has reached epidemic proportions threatening now Machines as well as humans. And suddenly it takes center seat. As in its the largest problem now, and Neo must go and get rid of Smith to save humanity and also seing that it might pose a problem for the bots as well, cracks a deal in hopes that he can use it as leverage to help Zion. Deus Ex agrees, Neo goes in and fights, they cancel each other out. The end.

So what happened? Everything went back to the way it was. Sort of. Were back to square bloody one. Except Zion was saved this time, in a wreck with no ships ofcourse. And the Matrix rebooted again, with Humans having a choice to leave if they wish. But answer me this. If the humans are the machines source of power, I doubt the machines will let everyone go. Only the ones that "want" to leave. So in a sence the whole war has gone from a hot one to a cold one. The machines don't want to let go of the humans, so ofcouse it'll make them stay. Propaganda time.

So nothing changed, humans will still fight the machines in order to save humans from the matrix, albeit now a bit more quietly. So what was Neo good for? 2 things.

1. Keeping Zion around a bit longer.

2. Cleaning up his own mess. (Setting Smith loose)

Everythign that has a beggining has an end? Hmm. Ok, I can see that if you look at Neo. As in "You've had your time fooling around in the matrix buddy, time to die and give someone else a turn." But plot wise, its just a whole damn circle.

*Puts on a Smith voice*
"It was inevitable..."

Oh yeah, and that little girl... Whats her name, kitkat or whatever. So she has the über-powers now. Ok...

Meh... In the end it was all just a big reworking of Jesus's story.

Though, I must admit again, that even though the plot fell through the floor in the end, it was still a fun and entertaining movie to watch. Defenitely must be watched straight after two though. Cause its just the end of that movie. ITs not a stand alone film. Not by a long shot. Which is rarely a good thing.

Though watching the Zion fight, did make me need to close my eyes for a few seconds to get the to relax. I swear I was almost getting a seizure with all that flashing and stuff. But great eye candy! :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 06, 2003, 07:37:55 am
Quote
Originally posted by Sandwich
Merv is a former one. Right. Convince me. :doubt:

He may also be just another exile. Somewhat more powerful, perhaps, but still an exile.

I get the feeling that you want every single tidbit explained. That'd just be no fun. After all, what are the Shivans?

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
So what happened? Everything went back to the way it was. Sort of. Were back to square bloody one. Except Zion was saved this time, in a wreck with no ships ofcourse. And the Matrix rebooted again, with Humans having a choice to leave if they wish. But answer me this. If the humans are the machines source of power, I doubt the machines will let everyone go. Only the ones that "want" to leave. So in a sence the whole war has gone from a hot one to a cold one. The machines don't want to let go of the humans, so ofcouse it'll make them stay. Propaganda time.

Everyone connected to the Matrix now has the choice of staying there or waking up to the real world. The Architect explicitly says that. And he means it.

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
So nothing changed, humans will still fight the machines in order to save humans from the matrix, albeit now a bit more quietly.

The hell they will. Everyone is already free. Fighting to take people out of the Matrix would make no sense.

So the 'back to square one' thing is total bull****.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Devils_Hitman on November 06, 2003, 08:10:33 am
I thort it was a big load of crap, story was unsatisflying and the acting was terrible.

Also, why is there a matrix!!, machines can survive in space, why they **** dont they go up there and make a big solar array? lol, or just use fission.

bah, all a heap of crud, they should of stoped at matrix 1, that was awsome :P
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 06, 2003, 08:53:16 am
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan

The hell they will. Everyone is already free. Fighting to take people out of the Matrix would make no sense.

So the 'back to square one' thing is total bull****.


I don't think so. The Architech said "Those that want to leave." He never said anything about everyone being free. There never was any implication that everyone in the matrix is free. Would the machines REALLY just let go of its power source? And even if they would where would they all go? ZION? Hell they can barely live as they are. No. Things are back to the way they were on the most part, just that people in the matrix have choice now, IF they find out its a dream. I mean if what you say is true, then all the plot elements the Wachowski's are writing for Matrix Online is just bull. And MO is going to take place after Revolutions. So why play a game where you're fighting agents when in fact things should be all peacefull.

In the end the whole trilogy was just Neo's story. Like I read somewhere, 1st one was about birth, 2nd about life, 3rd about death. So I suppose the brothers left the whole matrix still hanging around cause it seems they have other plans for it and it still has the potential to dish out a few more Games/movies/comics/anime.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 06, 2003, 08:53:41 am
Quote
Originally posted by Devils_Hitman
Also, why is there a matrix!!, machines can survive in space, why they **** dont they go up there and make a big solar array? lol, or just use fission.

Because if they did, there wouldn't be much of a story. :p

Or maybe it was their intent to preserve humanity. Remember, in the beggining all they wanted was peace.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Devils_Hitman on November 06, 2003, 08:59:09 am
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan

Because if they did, there wouldn't be much of a story. :p

Or maybe it was their intent to preserve humanity. Remember, in the beggining all they wanted was peace.


lol, did u watch the animatrix?, humans started it.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 06, 2003, 09:08:02 am
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
I don't think so. The Architech said "Those that want to leave." He never said anything about everyone being free. There never was any implication that everyone in the matrix is free.

If you took the ones that want to stay in the Matrix out of it, how free would they be?

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Would the machines REALLY just let go of its power source?

Not everyone would leave the Matrix. In fact, I'm betting a lot of people would rather stay there.

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
And even if they would where would they all go? ZION? Hell they can barely live as they are.

But humanity is not at war anymore. The surface can be rebuilt.

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
No. Things are back to the way they were on the most part, just that people in the matrix have choice now, IF they find out its a dream.

I could be wrong, as I've watched the movie just once, but from what I understood, people would be given the choice of waking up.

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
I mean if what you say is true, then all the plot elements the Wachowski's are writing for Matrix Online is just bull. And MO is going to take place after Revolutions. So why play a game where you're fighting agents when in fact things should be all peacefull.

I haven't played Matrix Online yet, nor have I read the story the Wachowski brothers are writing for it. So I can't comment on it.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 06, 2003, 09:09:50 am
Quote
Originally posted by Devils_Hitman
lol, did u watch the animatrix?, humans started it.

:wtf:
That's what I just said.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 06, 2003, 09:12:25 am
okay, let me adress one thing.

Let's assume for one, that Neo is dead. He died, because the Smith inside him exploded. Because somehow the Deus Ex did it. So did every other smith, as a chain reaction. So, everyone else in the matrix should also be dead.

Also, the machine are going to freely let go of every human who wants to leave the matrix. They're going to give up their food. I can live with that. Only it means there will be a sequel.

Also, the Reloaded ended with a lot of questions. The philosophical jibba-jabba the Architect made about the previous ones, the people who were supposed to rebuild the matrix, the door Neo was supposed to choose, cause and effect, the entire shiznit with the Merovingian, Persephone, The Trainman, the Twins (who even didn't ****ing appear in the second movie), is paid off how in Revolutions?

It's not.

You can pose unanswered questions in a Andrei Tarkovski film. Not in a hollywood money hog.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 06, 2003, 09:23:07 am
Ok. I guess people could go to the surface to live. Since its peace time. But then what Dozer said about Zion being the last remnant of humanity cause its close to the core, where its warm, wouldn't make sence. I mean, they went there because it was warm. So it means it would mean the surface is inhospitable. But people are resilient, and not having ten thousand squiddies breathing down your neck also probably makes the difference for people to find a way to live on the surface.

Matrix Online isn't out yet though. I've only read the FAQ at its website. www.matrixonline.com . So I don't know what they're going to write, but it did say that the brothers are writing for it. And continuing the story. And since fighting is going to be big in it as its also a MMORPG I came to the conclusiion that all is not well still in the Matrix.  Though I wouldn't mind if the Wachowski's would write the Matrix as books from now on. That wouldn't be bad. Cheap too.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: 01010 on November 06, 2003, 11:54:49 am
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Though I wouldn't mind if the Wachowski's would write the Matrix as books from now on. That wouldn't be bad. Cheap too.


That's what I'm saying, less emphasis on *WOW KABOOM BADOOSH* and more on plot and character developmen. Plus no Keanu Reeves.

Woah.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 06, 2003, 12:28:30 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Ok. I guess people could go to the surface to live. Since its peace time. But then what Dozer said about Zion being the last remnant of humanity cause its close to the core, where its warm, wouldn't make sence. I mean, they went there because it was warm. So it means it would mean the surface is inhospitable. But people are resilient, and not having ten thousand squiddies breathing down your neck also probably makes the difference for people to find a way to live on the surface.


This just occurred to me: After watching the Animatrix: Second Renaissance, I can't help but think that the military must have had a way to reverse Project Black Star.

"Hmm, if we darken the sky, that means all the plants on Earth's surface won't be able to grow. If the plants don't grow that means all the herbivore animals will starve. If the herbivores starve, then the carnivore animals will starve. And if all the animals and plants are dead, then we humans won't have anything to eat. And if us humans don't have anything to eat, we'll all starve to death. But since the Machines are about to wipe us all out anyway, let's go ahead and royally f*ck with Earth's biosphere so we can take the Machines out with us. YIPPEE!!!!!" *insert frenzied applause here*

Wait, that sarcastic remark just illustrated why the military might NOT have had an antidote to Project Black Star... My bad. :o

Still, with humans and machines working together now, they just might find a way to reverse the scorching of the sky. And if not... well, if all I had to look forward to in the real world was eating a bowl of amino acid snot every day for the rest of my life, I'd probably stay in the Matrix too. Go figure...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 06, 2003, 03:27:49 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
Also, the machine are going to freely let go of every human who wants to leave the matrix. They're going to give up their food. I can live with that. Only it means there will be a sequel.

...Why?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 06, 2003, 03:32:07 pm
It has been stated that there will be no more Matrix Films.

As for this movie.... The ending, was I the only person to whom the phrase 'more luck than judgement' came to mind?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Blue Lion on November 06, 2003, 04:23:33 pm
Who said the humans were going to be freed? I never saw that anywhere.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 06, 2003, 05:19:50 pm
In the end when the Architech speaks to the oracle he mentions that those that wish to go free can go free. Which in my oppinion is only a handfull.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 06, 2003, 05:23:24 pm
Well, there were humans willing to kill just to get back in again!

If I were offered a choice between 'reality' and a ShangriLa existence such as the first Matrix, I somewhat think I'd be asking 'Where do I plug in?'

Flipside :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 06, 2003, 05:29:39 pm
You know, I would have left the theater happy if Neo would have instead decided to go medieval on their ass and just use his über-powers to blow the big flying face to pieces, along with all the city. Or To make things more simple. Just use EMP on the Logos and wipe out the city, the Matrix, and Smith. Problem solved, the end. Oh well. Atleast it didn't end in "It was all a dream" way.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 06, 2003, 07:04:52 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Sandwich


Merv is a former one. Right. Convince me. :doubt:


OK.  here's why i think that (I thought the hints they threw were quite easy to catch).  

Obviously the "One" can, when his purpose is complete, either return to the mainframe and face deletion, or hide in the matrix... the Oracle stated that this is the choice determining all "completed" programs.  Obviously the merovingian decided to stay in the Matrix.  here's the two reasons why i think that's the case:

1) (biggest reason):  Perciphone wanted Neo to kiss her.  she said she wanted a REAL kiss, because she wanted to "remember" what it felt like to get a kiss like that.  she said "a long time ago, when we first came here" or something like that... meaning that a long time ago, the Merovingian was the same as Neo... which was why she wanted the kiss from him.  she also said that "such a thing was not meant to last"... she knew that in the end their love would die somehow, as it did between the Merovingian and Perciphone, so it did between Neo and Trinity (she was right, because she'd experienced this before, she was in the place of Trinity)

2) When Neo, Trinity, the keymaker, and Morpheus faced the Merovingian, and his bodyguards in the armory (Matrix: Reloaded) Neo says "You go after the keymaker, i'll handle them".  The Merovingian is disgusted, and says "You'll 'handle' us?  You know your predecessors had a lot more respect".  I think that although he doesn't outright say that he was a former one, i think he was "The One" from either the first or the second matrix, probably the first... and he'd obviously faced "The One" before, but he also showed us that Neo was different from the others (remember he ordered his men to fire guns at Neo, and when Neo stops the bullets he says "OK, you have some skill"... this shows that Neo is different from the previous "One"s that he's faced).  I think it would make sense that he was a former one.  Probably the first "One" because he's one of the most powerful programs out there, and it would make sense that he's from the first "Matrix" because the first Matrix was perfect, and extremely efficient, so therefore all of its programs would be too.  Note Seraph and the Oracle, who are both also from the first Matrix... Seraph is highly respected, as is The Oracle, so it would make sense that the Merovingian is too.  he's able to hack the Matrix (as is Neo), which leads me to the final point:

3)  The Merovingian (a "One" whose program has expired and has sought refuge in the Matrix still maintaining his skill as a programmer, etc.) says to Neo (in Reloaded) (as he sends the blonde woman the chocolate cake) "You see it do you not Neo?", and at that point Neo looks and you see what Neo sees... the Matrix code (everything made of numbers) and you see the cake glowing gold... he then says that he's programmed it himself.  how would the Merovingian know that Neo can see the Matrix.  Only the One can see the Matrix code from within the Matrix... it's part of his programming, and if the Merovingian can see it too, then obviously he was also a former "One"

It's just my theory, but i think it makes sense :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 06, 2003, 07:12:16 pm
you're all missing what they stated in the end (well, a lot of you)...  the war is OVER... which means machines don't control humans anymore.  the humans were given a choice (the architect clearly said that at the end) and those that wish to stay in the Matrix can, and those that want out will be allowed to be out.  I mean, i'm sure most of them would want to stay in the Matrix... it's the world they're used to!

Quote
Also, the Reloaded ended with a lot of questions. The philosophical jibba-jabba the Architect made about the previous ones, the people who were supposed to rebuild the matrix, the door Neo was supposed to choose, cause and effect, the entire shiznit with the Merovingian, Persephone, The Trainman, the Twins (who even didn't ****ing appear in the second movie), is paid off how in Revolutions?


Everything happened because Neo chose the door to go save Trinity, NOT to save the people of Zion... that was cause and effect.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Splinter on November 07, 2003, 01:52:54 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stealth
you're all missing what they stated in the end (well, a lot of you)...  the war is OVER... which means machines don't control humans anymore.  the humans were given a choice (the architect clearly said that at the end) and those that wish to stay in the Matrix can, and those that want out will be allowed to be out.  I mean, i'm sure most of them would want to stay in the Matrix... it's the world they're used to!


ok im not sure that I watched the same movie as ALL of you because all of you say that the Architect says in the end about those who want to be free will be free but as I recall it went like this: Oracle "And the others?" Architect "they will be freed." yeah maybe im mistaken but that dosnt occour often when quoting movies ;7

but so many of you thought it was the other way around im not so sure this time so dont kill me if im tottaly off.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: neo_hermes on November 07, 2003, 02:51:05 am
i think you right splinter....
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: TrashMan on November 07, 2003, 03:44:22 am
Crappy movie....too many plot holes!

Too many logic holes...
A program that can see into the future? (Oracle)  - forget about the stupid loop theory, no one can determine what actions a human will take - let's face it - we're too unpredictable!

Neo dies, and then suddenly he's alive again?

Bah.. I can go on like this for hours, but I just don't have the time now...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 07, 2003, 04:22:26 am
The only hole I can find in your theory, Stealth, is that Morpheus states that the earlier one (the one immediately before the current Neo) died (after which the Oracle prophesied his return). Not much of a point, but I always thought that the previous Ones all died of old age in Zion.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 05:04:43 am
The war isn't over. When that kid was running around screaming "The war is over!" I think it was just him being overly happy. You could hear from the tone of the Architechs voice when he said "How long do you think this 'peace' will last?" and the oracle said "As long as it can." That means that it almost only seems like a cease fire, since both of them seem rather doubtfull that this was the END of the war.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 07, 2003, 05:09:01 am
Yes, in fact it was the previous 'one' that freed Morpheus, he said as much in Matrix 1.

To be honest, they should have donated the money for the last 2 filmsto Tron 2 ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 05:19:25 am
Wohoo! I agree... :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 07, 2003, 05:46:34 am
What you don't know is that, fifteen minutes after the movie was over, the machines decided to double-cross Neo (who's dead anyway) and obliterated Zion.

:p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 07, 2003, 06:20:50 am
LOL

IF NEO <> BREATHING
LET PROMISE = NOT(TRUE)
ELSE GOSUB(PANIC)

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Wohoo! I agree... :D


Can you imagine the Tron Storyline where the programs have Matrixesque abilities :)

That WOULD be cool ;)

Flipside :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 07, 2003, 06:36:41 am
Yeah, well, having been prepared by all you lot, I watched Revolutions solely for the effects. I wasn't disappointed. ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 07, 2003, 07:48:11 am
yeah i wasn't disappointed either :D

and Setekh:  that's true, but it's the only thing that explains the Merovingian... and particularly why Perciphone wanted to kiss Neo... you understand what i'm saying, right?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 07, 2003, 07:51:30 am
Cool. Me, myself didn't have this thread to look at before the film, and the last three films I saw before the matrix were also special-effects reels, so I guess that's why I hate the third sequel with a passion.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Gloriano on November 07, 2003, 08:04:26 am
i just waited too much from Matrix revolution much better ending
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 07, 2003, 09:56:29 am
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
That means that it almost only seems like a cease fire, since both of them seem rather doubtfull that this was the END of the war.

The war is over. It's just that the Oracle and the Architect can't know for sure if humans really learned the lesson. But they explicitly hope we did.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 10:16:11 am
But how do you know its over? Where in the film is it certain the war is over? Except for a kid who sees the squiddies turn tail and gets happy and does a Jimmy Stewart from "It's a Wonderful Life"? And back to Matrix Online, if its over there would be no story in the follow up game. And then the whole thing about "Will we see Neo again?" And the oracle replying with something like "Probably" means that there will come a time again when things heat up again and people will need him again. Or actually, people are not happy and he emerges from their discontent which was pritty much the boiled down reason the architech gave in the 2nd movie.

It just seems like they couldn't tie things up because the matrix seemed like too much of a good comodity for WB and probably forced the brothers with lots of money to leave the end open for later developments. I'm not specifically saying films, I heard they wont make any anymore. But IE books/games/comics/anime series/collecting cards/cereal you name it. Its just how the business "over there" works nowadays.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: phreak on November 07, 2003, 11:10:13 am
i saw it on wednesday.  nice movie and special effects.  can't say i liked the final fight between neo and smith, but it did make sense since -neo=smith so smith+neo=0.  also with neo's death, smith had no purpose and got deleted.  i guess we were expecting so much due to the hype and nothing would have satisfied us.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 07, 2003, 11:26:25 am
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
But how do you know its over? Where in the film is it certain the war is over?

What did you expect, some kind of written agreement signed by both machines and men? Not even that would warrant eternal peace.

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
And back to Matrix Online, if its over there would be no story in the follow up game.

We don't have Matrix Online yet. You can't make assumptions based on it.

Also, Merovingian and his fellow exiles are able to withstand one more reboot. And they don't seem to behave nicely.

Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
And then the whole thing about "Will we see Neo again?" And the oracle replying with something like "Probably" means that there will come a time again when things heat up again and people will need him again. Or actually, people are not happy and he emerges from their discontent which was pritty much the boiled down reason the architech gave in the 2nd movie.

The One will rise again when the Matrix needs upgrades.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 12:04:51 pm
...grumble... I dunno... It was just a weak movie in my oppinion. But I see what your getting at. But all the more reason why I dislike it. It wasn't a definitive conclusion to a Trilogy. Singular movies don't need to have a definitive ending, but a trilogy must damnwell wrap everything, and I mean everything up in the end. Especially when the whole thing was designed to be a trilogy.

In my oppinion its just a cop out to leave it "open" for more. meh...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Blue Lion on November 07, 2003, 01:09:51 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
In the end when the Architech speaks to the oracle he mentions that those that wish to go free can go free. Which in my oppinion is only a handfull.



But he's talking to the Oracle, you never thought maybe they meant programs and not humans?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 01:13:58 pm
Oooh... Good point. :yes:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Falcon X on November 07, 2003, 01:23:15 pm
It was designed as two movies... not three.  The second just go too long.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sheepy on November 07, 2003, 01:34:08 pm
on the point about merv being a one ... the fact that he says its his job to know things and to collect infomation about 100 times in the second and third films doesnt slightly indicate that he a program to do just that? :rolleyes: :p

Also neo and smith fight, anyone else think itwas dragonball minus the fireballs?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 07, 2003, 01:40:34 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Sheepy
Also neo and smith fight, anyone else think itwas dragonball minus the fireballs?


Yep. I felt cheated when Neo didn't end the fight with a huge Kamehameha or whatever. :p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: phreak on November 07, 2003, 01:41:38 pm
Quote

Also neo and smith fight, anyone else think itwas dragonball minus the fireballs?


thinking the exact same thing.  i was waiting for Neo to vape smith with a fireball.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sheepy on November 07, 2003, 01:42:59 pm
would of made the movie that little more intresting if you asked me :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 07, 2003, 01:53:33 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
It wasn't a definitive conclusion to a Trilogy.

Then you might want to give an example of what a definitive conclusion could be. Please.

Quote
Originally posted by Blue Lion
But he's talking to the Oracle, you never thought maybe they meant programs and not humans?

That doesn't make much sense. The conversation was about the newfound peace with men.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 03:04:13 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan

Then you might want to give an example of what a definitive conclusion could be. Please.
 


Return of the Jedi.
Return of the King.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 07, 2003, 03:13:02 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Return of the Jedi.
Return of the King.


I think he meant a conclusion to the Matrix story. And indeed, it would be hard to do something different without being ridiculously silly, cheesy, disappointing or stupid.

But that's just me.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sheepy on November 07, 2003, 03:25:45 pm
anouther point, you all complain about the possibilty of neo still being alive, if you remember the matrix doesnt work with out the one, so inevitably hes going to turn up again in some shape or form ... wait actaully, it wouldnt have to be neo would it ... ah well
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 07, 2003, 03:36:54 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Sheepy
anouther point, you all complain about the possibilty of neo still being alive, if you remember the matrix doesnt work with out the one, so inevitably hes going to turn up again in some shape or form ... wait actaully, it wouldnt have to be neo would it ... ah well


yeah, it wouldn't have to be Neo, because all "One" programs were inserted in different people.

and remember that now that the machines and men are at peace, there is no use for "the One" program ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sheepy on November 07, 2003, 03:39:06 pm
isnt the one actually bi product of people in the matrix having a choice in some way or another? or did get that bit wrong, i dunno, and we know the matrix is still running, cause there still in it at the end.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 07, 2003, 03:40:08 pm
The One is not necessary now that people are free to choose between the Matrix or the real world...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sheepy on November 07, 2003, 03:44:33 pm
they already had choice, just they didnt really know about it, thats what i got from the whole confusing architect(sp?) scence at the end of reloaded.

Gah **** knows, i dont really care, the film wasnt too bad, got the adrenaline pumping at times, plot wasnt much but it entertained me in the way of big bright fight scenes ... so all in all it gets a thumbs up :yes: (im an easily pleased person)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 04:12:53 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Styxx


I think he meant a conclusion to the Matrix story.


Ah ok...

Well I dunno. I would have been happy with Neo in the end just using the EMP on the Logos. Or perhaps just destroying the machines in some über-mega plasma ball way in the real world, using his new found powers, freeing everyone, clearing up the clouds and just having everything be just dandy. Hell Neo could have died in that ending too, consuming himself in the blast,but at least it would all be over. No more machines, no more matrix, bo more clouds. Clean slate. We start again. And the a bloody clichéd monoluge by that bratty kid who used the APU, speaking about how everyone went back to the surface, helped the people from the matrix restart their lives and finally have a flashforward a hundred years to the future where people are living in cities again, kiddies playing in the park and a Statue of Neo in his Revolutions pose :D made out of black granite. Hell, throw in the even worse clichéd scene with a little girl and an old woman walking by with the girl looknig up at Neo and asking "Who is that Grandma?" The old lady smiles and replies "Oh thats a long story..." Pan to the sky that is partly cloudy and birds flying past the cam. And if you wanna bloody totally top it all off and STILL not want something definitive but just a final twist, you can add a little glitch where you see the matrix code for a second and then cut to credits.

*looks up...*
 :blah:

Ok. So its clichéd but definitive, and I would have been happier with that ending too. :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 07, 2003, 04:37:48 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Ah ok...

Well I dunno. I would have been happy with Neo in the end just using the EMP on the Logos. Or perhaps just destroying the machines in some über-mega plasma ball way in the real world, using his new found powers, freeing everyone, clearing up the clouds and just having everything be just dandy. Hell Neo could have died in that ending too, consuming himself in the blast,but at least it would all be over. No more machines, no more matrix, bo more clouds. Clean slate. We start again. And the a bloody clichéd monoluge by that bratty kid who used the APU, speaking about how everyone went back to the surface, helped the people from the matrix restart their lives and finally have a flashforward a hundred years to the future where people are living in cities again, kiddies playing in the park and a Statue of Neo in his Revolutions pose :D made out of black granite. Hell, throw in the even worse clichéd scene with a little girl and an old woman walking by with the girl looknig up at Neo and asking "Who is that Grandma?" The old lady smiles and replies "Oh thats a long story..." Pan to the sky that is partly cloudy and birds flying past the cam. And if you wanna bloody totally top it all off and STILL not want something definitive but just a final twist, you can add a little glitch where you see the matrix code for a second and then cut to credits.

*looks up...*
 :blah:

Ok. So its clichéd but definitive, and I would have been happier with that ending too. :D


Well, that definately breaks no cheesyness clause. :D

And I think I'd kill them if they had the ending with the glitch like that. :p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 07, 2003, 04:56:59 pm
Yeah. I think the glitch would have been too far. Just ending with everyone being happy and the machines dissasembled and used as pavement blocks or lamp posts. A total "Humanity wins! YEEE!" feeling. You can even cut out the monologue and the flashforward to the future, and just had it end with Neo going Supernova after killing Smith, destroying the machines, freeing everyone in the matrix and clearing up the sky. Cut to Zion and all the machines stop working. A bit Like Episode 1, but atleast humans won in the end. And the kid can happily scream "The War is over!" and actually mean it and then cut to credits.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 07, 2003, 06:09:32 pm
Oh. My. God.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 07, 2003, 07:52:25 pm
Quote
Originally posted by PhReAk
i saw it on wednesday.  nice movie and special effects.  can't say i liked the final fight between neo and smith, but it did make sense since -neo=smith so smith+neo=0.  also with neo's death, smith had no purpose and got deleted.  i guess we were expecting so much due to the hype and nothing would have satisfied us.


Totally agree, especially with the -neo=smith bit... I felt really happy when I figured that out. Kinda reminds me of Phantom Menace... too much hype ruins it.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 08, 2003, 12:57:54 am
Quote
Originally posted by Sheepy
on the point about merv being a one ... the fact that he says its his job to know things and to collect infomation about 100 times in the second and third films doesnt slightly indicate that he a program to do just that? :rolleyes: :p


Yeah, I never thought the theory of the Merovingian being a former One made sense either. Besides, in Reloaded, after the fight with the Merovingian's goons, the Merv said to Neo, "Mark my words, boy, and mark them well. I survived your predecessors, and I will survive you!"

If Merv was a former One, wouldn't he have said "our predecessors" instead of "your predecessors?":wtf:

Just a thought...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 08, 2003, 01:27:21 am
I think DA's 'old woman' idea woulda been the best, but ending it with the statue of Neo being totally old and ruined, covered in bird-crap and what-not, the accompanying plaque having long-since been faded to little more than a dull plate of metal. Kids swinging off the arms and chasing each other around it. Then we pan out a little to see a robot walking along with a spong-mop and a bucket of soapy water. It reaches its mop into the bucket, lifts it to the statue to clean it off, then, at the last possible moment, pulls back the mop, picks up the bucket and walks off down the street...........
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 08, 2003, 01:32:05 am
And in regard to the Smith and Neo thing, it's kinda obvious that if Neo is The One™, then it follows that Smith would be The Nothing™.

Neo creates peace, harmony and prosperity for both man and machine-kind. Smith destroys everything.

Basically, the whole personal battle between Smith and Neo equates to a simple true/false statement.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sandwich on November 08, 2003, 02:49:56 am
...Yeah!! Neo and Smith are like matter and anti-matter....... PING-PONG BALLS!!!! :hopping:

Seriously, I think the Neo-Smith showdown at the end is right up there with the Yoda-Dooku battle in the annals of, erm... Anal Good Guy v.s. Bad Guy™ records. *shudder*
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 08, 2003, 04:44:59 am
The Neo vs. Smith fight scene at the end was possibly the worst in the film.  It was far TOO unrealistic.  I think the choreographer took the day off when they made it.

On the other hand, the Defence of Zion was pretty cool.  Lotsa BIG guns...

Story as a whole: not unpredictable.  It's quite interesting to look back at the various predictions people made about where the story would go.  Everyone was looking for really tiny insignificant details pointing to a surprising ending, while totally disregarding the KISS principle, 'Keep It Simple, Stupid'.
They should've been looking for an overall trend, eg. the series tending towards being a pure action movie.  I kinda guessed that it was going to end up just being a showdown between Neo and Smith that saves the day.  Nothing complicated, just a bog-standard Good vs. Evil last stand.  Pretty pathetic end to a great series.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 08, 2003, 05:00:34 am
Quote
Originally posted by an0n
...Then we pan out a little to see a robot walking along with a spong-mop and a bucket of soapy water. It reaches its mop into the bucket, lifts it to the statue to clean it off, then, at the last possible moment, pulls back the mop, picks up the bucket and walks off down the street...........


Yeah, that would have been even beter! :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 08, 2003, 07:36:02 am
Now, that I've seen The Matrix Reloaded again, I'm really awed by how much superior it was to the third part. And how much weaker it was compared to the first part.

Reloaded had a lot more interesting fight scenes, because they had style, and did what the Matrix was famous for, only better. Revolutions did the big-ass robot vs. man-robot battle, we've seen oh so many times in oh so many films before.

Reloaded made the philosophical babble look actually bettter than something pulled from 6th grade literature, plus it actually tied in with the story. Too bad they didn't pay off on that. In Revolutions the philosophy seemed out of place, had the definitive 6th grade feeling to it and was as crappily written as the rest of the dialogue.

Reloaded didn't have any characters shouting "MWAHAHAHA"

Reloaded had the Merovingian actually seem like he was important somehow. Turns out, his not.

Reloaded had the oh-so-cool Twins, that were TOTALLY forgotten about in the second film.

Reloaded had the architect, who explained various ****, that at the time seemed actually relevant.

Which reminds me, if Neo was one of many ones, how did the other Ones defeat their counterpart Smiths. And how did that end in the destruction of Zion, if seemingly the only way to defeat the Smiths was to do what Neo did?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: aldo_14 on November 08, 2003, 07:53:05 am
Quote
Originally posted by an0n
And in regard to the Smith and Neo thing, it's kinda obvious that if Neo is The One™, then it follows that Smith would be The Nothing™.

Neo creates peace, harmony and prosperity for both man and machine-kind. Smith destroys everything.

Basically, the whole personal battle between Smith and Neo equates to a simple true/false statement.


No.... Snith would be The Minus One

1+0 = 1   1+(-1) = 0
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Bobboau on November 08, 2003, 09:01:01 am
negitive one
or
anti-one
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Kazan on November 08, 2003, 09:03:49 am
it makes sense for the architect to let go of the humans who want out go out - it balances the equasion
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 08, 2003, 09:47:16 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
Now, that I've seen The Matrix Reloaded again, I'm really awed by how much superior it was to the third part. And how much weaker it was compared to the first part.

yeah, that's your opinion, and i share the same opinion with you :)


Reloaded didn't have any characters shouting "MWAHAHAHA"
i agree that was possibly the stupidest part of the whole movie

Reloaded had the Merovingian actually seem like he was important somehow. Turns out, his not.
actually he's still one of the most powerful programs out there apparently.  remember, he'd be powerful enough if he controlled the Trainmaster, but in addition to that he controls much, much more... he's powerful, and rich, why do you think Trinity, Morpheus, and Neo went to him in the second movie and went to him again in the third movie.  they wouldn't have gone asking him if he wasn't powerful ;)

Reloaded had the oh-so-cool Twins, that were TOTALLY forgotten about in the second film.
yeah, but the third film had Seraph, who was also cool :D... i did miss the twins though :-/

Reloaded had the architect, who explained various ****, that at the time seemed actually relevant.
the architect confused more people than actually understood :lol: :)

Which reminds me, if Neo was one of many ones, how did the other Ones defeat their counterpart Smiths. And how did that end in the destruction of Zion, if seemingly the only way to defeat the Smiths was to do what Neo did?
because the other Ones didn't have to face the counterpart Smiths... Neo was a "special" One... the architect said it, the Merovingian said it, everyone knew that he was different from the others.  The Smith episode was what led to the peace between mankind and machines, because the machines feared that soon Smith would be powerful enough to beat them... and at that point Neo was the only one that had a chance to beat Smith, which was why the machines used him.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 08, 2003, 10:37:50 am
So in the end Smith saved Christmas? :p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 08, 2003, 10:46:58 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stealth
That was easy to figure out man!  "French Guy" - Former "One".


:confused: No.....
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: TrashMan on November 08, 2003, 11:52:33 am
STUPID!
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: beatspete on November 08, 2003, 04:03:47 pm
umm, the twins got blown up, after morph slashed the SUV.


Anyway, I've just seen Revolution and I think it makes a lot more sense than part2.  
As you've been saying,
smith+neo=0.
Which is kinda true.
But consider what the oracle and architect say over the last 2 films says.  She says that smith is the opposite to neo (who's there to balance out the imperfection of choice). Although neo is a person, he still has the power[i/] of a program(*) - possibly given to him by a subprogram - as the theory of choice cannot be created by machines alone.
In part 2 we get the fact that the programs that are no longer needed are tried to be deleted - such as the agents going after the keymaker. When smith absorbs neo in part 3, smith no longer has anybody to balance out.  Thus, he is deleted by the machines, and smith dies.

How the matrix is reset, i dont know. The Architect seems rather annoyed at the end that it has. This time, he may have realised that by giving humans more awareness of the choice, that neo is no longer needed - ie the humans who want to leave will be allowed to.  This is the answer to the problem of smith, since without neo smith is obsolete.


Overall, I liked part 3 as much as part 1.  Part 2 made to many questions, but they were answered in part 3.
The Dock fight was really cool. Actually all the stuff out of the matrix was a good laugh anyway.

The smith v neo end fight? Not realistic by this world's terms, but we arent in the matrix.  As programs, smith and neo(^*) can alter the matrix, including its physical properties.  They dont actually fly, they just move themselves in the matrix.
As for you people who ***** about the rain explosion effects, cars being flung about etc, its just the effects on the matrix, and the programs governing rain, cars etc.  Such changes in the basic physics of the matrix is bound to have effects on the programs based on them.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: 01010 on November 08, 2003, 04:23:53 pm
Quote
Originally posted by beatspete
Snip!


Without doubt the most rational and level headed analysis I've seen on the entire internet.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Kamikaze on November 08, 2003, 05:51:49 pm
****ty. They should have left it at the 1st movie. The only thing that saved that movie was the excellent effects, but even those were often badly used (e.g. near the end with all the shockwaves). Also, trinity's death was so predictable it wasn't even funny. I feel they killed her off pointlessly as well. In fact, I think alot of the story was utterly pointless.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 08, 2003, 06:27:54 pm
Hmmmmmm..... I think my main problem with the Matrix thing is that you would have thought a computer programming itself would logically take the optimal route. It's logic. When Bobboau wanted to create Glowing surfaces on ships, he would hardly have created a single pixel that then has to complete a pile of obscure tasks, killing off lots of other pixels at the same time, and then, should the pixel do the right thing at the right time, it will glow? It's just seems an incredibly long winded and wasteful technique?
Would have made a boring film though ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 08, 2003, 06:55:05 pm
Hmmm... I just watched it again. But I did something this time that was different. I watched it DIRECTLY after seeing Reloaded. The film instantly works better. Even Reloaded was better after seeing Revolutions because things now made sense, almost in a crazy way as if now you're seeing what the Oracle has seen. You know what will happen, so all these little hints and nuances in the film become clearer. So the 3rd film definitely improved the 2nd film. But watching the 3rd film worked better for me this time around only becuase I saw the second 10 minutes before! These films MUST be watched one after the other. Not the 1st film, but 2 and 3. They're the same movie. And when you watch it like that, then the whole mess has an actual beggining, middle, and end. Its finally cohesive.

So what I was basically saying that the film was empty, still holds true if you watch it as a seperate movie, but when you watch it directly after 2, they merge to form one film. Thus making the experience better IMHO.

I've also now have mixed feelings about the end. At the beggining as you saw, I was totally against it, hated it. But now... I dunno... I understood more. Yeah, its still a Jesus trilogy, that being obvious from the first movie. But it is a rather honest and almost noble ending if you think about it. This guy gets pulled out of his happy life to find out that it was all a lie, he then goes thru hell getting out of it, gets spoon fed this concept that he will save humanity and is the savior, he dies, comes back, starts believing in himself, finally gets together with his new identity only for that to be once again shot down, once again findoing out his 2nd life was nothing but a BS lie. Now he doesen't know who the hell he is, what is happening to him, finding out all he is fighting for is about to get destroyed, he suddenly goes blind, and loses his girl twice. Half of that would have probaly forced a normal guy to put a 9 cal. bullet firmly into their brain. But this guy, in the end a normal guy decides to still do the right thing and go to the heart of his enemy and try to form a peace.

I guess he realised there could never have been a total victory, he even found out that the machines weren't all evil. They were just pushed too far and were forced to do whats necessary in order to survive. Just like humans. So the only way in order to stop this whole thing was to call a truce. Which would never had happened if Smith wouldn't have posed a risk to the machine world.  

BUT. Watching Revolutions again I still think that not all humans were set free from the matrix. Having the conversation still fresh in my mind the oracle asked "What about the others?"
"What others?" The architech asked.
"The ones that want out..."
"Obviously they will be freed."

So its still seems she only talking about a few people that know of the reality of the matrix.

And it seemed like Neo probably didn't die yet. Something happened, because of the way the machines carried his body away. I doubt its because of reverence, but more likely because there was something still going on inside him. As you could see in Neo-Vision he was glowing as the trucked him off.

So its still not a definitive ending to the whole story, but it is in an odd way as well. The war in the end "might" be then over... Ok... I said it. But I mean as in the "hatred and vehemence" between machines and humans. Neo discovered that machines can love and machines discovered that humans are trustworthy and not all bad.

I heavent "seen" the light for this movie, its still not by a long shot better than the first, but you can say that I've seen it in a new light. There is in the end more to this film than what meets the eye. But only because its the 2nd half of Reloaded. It can't be a independent film. I can't stress that enough. Because alone, it sucks bad. But if it would even be edited so that 2 and 3 would be one 4 hour movie, that would be good. All the  philosophical stuff would be talked about in the first half of the film while the 2nd half would in the end reward the viewer and let their minds rest for at bit while Zion is attacked, then again after that they can once again think about stuff when Neo's story continues.

I have to say I was too drastic in my earlier comments perhaps without considering this as only part of a film. So as a the 2nd half of reloaded it was good. I would think it a good idea perhaps if they maybe release reloaded and revolutions as one film, perhaps called REVELATIONS. :D Oh well. All I really want to say is that watching it a second time right after reloaded redeems the movie quite a bit.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 08, 2003, 07:00:54 pm
i keep getting visions of Smith exploding, and then this huge writing appearing on a Blue Cloudless sky.....

A Fatal Exception has occured at &FF2B23A......

Ok, I'll stop :)

Flipside :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 08, 2003, 07:20:09 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ubermetroid


:confused: No.....


it made sense to me.  and a lot of "matrix theories" online said the same thing
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 08, 2003, 07:20:26 pm
Quote
Originally posted by aldo_14
No.... Snith would be The Minus One

1+0 = 1   1+(-1) = 0

.......So that'd be the one and only reason why Smith would be -1. To 'balance the equation', if that line is to be taken in its very most literal sense.

But if Smith represents 0, then it ties into Binary, the whole true-or-false thing of the Matrix, the basic defining qualities of the characters (Neo being the embodiment of a greater purpose and Smith being a representation of someone who believes in nothing) and so-on........
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 08, 2003, 07:23:16 pm
Quote
Originally posted by an0n

But if Smith represents 0, then it ties into Binary, the whole true-or-false thing of the Matrix, the basic defining qualities of the characters (Neo being the embodiment of a greater purpose and Smith being a representation of someone who believes in nothing) and so-on........


but smith doesn't represent "0", he represents "-1", the opposite side of the equation, to equal out everything.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 08, 2003, 07:46:24 pm
Nice reasoning skills there.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 08, 2003, 08:07:19 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Yeah, its still a Jesus trilogy, that being obvious from the first movie.

Then all the explicit references to Buddhism and other faiths had absolutely no meaning?
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
I guess he realised there could never have been a total victory

Nope. He realizes that destroying the machines would not be a real victory.
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
So its still seems she only talking about a few people that know of the reality of the matrix.

That doesn't make sense. Zion would simply not accept peace on these conditions. Deus Ex Machina knows that.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 08, 2003, 09:33:53 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stealth


it made sense to me.  and a lot of "matrix theories" online said the same thing


:nervous: What I got out of #2 what that all the other "ones" merged with the sorce.  Also, Merv is an exile, a program gone bad.

But that is what I got out of it.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 08, 2003, 09:51:09 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ubermetroid


:nervous: What I got out of #2 what that all the other "ones" merged with the sorce.  Also, Merv is an exile, a program gone bad.

But that is what I got out of it.


yeah, see, that's where my "theory" goes wrong...  the primary reason i thought that the Merivingian was a former "One" (apart from all the online theories) was because of Perciphone saying that she wants to remember what it's like (when she kisses Neo)... i thought, why would she ask Neo this?  why not someone else?  perhaps it's because the Merivingian was a "One", and she was the equivalent of Trinity, the Merovingian's lover, and she wanted to remember what it was like to kiss (the One?).  i'm not sure.  also the Merovingian posesses the "Matrix hacking" skills that Neo does, in that he can look at the Matrix (while in the Matrix) and see the matrix code (green symbols)... so far we know only Neo can do this, and he developed that skill... so the Merovingian can too?  I dunno, but you may be right, he may not (and probably isn't) a former "One" :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 08, 2003, 09:59:51 pm
And I'd like to point out that I was right. There was no deeper meaning to the incidents of Reloaded and Revolutions. It was all just a nice, simple little all-out war. No second Matrix. No robot-people. Just people fighting machines.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 08, 2003, 10:00:28 pm
at first I was quite certain that french accentguy was a previous incarnation of Neo. This is why Monica Belucci says that he was once a lot like Neo and wants to kiss him (as she then must be Trinity v5); but the Merovingian says that he survived Neo's predecessors, surely he couldn't be including himself in that list?



LOL what i love doing is going back now and seeing what everyone "predicted" Revolutions would be about and how it would end.  here's one that cracked me up:

Quote
Now this is just something that is a hunch. Probably a bit stupid but i'll throw it out there for all the people to mull over. ... Neo more machine like, Smith more human. The fight is no longer between man and machine. But identity. Prophescy is been blown apart and the war will destroy both man and machine is the answer isn't found. The death of both chosen ones. Thats right. Two. Smith and Neo must die to save the whole. As i said not thought through, and probably a bit stupid but i have this gut feeling.

Dan


This guy hit it right on the head months before Revolutions came out :D  and he seems more sure then of the Matrix than we do now after watching the 3rd movie ;).  but this is the funniest part... look at this reply that came after it:

Quote
there's no way Neo will be dead by the end of all this.


hahahaha.  woo... awesome

EDIT:
here's another good one:

Quote
I've got four words for y'all:

Trinity is The One.

Think about it....

-Stephen


in reply:

Quote
But if Trinity was meant to fall in love with The One, does that mean that she's a narcissist?

Think about that, dumbass.


HAHAHAHAH you guys should do this, it's awesome to see everyone in the dark lol


here's another guy's rendition:

Quote
... {about 2 pages of Matrix theory here}... That is just the real basic stuff obviously, but let's face it. It is only one movie. For these people who think that there will be time for 8 or 9 new twists, they need to take a lesson in realism. There will be a giant twist in this movie, but there won't be 4 or 5. The twists will come with the Meregivinian and what he is, with the connection between Smith and Neo, and then with the fates of the previous anamolies and Zions.

Bottom line: after projected box office returns of over $700 million, Larry and Andy Wachowski could pull a Wizard of Oz on us and laugh all the way to the bank.

Wizard of Oz: Neo wakes up in his office right after his boss yelled at him in the first movie for being late. Agent Smith turns out to just be a representation of his boss in the dream. (Look at the way the boss says "Mr. Anderson")

This would be the worst thing that could ever happen in many people's lives. And suicides among computer nerds would go up 462%. Keanu Reeves would never act again, the Wachowski's would be beaten retarded by the legions of Bill Gates, and the only person to come out ahead of the game will be Carrie-Anne Moss because she will still look hot in her dominatrix outfit.

Look particularly at the bottom paragraph. hahaha lol


here's one more.  after seeing the movie, someone says:
Quote
What an anti-climax. No questions were answered, no decent fight sequences, no point. I cant believe they ended it that way, what is it a love story!? i cried, im not joking, they spoilt a fantastic idea with their hippy (and obviously canadian) ideas of love, peace and hope. WHO THE HELL CARES ABOUT THAT RUBBISH! i wanted a well thought out ending, i got a kick in the nuts. Dont talk to me about movies again, ill never be excited about another movie again.....
£5.00 i paid for that movie! I bunked Sociology and English to watch it at 2pm and if i fail in lfe its all the waschowskis fault!


so some canadian takes offense to that (obviously):

Quote
id like for [you] to shut the **** up
talkin **** about canadians
stay in your ugly deadbeat dirtytooth society
and the answers were there
and quite obvious but
your a fagget who was just pissed off because
you couldnt go home and wack off to neo and trinity having sex again

and your a dirty homo


HAHAHA.  this is hilarious
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Joey_21 on November 08, 2003, 11:12:34 pm
I fricken loved every bit of it. Tied up everything nicely for me.

On a related note: http://www.darc.net/article.php?story=20031106073153116
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Turnsky on November 08, 2003, 11:53:28 pm
meh, i'm gonna see it tonight, i'll draw my own opinions on it, because quite frankly, I DON'T CARE whether you like it or not, or whether some old fart of a critic liked it or not, whether I like it or not, THAT'S what matters.. :ha:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Liberator on November 09, 2003, 12:27:52 am
Been back about 2 hours now.

I kept getting different vibes.  During the Dock Defense sequence, after the main Sentinel force breaks through and are "oozing" around mangling anything that moves, I kept feeling that they were the Army of Hell at the battle of Armageddon.  

As far at the Neo/Smith fight, I won't make a jesus analogy, instead I kept see the Archangel Michael fighting with Lucifer over the fate of Heaven and Earth.

And at the end, when Neo was carried off the field, it was more Arthurian than anything else.

Overall, taken by itself, as an action movie, it's fairly successful, even if it does get kind of Dragonball Z'ish at the end.  I mean, really, I was half expecting a KA-MAE-HA-MAE-whoa!

I enjoyed it though, and the ROTK trailer was great on the Big Screen even though I've seen it before.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Drew on November 09, 2003, 12:37:51 am
the first half was as boring as sh**... it had crappy dialog, corny acting, and the story was stupid and dumb. There wasnt much in there that explained anything that happend in the prequels (or anything that happend, period.)
however, the last half really amazed me. That battle sequence in zion i was like :eek: :eek2:

the Neo v Smith was a bot annoyiung tho, nothing eyepopping there. it just dragged onn... and on... and..... on....


AND WTF WAS THE TRAINMAN EVEN IN THERE FOR??????????????????????????????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: beatspete on November 09, 2003, 04:37:08 am
Quote
Originally posted by an0n
Nice reasoning skills there.


The Oracle stated that Smith was the opposite of Neo.


Anyway, its not about binary maths or anything, its about what we have seen in part 2.  Useless programs are deleted.  When smith absorbs neo, smith (as his opposite) becomes useless and is deleted.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 09, 2003, 04:37:21 am
Noone has answered my question yet. If there has been seven other incarnations of Neo, there also has to be seven other incarnations of Smith. How were they defeated?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 09, 2003, 04:52:48 am
What makes you think there have been seven other Smiths?

(No matter this is the sixth Matrix, so there could only have been five versions....)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 09, 2003, 04:55:58 am
I think this time it was different. And there was no Smith in the earlier ones. But I can be wrong.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: beatspete on November 09, 2003, 05:03:30 am
But the previous 'ones' weren't as powerful as this one.  The merlveng.. says so (ie, you have some skill, you predacesors had more respect).  Smith might not have been as powerful either.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 09, 2003, 05:08:37 am
The Agents in the previous versions of the Matrix were different, too.  The Merovingian has a whole zoo of them.  So Smith wouldn't even have EXISTED in the previous Matrices.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 09, 2003, 07:08:53 am
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
What makes you think there have been seven other Smiths?

(No matter this is the sixth Matrix, so there could only have been five versions....)


Because there was now. And consider the One program was pretty much the same every time, there should have been a -One as well every time.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Singh on November 09, 2003, 07:17:25 am
Just saw the movie. Thoughts-

For the half hour action scene, i swear i didn't blink (i was right in the front row) incredible action, maybe a bit too fast, but possibly the best last stand battle i've seen till today. The scene with the Hammer coming in and crashing was ultra cool as well :tup:

The french guy and the trainman were both nice additions to the story, and the Sati child and indian parents also added diversity to an otherwise mostly american show.

The last part.....it was confusing. It seemed like when Neo seemed to give up during the end, the machine 'overlord' as it were, took over and killed the smiths somehow. The scene towards the end was quite confusing, when the machines took Neo's body away- this is a deep plot....something.

Although it seems just like a fight of good vs evil, one must consider that it is a rather unique battle of good vs evil, where both get annihalated and only a mixture of something in-between gets left behind (especially when the architect referred to whether he was human)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 09, 2003, 10:25:25 am
Quote
Originally posted by Devils_Hitman
Also, why is there a matrix!!, machines can survive in space, why they **** dont they go up there and make a big solar array?


Did you notice when the hovercraft went through the nanobot clouds it lost all power?  The Machines probbly could not make it past the cloud layer either.

Quote
Originally posted by Devils_Hitman
lol, or just use fission.


It is stated that human body heat is the most efficient power sorce the machines can come up with.  And I would think they know about nukes and fission.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 09, 2003, 12:26:36 pm
I didn't know those clouds were made out of nanobots? COOL! Makes sence then with all that lighting. ALOT of friction.

And on powersources, I think the bots decided to use humans as power source just becuase they were sadistic bastards and felt it poetic justice that humans would spend the next thousand years under their thumb! :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: diamondgeezer on November 09, 2003, 12:54:08 pm
*stands in APU screaming 'RELOAD!'*
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Ashrak on November 09, 2003, 01:21:41 pm
i for one like it..... lotsa fighting story is nonexistent but i lovet the fighting :p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 09, 2003, 03:04:17 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
Because there was now. And consider the One program was pretty much the same every time, there should have been a -One as well every time.

It was not the same every time. This time was different, and that's why the Matrix didn't simply reload to restart the cycle.

Basically, two things went different this time. One of them is Trinity, the reason why Neo didn't simply choose the door that leads to the Source and to the reload of the Matrix. The other is Smith. If there was no Smith, Neo wouldn't have been able to make a deal with the machines.

This brings me to an interesting point. The Merovingian can't be a former One. Notice how Persephone makes clear that in the past she and the Merovingian were in love, like Neo and Trinity. Also notice how the Architect says that Neo is the first One to feel the attachment to the species in a specific manner - Trinity.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 09, 2003, 03:24:43 pm
Well, a lot of people here need to watch the whole series a few more times before they understand what was going on.  I mean, the storyline isn't THAT contorted.  There's blindingly-obvious hints all through it, and yet me, Levyathan and others still have to explain it in cartoon pictures...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: diamondgeezer on November 09, 2003, 05:05:58 pm
Well I think this sums Revolutions up: taken from an MSN conversation twixt me and my brother

DG says:
but i mean what the **** happened to neo?
DG says:
are we waiting for another film or what?
Jon says:
who knows, who cares
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Grey Wolf on November 09, 2003, 07:13:36 pm
[announcer voice]Coming soon to a theatre near you: Matrix IV: The Wachowskis vs. Asimov! In the final battle, we will see who's really right about the behavior of robots![/announcer voice]

This has been brought to you by someone who has nothing better to do right now :p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sandwich on November 09, 2003, 07:51:08 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Grey Wolf 2009
...someone who has nothing better to do right now :p



The Wachowskis, right? ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 10, 2003, 12:45:27 am
Well, I just got back from the theater. Overall, I found Revolutions much more entertaining than Reloaded. However, in retrospect Revolutions made much less sense than Reloaded.

What happened to the Oracle in the day or so after Neo last saw her?

If the Oracle is almost as big a wheel in the Matrix as the Architect, then why is she slumming around with only one program for protection?

Why is the Trainman such a bloody lunatic? What was up with that "Nobody can help me!" babbling?

How in the hell can Neo blow up Sentinels by just waving his hand in the air? After all the theorizing on this subject, the best they could come up with was "He just can, ok"?

Also, what did Neo do to block all the ballistic projectiles they were lobbing at him?

How can Neo link to the Matrix without a physical connection to it? Oh that's right, "He just can".

The machines have apparently never heard of the Maginot Line.

If Zion is in fact part of the Real Real World, and not a parallel Matrix program for collecting rejects (as some theorized), then why does the Architect need Zion to exist? To machines of his mindset, humans are batteries, period. A human no longer serving that purpose is useless and should be killed immediately.

And again, if Zion is the real world, how was Smith able to download himself into a human brain? That's like trying to play a CD by putting it in a toaster.

Why would Merv want the Oracle's eyes? Since when does a computer program have eyes?

Why do Sentinels suck so much at combat? The kill ratio between humans and machines looked to be about 500:1. Makes me wonder how the machines won the war in the first place. Most of the time the Sentinels seemed more intent on putting on a flying exhibition than actually fighting.

The scene where that girl was running through the crawlspace dodging Sentinel tentacles looked like an upside-down version of the graveyard scene from Army of Darkness.

If EMPs are such bloody powerful weapons against the machines, why isn't there a single one (let alone dozens) in the dock? Oh wait, it would knock down their defenses. Oh wait, it doesn't knock down the defenses on the ships, so why would the dock be any different? Oh wait, why not make EMP weapons with a smaller effective radius?

Since when can Smith fly? He couldn't a few hours ago.

Programs have to be productive members of society or face deletion? Sounds like machine society really sucks.

These two lovey-dovey programs have been talking to the Oracle, and therefore must know roughly what's going down in the Matrix, yet they choose to ship their "daughter" off there anyway?

Why is Smith taking over the Matrix a problem for the machines? The human bodies are still generating power, and as this film went to great lengths to establish, the only way in or out is through the train station. In the real world, this probably means the physical network connections to the Matrix simulators out in the fields are limited and tightly controlled. Just cut them.

On the other hand, apparently you can cut every cable in the breaker room of one of the humans' hovercraft, and it will still run just fine.

I think I'm going to like this movie less and less the more I think about it. Ugh.

PS-- Why are some people so bloody literal-minded when it comes to theorizing? First the "all previous Ones looked exactly like Neo" theory (based on the screens in the Architect room), and now the inane "the Merovingian is a One", and "Smith died because Neo died" theories. It's already been explained why Merv can't be a former One, and the Smiths clearly were able to be destroyed because Smith took over a body linked directly to the machine mainframe. The mainframe was then able to analyze the Smith program (with a little help from the submerged Oracle program), devise an exponentially-propagating anti-Smith virus, and introduce it into the Matrix via Neo's link.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Kazan on November 10, 2003, 02:17:45 am
ZyloneBane - thank you for realizing that last bit - THE MACHINES FSCKING RAN A PROGRAM THROUGH NEO

Some dude was talking to his friends after the movie about that trying to figure it out - and i was like "it's simple, by letting himself be assimilated neo allowed the machines to introduce a countervirus into smith's program" and they were all like "dude! now that makes sense!"
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 10, 2003, 02:35:32 am
Yeah I agree with that. Smith in essence returned to the source and got deleted. Neo was just the bait in the end. He only had to figure it out.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 10, 2003, 08:22:54 am
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
Why would Merv want the Oracle's eyes? Since when does a computer program have eyes?

He wanted her sight.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: TrashMan on November 10, 2003, 08:56:35 am
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
Well, I just got back from the theater. Overall, I found Revolutions much more entertaining than Reloaded. However, in retrospect Revolutions made much less sense than Reloaded.

What happened to the Oracle in the day or so after Neo last saw her?

If the Oracle is almost as big a wheel in the Matrix as the Architect, then why is she slumming around with only one program for protection?

Why is the Trainman such a bloody lunatic? What was up with that "Nobody can help me!" babbling?

How in the hell can Neo blow up Sentinels by just waving his hand in the air? After all the theorizing on this subject, the best they could come up with was "He just can, ok"?

Also, what did Neo do to block all the ballistic projectiles they were lobbing at him?

How can Neo link to the Matrix without a physical connection to it? Oh that's right, "He just can".

The machines have apparently never heard of the Maginot Line.

If Zion is in fact part of the Real Real World, and not a parallel Matrix program for collecting rejects (as some theorized), then why does the Architect need Zion to exist? To machines of his mindset, humans are batteries, period. A human no longer serving that purpose is useless and should be killed immediately.

And again, if Zion is the real world, how was Smith able to download himself into a human brain? That's like trying to play a CD by putting it in a toaster.

Why would Merv want the Oracle's eyes? Since when does a computer program have eyes?

Why do Sentinels suck so much at combat? The kill ratio between humans and machines looked to be about 500:1. Makes me wonder how the machines won the war in the first place. Most of the time the Sentinels seemed more intent on putting on a flying exhibition than actually fighting.

The scene where that girl was running through the crawlspace dodging Sentinel tentacles looked like an upside-down version of the graveyard scene from Army of Darkness.

If EMPs are such bloody powerful weapons against the machines, why isn't there a single one (let alone dozens) in the dock? Oh wait, it would knock down their defenses. Oh wait, it doesn't knock down the defenses on the ships, so why would the dock be any different? Oh wait, why not make EMP weapons with a smaller effective radius?

Since when can Smith fly? He couldn't a few hours ago.

Programs have to be productive members of society or face deletion? Sounds like machine society really sucks.

These two lovey-dovey programs have been talking to the Oracle, and therefore must know roughly what's going down in the Matrix, yet they choose to ship their "daughter" off there anyway?

Why is Smith taking over the Matrix a problem for the machines? The human bodies are still generating power, and as this film went to great lengths to establish, the only way in or out is through the train station. In the real world, this probably means the physical network connections to the Matrix simulators out in the fields are limited and tightly controlled. Just cut them.

On the other hand, apparently you can cut every cable in the breaker room of one of the humans' hovercraft, and it will still run just fine.

I think I'm going to like this movie less and less the more I think about it. Ugh.

PS-- Why are some people so bloody literal-minded when it comes to theorizing? First the "all previous Ones looked exactly like Neo" theory (based on the screens in the Architect room), and now the inane "the Merovingian is a One", and "Smith died because Neo died" theories. It's already been explained why Merv can't be a former One, and the Smiths clearly were able to be destroyed because Smith took over a body linked directly to the machine mainframe. The mainframe was then able to analyze the Smith program (with a little help from the submerged Oracle program), devise an exponentially-propagating anti-Smith virus, and introduce it into the Matrix via Neo's link.



Like I said - CRAP!!!!!
Title: :-)
Post by: übermetroid on November 10, 2003, 12:45:58 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
What happened to the Oracle in the day or so after Neo last saw her?

She was killed.  Merv had her taken out.  She then came back, but she had to get a new shell
Quote

If the Oracle is almost as big a wheel in the Matrix as the Architect, then why is she slumming around with only one program for protection?

Well, seeing how she can see into the future, she really does not need to have much protection, does she?
Quote

Why is the Trainman such a bloody lunatic? What was up with that "Nobody can help me!" babbling?

I have no idea, but he is in ETM.
Quote

How in the hell can Neo blow up Sentinels by just waving his hand in the air? After all the theorizing on this subject, the best they could come up with was "He just can, ok"?  Also, what did Neo do to block all the ballistic projectiles they were lobbing at him?

I thought this was explained pretty well.  In Machine land everything is connected through, lets call it the Machines Internet.  Neo is just a hacker on that Internet.  He was able to hack in and have the things self destruct.
Quote

How can Neo link to the Matrix without a physical connection to it? Oh that's right, "He just can".

He still has Machine parts in him.  (The plugs and such).  Maybe he also has wireless that no one else has?
Quote

The machines have apparently never heard of the Maginot Line.

Whats this?
Quote

If Zion is in fact part of the Real Real World, and not a parallel Matrix program for collecting rejects (as some theorized), then why does the Architect need Zion to exist? To machines of his mindset, humans are batteries, period. A human no longer serving that purpose is useless and should be killed immediately.

This was coverend in #2.  Zion exists because of the unbalanced equation that blah, blah, blah.

All tha Machines want is peace.  They don't want a war.  They never did.  The humans started it all.  Maybe the other reason Zion exists is because the Machines wanted to give the humans a chance to start the peace process again.  Which, I might add, Neo was able to do.
Quote

And again, if Zion is the real world, how was Smith able to download himself into a human brain? That's like trying to play a CD by putting it in a toaster.

He was able to download himself.  That is was he learned todo.  He is a virus after all.
Quote

Why would Merv want the Oracle's eyes? Since when does a computer program have eyes?

Oracle's eyes = the ability to see in to the future.  If you were in power wouldn't you want that ability too?
Quote

Why do Sentinels suck so much at combat? The kill ratio between humans and machines looked to be about 500:1. Makes me wonder how the machines won the war in the first place. Most of the time the Sentinels seemed more intent on putting on a flying exhibition than actually fighting.

They must fight like a bunch of bugs.  If you are in a group you are less likely to get hit.  The Machines did win though, and if that is what it takes, do it.
Quote

If EMPs are such bloody powerful weapons against the machines, why isn't there a single one (let alone dozens) in the dock? Oh wait, it would knock down their defenses. Oh wait, it doesn't knock down the defenses on the ships, so why would the dock be any different? Oh wait, why not make EMP weapons with a smaller effective radius?

Maybe they dont have EMP's with smaller radius?  Also we are never shown what happenes when one goes off in a ship.  I always assumed that everything would go died.
Quote

Since when can Smith fly? He couldn't a few hours ago.

He must have gained power.  I bet he assumed a bird or something and with access to that code learned to fly.
Quote

Programs have to be productive members of society or face deletion? Sounds like machine society really sucks.

True that.  But it is Machine thinking if you ask me.
Quote

These two lovey-dovey programs have been talking to the Oracle, and therefore must know roughly what's going down in the Matrix, yet they choose to ship their "daughter" off there anyway?

Whats wrong with that?  If she did not stay in the Matrix she would have been deleted.
Quote

Why is Smith taking over the Matrix a problem for the machines? The human bodies are still generating power, and as this film went to great lengths to establish, the only way in or out is through the train station. In the real world, this probably means the physical network connections to the Matrix simulators out in the fields are limited and tightly controlled. Just cut them.

The Matrix is connected to all Machines by the power sorce.  If Smith was not destroyed he would have taken over everything.  Neo says so near the end of the movie.  They need the power to live so why would they cut the lines?
Quote

On the other hand, apparently you can cut every cable in the breaker room of one of the humans' hovercraft, and it will still run just fine.

Yes, that was stupid.
Quote

I think I'm going to like this movie less and less the more I think about it. Ugh.

The more and more I think about it the more it fits together.  ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 10, 2003, 12:50:11 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
Also, what did Neo do to block all the ballistic projectiles they were lobbing at him?

They exploded before getting dangerously close to the Logos.
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
And again, if Zion is the real world, how was Smith able to download himself into a human brain? That's like trying to play a CD by putting it in a toaster.

Why do humans die in the real world when they die in the Matrix?
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
Since when can Smith fly? He couldn't a few hours ago.

Neo can fly in the end of the first movie, yet he can't in the beggining.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: TrashMan on November 10, 2003, 01:06:00 pm
UBER CRAP!
Title: Re: :-)
Post by: ZylonBane on November 10, 2003, 03:36:55 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ubermetroid
She was killed.  Merv had her taken out.  She then came back, but she had to get a new shell
That's a logical conclusion (and apparently supported by the game), but it doesn't justify the annoying tapdancing the movie did around what actually happened.

Quote
Well, seeing how she can see into the future, she really does not need to have much protection, does she?
My question wasn't so much the degree of protection, as the degree of slumming. She doesn't seem to have nearly the power you'd expect from the co-creator of the Matrix.

Quote
I thought this was explained pretty well.  ... He was able to hack in and have the things self destruct.
I could swear I saw big flaming balls of energy being fired. How do you hack a ball of energy?

Quote
He still has Machine parts in him.  (The plugs and such).  Maybe he also has wireless that no one else has?
Doubtful. With all the medical scans they ran on him when they first pulled him out, they would have noticed that.

Quote
This was coverend in #2.  Zion exists because of the unbalanced equation that blah, blah, blah.
No, the "choice to reject the program" exists because of the unbalanced equation. The people in the Matrix don't know that Zion exists at any level. If someone decides to reject the program, fine. They wake up and get flushed. Zion is superfluous at best, and a nuisance at worst.

Quote
Maybe the other reason Zion exists is because the Machines wanted to give the humans a chance to start the peace process again.
Maybe. But the movie doesn't even hint at this.

Quote
He was able to download himself.  That is was he learned todo.  He is a virus after all.
He learned to subvert avatar programs in the Matrix simulation. This is a far, far cry from reprogramming yourself from scratch to execute on an utterly alien chunk of hardware (a human brain). Even then, there's little chance the cyberjack would be physically equipped to rewire an entire human brain in an instant. There's absolutely no need for it to connect to anything beyond the central nervous system.

Quote
They must fight like a bunch of bugs.
These machines are a hell of a lot smarter than bugs. Yet they flew around in giant swarms either ignoring the defenders, or flying directly into their guns in a convenient column. With the numbers of Sentinels shown, they should have picked that chamber clean in under 5 minutes.

Quote
The Matrix is connected to all Machines by the power sorce.  If Smith was not destroyed he would have taken over everything.  Neo says so near the end of the movie.  They need the power to live so why would they cut the lines?
Please attempt to differentiate between a DATA line and a POWER line.
Title: Re: Re: :-)
Post by: Levyathan on November 10, 2003, 04:34:24 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
My question wasn't so much the degree of protection, as the degree of slumming. She doesn't seem to have nearly the power you'd expect from the co-creator of the Matrix.

She's not the Merovingian. He's the one who wants to look cool and powerful, remember?
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
These machines are a hell of a lot smarter than bugs. Yet they flew around in giant swarms either ignoring the defenders, or flying directly into their guns in a convenient column. With the numbers of Sentinels shown, they should have picked that chamber clean in under 5 minutes.

The main objective was to reach the city. Considering the number of Sentinels that were put down due to attacks targeted at the drill machine, it's possible that they were doing exactly what was supposed to be done.
Title: Re: Re: Re: :-)
Post by: ZylonBane on November 10, 2003, 04:36:59 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
The main objective was to reach the city. Considering the number of Sentinels that were put down due to attacks targeted at the drill machine, it's possible that they were doing exactly what was supposed to be done.
Don't the machines know that the best defense is a good offense?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: TrashMan on November 10, 2003, 05:52:18 pm
Quote
These machines are a hell of a lot smarter than bugs. Yet they flew around in giant swarms either ignoring the defenders, or flying directly into their guns in a convenient column. With the numbers of Sentinels shown, they should have picked that chamber clean in under 5 minutes.


Have you any idea how powerfull a minigun is. Todays minigun fire at a rate from 6000-24000 bullets a minute!!! (that's 100-400 bullets per second...for a comparison, standard rifles fire 3-4 bullets per sec).
I suppose in the future the miniguns are even more powerfull.
If anything, too many Sentinels survived.
With several hunderds of such guns aimed at the opening - NOTHING SHOULD HAVE SURVIVED AT ALL!!!!

Count...every mech had 2 such miniguns....how many defenders were there? Let's say 200?

In that case the opening was bombarded with  400000 bullets each second!:eek2:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 10, 2003, 06:19:56 pm
100 APUs. And I guess, but we don't really have a good way to judge how much armour the machines have other than what makes for a cool looking movie..

And I like Levy's idea of how Smith took over in real life. When you die in the matrix, you die because your brain tells your body you should be dead. So in theory, when Smith takes over your body in the matrix, your brain would tell you he should take over in real life. Your brain supplies all of Smith's code, because it know's it from the Matrix. Thus, Smith can take over.

and I don't remember the Trainman from ETM. :wtf:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 10, 2003, 06:33:42 pm
I remember the Trainman from Mad Max beyond Thunderdome: he was the airplane pilot guy who stole Max's stuff in the beginning of the movie and whose plane Max used to save the day at the end of the movie.

Max: You. I remember you.
Airplane pilot guy: You do?
Max: Yeah. You have a plane.
Airplane pilot guy: I do?
Max: Yeah. It just might save your life.
Airplane pilot guy: It will?

Mad Max and Airplane pilot guy, Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome

Quote
Originally posted by TrashMan
Have you any idea how powerfull a minigun is. Todays minigun fire at a rate from 6000-24000 bullets a minute!!! (that's 100-400 bullets per second...for a comparison, standard rifles fire 3-4 bullets per sec).

I suppose in the future the miniguns are even more powerfull.
If anything, too many Sentinels survived.
With several hunderds of such guns aimed at the opening - NOTHING SHOULD HAVE SURVIVED AT ALL!!!!

Count...every mech had 2 such miniguns....how many defenders were there? Let's say 200?

In that case the opening was bombarded with  400000 bullets each second!:eek2:


Yeah, but you have to remember that the metal that the Sentinels were forged with was forged at least 600 years in the future (assuming that each iteration of Zion lasted 100 years. With smelting technology that is 600 years ahead of what we have now, isn't it safe to assume that the Machines are capable of forging metal alloys many times tougher than today's steel?

Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
The machines have apparently never heard of the Maginot Line.


I had to respond to this, since no one else did and I happen to know what the Maginot Line is.

Ok, set the History Channel to just before World War II, when France was making fortifications to its border with Germany. The Maginot Line was a big wall fortification made by the French (in the Ardennes Forest, IIRC) designed to keep the Germans out of France. The only problem was that the Maginot Line didn't cover the entire border with Germany; it only went maybe 50 miles (I'm not sure of the exact length) along the border. The French were so certain that the Germans would advance through the Ardennes Forest (because that was what the Germans had done in World War I) that the French saw no need to extend the Line further along their border. So what happened when WWII started? You guessed it, kids, the Germans simply drove their tanks and troops through the part of the French-German border that wasn't fortified by the Maginot Line at all! In essence, the French built a big-ass wall but the Germans simply drove right around it and got halfway to Paris before the shooting even started!

With strategic stupidity like this, is it any wonder the French never won a war?

As for the Maginot Line theory being applied to the Matrix movies, it seems to me that the Machines actually did know about the Maginot Line. Remember, the Zionites only guarded the tunnel entrances, not their cave walls. The Zionites never anticipated the Machines drilling though the ground from above; they thought the Machines would try to use the tunnels instead. So the Machines did exactly what the Germans did: they advanced through an unanticipated and unprotected route.

Apparently, what ZylonBane meant is that it was the Zionites who never heard of the Maginot Line. But considering that the Zionites lost alot of historical records during the war with the Machines (they didn't even know who started the war, for crissakes'; Morpheus even said that in Matrix I), that's probably not surprising.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: TrashMan on November 10, 2003, 06:38:21 pm
So? They have allso better ammo....
Ammo development is allways infront of shielding...And the Sentinels got destroyed by the bullets in the movie...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 10, 2003, 06:40:30 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Knight Templar
So in theory, when Smith takes over your body in the matrix, your brain would tell you he should take over in real life. Your brain supplies all of Smith's code, because it know's it from the Matrix.
No human except Neo knows the code of an Agent. All anyone else knows is what they've observed.

Are you one of those people who thinks humans in the Matrix have actually had their consciousness uploaded as a computer simulation?

Quote
Originally posted by Su-tehp
Apparently, what ZylonBane meant is that it was the Zionites who never heard of the Maginot Line.
Ummm.... no. I meant what I said. If you don't see the parallel in Neo's inflitration of the machine city, then I can't help you.


Quote
Originally posted by TrashMan
Sentinels got destroyed by the bullets in the movie...
The Sentinels in Revolutions could be destroyed with harsh language. Anyway, some review I read compared their flight patterns with the bonus stages in Galaga. That guy got it right.  By sticking to huge swarms, they gave the defenders easy targets. They should have broken up, filling the dome with a uniform cloud of Sentinels. Then they could have mauled each defender from all sides at once, with perfect coordination.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 10, 2003, 06:45:20 pm
I don't mean that they know the code, just that the code being there and taking over the mind is present in the matrix, and the matrix and the real world are connected through the mind, i.e. what you feel in there, your mind 'feels.

You get hit by a truck in the matrix, your body feels like it's hit by a truck in real life.
You get assimilated by Smith in the matrix and your mind is assimilated by Smith in real life. Your mind is obviously capable of being assimilated within the matrix, and your real life body feels what your matrix body does apparently, so it would explain how he took control of Bane.

Didn't we learn this in Matrix one?

Su: He meant that for some reason still unrevealed (at least I missed it) Neo and Trinity got into the machine city with no resistance at all, untill they flew around and found the defenses.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 10, 2003, 06:47:26 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Su-tehp
Apparently, what ZylonBane meant is that it was the Zionites who never heard of the Maginot Line.


Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
Ummm.... no. I meant what I said. If you don't see the parallel in Neo's inflitration of the machine city, then I can't help you.


Oh, I get it now, you were referring to Neo and Trinity flying to Zero-One (aka the Machine City) in the Logos. Instead of going around the fortifications, like the Germans (and the Machines at Zion) did, Neo and Trinity went above the Machine defenses.

Ok, now that makes sense.

Well, as I showed above, the Machines did seem to know about the Maginot Line, they just forgot to apply it to Neo. :D

After all, who among the Machines would anticipate any human actually wanting to go to the Machine City? :nervous:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Nico on November 10, 2003, 07:01:21 pm
First:

Quote
Originally posted by Su-tehp

With strategic stupidity like this, is it any wonder the French never won a war?


Mmmh... f.uck you? yes, f.uck you, that's good enough. Heard that too many times to be diplomatic. I could explain to you why the germans went through Belgium to avoid the Maginot Line, why, they "forgot" they had a treaty with them, how many wars we actually won on our own compared to the USA ( 2 wars for you, right? you're far behind, man  ), how much I dispise people like you, but I think the list is enough, I don't want to elaborate. Geez, even in a thread about matrix, I have to bear tards like you.

ANYWAY

Back on topic: just saw it, Revolutions, that is. Well, the battle at Zion was cool, at least.
My first and main grip: I didn't play the friggin game, so I didn't get the begining. WTF with that? I'm happy there's not a 4th movie, you'd have to get the matrix mug or something to learn what happens between the two movies :doubt:

I also didn't understand many things: what's with that girl at the end, being able to change the colour of the sky? Why did Smith blow up? etc etc. Saw I just read half this thread ( too long ) and, I suppose I got some things:
Neo has some old code that triggers Smith's destruction? Mmh, maybe, really, can't remember, the architect said too much stuff, really can't remember that.
So, Ne is dead at the end, right? Not that it's really important anyway, I guess.
Hargh, I was wondering other things, but can't remember what.
Funny thing, even at the end, we never know trinity's true name :p
Not that it's really important either...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 10, 2003, 07:04:22 pm
In ETM, you see the Train Man just after that business at the Airport (rescuing a member of Soren's crew).  In particular, in the movie sequence at the hard line after the mission.

And as for miniguns:
The APUs had 30mm cannons.  It doesn't say anywhere that they had miniguns.  Given the size of each ammo box, and the size of each shell, I'd say that if they were firing 6000 rounds per minute they'd've gone through an entire box in less than 10 seconds.  So they weren't pumping out that much lead.  If they were, they could've 'jetpacked' around by aiming downwards...
The A-10 Thunderbolt has a 30mm minigun in the nose.  Hell, the nose IS the minigun.  That plane is built around the cannon, it's so big.  When it fires, the aircraft looses an appreciable amount of airspeed due to recoil.  So if an APU was carrying a 30mm minigun, it would have a hard time staying upright whilst firing.
I'd estimate the fire rate of a single APU cannon to be about 4-5 rounds per second, = about 300 rounds per minute.  Mind you, even at this fire rate, that's a lot of shredded tin...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 10, 2003, 07:06:17 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Knight Templar
You get assimilated by Smith in the matrix and your mind is assimilated by Smith in real life. Your mind is obviously capable of being assimilated within the matrix, and your real life body feels what your matrix body does apparently, so it would explain how he took control of Bane.
Agents don't assimilate people. They usurp control over their avatars (or "shells" as Revolutions called them). Smith's unique powers are that he can copy his code instead of simply moving it, AND he can absorb other programs (which I also have a problem with, since programs apparently use the same avatar/shell interface to the Matrix as humans). It's not known if Agents can do this too-- I can't think of any situation where it would have been an option.

I repeat-- there is no conceivable reason why the neural link to the Matrix would encompass anything beyond the central nervous system. That's all you need to feed simulated inputs to the five senses, receive muscular inputs, and monitor biological telemetry. You can't instantly reprogram a human brain that way. I don't think you can instantly repgrogram a human brain at all. The sheer amount of simultaneous electro-chemical activity would cause your head to explode (or at least ooze).

The Wachowskis had a decent sci-fi thing going with the original Matrix (by movie standards). But from the very end of Reloaded on through Revolutions, they just gave up and went with full-bore anything-goes science fantasy.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Kazan on November 10, 2003, 09:47:06 pm
sorry zylone - but your theories about the matrix link are exactly that - theories -- any theory you have that contradicts what we saw in the movies is exactly "Horse ****"

There are only two people who are qualified to speak about what can and cannot be done with the matrix link: The W-Bros
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Singh on November 10, 2003, 10:54:33 pm
hmmmmm......
I just had a somewhat interesting thought.
Maybe Smith killed himself?
In the previous movies, it was stated that his sole purpose was to destroy Neo- and when he finished that in this movie, it quite literally gave him no purpose- he even says it, almost as if he was begging for it- "Is it over?" or somewhere along those lines.
Just a thought, nothing more.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 11, 2003, 01:30:56 am
Quote
Originally posted by Nico
First:

Mmmh... f.uck you? yes, f.uck you, that's good enough. Heard that too many times to be diplomatic. I could explain to you why the germans went through Belgium to avoid the Maginot Line, why, they "forgot" they had a treaty with them, how many wars we actually won on our own compared to the USA (2 wars for you, right? you're far behind, man), how much I dispise people like you, but I think the list is enough, I don't want to elaborate. Geez, even in a thread about matrix, I have to bear tards like you.

ANYWAY...


Damn, I didn't even know that any Frenchmen frequented this board. Ah, well, that's what I get for being completely undiplomatic. I deserved Nico's rant, I admit it freely. :nod:

Still, I feel, as a good American, that I am honorbound to dispute Nico's contention that the USA has only won "2 wars on its own," but since I'm not sure what he meant by that, I'll keep my big gob shut until I find out what I'm talking about.

Fair's fair, after all. :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Grey Wolf on November 11, 2003, 01:45:36 am
Realistically, no country has really won a war on it's own in centuries.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Gloriano on November 11, 2003, 01:53:29 am
in wars there is no actualy  winners or losers there is suffering and death
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Liberator on November 11, 2003, 02:29:50 am
Any experiences you have while in the Matrix are downloaded into your brain.  We have proof of this with how Neo learned martial arts and gunplay in the first movie.

From Revoloutions, we learn that the mind is actually separated from the body while connected to the Matrix, thus it exists as digital data on a computer, where the experiences that are had are added to it and is then reloaded onto the brain during the disconnection process.

All Smith would have to do is copy his personality sub-routines into the file for the person he was assimilating.  When the file is unknowingly reloaded into the original body.  Bang!  Smith's got himself a physical body to strike at Neo and Zion where they are vulnerable.  It's really quite simple.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Bobboau on November 11, 2003, 02:40:04 am
what file format are our minds iin again FAT32 or NTFS?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 11, 2003, 03:17:10 am
Quote

War doesn't determine who's right.  It determines who's left.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 11, 2003, 03:43:18 am
Quote
Originally posted by Su-tehp


Damn, I didn't even know that any Frenchmen frequented this board. Ah, well, that's what I get for being completely undiplomatic. I deserved Nico's rant, I admit it freely. :nod:

Still, I feel, as a good American, that I am honorbound to dispute Nico's contention that the USA has only won "2 wars on its own," but since I'm not sure what he meant by that, I'll keep my big gob shut until I find out what I'm talking about.

Fair's fair, after all. :)


:wtf: Where have you been the last 3 years? He's been around and been French for quite some time now...:p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 11, 2003, 09:25:01 am
Quote
Originally posted by Kazan
any theory you have that contradicts what we saw in the movies is exactly "Horse ****"
Unfortunately, that also describes the degree of logic demonstrated by the official explanations.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 11, 2003, 10:59:13 am
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
*stuff*


First of all, I like french.

Now, that we've gotten that out of the way: ZB, I understand, and for once, agree with most of the points you've made, my only question is: How on earth could you have enjoyed Revolutions more than you did Reloaded.

I mean, at least Reloaded tried to include a story, and the action sequences were actually interesting (is biased, because of the Reloaded DVD. Man that sounds good at full volume).

And, I have mentioned before and I will keep mentioning it: The ending sucked.

Thank you.

[edit]
Oh and by the way, was it ever explained (and I mean not in the "Use the force....uhm...source" kinda way") how Neo got to see the machines when he was blind.

The sentinel thing, which was bloody stupid, has been mentioned already, so I'll just say that it was bloody stupid. It was bloody stupid.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 11, 2003, 11:21:28 am
He just could okay? Get ****ing used to it. "The power of the One extends beyond the Matrix." :rolleyes:


;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 11, 2003, 11:39:09 am
Oooh. I just came up with a totally obscure theory thats probably unfounded and weak, but its profound. Neo has BECOME the Matrix!!!!

*Cue mystery revealed music! DUM DUM DUUUUM!*

After Neo dies and Smith dissapears, it is Neo that says "It is done!" Thats why we still see Neo being carried away in Neo-Vision! Because Neo is seeing it!! NEO LIVES!

*Starts spray painting on walls "Neo Lives!" signs...*

:D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 11, 2003, 11:43:18 am
As for this Neo outside the Matrix thing.... we have wireless networking even these days, and it is actually possible with the right equipment to steal data off of a computer that you are not connected to in any way whatsoever.

Flipside
Title: Re: Re: :-)
Post by: übermetroid on November 11, 2003, 02:35:50 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
I could swear I saw big flaming balls of energy being fired. How do you hack a ball of energy?

They were not energy, they were the bombs used in #2 that the sentinals used.
Quote

Doubtful. With all the medical scans they ran on him when they first pulled him out, they would have noticed that.

Um...  The plug?  All the pod born people have Machine Tech in them.  Neo just used it more then everybody else?  But that is just me rambling
Quote

He learned to subvert avatar programs in the Matrix simulation. This is a far, far cry from reprogramming yourself from scratch to execute on an utterly alien chunk of hardware (a human brain). Even then, there's little chance the cyberjack would be physically equipped to rewire an entire human brain in an instant. There's absolutely no need for it to connect to anything beyond the central nervous system.

What you say is true, except that Smith did download himself into Banes Head.
Quote

These machines are a hell of a lot smarter than bugs. Yet they flew around in giant swarms either ignoring the defenders, or flying directly into their guns in a convenient column. With the numbers of Sentinels shown, they should have picked that chamber clean in under 5 minutes.

I really agree with you here, I just watched in for a second time and in that entire fight in the background there are just clouds of squids flying around looking cool.
Quote

Please attempt to differentiate between a DATA line and a POWER line.

Well whats to say there was not Data Lines there?  That is how that little girl got from the Machine world to the Matrix.  There is data lines somewhere.  

:D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 11, 2003, 02:46:54 pm
The plug is just a plug.  It doesn't have any facility for wireless connection.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Razor on November 11, 2003, 03:16:35 pm
Did anyone listen to the soundtrack?
Man it's awesome. You gotta love the Neodammerung.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 11, 2003, 03:51:55 pm
Have it. I was a little dissappointed at how lacking it was. I mean, there were the regular uber-don davis compositions, and Navras, but there was no sign of outside artists and two worthy contributions by Juno Reactor. I think it had way too much cinematic music that isn't always that great to listen to on it's own. (Baring the major fight musics)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 11, 2003, 08:39:56 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
How on earth could you have enjoyed Revolutions more than you did Reloaded.
I think it's because I liked the structure of Revolutions better. Unfortunately the details supporting the structure sucked.

The chain of events in Reloaded was so painfully contrived, it was like something directly out of a video game. The whole movie had Our Heroes running from point A to point B to point C, battling a mini-boss here and there (who always knew they were coming), collecting items for their quest, and culminating with one of the laziest cliches of gaming, the timed sequence.

If The One walking through that door was essential to the survival of the Matrix, you'd think the Architect would make getting to it a more straightforward affair. Like maybe, just knock?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 12, 2003, 02:06:26 am
He had to be sure that only the One would be capable of it.  Besides, everyone would be just a bit suspicious if the key to 'ending the war permanently' was, metaphorically speaking, left on a big pedestal in plain view with a neon sign saying 'This is it!' suspended above it.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Bobboau on November 12, 2003, 02:36:51 am
yet were suposed to just accept that all that crap he can do is be case... he just can
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Singh on November 12, 2003, 03:49:27 am
Quote
Originally posted by Bobboau
yet were suposed to just accept that all that crap he can do is be case... he just can


Umm......yeah.
Its not reality, just a story, and as stories are supposed to go, its exaggeration and makes the audience go "ooooooh...that's cool"
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 12, 2003, 04:22:18 am
Noo! Its all real! I believe it! Don't say its not! AAARGH!

*Jumps out of window.*

"Neo I believe!" *Splat*

But I agree with you. Its just a movie in the end. With many plot holes. Oh well.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Singh on November 12, 2003, 05:00:28 am
Quote
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
Noo! Its all real! I believe it! Don't say its not! AAARGH!

*Jumps out of window.*

"Neo I believe!" *Splat*

But I agree with you. Its just a movie in the end. With many plot holes. Oh well.


Still doesn't change the fact that the spectacular action scenes and the last stand (at least for a last stand based on Earth rather than space) in particular make it a damn good movie. :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 12, 2003, 07:49:46 am
what spectacular action scene? Surely not the boring robots-shooting-at-robots-with-men shootfest, with absolutely no emotion whatsover, and that dragged on for about three weeks (or so it seemed)?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 12, 2003, 11:21:15 am
Quote
Originally posted by Singh
Umm......yeah.
Its not reality, just a story
Stories are supposed to abide by their own rules. The premise of the Matrix, however unlikely, was firmly defined-- People made machines, machines took over, made people into batteries. Any super powers in the Matrix come from exploiting it. Outside the Matrix, people are just ordinary, everyday people. That is the premise the first film hammered into us.

The end of Reloaded then discarded that premise. The new rule from that point onward was merely, "Anything goes". And as a wise writer once asked, "If anything can happen, why should I care?".


And on a complete tangent, I only recently tweaked to the fact that since only humans are jacked into the Matrix, that means that every single animal is actually a program. Yeah, I'm slow sometimes.

Kinda makes you want to keep an eye on your dog though. And so much for trying to communicate with dolphins.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 12, 2003, 11:39:38 am
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
And on a complete tangent, I only recently tweaked to the fact that since only humans are jacked into the Matrix, that means that every single animal is actually a program. Yeah, I'm slow sometimes.

Kinda makes you want to keep an eye on your dog though. And so much for trying to communicate with dolphins.


You mean that all that time when I went to SeaWorld and those dolphins sprayed me with their blowholes, you mean it was actually the Machines in the Real World trying to tell me something??? :eek2: :eek: :shaking: :nervous: :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 12, 2003, 11:54:20 am
Then what does it mean when my dog tries to hump my leg?

:nervous:...What?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: aldo_14 on November 12, 2003, 01:58:03 pm
It means you may want to wash your trousers.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 12, 2003, 05:08:26 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
And on a complete tangent, I only recently tweaked to the fact that since only humans are jacked into the Matrix, that means that every single animal is actually a program. Yeah, I'm slow sometimes.

So you missed the conversation between Neo and the Oracle in Reloaded?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Rictor on November 13, 2003, 01:04:38 am
9 PAGES?!   HAVE YOU PEOPLE NO MERCY!!


I'de really like someone to respond to my giganto-post cause it would suck if everyone was simply tired of discussing this stuff and I just read 9 pages for nothing. Also, please forgive the multiple spelling errors which are bound to occur in  post this size. I am not a very good speller when I'm typing fast, but as long as you get the point of what I'm tring to say...  


A list of my general beef with the Matrix logic:

-If you know that the Matrix isn't real, then nothing can harm you. If you get shot, you just have to realize its not real, and they won't harm you.

-If you know the laws of gravity etc aren't real, then if you can move at speed X while living the illusion, and at speed 3X while unplugged, then why not at speed 100X or 1000X or at infinite speed. If you know the laws of physics are just an illusion, then you can totally ignore them, not just bend them slightly. Or if you like, you can bend them alot, so you move at speeds which no agent will be able to match.

-Why is Neo special? What he is able to do, he does as a result of the realisation that he can do whatever he wants in the Matrix. Wouldn't it be logical that EVERYONE else who has been unplugged has come to this same realisation? I would think that everyone would be able to be like Neo inside the Matrix and then some.

-If you simply unplugged everyone from the Matrix, then like 99.99% of people would die from starvarion, exposure or just from drowning in that big lake (or whatever) into which you get ejected. You can't very well just release 6 billions (maybe more) people out into the world, with no food, no shelter and no nothing. However, the machines would be able to survive to some degree and would most likely be able to wipe ou the rest of humanity. Simple freeing everyone insde the Matrix is not the way to win the war. Well it is, but it would also wipe out the vast majority of the human race, and the machines would mop up what was left.


OK here are my thoughts on Revolutions, in no particular order:

- I really don't have much of an opinion yet, becuase I don't understand just what the hell happened. Once I  do, I'll be more fit to judge. On the surface, it seemed like an action movie with continuity thrown to the wind. However, I think that it all fits in once you figure it out, and once you do (or someone else does, and explains it) you'll just go "Ahh, holy ****, it all makes sense, that was indeed and awesome movie"

- What happened in the end? I don't think the machines decided to just let everyone go who wanted to go. I think maybe the Oracle was reffering to programs, not humans.

-The war is over? No its not. The machines just stopped their attack on Zion. They still know where it is, they can still take it out. They still have the Matrix around. Humanity is still enslaved. The war isn't over.The only thing that has changed, is that THIS time, Zion was left in a slightly better chape that before (aka destroyed), and also the people in Zion didn't die to they have knowledge of what came before so it not all one big circle.

-Smith being able to go over into the real world seems very plausible. After all, in order for the Matrix to function, the human mind must be able to both upload and download info to the Machine Processor (the Matrix engine or whatever) and vice versa. If you're infected inside the Matrix, Smith's brain patterns (which are obviously as suffisticated as human, since the AI programs have almost all the movement/recognition/thinking capabilities of humans) are simply "written" into you brain (you physical brain)

-The Merovingian wants the eyes of the Oracle so that he can see into the future. When Smith assimilated the Oracle, you could see that when he looked around he had this amazed look on hs face, lke he saw everything in a new light. This is why he laughed (I actualy quite likd that part, it makes sense in the context) becuase he realized he had this cool new power.

-The Sentinels were flying around in big waves cause their job was to draw fire away from the diggers, until they breached the walls, and then they would really start attacking. So until the walls were breached, the Sentinels were useless so they were just decoys.

-If you can mount EMPs on ships, why not on buildings. They could easily have like 10-100 EMPS inside Zion, and they only needed 2 actually. One would be to take out the first wave, and then another to take out the second wave. It makes alot of sense for Zion to have a ton of EMP defences.

-One part that I don't understand is how Neo can control machines in the real world. One theory tha would explain this is if there were multiple Matrix layers, but this isn't the case. Even though he has machine code (or whatever) in his mind, his body is still human. And as far as I know, the human body is not capable of transimitting any signal at all, much less one that could distrupt a machine.

-The Neo-blindfold was nicely done, and it seemed to me that this was obviously a nod to some anime. You also had similar blindfolds in Last Flight of the Osiris.

-I have NO idea what happened at the end there. Was the Matrix just reset? I don' think it was.

-Neo didn't sacrifice himself, he was defeated. Or maybe, he let himself be defeated, becuase he knew the only way to kill Smith was to let himself be absorbed. Dont know.

-The choice that the Oracle was reffering to (her choice, the one she had to make), it might the following:  let Neo sacrifice himself and really achieve nothing in the end, or set him on the path that would result in him doing what every other The One has done before and just continue the circle. It was probably not too late to get on that path, and she did mention that it was harder to make a choice knowing full well the consequences, which would imply that she had made that choice before, which would imply that the previous The Ones had come to the point where it was up to the Oracle, which means that they all took the "Save Trinity" door and not the "Save Humanity" door. Which leads to my next point:

-How do we know that our Neo was different than all the previous ones by choosing the "Save Trinity" door. I don't remember the Architect ever saying which door they choose, just implying it. Or even if he did say it, he might have been lying. He is a machine afterall, and wants to work for the benefit f the machines. So "nudging" Neo towards the "Save Trinity" door would be his way of doing what was best for machine-kind, since we know that it turned out well for the machines in the end. I wonder what would have happened if Neo saw through the facade and chose the "Save Humanity" door, which might have actually been better for humanity and not worse, as the Architect implyed. The Architect also mentione that Neo was the first to manifest love, so the "Save Trinity" door might have been somthing esle for the previous The Ones (such as Save Oracle or Save Morpheus) becuase the Archtect mentioned that Neo was the first to manifest the emotion of love, but that all the previous ones had manifested some other emotion (I can remember the exact line) which might have persuaded the to not choose the "Save Humanity" door out of some emotion such as duty, honour or whatever.

________

Ok, its almost 2am and I need to take a whizz. I'de kind like to know what other people think of the little logical puzzles and whatnot.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stryke 9 on November 13, 2003, 01:08:04 am
Better yet, why not ignore physics long enough to throw a chair at .5c and then start paying attention to it again long enough for the chair and whatever it hits to explode nicely?

Would certainly make those agent fights a good deal cooler. Everything's better with nuclear explosions.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 13, 2003, 04:43:46 am
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
The chain of events in Reloaded was so painfully contrived, it was like something directly out of a video game. The whole movie had Our Heroes running from point A to point B to point C, battling a mini-boss here and there (who always knew they were coming), collecting items for their quest, and culminating with one of the laziest cliches of gaming, the timed sequence.


Dude, didn't you love beating the Merovingian Henchmen, getting the Keymaker in that awesome cutscene, and then getting onto level 5? I mean, it was seriously, just, uhh... oh, right.

[q]Or even if he did say it, he might have been lying.[/q]

Rictor, read your whole post, I agree with most of it. :) Only point that I care to raise (and which I don't remember being raised earlier on this thread) is that you have to basically take him for truth - otherwise, you can't really make any theories on anything that anyone says, because... it just all falls down. :ick
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Styxx on November 13, 2003, 06:27:22 am
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
When Smith assimilated the Oracle, you could see that when he looked around he had this amazed look on hs face, lke he saw everything in a new light. This is why he laughed (I actualy quite likd that part, it makes sense in the context) becuase he realized he had this cool new power.


Actually, I think that Smith laughed because he saw himself beating Neo in the future, not because he had those "cool new powers".

:)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 13, 2003, 09:09:11 am
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-If you know that the Matrix isn't real, then nothing can harm you. If you get shot, you just have to realize its not real, and they won't harm you.

The answer to this is simple: that's not how it works.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-If you know the laws of gravity etc aren't real, then if you can move at speed X while living the illusion, and at speed 3X while unplugged, then why not at speed 100X or 1000X or at infinite speed. If you know the laws of physics are just an illusion, then you can totally ignore them, not just bend them slightly. Or if you like, you can bend them alot, so you move at speeds which no agent will be able to match.

It's not just a matter of knowing it's a simulation. Notice the jump scene in The Matrix. At that point, Neo already knows he's inside a computer simulation, yet he is unable to ignore the laws of physics in order to get to the other building.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-Why is Neo special? What he is able to do, he does as a result of the realisation that he can do whatever he wants in the Matrix. Wouldn't it be logical that EVERYONE else who has been unplugged has come to this same realisation? I would think that everyone would be able to be like Neo inside the Matrix and then some.

This continues my previous point. In order to bend the rules of the simulation, you need a certain level of understanding. The whole first movie is about that, it's Neo's path to enlightenment. Being the One, he is able to 'free his mind' to degrees unimaginable to common people.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-If you simply unplugged everyone from the Matrix, then like 99.99% of people would die from starvarion, exposure or just from drowning in that big lake (or whatever) into which you get ejected. You can't very well just release 6 billions (maybe more) people out into the world, with no food, no shelter and no nothing. However, the machines would be able to survive to some degree and would most likely be able to wipe ou the rest of humanity. Simple freeing everyone insde the Matrix is not the way to win the war. Well it is, but it would also wipe out the vast majority of the human race, and the machines would mop up what was left.

I'm not sure what your point is. It's not like everyone was instantly freed after Revolutions.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
- What happened in the end? I don't think the machines decided to just let everyone go who wanted to go. I think maybe the Oracle was reffering to programs, not humans.

Nope, they were talking about human beings.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-The war is over? No its not. The machines just stopped their attack on Zion. They still know where it is, they can still take it out. They still have the Matrix around. Humanity is still enslaved. The war isn't over.The only thing that has changed, is that THIS time, Zion was left in a slightly better chape that before (aka destroyed), and also the people in Zion didn't die to they have knowledge of what came before so it not all one big circle.

The war is over. Humanity is no longer enslaved. If you choose to stay plugged into the Matrix, it's not much of a prison anymore.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-If you can mount EMPs on ships, why not on buildings. They could easily have like 10-100 EMPS inside Zion, and they only needed 2 actually. One would be to take out the first wave, and then another to take out the second wave. It makes alot of sense for Zion to have a ton of EMP defences.

What about the third wave? What about the countless other waves that would attack if the previous ones were defeated? Zion never had any chance.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-One part that I don't understand is how Neo can control machines in the real world. One theory tha would explain this is if there were multiple Matrix layers, but this isn't the case. Even though he has machine code (or whatever) in his mind, his body is still human. And as far as I know, the human body is not capable of transimitting any signal at all, much less one that could distrupt a machine.

Neo is always connected to the Source. Through the Source he is able to manipulate machine code. That's also how he sees the machines after having his eyes burnt.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-I have NO idea what happened at the end there. Was the Matrix just reset? I don' think it was.

Yes, it was reloaded. Not exactly like the previous times, though.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-Neo didn't sacrifice himself, he was defeated. Or maybe, he let himself be defeated, becuase he knew the only way to kill Smith was to let himself be absorbed. Dont know.

I'll let you figure this out by yourself.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-The choice that the Oracle was reffering to (her choice, the one she had to make), it might the following:  let Neo sacrifice himself and really achieve nothing in the end, or set him on the path that would result in him doing what every other The One has done before and just continue the circle. It was probably not too late to get on that path, and she did mention that it was harder to make a choice knowing full well the consequences, which would imply that she had made that choice before, which would imply that the previous The Ones had come to the point where it was up to the Oracle, which means that they all took the "Save Trinity" door and not the "Save Humanity" door.

The choice the Oracle had to make was to help or not to help Neo. She chose to help, by letting Smith take over her.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
-How do we know that our Neo was different than all the previous ones by choosing the "Save Trinity" door. I don't remember the Architect ever saying which door they choose, just implying it. Or even if he did say it, he might have been lying. He is a machine afterall, and wants to work for the benefit f the machines. So "nudging" Neo towards the "Save Trinity" door would be his way of doing what was best for machine-kind, since we know that it turned out well for the machines in the end. I wonder what would have happened if Neo saw through the facade and chose the "Save Humanity" door, which might have actually been better for humanity and not worse, as the Architect implyed. The Architect also mentione that Neo was the first to manifest love, so the "Save Trinity" door might have been somthing esle for the previous The Ones (such as Save Oracle or Save Morpheus) becuase the Archtect mentioned that Neo was the first to manifest the emotion of love, but that all the previous ones had manifested some other emotion (I can remember the exact line) which might have persuaded the to not choose the "Save Humanity" door out of some emotion such as duty, honour or whatever.

First of all, it was not the 'save Trinity' door. It was the 'back to the Matrix' door. The Architect never said Neo would be able to save Trinity by choosing the left door - he said said she would die no matter what door Neo chose.

Also, the previous five Ones did choose the right door. Otherwise either humanity would no longer exist or they would have found a way to break the cycle.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 13, 2003, 09:16:13 am
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
Neo is always connected to the Source. Through the Source he is able to manipulate machine code. That's also how he sees the machines after having his eyes burnt.


Right. How?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 13, 2003, 10:04:03 am
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
So you missed the conversation between Neo and the Oracle in Reloaded?
I didn't miss it, and the bit about the birds being programs seemed so self-evident that I didn't give it a second thought. However, at the time I only considered the information in the context that it was presented-- background creatures like birds, rats, insects, etc.

You'll note that there are few if any large or companion animals shown in The Matrix. Probably precisely because it would distract the audience into wondering what sort of human-friendly AIs run them.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 13, 2003, 10:04:26 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep


Right. How?


WiFi.  Or what ever is the latest thing in 600 years.  :wtf:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Rictor on November 13, 2003, 10:07:11 am
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan

The answer to this is simple: that's not how it works.


Why not? The Matrix series seems to be fairly good at keeping up with its own internal logic, so why not this?  Keep in mind, this is just a logical reasoning of what the experience should
be like, not what it actually is. It would probably not be so simple if it were really to happen, but it just seems to be a matter of being in control of your own mind

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
It's not just a matter of knowing it's a simulation. Notice the jump scene in The Matrix. At that point, Neo already knows he's inside a computer simulation, yet he is unable to ignore the laws of physics in order to get to the other building.


Thats right, but it was the first jump; the first time he's ever done it. It stands to reason that he would improve with time. If i were in that situation, I'de just calmly walk across, on the air....:):)

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
This continues my previous point. In order to bend the rules of the simulation, you need a certain level of understanding. The whole first movie is about that, it's Neo's path to enlightenment. Being the One, he is able to 'free his mind' to degrees unimaginable to common people.


Yup, I think thats what Morpheus was reffering to when he said "There's a difference between knowing the path and walking the path". There's a difference between knowing its not real, and believing its not real. However, it seems to be thats its just a matter of self discipline and control over your mind, which could be the answer to the question, since most people dont seem to be very good at that.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
I'm not sure what your point is. It's not like everyone was instantly freed after Revolutions.


Right. But, I think that it was sort of implied throughout the trilogy that freeing everyone was their ultimate goal. They simply couldn't pull it off. Maybe, maybe not. I'm just noteing the fact that freeing everyone all at once is not a feasible solution.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
Nope, they were talking about human beings.


I'm not quite sure here. The first time I saw the movie, (well the only time) I immediatly thought they were reffering to machines. Its not until I read other people's view on the subject that I even considered the possibility that they were talking about humans. Its just that, it kinda makes sense since there was alot of talk about exiled programs, especially in Revolutions. As well, I still don't believe machines would just let humanity go. Its not logical. And from what I can gather, the Machine Mainframe (whatever its called, the machine "leadership") functions on logic, not emotion (such as compation) so they would really have no reason to honour their promise to Neo, since honour is not something that is very high on the machine's priority list.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
The war is over. Humanity is no longer enslaved. If you choose to stay plugged into the Matrix, it's not much of a prison anymore.


Again, I dont believe the machines would let humanity choose. They have no reason to do so, other than their promise to Neo, and who says that machines feel honour-bound to follow up on their promises. They are clearly stronger, they still need the humans to survive so really they have no reason to let them go.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
What about the third wave? What about the countless other waves that would attack if the previous ones were defeated? Zion never had any chance.


Well, from what I've seen, the machines sent in an attack wave to kill off Zion. Once the Hammer hit the EMP, the first wave went down, and the machines sent in all the remaining Sentinels to take advantage of the situation. I don't think it was ever intended for the second wave to go in. Also, Locke (I think) said that the machines would send all their remaining forces to strike Zion while it was disabled. So that means that the first wave+the second wave =most of the machine army. 10 or so EMPs would certainly be enough to handle any additional waves, which would probably be so small that they could be taken care of by the APU squads (assuming they were kept a safe distance away from the EMPs as a backup plan). This is why Neo and Trinity had such an easy time getting to the machine city, all the Sentinel forces were otherwise engaged.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
Neo is always connected to the Source. Through the Source he is able to manipulate machine code. That's also how he sees the machines after having his eyes burnt.


Hmm, don't quite understand this. From what I know, Neo still has a human body. And a human body is not capable of broadcasting signals. However, since we only use a small percentage of our brain's potential, maybe the unused part is capable of transmitting, and this is the part that Neo unlocked (or had unlocked because he is The One). If his human mind was capable of transmitting a signal, then him being The One could explain how what signal is able to interfere with the machines, since he is connected to the Source.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
Yes, it was reloaded. Not exactly like the previous times, though.


I just don't buy it. The whole Matrix story has to achieve something more than "a slight improvement over previous times". Its got be have a greater impact.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
I'll let you figure this out by yourself.


Yeah, thats kinda the plan

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
The choice the Oracle had to make was to help or not to help Neo. She chose to help, by letting Smith take over her.


But what if thats what happened the previous times. The Architect could have been lying about Zion having been destroyed and Neo choosing X men and Y women to remake it.  In that case, the Oracle would have to choose between doing what she did (talking to Neo, letting Smith assimilate her) and simply continue the circle, or telling Neo how to really make a change.

Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
First of all, it was not the 'save Trinity' door. It was the 'back to the Matrix' door. The Architect never said Neo would be able to save Trinity by choosing the left door - he said said she would die no matter what door Neo chose.

Also, the previous five Ones did choose the right door. Otherwise either humanity would no longer exist or they would have found a way to break the cycle.


Assuming he was telling the truth. Its just that once people see some guy in ahite suit who looks like he knows whats going on, they assume that he is a source of truthful information. Remember, even the programs (the Architect, the Oracle) have their own agendas.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Rictor on November 13, 2003, 10:08:55 am
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
I didn't miss it, and the bit about the birds being programs seemed so self-evident that I didn't give it a second thought. However, at the time I only considered the information in the context that it was presented-- background creatures like birds, rats, insects, etc.

You'll note that there are few if any large or companion animals shown in The Matrix. Probably precisely because it would distract the audience into wondering what sort of human-friendly AIs run them.


Well, I don't see why animals wouldn't be in the same situation as humans. They still generate heat and power, so they would also be useful to the machines.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 13, 2003, 10:10:20 am
As I understood it, the animals weren't AI's, they were just programs. No more sentient or intelligent than the rain.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 13, 2003, 10:56:17 am
Quote
Originally posted by ubermetroid


WiFi.  Or what ever is the latest thing in 600 years.  :wtf:


Ah, so you can go to the internet in your brain. Why didn't I think of that. I always thought you'd need some kind of transmitter for that. Not that Neo would need one, even if he is an all powerful mighty god-being. There was never said anything about the machines implanting a god damn cellular phone into everyone's brain. I always though making a hole thingy where you could tap into someone's neural system was enough. But, as it seems, you need a cellular phone in your brain for it to work. 'course. And if Neo did have a cell phone in his brain, wouldn't it kinda negate the purpose of having a god-damn big dildo shoved into the back of his head every time he entered the Matrix?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 13, 2003, 10:58:25 am
But without the dildo, there'd be no point.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 13, 2003, 11:12:11 am
The entire movie was without point, so one more wouldn't really make a difference.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 13, 2003, 02:33:33 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Levyathan
It's not just a matter of knowing it's a simulation. Notice the jump scene in The Matrix. At that point, Neo already knows he's inside a computer simulation, yet he is unable to ignore the laws of physics in order to get to the other building.

This continues my previous point. In order to bend the rules of the simulation, you need a certain level of understanding. The whole first movie is about that, it's Neo's path to enlightenment. Being the One, he is able to 'free his mind' to degrees unimaginable to common people.


Another good way to think about this is pretend Quake is the Matrix.  You know it is not real, but those weapons will still kill you.  Now to be Neo you need to know how to input the cheat codes.  Neo was the only one that was truely able to press ` and type in GOD and NOCLIP.  (what ever the codes are).
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Rictor on November 13, 2003, 03:14:21 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ubermetroid
Now to be Neo you need to know how to input the cheat codes. Neo was the only one that was truely able to press ` and type in GOD and NOCLIP.


:lol: :lol:
Sig worthy.

Can anyone say aimbot?

__

Oh and, the Matrix is not like Quake. In Quake, you play with a set rule system. However, in the Matrix, there are really no rules, since you are free to use/not use any rules you wish. So basically, its like everyone has permanent god mode, except that its much more versitile since the world is much more interactive.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Dark_4ce on November 13, 2003, 04:55:46 pm
I still think Neo in the end merged with the matrix and took control of it... But thats just me...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stryke 9 on November 13, 2003, 05:19:50 pm
What I wanna know is- right, they've got this simulation of New York City, right (only 5 million humans left alive, then, but that's irrelevant)? And they establish pretty well that they can't handle anything bigger- Neo never bothers with it, Smith never bothers with it, everyone who's relevant in any way to the story lives somewhere in NY. New York is the world to them.

So, in all the hundreds of years of Matrixing, nobody ever tried to leave the city? Nobody reached any technological advance, built any structures, did anything that could deviate from the set scripting of the structure?

Yeah, right. Nobody in New York went on vacation in their entire lives. I wanna see what's outside the city. See, this sort of thing is why Dark City was so much better. That and the Strangers kicked ass- I have got to get some clothes like theirs.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 13, 2003, 05:44:09 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Why not? The Matrix series seems to be fairly good at keeping up with its own internal logic, so why not this?  Keep in mind, this is just a logical reasoning of what the experience should be like, not what it actually is. It would probably not be so simple if it were really to happen, but it just seems to be a matter of being in control of your own mind

It's obviously much harder than it seems.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Thats right, but it was the first jump; the first time he's ever done it. It stands to reason that he would improve with time. If i were in that situation, I'de just calmly walk across, on the air....:):)

If it was that easy, why would average unplugged people have any trouble when dealing with agents?
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Yup, I think thats what Morpheus was reffering to when he said "There's a difference between knowing the path and walking the path". There's a difference between knowing its not real, and believing its not real. However, it seems to be thats its just a matter of self discipline and control over your mind, which could be the answer to the question, since most people dont seem to be very good at that.

I'll just repeat what I've already said. You're assuming it's easy.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
I'm not quite sure here. The first time I saw the movie, (well the only time) I immediatly thought they were reffering to machines. Its not until I read other people's view on the subject that I even considered the possibility that they were talking about humans. Its just that, it kinda makes sense since there was alot of talk about exiled programs, especially in Revolutions.

So you think they were talking about letting exiled programs get out of the Matrix? Considering that exiles are in the Matrix to avoid getting deleted, I'm pretty sure that doesn't make sense.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
As well, I still don't believe machines would just let humanity go. Its not logical. And from what I can gather, the Machine Mainframe (whatever its called, the machine "leadership") functions on logic, not emotion (such as compation) so they would really have no reason to honour their promise to Neo, since honour is not something that is very high on the machine's priority list.

The Architect's last line in Revolutions proves you wrong.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Again, I dont believe the machines would let humanity choose. They have no reason to do so, other than their promise to Neo, and who says that machines feel honour-bound to follow up on their promises. They are clearly stronger, they still need the humans to survive so really they have no reason to let them go.

As I've already said in this very thread, not everyone plugged into the Matrix would reject it and choose to live in the real world. Take a look at Cypher, for example. If some people are willing to do all that just to get back to the Matrix, it's safe to assume that a considerable fraction of humanity will remain plugged in.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Well, from what I've seen, the machines sent in an attack wave to kill off Zion. Once the Hammer hit the EMP, the first wave went down, and the machines sent in all the remaining Sentinels to take advantage of the situation. I don't think it was ever intended for the second wave to go in. Also, Locke (I think) said that the machines would send all their remaining forces to strike Zion while it was disabled. So that means that the first wave+the second wave =most of the machine army. 10 or so EMPs would certainly be enough to handle any additional waves, which would probably be so small that they could be taken care of by the APU squads (assuming they were kept a safe distance away from the EMPs as a backup plan).

After having a whole wave destroyed by a single EMP, I very much doubt the machines would risk sending their entire army. More likely that second wave was just one more of countless others they had outside the city, waiting. This makes even more sense when you consider the tactics the Sentinels were applying - it really didn't seem like the machines were worried about the loss of a few thousand Sentinels.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
This is why Neo and Trinity had such an easy time getting to the machine city, all the Sentinel forces were otherwise engaged.

Easy time? If not for Neo's powers, any number of ships approaching that defense line would get instantly destroyed.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Hmm, don't quite understand this. From what I know, Neo still has a human body. And a human body is not capable of broadcasting signals.

A human body doesn't have a hole on the back of the head, either. What I mean is, we do not know how deep the modifications Neo's body has gone through really are.
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
I just don't buy it. The whole Matrix story has to achieve something more than "a slight improvement over previous times". Its got be have a greater impact.

Like, humans and machines existing together in peace?
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
But what if thats what happened the previous times. The Architect could have been lying about Zion having been destroyed and Neo choosing X men and Y women to remake it.  In that case, the Oracle would have to choose between doing what she did (talking to Neo, letting Smith assimilate her) and simply continue the circle, or telling Neo how to really make a change.

Why would that be true?
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Assuming he was telling the truth. Its just that once people see some guy in ahite suit who looks like he knows whats going on, they assume that he is a source of truthful information. Remember, even the programs (the Architect, the Oracle) have their own agendas.

Then we'd have no clue as to what is really going on and anything would be possible.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 13, 2003, 05:47:41 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stryke 9
What I wanna know is- right, they've got this simulation of New York City, right (only 5 million humans left alive, then, but that's irrelevant)? And they establish pretty well that they can't handle anything bigger- Neo never bothers with it, Smith never bothers with it, everyone who's relevant in any way to the story lives somewhere in NY. New York is the world to them.

Okaay... Where did you take that from?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Kamikaze on November 13, 2003, 06:15:04 pm
Wouldn't the megacluster required to compute the matrix require more power than humans could ever produce? Even with technological advances of a few hundred years, I doubt a parallel processing system that complex could possibly be energy efficient.

Why use the matrix anyway? Why not just plug the humans up into some chemical-injection system so they can have joyous orgies day and night instead of this "real life" stuff? Really, a bunch of orgasmic humans are a lot safer than the people who are plugged into "real life", though a bit messy. ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 13, 2003, 06:42:17 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Kamikaze
Wouldn't the megacluster required to compute the matrix require more power than humans could ever produce?
smacks Kamikaze with a rolled-up copy of Moore's Law
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 13, 2003, 07:41:29 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Kamikaze

Why use the matrix anyway? Why not just plug the humans up into some chemical-injection system so they can have joyous orgies day and night instead of this "real life" stuff? Really, a bunch of orgasmic humans are a lot safer than the people who are plugged into "real life", though a bit messy. ;)


Well the first Matrix was perfect but it failed and huge crops were lost.  Perfect to me would be alot of orgasmic girls and me.  ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Kamikaze on November 13, 2003, 07:44:37 pm
Maybe... but the Architect doesn't look like the type that goes for orgasmic girls. :p
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Grey Wolf on November 13, 2003, 08:49:59 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
smacks Kamikaze with a rolled-up copy of Moore's Law
Reminds ZylonBane that even Moore doesn't think Moore's Law can last much longer.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stryke 9 on November 13, 2003, 10:21:39 pm
Levy: From the fact that they specify that it's a simulation of New York in the first Matrix. From the fact that everything, absolutely everything, occurs somewhere in or immediately around Manhattan Island. From the fact that nowhere do they even mention the concept of non-New Yorkers, except when specifically referring to the people in Zion or whatever. You're gonna tell me that they've got an entire planet there, but they just happened to cluster everything of any even potential significance at all in a ten-square-mile area? That the Oracle and Whatsisname just happened to land in this one place? It'd be a terrible stretch to say there's anything else out there- and it's a concept the movie ignores entirely.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Kamikaze on November 13, 2003, 10:27:14 pm
We know for a fact that there's more space, in Reloaded Neo ended up in some mountains that were 60 miles, or something to that effect, away.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stryke 9 on November 13, 2003, 10:33:27 pm
Ah. Didn't see that bit, don't think.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Drew on November 13, 2003, 11:09:22 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stryke 9
That the Oracle and Whatsisname just happened to land in this one place? It'd be a terrible stretch to say there's anything else out there- and it's a concept the movie ignores entirely.

dude, remeber, the oracle can reach anywere through the back doors. And neo and gang can jack in to any place they want, the mountains or lower manhattan...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 14, 2003, 12:25:55 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stryke 9
Levy: From the fact that they specify that it's a simulation of New York in the first Matrix. From the fact that everything, absolutely everything, occurs somewhere in or immediately around Manhattan Island. From the fact that nowhere do they even mention the concept of non-New Yorkers, except when specifically referring to the people in Zion or whatever. You're gonna tell me that they've got an entire planet there, but they just happened to cluster everything of any even potential significance at all in a ten-square-mile area? That the Oracle and Whatsisname just happened to land in this one place? It'd be a terrible stretch to say there's anything else out there- and it's a concept the movie ignores entirely.


Except in Matrix 1 in the news paper there is an article about Morphus ditching the police in london.  And if you watch the director (or who ever) talk about the movie the guy says that the city is not meant to be any city, just a big general one.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: karajorma on November 14, 2003, 04:08:42 am
Hmmmm. The film ends when the main good guy and main bad guy fly up into the air and fight each other. Where have I seen that before?

*wanders off to refine his earlier Matrix is really just a retelling of Dark City theory*
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sandwich on November 14, 2003, 05:58:11 am
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
9 PAGES?!   HAVE YOU PEOPLE NO MERCY!!


:wtf: What's so special about a measly 9 pages?
http://www.hard-light.net/forums/index.php/topic,13858.0.html

:D

Quote
Originally posted by Stryke 9
Everything's better with nuclear explosions.


LOL!!! :lol: Sig-worthy!
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Unknown Target on November 14, 2003, 06:21:36 am
I loved the Matrix: Revolutions. Sure, the dialogue was canned and cliched, but the action....whoa.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 14, 2003, 06:57:47 am
Quote
Originally posted by Rictor
Well, I don't see why animals wouldn't be in the same situation as humans. They still generate heat and power, so they would also be useful to the machines.


It wouldn't be as ironic. ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 14, 2003, 08:48:16 am
Quote
Originally posted by Stryke 9
From the fact that they specify that it's a simulation of New York in the first Matrix.

No, they don't.
Quote
Originally posted by Stryke 9
From the fact that everything, absolutely everything, occurs somewhere in or immediately around Manhattan Island.

No, it doesn't.
Quote
Originally posted by Stryke 9
From the fact that nowhere do they even mention the concept of non-New Yorkers

Yes, they do.

So, there.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Unknown Target on November 14, 2003, 08:55:36 am
New York is known, at least to the people there, as The Center of The Universe.

Why shouldn't everything that happens in The Matrix, happen there? Where would you prefer? Paris? Washington DC?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 14, 2003, 09:12:33 am
Quote
Originally posted by Kamikaze
We know for a fact that there's more space, in Reloaded Neo ended up in some mountains that were 60 miles, or something to that effect, away.
If by 60 you mean 6000, then yes. Wasn't he in the Swiss Alps?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: phreak on November 14, 2003, 09:14:55 am
i thought Link said Neo was 500 miles to the southeast or something
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 14, 2003, 09:32:43 am
I don't actually remember. Ok, here we are:
Quote

Neo: Oh ****.
Link: Operator.
Neo: Link, where am I?
Link: You're not gonna believe this, but you're all the way up in the mountains.
Neo: Really.
Link: Yeah, it's gonna take me a while to get up an exit. Oh ****.
Neo: What?
Link: Those Twin things are after Morpheus and Trinity, and I don't have a way to get them out.
Neo: Where are they?
Link: Middle of the City, 500 miles due south.

Hmm. For some reason I thought he was on the other side of the planet. Oh well, it's still far, far outside New York.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: karajorma on November 14, 2003, 10:17:56 am
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
Hmm. For some reason I thought he was on the other side of the planet.


 Probably cause the real castle they used for the shot was from the other side of the planet :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 14, 2003, 01:42:50 pm
Maybe Matrix-Earth is only 500 miles in diameter!
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Descenterace on November 14, 2003, 04:35:52 pm
That would provide an even better explanation for why they can defy gravity...  there's less of it...
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Unknown Target on November 14, 2003, 04:54:41 pm
Or they could just be in a computer world...:rolleyes:

I K|\|0\/\/!!!1111 |\30 (DA DUDE!!!1111) |_|53|) |_|83R |_337 94|\/|1|\|9 |-|4(|
:D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Grey Wolf on November 14, 2003, 06:14:12 pm
So what you're saying is that Neo went to Canada, Zylon.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 14, 2003, 07:17:31 pm
Either Canada or some other place 500 miles north of a random major city.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stryke 9 on November 15, 2003, 02:22:42 am
Levy: Um, yes, they do. Quite plainly so on the first count, if you bother to pay attention to the one string of long-winded exposition in the entire ****ing series that is worth paying attention to in the slightest; evidently entirely so on the second except for one scene; and debatably so on the third. Do you just enjoy being wrong or something?

Metroid: Yeah, they can say that, but they specify New York several times, and even if they didn't, there's all of maybe three cities on the planet that look like the one in the Matrix did and that sure as **** ain't anywhere in Asia. Basically, whoever made that claim was talking out of his ass, it's pretty damn obvious specifically where they are, it's just that the directors were on ****ing crack for the latter two movies and didn't know what the hell they were doing half the time.

UT: True, but for something of global scale, you'd expect at least a nod to global reach. Like I said previously- is there any logical reason why everything of any even passing importance would be clustered in New York? It's not so much a question of why not New York as why be restricted to one place when you're trying to save the world? Especially when a good chunk of that world-saving involves wandering pretty much aimlessly for at least one movie?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 15, 2003, 02:35:58 pm
Well, sorry then. I guess I've watched some kind of obscure version of the movie, in which all your points are invalid. How very odd.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 15, 2003, 10:22:23 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Unknown Target
Or they could just be in a computer world...:rolleyes:

I K|\|0\/\/!!!1111 |\30 (DA DUDE!!!1111) |_|53|) |_|83R |_337 94|\/|1|\|9 |-|4(|
:D


Damn...  I'm not cool enough to know what that means...  :mad:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 16, 2003, 07:29:25 am
[q]I KNOW!!!!!!! NEO (DA DUDE!!!!!!!) USED UBER LEET GAMING HACKS[/q] (I'm guess his lesser than and greater signs were parsed about by the vB)

You're not missing out that much. :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 16, 2003, 12:12:48 pm
damn 1337 n00bs ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 16, 2003, 08:42:43 pm
And on a side note, I did not know New York had billions of inhabitants. Guess I should start to make sure that I know what I'm talking about before posting, huh?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 16, 2003, 11:43:08 pm
I still don't think it took place in a fake New York.  I am going to have to watch 1 and 2 to see what I missed.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 17, 2003, 03:03:12 am
Well, I finally watched it.

And I liked it. More-so than Reloaded.

The only problems I have with it are the editting and the final 2 scenes.

There coulda been a more simultaneous feel to it instead of shifting drastically from one plot-line to the other the way it did. And the way the kid declared the war over was a little....I dunno, just kinda ghey somehow. The final scene, with the Oracle and the kid, was waaaaay too cliched for my liking. They shoulda done away with all the cutesy bits and just had the Architect's bit and the Oracle saying something profound.

As for the editting in a wider context, just re-arranging some stuff between Reloaded and Revolutions woulda made both films a whole lots better.

Really, I think all it suffers from are the final 2 scenes and a lack of flow. But I suppose it's hard to inter-mix everything when the characters are all apart, doing their own distinct thing.


Oh, and the Machine God. I'm not happy at-all with the way that situation and 'character' was presented. Something more akin to the Architects' room woulda been better, with hundreds of little machines chiming dialogue, all slightly outta sync. That way it'd've given more of a sense that he was speaking to the whole machine race as opposed to just chatting with the server.

It's just the few little nagging things that bring it down a notch.

But overall it kicked ass.

On-par with the original for watchability, if not lacking in the philosophy of it's predecessors.


And in regards to Neo, he is dead, there's no doubt about that. But he died inside the Matrix, so the essence of The One goes on. And I think that thing was less of an honour-guard and more of a "liquify the dead and feed them intravenously to the living" robot. Though I suppose it could be argued that he'd just saved both races from annihilation so they'd wanna dispose of his remains in a respectful manner.

Anyway, it's 8:57am and I've been up for 14 hours so a more indepth study of the film is going to be put on my [never]-to-do list.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 17, 2003, 09:58:24 am
Anyone else get an occasional strong "TRON" vibe from Revolutions? There were a couple occasions where I expected a character to say, "Greetings, program!" And that bit where someone says, "Neo. He fights for us.", sounded more than a little like, "Tron. He fights for the users."
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: phreak on November 17, 2003, 11:02:52 am
hmm..  i've been thinking about revolutions and the architect's little spiel at the end of the reloaded.  the architect said Neo was to return to the source to save humanity.  I'm thinking that the "source" was not actually the door on the right, but the machine city where Deus Ex Machina is (God from machine, rather fitting ;)).  When neo went to the city he saved humanity for the time being.  This may have been already said in this thread, but i haven't read that much
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Su-tehp on November 17, 2003, 11:21:16 am
Quote
Originally posted by PhReAk
hmm..  i've been thinking about revolutions and the architect's little spiel at the end of the reloaded.  the architect said Neo was to return to the source to save humanity.  I'm thinking that the "source" was not actually the door on the right, but the machine city where Deus Ex Machina is (God from machine, rather fitting ;)).  When neo went to the city he saved humanity for the time being.  This may have been already said in this thread, but i haven't read that much


My take on this is that the door on the right really did lead to the Source, but Neo, being the sixth One who was destined to take a different path than his predecessors, managed to find a different route to the Source/Deus Ex Machina.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 17, 2003, 04:07:07 pm
......They both lead to the source you fools. The right door lead straight to the machine city (where he would've just been killed by the machine), while the left door lead to the path to the machine city (where he had a chance to stop the war).

By taking the path, he was able to pick up Trinity (whose purpose was to take him back to the machine city and to show him that eventually you just had to let go and die) and give Smith time to become a problem (so he'd have a bargaining chip). By chosing to save Trinity instead and not to fight the source (left door), he stopped the overall fight.

Basically, by taking the long-route to the Mecha-God he let things fester.

And even if he had gone to the source, he was having trouble blowing up a bunch of those killer-slugs and a few Sentinels. There'd've been no way he coulda taken out the city and/or defended Xion with his powers.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 17, 2003, 05:32:48 pm
Quote
Originally posted by an0n
......They both lead to the source you fools. The right door lead straight to the machine city (where he would've just been killed by the machine)
Uhh... no. The doors existed in the Matrix. The machine city is in the real world. For a virtual door to lead to a real-world location would have been quite a trick. Also, I thought it was fairly clear that the One wouldn't be killed after entering the Source, and in fact had historically gone on to found the next iteration of Zion.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 17, 2003, 05:57:58 pm
I didn't mean literally that he'd be there. But he'd be able to screw with the real-world machines through the link, like how he screwed with the Matrix. But as I said, they'd've just electronically raped him.

And the reason all the other One's went on to found the next Xion was because they never had as much love for their Trinity as Neo did.

Everything for them went exactly the same, except for that through Trinity, Neo learned that eventually you have to risk everything to do what's really important. So where the other Ones just ignored the Machine City and tried to defend Xion (and failed) and/or to retake the Matrix, Neo left Xion to be possibly wiped out in the hopes that he could stop the war once and for all.


Granted, the order of my theoretical chain of events is a little outta-whack, but I'm too tired to fix it up any.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 17, 2003, 06:32:17 pm
Keep going you are on a role....  Try to find out WHY the machines decided to keep humans alive, was it just for power?  or to annoy anybody that got free?

Oh, and to you really think that ALL the humans are in the Matrix?  There has got to be a few that were on the Machine team from the very beggening.  Maybe the got spared and lived downunder?  :wtf:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 18, 2003, 02:29:37 am
I just started watching it over again and I've come to my first new point of interest:

I now know what that robot was at the end, the one that carried Neo away.

It was the black guy from the train station. Ramakandra.

He's the "power-plant's systems manager for recycling operations". Which means it's his job to keep those 'liquify the dead' robots doing the right job(s). And since he's a big, powerful, middle-management type who lived in the city, the big-ass robot was probably his body.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 18, 2003, 02:56:41 am
And the Oracle DID manipulate Smith.

Merovingian suggests that the "eyes of the Oracle" cannot be taken and must be given.

So she let Smith take her and see the future, knowing full well that he'd not be able to see any further than she had. That the premonitions would be halted at the battle and he wouldn't see himself being destroyed. But she still knew he'd be destroyed, not through her precognative abilities, but through her beliefs.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 18, 2003, 03:05:26 am
And Neo (nor any of the other One's for that matter) have ever chosen the Source-Door in the Archtect's room.

I summise this because the Oracle tells Neo that when he downed those Sentinels at the end of Reloaded, he was touching the Source and that, because he wasn't ready for it, it should have killed him. Now I'm guessing diving into the Source through the door is a lot worse than grazing it through the odd Sentinel.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 18, 2003, 03:07:36 am
Also, it's the Oracle's fault Smith got so much power. She engineered the whole thing.

By showing Neo that he could have so much power, she unbalanced the equation, knowing that the Architect would grant Smith a ****-load of extra power to try and rebalance the equation. All leading to Neo having a bargaining chip when meeting with the Machine God.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: karajorma on November 18, 2003, 07:30:24 am
Quote
Originally posted by an0n
I now know what that robot was at the end, the one that carried Neo away.

It was the black guy from the train station. Ramakandra.

He's the "power-plant's systems manager for recycling operations". Which means it's his job to keep those 'liquify the dead' robots doing the right job(s). And since he's a big, powerful, middle-management type who lived in the city, the big-ass robot was probably his body.


That does make sense actually but I thought it was the machine god who took in Neo's body (could easily be wrong though).

Might explain why the Oracle was so certain that Neo would be back.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 18, 2003, 09:55:16 am
I never fail to find these "philosophy dictates reality" theories amusing.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 18, 2003, 05:13:01 pm
Quote
Originally posted by an0n
I just started watching it over again and I've come to my first new point of interest:

I now know what that robot was at the end, the one that carried Neo away.

It was the black guy from the train station. Ramakandra.

He's the "power-plant's systems manager for recycling operations". Which means it's his job to keep those 'liquify the dead' robots doing the right job(s). And since he's a big, powerful, middle-management type who lived in the city, the big-ass robot was probably his body.



oooh yeah.  good point.  i never really thought of that.

although wait a second, wasn't that Indian (Arab) guy from the station just a regular program?  programs don't operate the machines though, they only work inside the Matrix, don't the machines run themselves?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: karajorma on November 18, 2003, 05:22:44 pm
He was a program from the machine city. Some programs fled the machine city to hide in the matrix. That's what he was doing with his daughter.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 18, 2003, 05:24:05 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stealth
oooh yeah.  good point.  i never really thought of that.

although wait a second, wasn't that Indian (Arab) guy from the station just a regular program?  programs don't operate the machines though, they only work inside the Matrix, don't the machines run themselves?


Well yes, but...  Remember his little girl had no job that is why she was smuggled into the Matrix?  And her mom and dad were not staying with her, she was going to live with the Oracle.  Remember, the Matrix is a world, one were both men and machines can connect to.

The junk dude just hacked in to the Matrix using the crazy subway dude's hacking methiod.  And the he dumped his little girl so she would not get shoved in the recycle bin in real life.

Edit, I now have over 100 posts!  YEA!!!  ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 18, 2003, 05:31:41 pm
karajorma and ubermetroid:  good point.  i just watched that part again, and you're right.  that's weird though, it's the fact that machines could hide in the matrix that was one of the factors that messed up one of my previous "theories" ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 19, 2003, 07:03:05 am
The Machines are probably not 'hiding' in it, as such. More like illegally networking to it.

I got the impression it was just Programs that were hiding there.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: phreak on November 19, 2003, 09:12:56 am
Ah ha!  So the matrix has to exist for the machines and humanity to interact peacefully.  The Architect and probably the Oracle have doubts wether the peace in the real world will last.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 19, 2003, 10:02:59 am
Simply networking to the Matrix wouldn't be any sort of hiding place at all. The whole idea of rogue programs hiding in the Matrix is to get their executing code off systems controlled directly by the MCP. This reinforces the implication that the Matrix is somewhat of a sealed system.

As for the Machine/Program dichotomy... there's no logical reason to assume that a given program is irrevocably tied to a given piece of hardware. Revolutions established this with the machine "couple" Neo met.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 19, 2003, 11:11:52 am
yeah.  now we're getting somewhere :D
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: 01010 on November 19, 2003, 11:43:42 am
I had a thought today, when the Logos crashed in machine city, (if it had been possible) what would the outcome of the films had been if they had used the EMP rather than Neo going to see Deus Ex Machina?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Sandwich on November 19, 2003, 04:27:59 pm
I thought of that too, but I guess the limited range of the EMP would have made its effects minimal.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 19, 2003, 05:01:01 pm
Quote
Originally posted by 01010
I had a thought today, when the Logos crashed in machine city, (if it had been possible) what would the outcome of the films had been if they had used the EMP rather than Neo going to see Deus Ex Machina?


A better ending?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 19, 2003, 05:17:15 pm
Quote
Originally posted by 01010
I had a thought today, when the Logos crashed in machine city, (if it had been possible) what would the outcome of the films had been if they had used the EMP rather than Neo going to see Deus Ex Machina?
It would have knocked out the Machine city up to the radius of the EMP. Then Sentinels would have come and killed Neo.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 19, 2003, 05:17:43 pm
naaa i don't think that'd have worked.  the EMP has a limited range, so for them to be able to do anything, they'd have to be real close.  then, remember that the ship has to be completely shut down to charge/activate the EMP, and for the ship to be stopped, it would have to be vulnerable, and all those thousands of machines attacking it, it'd be vaporized before it even came to a complete standstill
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 19, 2003, 05:26:16 pm
They're ship was ****ed at that point either way. If the ending was written around Neo EMPing the Central Machine Complex or whatever, he'd be dead by the end wether he did it or not. He could blow them up, but apparently he can only do that a little bit.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 19, 2003, 11:51:43 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
Simply networking to the Matrix wouldn't be any sort of hiding place at all. The whole idea of rogue programs hiding in the Matrix is to get their executing code off systems controlled directly by the MCP. This reinforces the implication that the Matrix is somewhat of a sealed system.

As for the Machine/Program dichotomy... there's no logical reason to assume that a given program is irrevocably tied to a given piece of hardware. Revolutions established this with the machine "couple" Neo met.

I made a distinction between Programs and Machines for that very reason. (Programs merely being Matrix constructs and Machines being the AI out in the real-world moving **** around).

Machines wouldn't hide in the Matrix. They'd only link to it so they could do things like, as in the case of Ramakandra, hide their kids there. But they'd still be controlling a Machine body out in the real world. And while that body-grabber at the end of Revolutions may not have actually been Ramakandra, it'd at least be under his control as 'recycling operations' at the 'power plant' is basically a euphamism for mushing up Matrix-corpses into pink goo.

Anyway:

When a Machine controling Program had outlived their usefulness and had become obsolete, they'd get the order to switch control to another Program and return to be deleted. It'd be at this point that they'd say "**** that" and scurry off into the Matrix before anyone could stop them.

Hmmm. I'll have to watch the Architect's speech in Reloaded again, but maybe the Machines deciding not to be deleted is part of the whole chaos thingy he was on about.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 20, 2003, 01:23:08 am
:wtf:

So the little girl would be the machines way of getting into the matrix world? And if that's right, then couldn't they have just killed Smith through her?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 20, 2003, 01:30:40 am
No, she was just a ****ty little program with no purpose.

To totally **** the Matrix over, they needed a combination of Neo's power and the root power of the Machine God.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 20, 2003, 01:44:10 am
I figured they just anti-virused Smith and then got control of the matrix again. that or the whole balancing of the equation thing, meaning it has to be balanced all the time. So if neo goes, Smith would go.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 20, 2003, 02:03:53 am
The Machines can't control the Matrix. They don't have the permissions.

Only the Architect can do that.

And the Machines couldn't find the bodies that had been infected by Smith as, since Smith had removed his ear-piece (his connection to the Machines) they'd need to run one of them red-pill tracer things on him.

Smith was also operating outside the normal bounds of the Matrix with all sorts of firewalls running inside him to make sure no-one could screw with him.

When he took Neo, he let him past his defences but also wiped all his memory. The Machines then restored Neo somewhat (the first little jolt). They then poured massive amounts of code (maybe even the Machine-God itself) into Neo's super-powers and combined the Matrix-****ing powers of the One with the uber-Source-control of the Machine God. So now they had enough power to blast through the link between the Smiths and nuke them all with a code overload.


Not one of my more coherant explainations, but it'll do in the absence of any evidence to the contrary.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 20, 2003, 02:19:20 am
Meh. Good enough.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 20, 2003, 11:15:59 am
Quote
Originally posted by an0n
The Machines can't control the Matrix. They don't have the permissions.

Only the Architect can do that.


but the architect is controlled by the machines isn't he?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 20, 2003, 02:12:35 pm
I would say that it is mor elike he is part of the Machine community.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 21, 2003, 03:17:18 am
The Architect is just another super-program. If he had any real-world manifestation, I'd say it'd be the whole 'power-plant'/Matrix.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Devils_Hitman on November 21, 2003, 03:29:19 am
he's Cornel  Sanders.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 21, 2003, 04:15:01 am
"Well, s'n. I say, we seem t' have a praahblem he'r. It seems that boiee call'd Nee-oh has caous'd sum praahblems in that the-ar May-treecks."
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: ZylonBane on November 21, 2003, 10:48:56 am
Quote
Originally posted by Knight Templar
... the whole balancing of the equation thing, meaning it has to be balanced all the time. So if neo goes, Smith would go.
I really want to whack people with a wrench when they pursue this line of thought. The balance people keep squawking about in the Matrix films is primarily a philosophical concept. The idea that, "OMG if Ne0 dies than all teh Smiths die becuz of that thing the Oracle said about him being his oposite!" is bull****. This is the sort of hopelessly fuzzy thinking that also has no problem with Neo being able to wirelessly connect to the Matrix.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 21, 2003, 07:06:30 pm
:wtf: I still thought that that was just as stupid as you apparently think it was. And I'm not really a 'balance' person.. it's just a theory.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 21, 2003, 07:06:36 pm
It sounds too much like Star Wars too....  Not that I disslike starwars, but the balance of the force is lame.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: 01010 on November 21, 2003, 09:08:55 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ZylonBane
I really want to whack people with a wrench when they pursue this line of thought. The balance people keep squawking about in the Matrix films is primarily a philosophical concept. The idea that, "OMG if Ne0 dies than all teh Smiths die becuz of that thing the Oracle said about him being his oposite!" is bull****. This is the sort of hopelessly fuzzy thinking that also has no problem with Neo being able to wirelessly connect to the Matrix.


I think that Smith dies because once Neo destroys him the first time and he comes back, his sole aim is to destroy Neo. Once he achieves that aim he has no reason to exist and he kinda just self destructs. I dunno, it's kinda a loose theory but it sort of fits to me.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 21, 2003, 11:47:42 pm
Quote
Originally posted by 01010
...his sole aim is to destroy Neo. Once he achieves that aim he has no reason to exist and he kinda just self destructs. I dunno, it's kinda a loose theory but it sort of fits to me.


Yeah, it is loose - and it ignores Smith's own declaration that he wants 'everything' (destroying Neo = everything? questionable). I like ZB's theory - Smith was connected to DEM via Neo, allowing DEM to devise and distribute an anti-virus into Smith and destroy him.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: 01010 on November 22, 2003, 03:59:45 am
Quote
Originally posted by Setekh


Yeah, it is loose - and it ignores Smith's own declaration that he wants 'everything' (destroying Neo = everything? questionable). I like ZB's theory - Smith was connected to DEM via Neo, allowing DEM to devise and distribute an anti-virus into Smith and destroy him.


My memory is shot to bits so I don't remember Smith stating that. My bad. I must admit, I do like the way a lot of the film is open to interpretation, but there are too mant important pieces of plot that seem to just happen without much explanation as to why.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Setekh on November 22, 2003, 06:38:37 am
Quote
Originally posted by 01010


My memory is shot to bits so I don't remember Smith stating that. My bad. I must admit, I do like the way a lot of the film is open to interpretation, but there are too mant important pieces of plot that seem to just happen without much explanation as to why.


[q]Smith: you look surprised to see me again, Mr. Anderson, that's the difference between us. I've been expecting you.
Neo: What do you want, Smith?
Smith: Oh you haven't figured that out? Still using all the muscles except the one that matters. I want exactly what you want. I want everything.[/q]

Transcripts are our friends. At least till I get the DVD. :)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 22, 2003, 11:12:39 am
(http://maddox.xmission.com/matrix_question_tot1.gif)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 22, 2003, 11:48:19 am
Quote
Originally posted by Setekh
Smith was connected to DEM via Neo, allowing DEM to devise and distribute an anti-virus into Smith and destroy him.

Except that it was Neo who did that, not Deus Ex Machina.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 22, 2003, 12:04:13 pm
I still think Neo, once taken by Smith, was little more than a meat-puppet for the Machine-God. It abused his body so it could screw with the Matrix.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stunaep on November 23, 2003, 04:28:19 am
Well, to sum up, The W brothers never intended it to be three movies. That's clear now.

Die, hollywood, die.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Levyathan on November 23, 2003, 09:47:59 am
That's true. They just knew they had too much material for one movie - which doesn't mean it was supposed to be a trilogy.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: übermetroid on November 23, 2003, 06:21:35 pm
I think they had plenty of meterial for 3 movies...  They just never used it all the the extreme.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 27, 2003, 12:10:25 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Stunaep
Well, to sum up, The W brothers never intended it to be three movies. That's clear now.

Die, hollywood, die.


no, they did.  in the very beginning they said there'd be three movies, one about his birth, another about his life, and yet another of his death
Title: Ver intersting...
Post by: übermetroid on November 27, 2003, 03:42:38 pm
Spoiler for the Matrix Comics...

Has anybody read the comics?  On one of the storys that Machines fight Aliens!  I am telling the truth!

The story is a good read so I suggest you get the comic and read it...  If not I guess I could post a write up about what happened...   :rolleyes:
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: diamondgeezer on November 27, 2003, 03:57:24 pm
Well, Aliens turn up all over the place. I assume you mean Aliens as in 'Alien' and 'Aliens' and so forth, anyway. I belive Superman fought them once...
Title: Re: Ver intersting...
Post by: Nico on November 27, 2003, 04:15:54 pm
Quote
Originally posted by ubermetroid
Spoiler for the Matrix Comics...

Has anybody read the comics?  On one of the storys that Machines fight Aliens!  I am telling the truth!

The story is a good read so I suggest you get the comic and read it...  If not I guess I could post a write up about what happened...   :rolleyes:


surely not in the original comics, the one from which the movies originate ( which barely even explains what the matrix is, you just get a couple hints here and there, and you never get to see how it is outside of it ).
As for the trilogy thing, that's bull****, the W brothers claimed they planed a trilogy AFTER the first one was a hit. If they really did plan 3 movies, what's with the rush to get the two others out? That makes no sense, they would have done the sme as Jackson did for the LotR trilogy, they would have shot all the scenes at the same time, then refined the CGI stuff later, releasing one movie after the other. Think that if they did the normal way, you'd only just get the second movie right now. Would you be that hot to get the third one in ne year? After the big disapointment of the second opus? I think not. That's all marketing.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Nico on November 27, 2003, 04:16:46 pm
Quote
Originally posted by diamondgeezer
Well, Aliens turn up all over the place. I assume you mean Aliens as in 'Alien' and 'Aliens' and so forth, anyway. I belive Superman fought them once...


Superman did, and so did Tarzan and terminator ( that's true ).
I wonder if Bugs Bunny didn't fight them at some point :p
Title: Re: Re: Ver intersting...
Post by: karajorma on November 27, 2003, 04:23:11 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Nico
If they really did plan 3 movies, what's with the rush to get the two others out? That makes no sense, they would have done the sme as Jackson did for the LotR trilogy, they would have shot all the scenes at the same time, then refined the CGI stuff later, releasing one movie after the other.


And I guess by that logic the team behind Space : Above and Beyond only planned one series and just left us on a cliffhanger cause they were bastards.

It is fully possible that they wanted to make three movies, planned and even partially wrote 3 but only recieved the money to make one.

Have you any idea how hard it was for Jackson to convince the New Line to make three films in a row knowing that they would be out of poicket if the first one bombed? And that was with a book that has been voted best book ever written on several occassions!
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Nico on November 27, 2003, 04:26:08 pm
You're joking, right? You probably know that for matrix reloaded alone, they had more cash than Jackson for his whole trilogy? limited cash my ass.
As for convincing New Line, there was no such thing. They would agree, or they wouldn't. It's not coz Jackson would say "come on, it's gonna be great!" that they will let him do it. They studied the possibilities, and they decided it would work. That's it.
If matrix was planed as a trilogy from the begining, everybody would have known it before the first movie started. It's exactly the same deal than with Starwars. In each case, the first movie works well as a standalone ( and in the matrix case, it still works well as a stand alone movie :doubt: ). They left it open ended in case it would be a hit, but that's it. Matrix plot was well thought, the 2 and 3 are rushed. I repeat: RUSHED. They would have spent more time on the plot, and less on the CGI, the movies would have been better.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Flipside on November 27, 2003, 04:27:20 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Nico


Superman did, and so did Tarzan and terminator ( that's true ).
I wonder if Bugs Bunny didn't fight them at some point :p


Marvin the Martian ;)
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 27, 2003, 04:39:44 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Flipside
Marvin the Martian ;)

I don't recall ever seeing him burst through anyone's ribcage.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: karajorma on November 27, 2003, 05:01:41 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Nico
You're joking, right? You probably know that for matrix reloaded alone, they had more cash than Jackson for his whole trilogy? limited cash my ass.
As for convincing New Line, there was no such thing. They would agree, or they wouldn't. It's not coz Jackson would say "come on, it's gonna be great!" that they will let him do it. They studied the possibilities, and they decided it would work. That's it.
If matrix was planed as a trilogy from the begining, everybody would have known it before the first movie started. It's exactly the same deal than with Starwars. In each case, the first movie works well as a standalone ( and in the matrix case, it still works well as a stand alone movie :doubt: ). They left it open ended in case it would be a hit, but that's it. Matrix plot was well thought, the 2 and 3 are rushed. I repeat: RUSHED. They would have spent more time on the plot, and less on the CGI, the movies would have been better.


 Mentioning Star Wars was a really bad choice. Are you really claiming that Star Wars was planned as a single movie and then expanded into a trilogy (and then later 6 movies?). Your post doesn't make it clear but if so you're going to get stomped all over by warsies for that one.

 Apart from the Episode 4 thing at the start Star Wars looks exactly like a stand alone movie. The reason being that they couldn't get the backing to shoot all six movies. They got enough to make one. When that was a success they got the money to make more. Had Star Wars not been a success they wouldn't have.

All your arguements against the Matrix are all based on your personal opinions of the movie. You don't raise a single concrete example of why the same thing that happened to Star Wars couldn't have happened to the Matrix.

Besides I remember reading an article BEFORE the matrix came out where the W brothers said it was a trilogy.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: an0n on November 27, 2003, 05:06:53 pm
Star Wars WAS planned as a single movie. But being like he is, Lucas conjoured up the back-story so his universe was more stable and coherant with better motivation and flow.

He never intended to make more than 1 film, he just wanted everything in that film to seem as though it was part of a larger universe as opposed to everything just happening within the scale of the movie.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 27, 2003, 05:22:34 pm
Quote
Originally posted by karajorma


Besides I remember reading an article BEFORE the matrix came out where the W brothers said it was a trilogy.


HA!

so you remember reading that too.  good, now i have backup :D
Title: Re: Re: Ver intersting...
Post by: Levyathan on November 27, 2003, 06:14:54 pm
Quote
Originally posted by Nico
If they really did plan 3 movies, what's with the rush to get the two others out? That makes no sense, they would have done the sme as Jackson did for the LotR trilogy, they would have shot all the scenes at the same time, then refined the CGI stuff later, releasing one movie after the other.

Yes, because everyone can take the risk of investing hundreds of millions of dollars with no guarantee of making a profit.
Quote
Originally posted by Nico
Think that if they did the normal way, you'd only just get the second movie right now. Would you be that hot to get the third one in ne year? After the big disapointment of the second opus? I think not. That's all marketing.

"Let's release the third movie right after the second, because otherwise people will notice the story sucks and won't give us more money."

That seems like quite some marketing, doesn't it?
Quote
Originally posted by Nico
You're joking, right? You probably know that for matrix reloaded alone, they had more cash than Jackson for his whole trilogy? limited cash my ass.

That statement also makes perfect sense, because they obviously can see the future, like the Oracle. That way, they knew the movie would make money before they even started working on it.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Knight Templar on November 27, 2003, 09:21:53 pm
Err.. Lucas originally had a 9 - 12 hour movie, and then script left over. For obvious reason he had to segment it into the trilogy, then he took a break I think to raise his kids or sommat before doing the first three.

Watch the interviews in the THX edition tapes.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Nico on November 28, 2003, 06:58:44 am
Whatever, seems you know the Truth, so think what you want, I know my facts and don't need to convince you.

As for StarWars, just to point out:
first release was dubbed starwars. period.
second release was dubbed episode 1
third release finally got episode 4.
wheeeeeeeeeeee. but probably I made that up, or maybe that was all part of the plan.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: aldo_14 on November 28, 2003, 07:37:20 am
Quote
Originally posted by 01010


I must admit, I do like the way a lot of the film is open to interpretation,


Doesn't that translate to 'full of plot holes'?
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: diamondgeezer on November 28, 2003, 08:45:09 am
IIRC from the THX edition interviews, Lucas said that he named New Hope episode 4 because he knew there was stuff that came before it but he hadn't figured out quite what at the time. This is a really ghey argument by the way, so I'm putting some distance between me and this thead from now on.
Title: Matrix: Revolutions
Post by: Stealth on November 28, 2003, 12:34:51 pm
naaa, it's more like a discussion :D