Originally posted by 01010
That's what I like to call overkill.
Originally posted by J3Vr6
How is a cluster bomb attack on troop positions an overkill? Can you think of a quicker way to neutralize large quantities of soldiers without the use of napalm?
This footage reminds me of the video of the marine gunship in Afghanistan taking out targets and what-not. Anyone see that one? I think it was on here before.
Originally posted by J3Vr6
His comment was regards to it being overkill, which is what I was responding to. Cluster bombs are extremely effective on troops and airstrips.
The only issues that cluster bombs have is that some don't detonate, and that could be said about any explosive device. Yeah, they look like ration packets but that's besides the point. There are hundreds of people who get killed by landmines yearly worldwide that were placed there 30-40 years ago, but it still doesn't take away from their effectiveness at stopping troop and carrier advancement during the war they were placed in.
Originally posted by mikhael
I find it interesting that they shot the guy messing with the tractor but chose not to shoot the wounded guy. They shot the pickup instead. Its obviously deliberate.
Originally posted by 01010
That's what I like to call overkill.
Army officials acknowledged that the 30 mm cannons used by the Apache gunners were far bigger than what was needed to kill the men, but said it is the smallest weapon the Apaches have.
Originally posted by Zeronet
According to ABC news, they obtained the footage and showed it. Appears to be 3 iraqi insurgents handling a cylinderical object 4 feet or so, maybe a RPG through the thermal camera of an Apache.
http://abcnews.go.com/sections/WNT/US/apache_video_040109.html
Originally posted by mikhael
From the ABC article:
Yeah. That's definately overkill.
Originally posted by mikhael
I was agreeing with you 01010. The apache's 30mm cannon IS overkill against three guys on the ground.
Originally posted by Zeronet
Appears to be 3 iraqi insurgents handling a cylinderical object 4 feet or so, maybe a RPG through the thermal camera of an Apache.
Originally posted by aldo_14
I am, as you well know, considering the recent theatres of war which the Us has been engaged in... of those, the one which seemed most likely to have farmland (as it appears to be - i.e. ploughed, seems a bit rutted) is, IMO Yugoslavia. Tenous, granted, but there is logic.
Originally posted by aldo_14
Regardless, it is somewhat tasteless that someone decided this should be made public.
Originally posted by demon442
The pilot and gunner claim that the chin turret was the smallest weapon they had(most likely true), but the human-rights advocates claim that it was overkill. And what would you have them do; if they could not use anything more than a sling-shot on well-armed militia that intend to kill you and the 2 other people with you?
Originally posted by Rictor
I think its just the opposite. I think its great that this was made public, it gives us a glimpse into the actions of the US military, which would otherwise go totally unquestion. I don't mean this in a completely negative way. Its better to have public scrutiny than have none, regardless of who is right or wrong./B]
Originally posted by Rictor
As for the SAM, I don't really know. Its seems like a excuse made up after the fact. I'de have to see the full video to make a judgement. And even then, why did they finish off the wounded guy? They could have just as easily left him there, he was in no position to threaten their safety, and ground troops could have been called in to apprehend him...
Originally posted by SadisticSid
I don't see what's so sick about it, it's not like you can tell whether the bits that are blown about the place are human flesh or ground or pieces of truck. In this way it's not much different from a bomb camera.
Originally posted by SadisticSid
I don't see what's so sick about it, it's not like you can tell whether the bits that are blown about the place are human flesh or ground or pieces of truck. In this way it's not much different from a bomb camera.
Originally posted by aldo_14
Imagine it was someone you knew or were related to.... it's the principle of the thing.
Originally posted by Knight Templar
Yeah... boo hoo. That's what happens when you're in war with an enemy in your country and you carry something that appears to be an RPG around. Sure, it might be 'shocking' to see infared blobs of people get hit by explosive rounds, spraying body matter all o'er the place, but really, shouldn't video games and moves have dessensitised you guys to this by now? :p
Originally posted by 01010
...violent nutjobs who just need a right reason to nuke their school or something.
Originally posted by Sandwich
If one has the right reason, then what's the problem? :drevil:
Originally posted by Beowulf
Actually, that isn't the whole clip. The real version shows the men handling an RPG at the sound of the helicopter. For some reason that was left out.
Originally posted by Dark_4ce
...You know how much that ammo costs? Well, Sandwich should know...
*Looks at avatar*
tho I do think thats a slightly smaller caliber, you're donning. :D