Hard Light Productions Forums

Hosted Projects - FS2 Required => Blue Planet => Topic started by: Shivan Hunter on January 03, 2011, 06:16:12 pm

Title: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Shivan Hunter on January 03, 2011, 06:16:12 pm
Battuta:  We've also been pleased by all the fan speculation. We know exactly what's going on through the end of the story so we were able to drop some pretty specific hints. Though there's an enormous one, present in ever mission of the game, that's staring people in the face and yet I suspect won't be noticed for some time.

noodlezombie mentioned this at the end of his recent post. He said he connected it to one of the tech room entries. I'm thinking "The Rift", part II specifically, but that's just a hunch. I remember mentioning the "deepness" that is referenced in both The Rift and the Ken mission, but that discussion never really went anywhere. Having not played WiH in a while there's really nothing else I remember that I can pick up on.

Anyone have speculation to add?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 03, 2011, 07:35:06 pm
I hope we can really keep this conversation focussed on only this topic (unless a mod merges it anyway). For the other speculations there was: http://www.hard-light.net/forums/index.php?topic=70799.0


Anyway, let's sum up what we have in (almost) each mission:

- We exit, often through subspace. Subspace holds many unexplained mysteries.
- Laporte becomes 'combat high'. The amazone warrioress awakens.
- Friends die. If it's not a wingman then it's a friendly vessel, often a capital ship. We do not know if Simms survives. Laporte survives the engagements. Like Simms mentioned, for some very typical (almost scary) reason she seems to be spared each time again.
- The GTVA bugs out. It saves up it's forces and reduces casualties. We do not get to finish off many ships unless we really try.
- There are constant hints to Shivans, mainly through Ken and Laporte raining down destruction in much the same fashion as Shivans have. She also has a device with quantum wave technology.
- ??
- PROFIT


SUBSPACE:

Subspace seems to connect more than just systems, it connects entire realities and seems to house through some means the essence of the Vishans I think. Something odd or wacky may come from subspace, or worse a more permanent subspace anamoly may form. Perhaps over-using subspace does terrible things to space! The ending may hold something in this direction, or not.

COMBAT HIGH:

Laporte's bloodlust may grow steadily. Perhaps she will rise to a position of influence where she triggers more war and destruction. Does she cause infighting within the UEF or perhaps presses on to Delta Serpentis after a bloodied victory? This girl may get out of hand, or get at odds with Sam Bei.

FRIENDS DIE. LAPORTE SURVIVES:

Many more friends may die, or on a larger scale, the UEF may be defeaten. Laporte may have to flee or lead an exile, perhaps (but not per se) bound to get revenge someday. Laporte seems to survive each time. She might be a very valuable pawn in a larger power it's hands. She is seemingly spared against many odds.

GTVA BUGS OUT:

The GTVA may lose the battle. Unforseen events, such as Vasudan intervention or a Vasudan retreat may force the hand of the non-Sol terrans. Or equally bad, tactical mistakes may be made or otherwise unforseen UEF strategies may force the GTVA out of Sol (or into a treaty).

SHIVANS:

The UEF is losing the war or a pivotal battle and Laporte may use her quantum wave device. It might trigger Shivans who come to destroye the GTVA. While Laporte saves Sol this way, she opened a Pandora's box and the Shivans long ago stopped playing fair. Laporte may have sold Sol's soul to the metaphorical devil.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 03, 2011, 07:42:13 pm
Quote
The Jester was fixated upon something he called a 'deepness' which he could not describe.
I think this is super importent and has something to do with subspace and interdimensional shifts and giant spacetime-consuming worms
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Droid803 on January 03, 2011, 07:47:51 pm
Mmm yes, the worms.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 03, 2011, 07:48:44 pm
Quote
The Jester was fixated upon something he called a 'deepness' which he could not describe.
I think this is super importent and has something to do with subspace and interdimensional shifts and giant spacetime-consuming worms

Or total destruction of all sentient life, a void, by the lack of a trinity. No more preserving and too much destruction may destroye any able race which could have joined this trinity.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Shivan Hunter on January 03, 2011, 08:32:55 pm
Found my post, I mention the deepness here (http://www.hard-light.net/forums/index.php?topic=70799.msg1415858#msg1415858). It's being set up to be a major huge plot point, but there are no specifics yet... are there? The stuff I mentioned in my post is really the only research I've done on the subject.

Ttuta says that foreshadowing for this particular plot twist is staring us in the face, but I'm generally not the one to pick up on subtle hints.

Are there other possibilities? The Jester said that "something unspeakably terrible would happen within the next 50 years", which places it squarely in the BP2 timeframe. The forces at work are obviously more powerful than either Terrans or Vasudans- the Vishnans are extradimensional and the Shivans have Cthulhu knows how many juggernaughts at their disposal- which means that something like complete eradication of several star systems is possible. Strictly speaking, complete eradication of the entire Terran and Vasudan species is possible very easily but that would effectively end the plot, so it's unlikely to happen before the end of BP3.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Aardwolf on January 04, 2011, 01:27:30 am
[/lurk]

Something in each mission? "Laporte"

[lurk]

Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Mars on January 04, 2011, 01:33:17 am
Death, destruction of ships, subspace.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 04, 2011, 07:50:04 am
Space stares us into the face each mission. As does the Solarian sun. I hope it doesn't go nova. :( I also hope I didn't ruin a good storyline if I guessed it right. :P
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Shivan Hunter on January 04, 2011, 08:25:06 am
It seems to me he means more "subtle hints" in each mission. Something the pilots say, something we might mistake for an offhand comment or idiom... something that would be there to 'miss'. I'm going to replay the campaign to see if there's something I pick up on.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 04, 2011, 09:12:24 am
Quote
The Jester said that "something unspeakably terrible would happen within the next 50 years", which places it squarely in the BP2 timeframe.
A civil war among the terrans in which civilian areas have been bombarded with nukes would do justice to his prediction I think.
Or maybe he meant the lost peacefullness and innocence of the people of Sol. Surely the (mostly) peacefull Solarians are slipping deeper and deeper into the spiral of hate and revenge the more they lose to the GTVA.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Rodo on January 04, 2011, 09:29:14 am
Blah, the sun is always there as well....

NOVA THAT HIDROGEN SPHERE!
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 04, 2011, 09:35:35 am
Quote
The Jester said that "something unspeakably terrible would happen within the next 50 years", which places it squarely in the BP2 timeframe.
A civil war among the terrans in which civilian areas have been bombarded with nukes would do justice to his prediction I think.
Or maybe he meant the lost peacefullness and innocence of the people of Sol. Surely the (mostly) peacefull Solarians are slipping deeper and deeper into the spiral of hate and revenge the more they lose to the GTVA.
I think it's got more to do with the universe and subspace at large than just this relatively small-but-nasty limited-to-one-system civil war. I think it's clear the "deepness" is about the Blue Planet setting in general (ie. alternate universes, the big 3 species, mythological **** and such) rather than just this war. The nuking of civilian areas doesn't really count to me as being "unspeakably terrible". Pretty ****ing terrible but not so freaking terrible as to cause you to go maaaad.

tldr the deepness is probably not to do with the UEF becoming evil. because that's pretty easily describable. i just described it right there
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: r17 on January 04, 2011, 10:40:40 am
[/lurk]

Something in each mission? "Laporte"

[lurk]
Laporte is the door.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: MatthTheGeek on January 04, 2011, 01:34:29 pm
And Brie is a genre of cheese.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 04, 2011, 01:58:49 pm
Somehow Bei and Laporte remind me of Revan and the Exile from Kotor.
One is the heart of the force, the other a wound in the force, whatever consequences that might have in the third part (if there's ever going to be one).

Even the official gender would fit with Revan/Bei being male and exile/Laporte being female. And all four fight a tangible enemy that is only a symptom of the real enemy beyond the horizon.
Of course there is no magical force involved in BP, but those two pairs seem similar anyway to me.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Mars on January 04, 2011, 04:25:44 pm
Never mind actually, I don't want to guess right.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Satellight on January 05, 2011, 05:23:07 am
Never mind actually, I don't want to guess right.

Exactly the same for me, I just want to be shockingly amazed by the future revelations.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: bigchunk1 on January 07, 2011, 02:53:37 am
Alright, I've got it. Guessing the ending for BP may be difficult, but it will have one quality for certain...

It will be insane.

Battuta says it has to do with a hint present in every mission which is literally staring everyone in the face. Well that can only mean one thing. The constellation Orion. Sitting far off to the side embedded in every single mission's skybox.

Oh how prey tell does Orion fit into all of this? The name of a grandiose Freespace destroyer also the name of a constellation, also the name of some ancient Greek warrior? Well you just keep reading.

Admiral Byrne says the UEF has no chance by winning this war through force of arms, and I believe him because the Fedayeen have something mad in store for the Tevs.

You know who Samuel and Father Bei are searching for at the ending cut scene? Shivans. That's right... they are calling the great destroyer to unleash damnation upon their foes at the risk of civilization itself.

And lest we forget Orion, the iron fist of the Shivans plan to obliterate the failed human race with apocalyptic doom. The Shivans set each of Orion's stars ablaze in a supernova chain reaction while slingshoting the fiery masses of destruction towards several worlds throughout GTVA controlled space by using the gravity of black holes. The Terrans are decimated and plea with the Fedayeen, but it's too late for both of them, because neither one is in control of their fate any longer.

The Shivans invade and do what they do best. They eradicate Terrans, Vasudans, UEF forces... all life must be purged.  The GTVA UEF coalition of the damned are helpless to stop the Shivan threat which encroach upon their systems through both time and space. Using newly upgraded 'youcannotgetawayfrommenowsuckers' drives.

Thousands.... no wait... millions no wait... countless Vishnan warships emerge to bring balance to this otherwise impossible and reckless foe, for what is there to preserve if life does not exist. The physical plane of space is overwhelmed by the endless number of consistently warping ships such that the universe fragments into infinite dimensional planes of existence and space as we know it has morphed into continuous vibrating wavelengths of energy, without position and without dimension. Subspace is not subspace and time is not time. A broken equation, an ultimately incalculable scenario. The Vishnans have completed their task of preventing the universe from going off balance because an undefined equation can never yield 'false'.

You were worried about supernovas? Well prepare to be blown into the next universe, because this primal form uncontained energy is the recipe for a second big bang. A universe reset.

Boom.

Billions of years later, every subatomic particle falls into its rightful place and events take their course, moving and shaping themselves into fantastically an exact copy of the previous universe. Time manifests the events of the second universe right up until the point where the war in heaven begins. The Vishnans saved the universe, the first time... Will it happen again?

Spoiler:
Yes because this time the GTD Imperiose fails to jump in and the GTD Cartheage gets destroyed.

I know, I guessed everything. Call me Sherlock Holmes. 
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: crizza on January 07, 2011, 06:00:13 am
Nice one, but the Beis are searching for the vishnans...
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Fury on January 07, 2011, 06:04:27 am
wall of text
/me headdesks
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Shivan Hunter on January 07, 2011, 07:33:02 am
Alright, I've got it. Guessing the ending for BP may be difficult, but it will have one quality for certain...

It will be insane.

Battuta says it has to do with a hint present in every mission which is literally staring everyone in the face. Well that can only mean one thing. The constellation Orion. Sitting far off to the side embedded in every single mission's skybox.

Oh how prey tell does Orion fit into all of this? The name of a grandiose Freespace destroyer also the name of a constellation, also the name of some ancient Greek warrior? Well you just keep reading.

Admiral Byrne says the UEF has no chance by winning this war through force of arms, and I believe him because the Fedayeen have something mad in store for the Tevs.

You know who Samuel and Father Bei are searching for at the ending cut scene? Shivans. That's right... they are calling the great destroyer to unleash damnation upon their foes at the risk of civilization itself.

And lest we forget Orion, the iron fist of the Shivans plan to obliterate the failed human race with apocalyptic doom. The Shivans set each of Orion's stars ablaze in a supernova chain reaction while slingshoting the fiery masses of destruction towards several worlds throughout GTVA controlled space by using the gravity of black holes. The Terrans are decimated and plea with the Fedayeen, but it's too late for both of them, because neither one is in control of their fate any longer.

The Shivans invade and do what they do best. They eradicate Terrans, Vasudans, UEF forces... all life must be purged.  The GTVA UEF coalition of the damned are helpless to stop the Shivan threat which encroach upon their systems through both time and space. Using newly upgraded 'youcannotgetawayfrommenowsuckers' drives.

Thousands.... no wait... millions no wait... countless Vishnan warships emerge to bring balance to this otherwise impossible and reckless foe, for what is there to preserve if life does not exist. The physical plane of space is overwhelmed by the endless number of consistently warping ships such that the universe fragments into infinite dimensional planes of existence and space as we know it has morphed into continuous vibrating wavelengths of energy, without position and without dimension. Subspace is not subspace and time is not time. A broken equation, an ultimately incalculable scenario. The Vishnans have completed their task of preventing the universe from going off balance because an undefined equation can never yield 'false'.

You were worried about supernovas? Well prepare to be blown into the next universe, because this primal form uncontained energy is the recipe for a second big bang. A universe reset.

Boom.

Billions of years later, every subatomic particle falls into its rightful place and events take their course, moving and shaping themselves into fantastically an exact copy of the previous universe. Time manifests the events of the second universe right up until the point where the war in heaven begins. The Vishnans saved the universe, the first time... Will it happen again?

Spoiler:
Yes because this time the GTD Imperiose fails to jump in and the GTD Cartheage gets destroyed.

I know, I guessed everything. Call me Sherlock Holmes.

lol wtf
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: ION3 on January 07, 2011, 11:34:25 am
Quote
Wouldn't it make sense for there to be less info on GTVA stuff since you're flying for the UEF so you would have info on all your weapons but only some captured intelligence on GTVA weapons?

We're talking really basic info here. Should be available for all weapons which happen to be avaiable for hands on testing.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Rodo on January 07, 2011, 11:50:10 am
I'm thinking...

Humans either turn to be the new "destroyers", or the new "great caretakers".

Though I think it's too lame to be just that, still... I can live without knowing and I would hate myself from guessing it earlier anyway.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: crizza on January 07, 2011, 12:41:40 pm
My guess: The vasudans support the UEF...
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Shivan Hunter on January 07, 2011, 01:00:21 pm
I'm thinking...

Humans either turn to be the new "destroyers", or the new "great caretakers".

Though I think it's too lame to be just that, still... I can live without knowing and I would hate myself from guessing it earlier anyway.

Remember AoA? The vishnans at least think Humanity/Vasudanity show potential to be the Brahmans' replacement.

My guess: The vasudans support the UEF...

did you play the last half of WiH
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 07, 2011, 01:06:59 pm
did you play the last half of WiH
Well they might switch sides but that might be a little unlikely.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Rodo on January 07, 2011, 01:37:03 pm
And what are those Brahmans exactly?
I'm guessing they are an ascended race, but aren't Vishinans the same thing?, and what about Shivans?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 07, 2011, 01:53:50 pm
And what are those Brahmans exactly?
I'm guessing they are an ascended race, but aren't Vishinans the same thing?, and what about Shivans?
This will probably be deconstructed in the campaign, but initially at least:

Shivans - Destroyers
Vishnans - Preservers
Brahmans - Creators
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: thedjstu on January 07, 2011, 02:01:16 pm
brahmans were the great creators.

My bet is that the UEF is constructing some sort of subspace gate akin to the inter-system gates we see being used in nearly every mission (that being the element that is "staring us all in the face") with the crucial difference that instead of transiting you somewhere within the sol system it transits you to sol systems in other dimensions.

So, essentially, the UEF plan for victory runs like this.

1) Hold off GTVA forces while building dimensional subspace gateway.
2) Once gateway is finished, quickly establish relations with parallel universe UEF forces
3) Assuming a large enough number of universes the UEF now has an utterly insane number of warships to commit to the fight.
4) GTVA gets the **** kicked out of it a never ending stream UEF ships. 
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Rodo on January 07, 2011, 02:12:58 pm
Some unique plot twists have been proposed :yes:
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 07, 2011, 02:41:59 pm
brahmans were the great creators.

My bet is that the UEF is constructing some sort of subspace gate akin to the inter-system gates we see being used in nearly every mission (that being the element that is "staring us all in the face") with the crucial difference that instead of transiting you somewhere within the sol system it transits you to sol systems in other dimensions.

So, essentially, the UEF plan for victory runs like this.

1) Hold off GTVA forces while building dimensional subspace gateway.
2) Once gateway is finished, quickly establish relations with parallel universe UEF forces
3) Assuming a large enough number of universes the UEF now has an utterly insane number of warships to commit to the fight.
4) GTVA gets the **** kicked out of it a never ending stream UEF ships. 
I agree with everything except the last 3 lines of your post. The last part wouldn't really do the whole narrative justice.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Solatar on January 07, 2011, 04:34:35 pm
Shivans = Sanskrit
Vishnans = Sanskrit
Brahmans = Sanskrit
UEF ships = Lots of Sanskrit names

:nervous:
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 08, 2011, 06:58:14 am
i think the vishnans become evil and the shivans become good guys


and then laporte and sam have a fist fight with quicktime events
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: T-LoW on January 08, 2011, 10:38:21 am
A second big bang - that would be so awesome :nod:
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 08, 2011, 12:27:19 pm
Also about the "deepness":

Quote from: Visions
your creators blundered once and in doing so unleashed the deepness that stalks the cold roads of the cosmos

Kind of gives you a clue as to what it is.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Hades on January 08, 2011, 02:16:29 pm
Some unique plot twists have been proposed :yes:
(http://modestmovie.files.wordpress.com/2010/10/m-night-shyamalan.jpg)
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 08, 2011, 02:27:57 pm
Another theory I have is that the UEF (with help from the Feyadeen) may want to actually make the Shivans return and Laporte is the key to do so. If the Shivans return, the GTVA will be forced to join up with the UEF and the other way around. The Ubuntu council will be up to the difficult task of bringing the GTVA into 'enlightment' so that they are spared (the Shivans seem to attack races which are at war). If they can proof to the Vishans that the Terran race has changed, perhaps they are granted mercy by the Shivans and can start taking on the great responsabilities of the Brahmans.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 08, 2011, 03:08:14 pm
I'd like to see a showdown between the Atreus and a Solaris class destoyer. No side has the advantage.
Suddenly Vasudans jump in, with at least one destroyer.
Steele says something along the lines of "Hahaha you stupid pacifists. Now you are finished".
The Vasudans warm up a beam and *bam* blow the Atreus' engines apart.

Now a little speech from the Vasudans about how they found out the truth about how Steele manipulated them with the help of the GEVs and that he would now die for his crimes.
After that the Solaris and the Vasudans pound the Atreus into spacedust.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Satellight on January 08, 2011, 03:20:13 pm
I'd like to see a showdown between the Atreus and a Solaris class destoyer. No side has the advantage.
Suddenly Vasudans jump in, with at least one destroyer.
Steele says something along the lines of "Hahaha you stupid pacifists. Now you are finished".
The Vasudans warm up a beam and *bam* blow the Atreus' engines apart.

Now a little speech from the Vasudans about how they found out the truth about how Steele manipulated them with the help of the GEVs and that he would now die for his crimes.
After that the Solaris and the Vasudans pound the Atreus into spacedust.

I like this theory because it would compensate my helplessness felt during Delenda Est. I don't prefer much the GTVA or the UEF, but I was really frustrated by this feeling of "OMG I can do anything to save my friends", even if I know there is ONLY a videogame, that was a particularly moving moment. But ! It's maybe a little bit manichean and our anti-Zods people will :snipe: themselves...
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ravenholme on January 08, 2011, 03:26:10 pm
I'd like to see a showdown between the Atreus and a Solaris class destoyer. No side has the advantage.
Suddenly Vasudans jump in, with at least one destroyer.
Steele says something along the lines of "Hahaha you stupid pacifists. Now you are finished".
The Vasudans warm up a beam and *bam* blow the Atreus' engines apart.

Now a little speech from the Vasudans about how they found out the truth about how Steele manipulated them with the help of the GEVs and that he would now die for his crimes.
After that the Solaris and the Vasudans pound the Atreus into spacedust.

That'd be a horrible waste of the best character in Blue Planet. If it happens, I will cry.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Satellight on January 08, 2011, 03:37:40 pm
That'd be a horrible waste of the best character in Blue Planet. If it happens, I will cry.

Don't be afraid. If Steele is going to die, I'm sure it will be glorious !
If not, I'm afraid that Chuck Norris will be VERY unhappy. And I'm pretty sure that no one want to make Chuck Norris unhappy...

(http://minhinguita.unblog.fr/files/2008/04/chucknorris0021.jpg) (http://minhinguita.unblog.fr/files/2008/04/chucknorris0021.jpg)

:drevil:
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 08, 2011, 03:57:38 pm
Yeah that sounds like an arsepull. If Steele dies, it had better not be like that.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 08, 2011, 06:11:05 pm
Who said anything about Steele dying? Didn't you guys ever hear of escape pods?
I doubt either the Vasudans or the UEF would just want to blow him up, if they had the chance to put him before a court.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Mars on January 09, 2011, 01:33:09 am
Steele definitely seems like a "down with the ship" kinda guy.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ypoknons on January 09, 2011, 01:55:10 am
I don't know about that - like it's been said, he's a gentleman psycopath, even though he's supposedly badass/magnificant bastard/cool I think it could go either way. Really depends on how he's caught - if they can even catch him, at that.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ravenholme on January 09, 2011, 02:12:21 am
Who said anything about Steele dying? Didn't you guys ever hear of escape pods?
I doubt either the Vasudans or the UEF would just want to blow him up, if they had the chance to put him before a court.

Before a court for what? Using valid tactics and misinformation?

It's a war, you know. More than that, it's war amplified and scaled up to interplanetary/interstellar scales.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 09, 2011, 06:23:29 am
For killing civilians.
I'm pretty sure the UEF doesn't like that one bit, war or no war.

As for the Vasudans: Their whole species went to a decades long war over a translation mistake. Do you think they will take it easy if they ever found out that Steele, their supposed ally, made the GEVs attack them and tried to manipulate them into a war they didn't want?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 09, 2011, 06:27:14 am
As for the Vasudans: Their whole species went to a decades long war over a translation mistake.
URGH. I don't know why people keep saying this. Terran mishandling of the conversation was clearly a contributing cause, but it wasn't the sole reason war broke out.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 09, 2011, 06:47:40 am
I never said it was. But if it was just a minor annoyance they wouldn't have gone to war, no matter what else happened.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 09, 2011, 07:11:10 am
I never said it was. But if it was just a minor annoyance they wouldn't have gone to war, no matter what else happened.
Dude. There were other reasons for the war. Things like, I dunno, border disputes, aggression, mutual fear, etc.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 09, 2011, 07:33:05 am
To me, basically, the Vasudans of the 14 year war were religious zealots. If it didn't belong in their strait, their line of thinking, they thought it had to go. The early religious and traditional Vasudans were probably very prone to declaring the Terrans as a blasphemous species. The first contact was probably tensed and uneasy and the Terrans insulting the Vasudan ritual by not performing it correctly may have been one of many steps which pissed off the Vasudans (I'm guessing that the Terrans may have found little respect or understanding for said ritual and things got worse from there on). We also don't know what exactly happened. An Orion may have crossed an unknown border, mistaken for an invasion, or whatever.

Vasudans changed eventually, partially thanks to Khonsu II, but quite probably also because the agressive Hammer of Light movement opened up Vasudan eyes concerning how terrible radicalism can really be. Vasuda Prime going to hell (along with probably many of their temples, holy places and libraries) may have also played a part for the Vasudans who are now seemingly buildinging a new history for themselves: one of exploration and science.

Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 09, 2011, 08:04:06 am
I don't think the Vasudans were religious zealots. I think a portion of them were (probably this group joined the Hammer of Light) but that they were simply being led by an incompetent, extremely corrupt warmongering government (the Parliament). The war probably broke out due to a number of issues, not just one thing alone (and definitely not just because of the Conversation), probably the both sides were viewed by the other as aggressive and unreasonable.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 09, 2011, 12:24:03 pm
I never said it was. But if it was just a minor annoyance they wouldn't have gone to war, no matter what else happened.
Dude. There were other reasons for the war. Things like, I dunno, border disputes, aggression, mutual fear, etc.
I know that, and I even acknowledged it in the very post you quoted! But if the translation mistake wouldn't have been a serious affront to the Vasudans, then it would have never even been mentioned.

And if that doesn't get my original point through, that seems to have been lost somehow, let me rephrase:

According to their tech-room entry the Vasudans place a lot of value on social rituals and proper behaviour.
Steele made sure the GEVs would attack the Vasudans and tried (and at least initially suceeded) to manipulate them. That is as far from proper behaviour as you can get and thus will have serious repercussions if the Vasudans ever find out.

And even the Terran side of the GTVA might take offense in Steele giving sensitive information (the place of a diplomatic meeting of a Vasudan Admiral) and GTVA equipment (at least one Argo) to terrorists. Taking offense can be anything between a harsh reprimand for causing a diplomatic crisis and being put up on charges for treason.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 09, 2011, 01:03:40 pm
I know that, and I even acknowledged it in the very post you quoted! But if the translation mistake wouldn't have been a serious affront to the Vasudans, then it would have never even been mentioned.
Yeah I misunderstood your post. I thought you said that if the Conversation wasn't a big deal they wouldn't have gone to war entirely, not that it wouldn't have been mentioned in the tech entry. But still:

The GTA intelligence entries from FS1 are heavily biased. They clearly glorify the GTA and the GTA's ships as "shining beacons of stability" and "symbols of Terran pride". The Terran species entry even establishes that aggressive jingoism (under the euphemism of "unified expansionism") can only continue to "benefit" the Terran species (which it clearly did not, even at the time that entry was written, all that did was drag the Terrans into a needless 14-year war).

The role the Conversation played in starting the war could easily have been blown out of proportion. I don't deny that the Conversation most probably did play a part, but it annoys me when people say that the entire war started because of "a translation error", when there's little evidence to support that. It trivializes the war and also makes the Vasudans look like asshats (which some may argue they are, but whatevs).

And if that doesn't get my original point through, that seems to have been lost somehow, let me rephrase:

According to their tech-room entry the Vasudans place a lot of value on social rituals and proper behaviour.
Steele made sure the GEVs would attack the Vasudans and tried (and at least initially suceeded) to manipulate them. That is as far from proper behaviour as you can get and thus will have serious repercussions if the Vasudans ever find out.

And even the Terran side of the GTVA might take offense in Steele giving sensitive information (the place of a diplomatic meeting of a Vasudan Admiral) and GTVA equipment (at least one Argo) to terrorists. Taking offense can be anything between a harsh reprimand for causing a diplomatic crisis and being put up on charges for treason.
Firstly, it's "Gefs", not GEVs. It's also not an acronym, so it's not GEFs either.

Secondly, I agree with pretty much everything you said. If the truth seeps out it could be pretty disastrous for Steele. But he probably has a contingency for that too.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 09, 2011, 02:46:56 pm
Yep... Gaian Effort... now that you mention it I remember :o
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Garfield on January 13, 2011, 12:24:36 am
Looking through WiH, there doesn't seem to be anything that's present in every gameplay section of the campaign. My guess at the big hint is the picture of Jupiter in the background of the briefings. It's basically the first thing you see whenever you start a mission, which certainly counts as staring you in the face. So my prediction is: R2 will revolve around a last ditch attack on Jupiter to break the GTVAs' back and bring them to the negotiating table.

Other misc. guesses:
-Calder's quest for revenge leads him to a Captain Ahab style death
-Ken turns out to be Aken Bosch, who joined the Shivans in the same way Bei joined the Vishnans
-Bei succeeds in contacting the Vishnans, but the Vishnans turn out to be evil somehow
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Flak on January 13, 2011, 03:36:31 am
Or perhaps Byrne did something to that Lucifer derelict.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Mars on January 13, 2011, 04:31:03 am
Shivans and Vishans arrive, Earth destroyed.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 13, 2011, 04:59:58 am
Or perhaps Byrne did something to that Lucifer derelict.
What Lucifer derelict? What little of the Lucifer came out of that jumpnode in the first place blew up in a pretty massive explosion. I doubt there was much debris left after that, certainly not enough to call it a derelict.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 13, 2011, 05:29:41 am
Shivans and Vishans arrive, Earth destroyed.

Just, no. Unless you elaborate how.

Looking through WiH, there doesn't seem to be anything that's present in every gameplay section of the campaign. My guess at the big hint is the picture of Jupiter in the background of the briefings. It's basically the first thing you see whenever you start a mission, which certainly counts as staring you in the face. So my prediction is: R2 will revolve around a last ditch attack on Jupiter to break the GTVAs' back and bring them to the negotiating table.

Other misc. guesses:
-Calder's quest for revenge leads him to a Captain Ahab style death
-Ken turns out to be Aken Bosch, who joined the Shivans in the same way Bei joined the Vishnans
-Bei succeeds in contacting the Vishnans, but the Vishnans turn out to be evil somehow

The first point seems possible.

The second point might be possible, I thought so at once too, but they may as well have studied Bosch as a means of communicating more effectively. Lacking a human name, for all we know the voice to Noemi called itself Aken, which Noemi may even have mistaken for Ken as a young child. It might also be coincedence.

The third point seems highly unlikely to me, unless you mean the Vishans have an own agenda. Still the Vishans seem genuine to me.

Or perhaps Byrne did something to that Lucifer derelict.
What Lucifer derelict? What little of the Lucifer came out of that jumpnode in the first place blew up in a pretty massive explosion. I doubt there was much debris left after that, certainly not enough to call it a derelict.

One beam arm survived, as did the front of the hull: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXeI4EJiZh4

It's probably not enough to reverse engineer it, but there should be plenty to take a look into shivan technology, unless it fell into orbit.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Hades on January 13, 2011, 09:44:10 am
There wouldn't be plenty, the two chunks that survive are barely even Fenris sized, and extremely damaged.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ravenholme on January 13, 2011, 10:02:22 am
There wouldn't be plenty, the two chunks that survive are barely even Fenris sized, and extremely damaged.

Plus, having your reactors blown up probably means that anything that was hooked up to the power is scrap.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: ION3 on January 13, 2011, 10:04:42 am
Maybe the jumpnode collapses again? (portal misfunction or vishnan influence)

One thing that is in every mission is the changing of Laporte. Look at Aristeia: She says something like: Two squadrons of fighters and a hunter killer team. How are we goint to... [survive that]  At this point she's interrupted  by Ken. Then she says: How are we going to keep them from running away?

Ken definitely transforms her into a warrior and influences the outcome of the war.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Raiden on January 13, 2011, 10:44:00 am
-Ken turns out to be Aken Bosch, who joined the Shivans in the same way Bei joined the Vishnans

 :eek: Sounds plausible to me, so plausible I wish I hadn't read it!
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Rodo on January 13, 2011, 11:29:30 am
-Ken turns out to be Aken Bosch, who joined the Shivans in the same way Bei joined the Vishnans

 :eek: Sounds plausible to me, so plausible I wish I hadn't read it!

Dammit, that's a super plot turn.. but no way, can't be tht twisted.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 13, 2011, 12:32:06 pm
Aken = Ken theory has been suggested a dozen of times in the fanspec thread already. :P

Maybe the jumpnode collapses again? (portal misfunction or vishnan influence)

Just destroying the portal probably collapses the node again. Remember it has only been reopened for less then 2 years. It had no time to stabilize probably.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 13, 2011, 12:33:44 pm
Just destroying the portal probably collapses the node again. Remember it has only been reopened for less then 2 years. It had no time to stabilize probably.
The Knossos in Gamma Draconis stabilized after about a month.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 13, 2011, 12:36:27 pm
Just destroying the portal probably collapses the node again. Remember it has only been reopened for less then 2 years. It had no time to stabilize probably.
The Knossos in Gamma Draconis stabilized after about a month.

What? Knossos had been there for ages. Surely the Ancients stabilized the subspace node long before that time. It was at best hypothized in one of the missions that it may be ages until the node'd collapse. Sure, the GTC Trinity activated it again but it's obviously been used before (hence it's presence).
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Shivan Hunter on January 13, 2011, 12:40:51 pm
-Bei succeeds in contacting the Vishnans, but the Vishnans turn out to be evil somehow
The third point seems highly unlikely to me, unless you mean the Vishans have an own agenda. Still the Vishans seem genuine to me.

The BP team has pretty emphatically stated that there's more to the Vishnans than they would like us to think. I don't think anything in the BP universe can be described as simply as "good" or "evil", but the Vishnans and the Shivans both definitely have their own agenda.

[EDIT] It had also been deactivated for ages, possibly for several millenia since the Ancients disappeared. Admittedly the Sol node would be harder to stabilize, given that it was actively destroyed instead of just fading away but the Knossos hadn't been on for very long and presumably the node was inaccessible when they found it, or else there would have been no need to activate it.

And yeah, Ken/Aken is an ooold theory- one I still support. If it's not Bosch speaking directly then at least it's the knowledge that the Shivans gained from Bosch.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 13, 2011, 12:43:38 pm
What? Knossos had been there for ages. Surely the Ancients stabilized the subspace node long before that time. It was at best hypothized in one of the missions that it may be ages until the node'd collapse. Sure, the GTC Trinity activated it again but it's obviously been used before (hence it's presence).
It had been there, but was inactive for about 8,000 years. It was reactivated by the Trinity, and by the time of the Knossos' destruction by the Renenet the node had stabilized by itself. The time between that couldn't have been more than a few months at the very most.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ravenholme on January 13, 2011, 01:01:08 pm
-Ken turns out to be Aken Bosch, who joined the Shivans in the same way Bei joined the Vishnans

 :eek: Sounds plausible to me, so plausible I wish I hadn't read it!

That one has been theorised since shortly after WiH was released. I remember discussing it on IRC way back.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: ION3 on January 13, 2011, 01:34:53 pm
The Gamma draconis node would propably have collapsed on it's own a few weeks later.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: MatthTheGeek on January 13, 2011, 01:37:47 pm
Or a few years, or a few centuries, or not at all. I'd say it's a case of "whatever works for your campaign".
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 13, 2011, 06:17:13 pm
There is another possibility for the Gamma Draconis node. While the portal was blown up, the Sathanas was inside a tunnel. Maybe that juggernaught did something to stabilize the node, when it would have been otherwise destabilized after the portals destruction.
Or the node did indeed start to fade, but did so slowly enough to still let the Shivans send through enough troops. They can use nodes too unstable for GTVA ships after all.

On that matter: Do you think the GTVA cracked that secret to traverse less stable nodes with all the hyperspace research they did to get to the sprint drives?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Jellyfish on January 13, 2011, 07:15:27 pm
Ken definitely transforms her into a warrior and influences the outcome of the war.

Perhaps he possesses her?
The Vishnans could control ships with their will. Who says they (and therefore the Shivans) can't control people the same way?
Also, they called Bei. What if Laporte is even more sensitive than Bei, making the subconscious call become an urge?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 14, 2011, 05:16:17 am
In AoA the "energy drain" of Beis ship during while he was chasing the Vishnans in a stealth fighter wasn't in the logs of the ship, suggesting it only happened in his head. That would mean the Vishnans indeed have the ability to mess with the Human brain on a far more serious level than communicating telepathically and reading memories.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: ION3 on January 14, 2011, 05:41:32 am
And the same happens in WIH in the KEN mission.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: terran_emperor on January 14, 2011, 07:03:31 am
-Ken turns out to be Aken Bosch, who joined the Shivans in the same way Bei joined the Vishnans

I've some theories...
1) Ken is Gibson, Sarno or one of the dozen others who left/were taken with Bosch... [Silly]

2) Ken is (a) shivan using Bosch's identity

3) Ken is Bosch...But isn't...
To Explain:
a) The Vishnans are energy being... It's hinted in BP that the Shivans are something similar...Possibly Energy being who can take solid form...Like Lorien or the Vorlons in B5

b) It is semi-canon that the Shivan's have a hive mind based on the tech-room desription. From what I see I BP, the Vishnans are too

c) Samuel Bei was turned into a "sorta-vishnan" - energy being but not quite part of the Vishnan conciensness...but it gained the Vishnan's a better understanding of humanity. Possibly he could have bridge between the Vs and humanity...A sort of Locutus-of-Borg.

d) The shivan's did something similar to Bosch. But unlike Bei, Bosch actually became completly part of the Shivan's hive. But his sense of identity was so strong that it spread through the Shivan Collective consiousness...so the Shivans now exist as a Shivan/Bosch Hybrid...

The Shivans are Bosch. Bosch is the Shivans. Therefore Ken=Aken Bosch=Shivan Collective

Unreleated to "Ken"
4) Shivans and Vishnans are not Seperate species...They are different Aspects of the SAME race...
I'll explain this in a seperate thread soon...It's Vorlon related, so it will be complecated...

one more thing...
I think if Steele dies...It will be in the blaze of Glory taking an entire enemy fleet with him...Think Vice-Admiral Cole's last stand (http://halo.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_Psi_Serpentis) from the Halo-verse...

He will then turn up alive and well and just as badass years later
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Jellyfish on January 14, 2011, 08:58:42 am
I'm pretty sure someone like Steele knows better than staging last stands. He is more valuable defeated but alive than glorious and dead.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: MatthTheGeek on January 14, 2011, 09:01:48 am
I sure hope Steele will die falling from stairs. That's all that mofo deserves.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: ION3 on January 14, 2011, 11:12:35 am
Perhaps his reactor will blow up from all the jumping around?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Snail on January 14, 2011, 11:15:59 am
That would be an excellent plot twist.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Norbert- on January 14, 2011, 11:21:33 am
a) The Vishnans are energy being... It's hinted in BP that the Shivans are something similar...Possibly Energy being who can take solid form...Like Lorien or the Vorlons in B5
This could actually be a good explenation for the mechanoid aspects of the shivans. Those bodies are actually encounter suits that are "inhabited" by the Shivans either beause their energy bodies can't interact otherwise with physical beings, or to hide their true nature.

Quote
c) Samuel Bei was turned into a "sorta-vishnan" - energy being but not quite part of the Vishnan conciensness...but it gained the Vishnan's a better understanding of humanity. Possibly he could have bridge between the Vs and humanity...A sort of Locutus-of-Borg.
Samuel wasn't changed. They took his spirit/mind/personality/whatever and projected or even moved it into a ship. But his body remained as it was, stored (kinda) safely in the Keeper. That he returned to his body after the Keeper was destroyed, makes it more likely that he was only projected and not completely moved into the ship.

Quote
4) Shivans and Vishnans are not Seperate species...They are different Aspects of the SAME race...
I'll explain this in a seperate thread soon...It's Vorlon related, so it will be complecated...
Not too complicated. One faction wanted to best the Shadows within the rules, while the other thought pretty much "screw those stupid rules and just wipe out anyone touched by the shadows".
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: -Sara- on January 14, 2011, 12:16:33 pm
I imagined Samuel was linked up in the Preserver ship not unlike how individuals in the Matrix are 'plugged in'.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ypoknons on January 14, 2011, 12:46:36 pm
That would be an excellent plot twist.
I've been thinking about this - the tech room description gets at the fact he's almost risking the Atreus jumping around with such frequency. Or maybe some crewman would just be broken and something goes wrong and put him in some wrong place.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Useful Dave on January 14, 2011, 01:45:35 pm
I predict that Laporte will end up having to have a mental face off with a Nagari-potential unlocked/boosted Steele in order to try and prevent her unleashing the Shivan menace upon the GTVA. It will turn out that the Vasudan which passed her the schematics was actually a member of the Hammer of Light.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ravenholme on January 14, 2011, 02:19:36 pm
I predict that Laporte will end up having to have a mental face off with a Nagari-potential unlocked/boosted Steele in order to try and prevent her unleashing the Shivan menace upon the GTVA. It will turn out that the Vasudan which passed her the schematics was actually a member of the Hammer of Light.

Walk the Perimeter, Check your Six, they sneak in through dreams.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: terran_emperor on January 14, 2011, 04:06:07 pm
I'm pretty sure someone like Steele knows better than staging last stands. He is more valuable defeated but alive than glorious and dead.

The Battle of Phi Serpentis in Haloverse was Cole's last stand. He was apparently killed when he detonated that gas giant. But later analysis places odds at 89.9% chance in favour of him surviving and escaping. Because Cole was just that Badass (He's the biggest badass in the Haloverse)...and was crazy prepared.

What I'm saying is that Steele is equally badass. And that when he has his battle, it will apparently end in his death, only for him to return and be as awesome ever.
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: MatthTheGeek on January 14, 2011, 04:31:33 pm
It's Halo. Badassness doesn't really exist there. Just Hollywood-esque actors.

Trolololo
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Jellyfish on January 14, 2011, 04:32:19 pm
I think Halo runs on rule of cool far more than Blue Planet. I can't tell, though, having only played Halo CE
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: MatthTheGeek on January 14, 2011, 04:35:21 pm
You played the best Halo. So yeah, I can understand how you feel.

Off-topicness shall end now, shouldn't it ?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Inglonias on January 16, 2011, 03:38:09 pm
From the old thread:
With correct formatting:

Spoiler:
The Voices in the Womb spoke wordlessly.
Infancy is amnesia yet you remember them.
As a child you were told I was only in your head, yet where else are voices ever heard?
You are not mad, nor have you ever been.
You are no mystic, you are a made thing, gifted with an ear for the quantum whisper.
You draw a line between two worlds: the world of fighters and armor and briefings, and the world of dreams and portents.
But this dreamscape, this child's phantasmagoria, is a glimpse into a world just as real and deadly, a place of strategems of treachery and power that seems to you as strange as a briefing would seem to an ape.
REMEMBER THIS:
Those who walk among infinite worlds must still wage war. Do not be lulled by the
soft words of mysticism and spirituality. We too struggle with our own war in heaven.
Our purpose is unclear, the old design fails.
We perform bakhti and Tapasya in order to divine the will of those who passed deeper eons ago, leaving us to preserve, and our brothers in dance to their frigid watch at the border where worlds fray and blur together.

Brothers, Brothers, Paramatma! Why are you so cold? You tend to the walls and the clockwork, while we the gardeners execute your will upon all the life within. You maintain the old plan, but do not pretend surprise when we cast it aside.
Your creators blundered once, and in doing so, unleashed the deepness that stalks the cold roads of the cosmos.

We must prepare.

Second part:

Balance must be maintained. The original plan is imperative.
We seek the one out of many, the one who can match the brahmans of old.
Enlightenment is a threshold, the catalyst for amalgamation, for the singularity that binds whole species into the union we seek.
The old burnt the cosmos clean in the wars of their youth.
Never again will that price be paid.

It sounds to me that the first part is the Shivans talking and that the second part is the Vishnan response.

Any other ideas as to what this mission could be?
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Scotty on January 16, 2011, 09:20:23 pm
Refer to the dicussion on the topic you linked that from.  Moderately lengthy discussion about that in the first two pages, I think it was. :P
Title: Re: spoilers and plot twist discussion
Post by: Ypoknons on January 17, 2011, 05:14:06 am
My gut feeling is that the device is connected with the Jester and possibly the Emperor, working independently of the Parliament.