Hard Light Productions Forums

Off-Topic Discussion => General Discussion => Topic started by: Mars on April 22, 2011, 07:48:40 pm

Title: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Mars on April 22, 2011, 07:48:40 pm
So apparently I may have asthma. . .

I feel weak, unattractive, ashamed and pathetic. I feel like I shouldn't have children. I know that's an incredibly offensive thing to think. . . but at the moment, its how I feel.

I can't think of a reason why I'd be wrong in thinking that.

Got back from a run. . . couldn't breath. My (doctor) sister did the peak flow test, gave me an inhaler, told me to go get diagnosed because she couldn't officially.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: General Battuta on April 22, 2011, 07:55:51 pm
Everybody has asthma, it's incredibly common. Some estimates say 10% of everyone in the world has asthma.

I have asthma, I'm a genius and in good shape, I do weights and cardio just fine. You know who has asthma? Bill Clinton. A bunch of Olympic swimmers. JFK had asthma. Alex Zulle, an olympic cyclist, had asthma. List goes on.

You'll be fine. It's also not purely genetic so don't worry about kids.

Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Mars on April 22, 2011, 08:01:18 pm
Everybody has asthma, it's incredibly common. Some estimates say 10% of everyone in the world has asthma.

I have asthma, I'm a genius and in good shape, I do weights and cardio just fine. You know who has asthma? Bill Clinton. A bunch of Olympic swimmers. JFK had asthma. Alex Zulle, an olympic cyclist, had asthma. List goes on.

You'll be fine. It's also not purely genetic so don't worry about kids.


W00t! Thank you! Definitely what I needed to hear XD

Had no idea about the Olympians.

I guess its just weird to not quite trust my body the way I have. . . with the exception of mono I've never had anything go wrong that wasn't quickly over.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Shivan Hunter on April 22, 2011, 08:28:18 pm
I'm still waiting for brain uploading.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: StarSlayer on April 22, 2011, 08:31:16 pm
I wrestled in highschool, it's far and away the most physically demanding and rigorous sport offered.  I'd  wrap up football season in damn good shape and it was like starting from square one when it came to wrestling.  One of my friends was one of the team captains, he ended up State Champion in his weight class, placed on or near the top of every tourney his senior year and he had asthma. 

Besides, work hard and you too can have hard science fiction like abs same as tutta :D
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Dilmah G on April 22, 2011, 09:39:02 pm
Don't worry about it man, asthma's really a non-event these days with inhalers and all that, and it won't stop you from keeping in shape, as you can see from the posts above. The only time I'd be worried is if you're trying to join the the forces or the local Police Department, and if you're not doing either then you're basically safe. :)
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: General Battuta on April 22, 2011, 09:57:42 pm
You can get into the armed forces even with asthma (mostly you lie about it) and then get a discharge whenever you like by discovering your Reactive Airway Disease!
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Nuclear1 on April 22, 2011, 10:23:25 pm
Yeah, I've had a few friends that that's happened to.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Dilmah G on April 22, 2011, 10:26:05 pm
You don't have to lie about it, most logistics roles and non-direct combat roles don't require you to be asthma free anymore IIRC. However if someone was planning to enter aviation and lie about it, I'd advise them to read up on the effects of high altitudes upon asthma sufferers. If someone was planning to enter Infantry, well, don't even bother, if the enemy don't kill you, your mates will after they have to drag your ass to cover when you suffer an asthma attack after inhaling the contents of a smoke grenade during a break contact drill.

In short, the roles that still have the restrictions there have them for a reason. You'd be a real c*nt to put your mates in the line of fire knowingly because you didn't declare that you were an asthmatic.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: General Battuta on April 22, 2011, 10:40:22 pm
It's something to worry about in theory, but in practice you can read memoirs of plenty of perfectly seasoned soldiers who had asthma. Conscription dug up far sorrier cases than them.

One of the better reads I had during the height of the Iraq was the memoirs of a bitter, PTSD-riddled infantryman who'd come away from his last tour in the army advising everyone who picked up his book to stay the hell away. After a number of years over there he finally figured out he had asthma and was discharged. Didn't noticeably bother him beforehand.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Shade on April 22, 2011, 10:42:38 pm
I have asthma. It's not something that'll keep you from leading a perfectly normal life, if treated - Indeed, depending on various factors it may go into remission so that you'll go months without ever feeling it. I'm having one of those periods right now, in fact, and haven't needed medication for almost half a year, even though I know with near-certainty that the spring pollen-onslaught is going to get it going again.

On that note, environmental factors are what seem to cause it, not genetics. For me, it's cigarette smoke, pollen, and certain levels of cool+damp air, the middle of those presumably because I also have mild allergies. When either of those are around, my asthma will flare up with near certainty, but take them away, and a couple weeks treatment (treatment being inhaling twice a day, no pills, needles or other nastiness) later I can breather almost normally again even before I get my daily doses.

So seriously, don't fret it. It's like the most common condition in the world, and it's treatment is probably the least uncomfortable there is.

PS. I served in the army. And they knew about the asthma too, when they recruited me :p Asthma wasn't a problem at any point, since inhalers are small and easy to stash.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Pred the Penguin on April 22, 2011, 10:43:49 pm
I have asthma... I think. I used to be in pretty good shape, now I'm just a lazy ass. Asthma never has been the real limitation for me.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Dilmah G on April 22, 2011, 11:03:07 pm
It's something to worry about in theory, but in practice you can read memoirs of plenty of perfectly seasoned soldiers who had asthma. Conscription dug up far sorrier cases than them.

One of the better reads I had during the height of the Iraq was the memoirs of a bitter, PTSD-riddled infantryman who'd come away from his last tour in the army advising everyone who picked up his book to stay the hell away. After a number of years over there he finally figured out he had asthma and was discharged. Didn't noticeably bother him beforehand.
Well I'd say people whose asthma wasn't so good would probably have collapsed in a wheezing mess during basic training, if not at the School of Infantry, leaving the asthmatic blokes who could hack it. Either way, it's not a chance I'd encourage people to take.

PS. I served in the army. And they knew about the asthma too, when they recruited me :p Asthma wasn't a problem at any point, since inhalers are small and easy to stash.
That's interesting, which army did you serve in?
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: General Battuta on April 22, 2011, 11:04:38 pm
Well the whole point of this thread is that the fact that you have asthma doesn't mean you can't take a physical challenge (like basic training). It doesn't turn you into an invalid, as those Olympic athletes should attest to.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Dilmah G on April 22, 2011, 11:18:11 pm
Oh of course, I was an asthmatic as a kid and I was one of the best cross-country runners at my school, but the point I was making was that those roles I said earlier are the only ones that being an asthmatic might stop you from filling. I doubt Mars was into them anyway. :P
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: PsychoLandlord on April 22, 2011, 11:25:20 pm
One of my best friends has asthma, and routinely whoops my ass in Kung-Fu. I think you'll be fine.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Dilmah G on April 22, 2011, 11:48:52 pm
Yeah man, asthma ain't no big deal. :)
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Mars on April 22, 2011, 11:59:35 pm
You people are all legit awesome.  :D
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Mikes on April 23, 2011, 02:23:47 am
I'm still waiting for brain uploading.

So you can eventually talk to yourself on your deathbed? ;)
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Nuclear1 on April 23, 2011, 02:34:04 am
So I can watch myself die.

/trippy
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: watsisname on April 23, 2011, 03:30:22 am
hey man, pass those internets
oh yeah look at that
oh what the ****
this was a bad idea
hold on
hold on
oh yeah
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: QuantumDelta on April 23, 2011, 04:48:47 am
Lets see, I was one of the best sprinters in my school.
I regularly sailed small craft (the hardest kind), kyaked, cycled(miles), I was a competitive swimmer, climbed mountains (both hiking and literal rock climbing), and played a whole host of competitive sports (football, rugby, baseball doesn't really count...), was considered a wunderkind at Tae Kwon Do

All with asthma, and was damn good at some of them (read; nationally competitive). Just endurance **** didn't work for me (despite some of those activities if you paced yourself correctly I'd never feel the asthma), though my muscle type is also not really tuned for endurance, my strength and speed is well above the norm, but between asthma and my muscle type - I could probably never ever run a marathon.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Grizzly on April 23, 2011, 06:30:02 am
You people are all legit awesome.  :D

So are you! Your questions uncovered their legit awesomeness once more!
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Shade on April 23, 2011, 10:01:29 am
That's interesting, which army did you serve in?

The only one we've got around here, the Danish army. That's some twelve years back now though, well before I even knew HLP existed :p
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Dilmah G on April 23, 2011, 11:47:36 am
Ah, you're a Dane, faaair enough. :D
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Androgeos Exeunt on April 23, 2011, 12:24:39 pm
I am so out of my league if I compare my physical abilities to any of you, but I'm still happy anyway. As long as I feel that I've tired my body out, even if I'm nowhere near the physical level of other people, I've no regrets. :)
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: Snail on April 23, 2011, 06:35:41 pm
I can outrun a house cat.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: -Sara- on April 23, 2011, 06:39:27 pm
Mogens Jensen from Denmark has asthma, he climbed the Mount Everest to the top, a place where the air is SO thin that it feels for everyone as if they got a bad case of asthma once up there. With medication, a careful diet and proper excercise (as appointed by your doctor!) living conditions can be anywhere from above moderate to great. Sorry, not going to increase on your insecurities. I'm disabled waist down myself and I can't run or do many physical sports at all. But I know I'm not weak, definately not pathetic and most certainly want to raise a brat or two someday (and I darn well think I'd make a great mother too, disabilities don't change that). So chin up, Mars! :) You'll be fine. Try to think there's always someone in the world who is having it worse. :yes: Also remember that if your doctor is not supportive or does not offer proper plans or options to live an active life, finding a proper support group is a great idea to see how to manage this sudden change in your life.
Title: Re: Weakness, strength, masculinity. . . and asthma
Post by: JGZinv on April 23, 2011, 09:33:50 pm
I have had asthma since I was 3... had only a couple attacks, was forced into the school activities that were for "normal" or highly active folk.
Ran out of breath easily, never really exercised, etc. Ran through the gamut of emotions and mild depression over it. Couldn't keep up
with other people. Had the nebulizers, dozen different inhalation drugs, inhalers, regular annoying doctors.

So I worked on my brains instead. Granted, I'm an introvert, but I'm a wise introvert with more knowledge than a vast majority of my peers.
I still don't have much stamina more than 20 years later. But you learn to deal with it. I can force my body to do things others would give up
on simply by force of will.

It ain't the end of the world. Some people grow out of it too. I don't take anything for it anymore, I just have to pace myself or back off if I get
all red and out of breath. I'm 6'4" and 200 pounds, and every so often I get looks and compliments.. so I guess I qualify as attractive.  All is not lost.

You want something to worry about, try catching double pneumonia along with other infections. After 6 months of therapy the doctors tell you
to go home because there's nothing left to try. Alternatively, having a doc tell you that if you don't see a measurable improvement in 3 days he'll
be removing your arm at the shoulder. Moral of the story - I'm still here and have both arms. Don't necessarily treat everything a doc says as gospel.