[Nuclear1]

Alright, everybody, it's time for Nuclear to ask for help again! This time it's about music. Currently, I've got two more ideas for briefing music set out, but I need suggestions as to which one to actually use.

Samples are here. Now, I won't insult your intelligence and say that you probably haven't heard these somewhere before, so I'll give you the sources for both. The first, a much more uplifting and victorious tune, is entitled "International Code" on the Independence Day soundtrack by David Arnold, and the second, a much darker and intense piece called "Fire Storm", comes from the same soundtrack.

However, I cannot decide which to use. GTI Rebellion's already pushing the limit on music here, so we can't really afford to have more than one of these released. So, which one?

[Kie99]

The first one is awful, truly awful, not jsut as briefing music but in general as well.  The second one seems more suited to in-game music, but would be OK as briefing music.  If you're looking for something else along the lines of the second one I can recommend Chateau by Rob Dougan.

[FireCrack]

Neither i'd say, the first one is more of a "sucess" debreif, the second seems more like ingame music.

[Goober5000]

Honestly, to both.

[Nuclear1]

And neither it is

[WMCoolmon]

Curses...now I want to see Independence Day again. They last showed it on NBC or something and I missed the last half.

Uhm, anyway, yeah, I'd vote neither too. Too recognizable. But then, David Arnold is one of the few composers that I recognize (Stargate, Independence Day, Wing Commander)

[Braxis]

The First one is more suitable for a very sucessful debrefieng.
The second one is good for the begginning of an in-game battle.

[TopAce]

After seeing Independence day at least twenty times before, I can say that the tracks in the movie were a lot better and make these ones sound weird and bad. Probably if I hadn't known these tracks previously (knowing a better version which was played in the movie), I would say these tracks are all right. The main problem is that most of the people know a better version of those tracks.