Author Topic: Generations of ships?  (Read 3692 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

The entire problem with the Orion is that it was always an almost exclusively anti-capship design.
Against smaller vessels the problems mount up:
  • Lack of backwards facing turrets, exposing the massive single engine to attack from cruisers, corvettes and bombers.
  • Lots of areas (near the frontal antenae especially) that have few turrets defending them, exposing the ship to attack by bombers.
  • Overall lack of turrets and terrible firing arcs, making it easy for small craft to take out the turrets and then fire away until the destroyer falls.
  • Slow speed, allowing more modern vessels to outrun it with ease, making it a primarily defensive ship.
Overall it would make the cost difference between designing new vessels and fixing all the design flaws of the orion negligible.

 

Offline NGTM-1R

  • I reject your reality and substitute my own
  • 213
  • Syndral Active. 0410.
The presence of the Orion's fightercraft group in practice cancels out the deficit of antifighter armament. The same really can't be said of the Hecate's lack of anticapital weapons.

On the subject of what can and can't be retrofitted to a ship, the basic rule of thumb is that you can fit whatever guns you want, since they're on the outside of the ship and easy to add or remove, so long as you can also supply them with power/ordnance. In the case of Avengers (or flak guns) this means magazines, ammunition feeds, and major internal restructuring. Such a refit would take a month or more of time and major resources, but would be doable.

On a related note, it probably isn't unreasonable to assume that the Orion didn't originally have facilities to handle the Harbinger as regular fightercraft ordnance, and so they couldn't be kept in the magazines, but rather on the hanger deck. In the open. Where a multiton fighter might bump into them. Can't have been good for the morale of the crew, and it would have slowed down flight ops. (Which might explain why the Bastion was so slow to get off the entire strike at the Lucifer.)
"Load sabot. Target Zaku, direct front!"

A Feddie Story

  

Offline bfobar

  • 28
my theory is that they had to rip out the officer's spa, bath, and massage parlor deck in the Orion to fit in the reactor for the beamz, and GTA command wasn't going to put up with that. I mean, the Hecate has a pair of high-rise penthouse apartment complexes above the engines. GTA officers need their R&R you know.