I purchased a copy of Freespace 2 from GoG.com
I found a few of "Turney's"(sp?) walkthrough on this forum and others, and from what I believe, I followed the instructions closely.
I installed the game into directory C:\Games\Freespace2\
I downloaded and installed the windows Installer
I ran the installer and allowed it to update. As suggested I ran the installer twice after in case anything installed incorrectly.
I installed OpenAl for windows.
I made sure to run the installer into the aforementioned directory, and made sure there was no C:\games\freespace2\freespace 2 as mentioned in another person's post.
I still have no idea what it is I'm doing wrong.
I'm running Windows 7 64 bit if that matters, and am more than willing to provide pictures of what the contents are of any related folders.
[attachment deleted by ninja]