[Gloriano]

so if SSD is 17,6km then Eclipse class would be 35,2km (if it was 2x)

[TopAce]

I just tried to do something valuable. read it before posting, OK?

[Carl]

Originally posted by diamondgeezer

Dude, not being funny but you're geting paranoid now. I don't bash you for the sake of it, you know. And I'm not bashing you this time, or your article - I haven't even read it. My point is that comparisons between to fictional universes is utterly pointless since you have very few facts to go on, and some extremely shaky physics. Fundamental questions like 'would FS beams puncture SW shields?' are basically a case of tossing a coin, and thus the conclusions drawn are built on flawed foundations. That, and many peeps here are fed up with Warsies who endlessly engage in these kind of exercises despite the protests of more reasonable folk. Now, if you really want to discuss the matter with someone who really genuinely cares, look up an HLPite named Authur Tuxedo - he's tried this kind of thing on before and been smacked down for it, so I'm sure he'd be glad to meet someone who he could share his interest with

BTW, I seem to find myself saying this stuff largely cos Stryke and the other one aren't here to say it. Blame them, not me

ummm...what you are saying is essentially what the article is saying.

[diamondgeezer]

And I haven't read the article. What goeth around cometh around. Or something. Who fancies a pint?

[vyper]

You getting the first round in?

[TopAce]

You like it or not. I submit that article to hLP. It is already up.