Nice work Lightspeed. However, something about it just doesn't sit well with me. I think its the dark textures, though I will admit that it looks very close to the original (in a good way). I think that when you go with a lighter overall texture (like the new ones in the previous thread, I think by Carl), it feels more "powerful" or something along those lines.
That, and what I also liked about the old new (previous thread) version, was how it had the "lightning" texture, which was very appropriate. Yours however had the advantage of looking "solid" as opposed to "energy-like".
....And I'm fairly certain that made no sense at all, but then again, most of what I say doesn't.