Welcome to science; the justification is pretty much always "it happens to work."
I know. Graduated several years ago, publish stuff in the field of Optics - it's a shame they don't mention that often in the classes that dumb luck has a lot to do with scientific progress... Not to discourage those who are still in the University

Also the capability to note that "wait a second, what did it actually do?" or my personal favorite, "it isn't supposed to do that".
The reason I asked about dust is related to the scattering effect with in the plane of the disk and the apparent luminosity around the stars.
More on tomorrow
EDIT: too tired to write coherent English