Originally posted by Knight Templar
Meh so the rotamatatorlite spins in the way.. you could justs have missle launchers on the wings that could cover most of the arc, if not some.
Its a science ship after all. It is allowed to have some blind spots, i think....
Originally posted by Goober5000
It doesn't have to scan everywhere. It'll just have very good scanning ability in one direction. 
That goes along with what we've seen of the Vasudans before - they do thinks a little bit strangely....
If it has blind spots then you might as well get rid of the whole rotating scanner. If if it rotates and cant scan in at least two directions, then why have it at all? AWACS are
supposed to scan in all directions; thats what detecting the enemy is all about. If you have a deliberate blind spot in your scanning ability, then you're just ASKING the enemy to hit you from that blind spot. How much military sense does that make?
And Goober, your analogy about the Mekhu gun and the Edjo sentry gun are incorrect. The problem the Terrans had with the Setekh wasn't that its scanning ability was flawed, it was that the Setekh
was an unnecessarily fragile ship. It had less armor and could be shot down more easily, but it
scanned just as well as the Charybdis.And KT, is this ship a science cruiser or an AWACS? If it's a science cruiser, get rid of the rotating scanner entirely because it's superfluous and unnecessary. If it's an AWACS, then don't compromise the mod with such an obvious design flaw by putting the scanner on the bottom when scanning from the top makes more sense.
Go one way or the other, but multitasking ships tend to do poorly if they have to perform a number of unrelated functions at once. Research is NOT related to AWACS duties. Thus, they should be done on separate ships.
In real life, do Air Force technicians stationed on AWACS planes do scientific research or do they scan for enemy planes so their buddies don't get shot down? Everyone here should know the answer to that...