Originally posted by heretic
The US dropped the bombs to end the war. The Island campaign killed hundreds of thousands, and the eventual fight on Japanese soil was too grim to not consider it.
That's the official bull**** line. Doesn't explain why a military target couldn't have been chosen, or some place highly visible but unpopulated. And since all available evidence suggests that, counter to what US politicians said at the time, Japan was on the verge of surrender and we knew it, I don't buy it.
also, the US does not go around violating other country's soverengty (sp?), or make terroristic threats. Not to mention being the only superpower
The first part of this is so silly I don't even feel the need to respond to it. It's what the government is doing as this post is typed. As for the "terroristic threats", I suppose that depends on the definition of "terroristic". We DO make a ****load of demands from a good many countries, with the threat of invasion implied in many cases.
and before anyone says, we don't think the US should police the world, etc... you say that until your country gets invaded, or has a civil war, or needs aid. In fact, every country recognized by the UN gets AT LEAST 1M from us in aid/assistance every year.
...Except that the UN is basically a USA fanclub, where the members have to do more or less as we say. Only this year has the UN not gone along with EVERYTHING the US wants, and it's a mild protest now, at that. I think, in light of that, a little pocket change is only fair.
Besides which, if we took the time to rein in our corporations or helped most of the poorer nations in genuinely useful ways, instead of just giving empty monetary gestures, we could keep those millions. Which, as I said, on a national scale are pocket change. It takes a million dollars for a politician to take a ****, practically.
even the god damned Taliban controlled Afghanastan got 8 Billion in aid in 2000.
Sign of the efficacy of our aid program, don't you think? We prop the governments up and let them slaighter civilians until we decide we need to go invadin', then, all of a sudden, they're terrorist rogue nations who torture their populace. Policing the world, indeed.
StratComm: True. There wasn't much of a way TO know, at that point. But it was still kinda low, and after we found out the government coulda at least felt bad...