Personally I liked Nyxfall better but only because it was entirely of my own creation.
Quick synopsis of Nyxfall for those wondering:
It is the distant future. Earth has been destroyed and the Sol system conquered by a powerful race known only as the Nyxians. For decades humanity has lain scattered to the stars, formed into powerful factions who vie for control in a harsh galaxy.
In this time, one man seeks to do the unthinkable, the impossible, the fatal. He seeks to start a war with the race who threw humans to the void and stole our anchient birthplace. His name is Johnathan Sirius, leader of the Terranovan Combine. To most he is a foolish man with dreams of unity amid a people who have known only war since their fall. To others, he is the one hope to lead humanity in a war against a race who has been called The Killer of Worlds by dozens of races for centuries.
However, Sirius has a secret weapon, a single piece of information on the lost whereabouts of the only race to defeat the Nyxians and win. Now he races against rival factions, the threat of civil war, and the oncomming return of the Nyxian Horde to discover the truths a centuries old myth. A myth that is the only hope humans have against becomming the next race erased in a brutal cleansing...the Nyxfall.
