I like the way things are, because debates help keep the main forum alive. Think about it - what would you post about in Hard Light if every touchy subject had to go into a different forum? Plus, you'd have to surf two forums just to get the same info that works fine in one right now.
What I don't like are rules threads

HLP has usually been pretty good with rules, and it's only the influx of new members that are the ones that are really causing trouble. Other forums usually have this giant "READ THIS BEFORE YOU POST OR DIE" at the top of their main forum, and it turns many new users off to their forums, imo, because you (me, at least), don't feel like you can post things without having to watch what you say. I think really the only main rules at Hard Light were and always have been "use the search" and "don't post about FS3". The other things are nice suggestions but not really rules. The thing about flamewars at HLP is that they're entertaining (because if it's between older members, the language is usually pretty entertaining, and if it's between an older member and a younger immature one, it's fun to watch the latter get spanked

) - in most other places I've been to, flame wars devolve into "OMFG U LOZR UR NFVER GONNA GET LAYED LMFAO!!!!11".
Btw, there's a very good example of the latter "spanking" flamewar in...General Discussion right now, I believe
