Lessee... the original Eagle still holds a special place in my heart for being the first campaign with any custom ANIs (i checked). Which is why I'm bringing it back and completely revamping it

(points to sig)
Cardinal Spear was interesting. I kinda hope someone goes back, mods it more strenuously and SCP-ish (e.g. a model for the GTB Gorgon, use of the GTF Angel model, making the Vulcan cannon a ballistic primary, etc). It was one of the first campaigns with new ship models, if not
the first.
Battle for Altair... not a bad first effort. And i did like the idea of being extremely limited (your selection of ships towards the end boiled down to basically 1 bomber and 2 fighters that the Orff could scrounge up).
Awakenings was probably the best of the ones I played. Dunno what needs to be said. B)
McCarthy was a decent campaign (and looking back, using old-school VLLs, ML-16s and Furies to fight Shivans was a fun challenge). There aren't many campaigns with a major plot branch, and this one was well written.
I never got the chance to play Aftermath or Black Horizon. I hope you still have Black Horizon, Kernal, cause the VW archives won't let me DL them...