Well, AFAIK Sandwich HAS been paying this whole thing from his own pockets for some time (don't know for how long), and thus your message quite nullifies itself.
Secondly, as you would know if you hadstudied the matter more, the current shared hosting service used sucks bits occasionally, which has resulted in intolerable technical problems lately, mainly too much downtime.
So, the HLP (and Game Warden) are going to get a dedicated server. However, dedicated servers cost a lot more than shared hosting solutions. The estimated money flow (for ideal server solution) will increase to about 200$ a month, 2400$ a year... I'm sure you understand that it would be unfair to presume that a few people on the forums would be willing to pay that much. Even for ten people to pay, it would still be 240$ a year.
But if you get even a hundred donators, the price per year per capita reduces to only 24$. More donators, less stress on individual pockets.
Plus, it's awesomely adolescent behaviour to go suggesting things like that. It's like "Hey, you're a big car dealer. Why don't you give me free car with all the special equipment there can be, and you pay the importer? You've got monet and I want a car."
In this analogy, the devs and admins are already working hard to get you the car with all the equipment, and now you want them also to pay for it...?