You would be well adviced to question the wisdom of older forumites, we all have our preferences and perversions.
Quod erat demonstrandum...

Anyway, as to the subject I can only say the same things I've said before.
Logitech sticks are ergonomically pretty good, but electronically they're like Russian roulette with a semi-automatic. The rate of the sticks that go bad in unacceptable short time seems to be pretty high and that includes mine.
As far as Saitek sticks go, Saitek Cyborg Evo has been pretty good. Electronically, way more durable than the Logitech's Extreme 3D Pro, anyway. I bought mine almost two years ago and only recently I've had some anomalous readings in the middle area of Y-axis. However, ergonomically I have to say that the Logitech stick was somewhat better for my hand.
Durability-wise, I've had some problems with the Saitek trigger but that's not really Saitek's fault, it's just that my hand doesn't believe the fact that bullets don't fly faster when I press the trigger more...

But it's nothing a good dose of duct tape didn't fix.
Also, the gimbal structure has worn out slightly, which increases the mechanical response deadzone in the middle of the stick.
And by the way, I got interesting results when I added some little WD-40 oil to the visible moving parts of the gimbal system. Movement went a whole lot smoother in a blink, and thus far there's been no corrosive damage of any sort either...
