[Snail]

Well without the 'users' themselves, there would be no FSPort, so it's custom made campaign.


OH!! I JUST NOTICED!! I FORGOT TO ADD THE MAIN FREESPACE CAMPAIGN!!

[Hades]

Homesick PI and Derelict.
Are my choices.

[Jeff Vader]

OH!! I JUST NOTICED!! I FORGOT TO ADD THE MAIN FREESPACE CAMPAIGN!!

Well, wouldn't it have worked if we had only voted for user-made campaigns? I mean, doesn't everyone play the main campaign first? I thought we were ranking all the great campaigns that fans have made for FreeSpace, trying to find out which of them are popular.

That would also question the presence of the FSPort. It is basically the main FS1 campaign, though it is in a way a 'custom made campaign' (cheers, GalacticEmperor).

I'd say that you should only include user-made stuff so that we'd see which of them are played and liked. We all played the main campaign and liked it.

[Snail]

I did not say anywhere that it was ONLY fan-made campaigns, did I?

But if you want me to rip it off and eat it fine.

[Jeff Vader]

Dude, just do what you want. I guess I misunderstood that part about which campaigns are included. My bad.

Your poll, your list, your decisions.

[CP5670]

I don't see much point in including the main campaign either. Everyone obviously liked that. Throw in some of the FSPort ones like Awakenings, Cardinal Spear and Destiny of Peace instead.

[Jeff Vader]

I don't see much point in including the main campaign either. Everyone obviously liked that. Throw in some of the FSPort ones like Awakenings, Cardinal Spear and Destiny of Peace instead.

Oh, piss eggs. I totally forgot about those. I could have voted for at least Cardinal Spear. Dangit.

[Mobius]

You had an interesting idea, Snail, but I would like to have more than 3 options. I really enjoyed PI, Transcend and Derelict, for example, and I couldn't vote them.

[TrashMan]

I don't see much point in including the main campaign either. Everyone obviously liked that. Throw in some of the FSPort ones like Awakenings, Cardinal Spear and Destiny of Peace instead.

Just played Awakenings and Cardinal spear....nice, but so many plot holes...or at least holes in canonicity (canoness? canon?)

[Dark Hunter]

Where is Into the Depths of Hell??? 


With that off the list, I gave its spot to the original JAD.

Also voted Derelict and Transcend.

[Snail]

ITDOH is there now.

[Game_Master64]

ITDOH is there now.

that's hardly fair, the results will be biased because of the newer additions

[TrashMan]

The results were biased from the very begining. This thread is a mockery, but it doesn't matter anyway.

[Snail]

Oh whatever.

Now it's a champagne poll.

[Deepstar]

It's difficult, i enjoyed the most campaigns on this list and a few of them i never see before, and Boomerang was long time ago.

But i can only vote 3, then i vote them: Homesick, Sync and Derelict.

[Snail]

Since everyone thinks this is biased because of the new entries, does anyone here want me to restart the poll?

[Jeff Vader]

Since everyone thinks this is biased because of the new entries, does anyone here want me to restart the poll?

Um... yes, that would probably be a good option, if you're going to continue with this campaign poll issue.

The way I see it, we should all first work together in order to list every goddamn campaign that has been made, and AFTER that actually set the poll up, because it really screws things up, if new choices are added afterwards.

In the end, it's your poll so just decide what you want to do with it, chief.

[Snail]

So anything else you can think of?

Oh, I'm going to lock the poll for now.

[Jeff Vader]

Rain on Ribos 4, Incursion, Return to Sol, Phantoms/Echo Gate. Those for starters. Can't think of anything else. Let's see if other people can come up with something.

Wait... are we listing TBP stuff too? That would complicate matters.

[Turey]

BtRL!