Author Topic: proof of evolution  (Read 7894 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Kosh

  • A year behind what's funny
  • 210
http://science.slashdot.org/science/08/01/18/1943255.shtml


Quote
"When the researchers measured changes in 40 defined characteristics of the nematodes' sexual organs (including cell division patterns and the formation of specific cells), they found that most were uniform in direction, with the main mechanism for the development favoring a natural selection of successful traits, the researchers said."


Who wants to go first?
"The reason for this is that the original Fortran got so convoluted and extensive (10's of millions of lines of code) that no-one can actually figure out how it works, there's a massive project going on to decode the original Fortran and write a more modern system, but until then, the UK communication network is actually relying heavily on 35 year old Fortran that nobody understands." - Flipside

Brain I/O error
Replace and press any key

 

Offline Ford Prefect

  • 8D
  • 26
  • Intelligent Dasein
Well, it's about time someone provided some evidence for this "evolution."
"Mais est-ce qu'il ne vient jamais à l'idée de ces gens-là que je peux être 'artificiel' par nature?"  --Maurice Ravel

 

Offline Mobius

  • Back where he started
  • 213
  • Porto l'azzurro Dolce Stil Novo nella fantascienza
    • Skype
    • Twitter
    • The Lightblue Ribbon | Cultural Project
Good, good...more proof!

And what about:

Vatican has widely accepted evolution and the possible existance of aliens so the only creationists left are mad fanatics living in the US? We could care less about their opinions. They should have their own Church, too.
The Lightblue Ribbon

Inferno: Nostos - Alliance
Series Resurrecta: {{FS Wiki Portal}} -  Gehenna's Gate - The Spirit of Ptah - Serendipity (WIP) - <REDACTED> (WIP)
FreeSpace Campaign Restoration Project
A tribute to FreeSpace in my book: Riflessioni dall'Infinito

 

Offline Bobboau

  • Just a MODern kinda guy
    Just MODerately cool
    And MODest too
  • 213
wait a second, did anyone read that, it sounds like they are saying mutation is not random... I'm not sure if that's what it was saying or if it was just reconfirming again natural selection, but it sounded like it was saying that mutations (not there expression across generations) have directed trends.
Bobboau, bringing you products that work... in theory
learn to use PCS
creator of the ProXimus Procedural Texture and Effect Generator
My latest build of PCS2, get it while it's hot!
PCS 2.0.3


DEUTERONOMY 22:11
Thou shalt not wear a garment of diverse sorts, [as] of woollen and linen together

 

Offline Kosh

  • A year behind what's funny
  • 210
wait a second, did anyone read that, it sounds like they are saying mutation is not random... I'm not sure if that's what it was saying or if it was just reconfirming again natural selection, but it sounded like it was saying that mutations (not there expression across generations) have directed trends.

Quote
, they found that most were uniform in direction, with the main mechanism for the development favoring a natural selection of successful traits, the researchers said.

Looks like reconfirming natural selection
"The reason for this is that the original Fortran got so convoluted and extensive (10's of millions of lines of code) that no-one can actually figure out how it works, there's a massive project going on to decode the original Fortran and write a more modern system, but until then, the UK communication network is actually relying heavily on 35 year old Fortran that nobody understands." - Flipside

Brain I/O error
Replace and press any key

 

Offline Ford Prefect

  • 8D
  • 26
  • Intelligent Dasein
Yeah, I don't think they're saying the trends are directed, just that evolution is deterministic, meaning that a given occurrence emerges causally from previous occurrences. I didn't realize this was still a debate; it doesn't sound particularly radical.
"Mais est-ce qu'il ne vient jamais à l'idée de ces gens-là que je peux être 'artificiel' par nature?"  --Maurice Ravel

 

Offline Bobboau

  • Just a MODern kinda guy
    Just MODerately cool
    And MODest too
  • 213
saying it's deterministic implies you can predict what will happen precisely, which to a degree is true. if an animal feeds from a tree and the tree gets taller, then the animal will have to get taller or starve, but it can not tell you if it will get long legs or a long neck, hell the animal could learn to climb and actually get shorter.
Bobboau, bringing you products that work... in theory
learn to use PCS
creator of the ProXimus Procedural Texture and Effect Generator
My latest build of PCS2, get it while it's hot!
PCS 2.0.3


DEUTERONOMY 22:11
Thou shalt not wear a garment of diverse sorts, [as] of woollen and linen together

 

Offline Ford Prefect

  • 8D
  • 26
  • Intelligent Dasein
The term "determinism" only implies you could theoretically predict precisely what will happen if you had every possible piece of information, which no one ever has, in any situation.
"Mais est-ce qu'il ne vient jamais à l'idée de ces gens-là que je peux être 'artificiel' par nature?"  --Maurice Ravel

 

Offline Bobboau

  • Just a MODern kinda guy
    Just MODerately cool
    And MODest too
  • 213
in which case everything in the universe is deterministic.
Bobboau, bringing you products that work... in theory
learn to use PCS
creator of the ProXimus Procedural Texture and Effect Generator
My latest build of PCS2, get it while it's hot!
PCS 2.0.3


DEUTERONOMY 22:11
Thou shalt not wear a garment of diverse sorts, [as] of woollen and linen together

 

Offline Ford Prefect

  • 8D
  • 26
  • Intelligent Dasein
Precisely. That's why the link strikes me as odd, but then again there isn't much of it.
« Last Edit: January 18, 2008, 10:28:43 pm by Ford Prefect »
"Mais est-ce qu'il ne vient jamais à l'idée de ces gens-là que je peux être 'artificiel' par nature?"  --Maurice Ravel

 

Offline MP-Ryan

  • Makes General Discussion Make Sense.
  • Global Moderator
  • 210
  • Keyboard > Pen > Sword
I'd like to see a journal article rather than such a brief summary.

Genetic mutation is not deterministic; it is random.  Mutation visible in the population at any given point in time will appear deterministic, however.
"In the beginning, the Universe was created.  This made a lot of people very angry and has widely been regarded as a bad move."  [Douglas Adams]

 

Offline Kosh

  • A year behind what's funny
  • 210
I'd like to see a journal article rather than such a brief summary.

Genetic mutation is not deterministic; it is random.  Mutation visible in the population at any given point in time will appear deterministic, however.


Mutation is random, but natural selection is not, which is what this study was about.
"The reason for this is that the original Fortran got so convoluted and extensive (10's of millions of lines of code) that no-one can actually figure out how it works, there's a massive project going on to decode the original Fortran and write a more modern system, but until then, the UK communication network is actually relying heavily on 35 year old Fortran that nobody understands." - Flipside

Brain I/O error
Replace and press any key

 

Offline Ford Prefect

  • 8D
  • 26
  • Intelligent Dasein
It actually seems like poor word choice, seeing as "determinism" is a concept that still has one foot planted firmly in philosophy. Whoever wrote that summary opened up a whole can of worms that I doubt they meant to suggest.
« Last Edit: January 18, 2008, 11:21:00 pm by Ford Prefect »
"Mais est-ce qu'il ne vient jamais à l'idée de ces gens-là que je peux être 'artificiel' par nature?"  --Maurice Ravel

 

Offline jdjtcagle

  • 211
  • Already told you people too much!
Quote
Mutation is random, but natural selection is not, which is what this study was about.

Exacly, but that's not what that thread implies... So they bred worms and a majority started to developed certain advantages changes to their environment?  What changes to what environment.  Also isn't there also things called environmental genes that only "kick in" when the organism is under certain environments.  Testing was done on twins that grew up in different environments.

Something to think about.

Yes, I do 'obviously' believe in God but also believe in not judging others for their belief in whatever, which in turn "not very Christian" I'm NOT here to get into any religious debate. Just always like to keep my ears open and learn
"Brings a tear of nostalgia to my eye" -Flipside
------------------------------------------
I'm an Apostolic Christian (Acts: 2:38)
------------------------------------------
Official Interplay Freespace Stories
Predator
Hammer Of Light - Omen of Darkness
Freefall in Darkness
A Thousand Years

 

Offline MP-Ryan

  • Makes General Discussion Make Sense.
  • Global Moderator
  • 210
  • Keyboard > Pen > Sword
Mutation is random, but natural selection is not, which is what this study was about.

That's not what I got from the summary, but then again that's a VERY badly written summary (which is why I want to see the journal article, if they'd bothered to actually put down the names of the researchers *sigh*).

If the study honestly concluded that "natural selection is not random," then I'd like to award the authors the Captain Obvious Prize for 2008.  That's the fundamental premise of natural selection, hence the "selection" part.  If you read On the Origin of Species, Darwin himself states that natural selection isn't random.  It can't be random for eveolutionary theory to make any sense.

Again... bad summary.  I suspect this isn't what the researchers found at all.  If it is, they need to be properly ridiculed for it.

Quote from: jdjtcagle
So they bred worms and a majority started to developed certain advantages changes to their environment?  What changes to what environment.  Also isn't there also things called environmental genes that only "kick in" when the organism is under certain environments.  Testing was done on twins that grew up in different environments.

I'm putting this as politely as I can.... pleeeeeaaaase don't talk about genetics if you don't actually know what you're talking about.  It'll confuse people.

I don't know what you're getting at with your first two sentences, but your third is, I suspect, referring to environmental triggers?  Gene cascades are frequently activated by external stimuli, ranging from touch, to temperature, to pressure, to salinity, etc etc ad nauseum.  That in itself has little to do with natural selection wherein an organism with mutations that promote survival in certain conditions will reproduce successfully while those without will die.
« Last Edit: January 19, 2008, 12:25:52 am by MP-Ryan »
"In the beginning, the Universe was created.  This made a lot of people very angry and has widely been regarded as a bad move."  [Douglas Adams]

 

Offline MP-Ryan

  • Makes General Discussion Make Sense.
  • Global Moderator
  • 210
  • Keyboard > Pen > Sword
I tracked down the article.  Here's the tidbits I can legally reproduce:

Quote
Summary
Background: A surprising amount of developmental variation has been observed for otherwise highly conserved features, a phenomenon known as developmental system drift. Either stochastic processes (e.g., drift and absence of selection-independent constraints) or deterministic processes (e.g., selection or constraints) could be the predominate mechanism for the evolution of such variation. We tested whether evolutionary patterns of change were unbiased or biased, as predicted by the stochastic or deterministic hypotheses, respectively. As a model, we used the nematode vulva, a highly conserved, essential organ, the development of which has been intensively studied in the model systems Caenorhabditis elegans and Pristionchus pacificus.

Results: For 51 rhabditid species, we analyzed more than 40 characteristics of vulva development, including cell fates, fate induction, cell competence, division patterns, morphogenesis, and related aspects of gonad development. We then defined individual characters and plotted their evolution on a phylogeny inferred for 65 species from three nuclear gene sequences. This taxon-dense phylogeny provides for the first time a highly resolved picture of rhabditid evolution and allows the reconstruction of the number and directionality of changes in the vulva development characters. We found an astonishing amount of variation and an even larger number of evolutionary changes, suggesting a high degree of homoplasy (convergences and reversals). Surprisingly, only two characters showed unbiased evolution. Evolution of all other characters was biased.

Conclusions: We propose that developmental evolution is primarily governed by selection and/or selection- independent constraints, not stochastic processes such as drift in unconstrained phenotypic space.

And I conclude that the Slashdot and ScienceDirect authors need to learn how to read scientific papers, because their summary is about as relevant to this paper as pink elephants.

This paper is discussing developmental evolution, which is not the same type of evolution that non-biologists are familiar with.

Interesting paper though, I take back the ridicule =)
"In the beginning, the Universe was created.  This made a lot of people very angry and has widely been regarded as a bad move."  [Douglas Adams]

 

Offline jdjtcagle

  • 211
  • Already told you people too much!
Mutation is random, but natural selection is not, which is what this study was about.

Quote from: jdjtcagle
So they bred worms and a majority started to developed certain advantages changes to their environment?  What changes to what environment.  Also isn't there also things called environmental genes that only "kick in" when the organism is under certain environments.  Testing was done on twins that grew up in different environments.

I'm putting this as politely as I can.... pleeeeeaaaase don't talk about genetics if you don't actually know what you're talking about.  It'll confuse people.

I don't know what you're getting at with your first two sentences, but your third is, I suspect, referring to environmental triggers?  Gene cascades are frequently activated by external stimuli, ranging from touch, to temperature, to pressure, to salinity, etc etc ad nauseum.  That in itself has little to do with natural selection wherein an organism with mutations that promote survival in certain conditions will reproduce successfully while those without will die.

Duely noted, I'm not saying I know anything... In fact I was attempting to ask a question.  btw, being misunderstood doesn't automatically put me in the ignorant category, again I was asking how they got this info. I ASK because I don't understand.

I'm not being biased so please before you quote me know I'm listening not attacking.

YES I was talking about environment triggers, thank you.
"Brings a tear of nostalgia to my eye" -Flipside
------------------------------------------
I'm an Apostolic Christian (Acts: 2:38)
------------------------------------------
Official Interplay Freespace Stories
Predator
Hammer Of Light - Omen of Darkness
Freefall in Darkness
A Thousand Years

 

Offline jdjtcagle

  • 211
  • Already told you people too much!
Alot words in there are brutal for my puny mind...  :D

I'm having difficulty understanding the part about how all but 2 showed "biased" changes...  :confused:

Quote
We propose that developmental evolution is primarily governed by selection and/or selection- independent constraints, not stochastic processes such as drift in unconstrained phenotypic space.

Someone please define this in laymen terms... thank you

"Brings a tear of nostalgia to my eye" -Flipside
------------------------------------------
I'm an Apostolic Christian (Acts: 2:38)
------------------------------------------
Official Interplay Freespace Stories
Predator
Hammer Of Light - Omen of Darkness
Freefall in Darkness
A Thousand Years

 
It's still quite a leap from simultaneously developing the dozen or so chemical processes required to make blood clot, all in time to keep early lifeforms from bleeding to death.
Could we with ink the ocean fill, and were the skies of parchment made
Were every stalk on earth a quill, and every man a scribe by trade
To write the love of God above, would drain the ocean dry
Nor could the scroll contain the whole, though stretched from sky to sky!

 

Offline redsniper

  • 211
  • Aim for the Top!
early lifeforms didn't have blood.
"Think about nice things not unhappy things.
The future makes happy, if you make it yourself.
No war; think about happy things."   -WouterSmitssm

Hard Light Productions:
"...this conversation is pointlessly confrontational."