Hrmmm... I read four reviews today, all of which said the plot was incredibly thin.
Rental, methinks.
Mr. Ryan, please, I want a moment.
I went into this movie sneering. I read the crushing io9 review and I watched that RottenTomatoes meter drop. I have no love for the original and I was ready to cut this loose.
I loved this movie. It had a (veiled, but present) genuinely thoughtful hard SF concept, it had an absolutely
smashing score that carried the whole film, it had excellent art direction and good cinematography, the action sequences were thrilling in a way that most of the quick-cut pablum of late has not been, the actors were all good (though Olivia Wilde stole the show and Beau Garrett stole my crush object totem) and the plot, for all the holes I can pick out, was compelling and moved along nicely.
There is more clean elegant vision in some of the effects shots of these movies than I've found in entire novels. See it, in 3D if possible, just so you can be sure. It needs the bass and it needs the big screen, not to cover up its story faults but because those touches genuinely help sell the story and its emotional underpinnings.