It's been a while since I played Derelict, but I can see why Homesick ranks alongside it as one of the best user-made campaigns ever made in the Freespace Fanverse.
You just never run out of fun fuel in Homesick. I just don't know how to describe it, but blowing fighters and bombers to hell literally never got so fun. And the chatter is possibly the best ever.
Also Battuta, I think your persuading them to see the new campaigns stems from your enthusiasm in taking a role in the BP team, which is understandable.
Anyway, I'm not actually a veteran here, but I'm somewhat sure they played the newer campaigns too, they just love the nostalgia factor and the "classic" thing behind Derelict. For me, user-made campaigns that uses RETAIL instead of any add-on has its own flavor, while things like Blue Planet have some other type of charm.
I haven't played much of BP:WiH yet (finished BP:AoA though), but sad to say, it's kinda lag in the first mission. I hope the lag somehow stops in the succeeding ones, otherwise it's going to be a bit of a problem.
Okay, *expects wave of flames*, but I somehow find it a minor setback to play as a female.