Yes, exactly.
Kind of defeats the purpose. Aces are supposedly elite pilots, not pilots who win all the time simply because they've got better equipment.
It would fall in the same category as the BALLS OF STEELE buffs; you lie and tell the player that they're flying the exact same ships as he is, but theirs are really better.
Having
different equipment would actually be a separate way to make them seem elite to the player. Going back to "My Brother, My Enemy," one way you can tell that the enemies are elite pilots is that they each have very customized loadouts, including Trebuchets, which in WiH are reserved for special occasions.