[Luis Dias]

Alpha 1 was just testing them out. "meh" he concluded, "not half bad".

[Legate Damar]

The Cardassians, of course

[MP-Ryan]

We lose, because we get involved in a cross-universe fight discussion

QFT.

[Luis Dias]

Herpes Wins! Flawless victory.

[IronBeer]

Herpes DERPies.

[BloodFleet]

Well according to the games Shivans have firepower in the gigaton level while Reapers are in the kiloton level...obvious victor is obvious.

but, Shivan vs Reaper? Been there done that http://imageshack.us/f/825/ss00018.jpg/

[General Battuta]

Well according to the games Shivans have firepower in the gigaton level while Reapers are in the kiloton level...obvious victor is obvious.

but, Shivan vs Reaper? Been there done that http://imageshack.us/f/825/ss00018.jpg/

you said gigaton

[Luis Dias]

He meant Megatron. Unicron would fart the **** out of these puny creatures.

[Phantom Hoover]

BP Shivans win handily; they're god-killers, after all. Canon-restricted Shivans, there's next to no information to work with above maybe fleet level, which means the discussion just turns into numberwank from condescending wannabe physicists (cf. all of these discussions).

[starbug]

Shivans hands down, as they have beams! Reapers don't if you read the Codex's Reaper weapons arent actually beam weapons, also their weapon ranges don't seem the be that far. As other people have said Reapers need to land on planets to harvest, shivans just blast them from orbit. Then Shivans wipe out the borg!

[Phantom Hoover]

that's numberwank! no but seriously thinking of this in terms of direct ship-to-ship combat is boring, hackneyed and ends up wasting everyone's time and attention on a dumb non-discussion

[wistler]

A dumb discussion everybody can't help but post on, because deep down we all love a good vs. debate 

[An4ximandros]

 All the people who post in this thread lose. gg no re. Yes, that includes me :b

[wistler]

Well according to the games Shivans have firepower in the gigaton level while Reapers are in the kiloton level...obvious victor is obvious.

but, Shivan vs Reaper? Been there done that http://imageshack.us/f/825/ss00018.jpg/

you said gigaton

ha, this is bringing back bad memories of the SpaceBattles forum I used to go on in college.

[esarai]

Nagari vs. Indoctrination go

[An4ximandros]

"I don't mean the Systems Alliance, Mister Shepard. I mean you. Surely you have seen what will happen if you fail..."

 "The survival of the human race is utterly contingent upon your ability to do one simple thing."

 "You must destroy the Citadel Council."

  *Joy +999*

 Coolness:
 
 Nagari: 999
 Ghost Kid Overlord: 5

[Gray113]

Catalyst vs Shambhala go

[Luis Dias]

Nagari seems to be less haphardous than Indoc to the subject, if he doesn't dwell too far out. And it doesn't rely on quantum entanglement for its job, so for that alone, it is a clear winner.

Don't forget, next up is Bosch vs TIM.

[Gray113]

Just to bad alpha 1 didn't have a "romance option" involving choosing between banging their wingman or some hot vasudan that they rescued 

[An4ximandros]

 Yep.