[Mongoose]

(Nah actually Phoenix V. Dunno why, it just makes feel warm and fuzzy.)

One-shotting those Dragons in A Failure to Communicate was a thing of beauty.

[Lepanto]

Another vote for the Trebuchet. Fighters, bombers, turrets, all will fall without getting with 4KM.  Tornado a close second since it's basically like pressing ~+K at medium range.

Plus the Harpoon, of course, for sheer reliability and ammo efficiency.

Also, the Slammer in WiH. It's tricky to use, but it's worth it when you vaporize multiple wings with a single shot.

[SmashMonkey]

Hornet. Definitely the Hornet.

(My favorite moments are when I fire bank after bank of Hornets and all of them miss...)

[wardog300k]

fire bank after bank of Hornets and all of them miss

The reason you should use Tornado instead,it never misses

[TwoCables]

fire bank after bank of Hornets and all of them miss

The reason you should use Tornado instead,it never misses

Yeah, but they didn't have Tornadoes back then.

[wardog300k]

I'm thinking during second incrusion,not great war.

[TwoCables]

Oh wait, that's right: he's comparing the Interceptor to the Harpoon. I got myself into thinking that he was only comparing secondaries from the FS1 era.

[Rodo]

Harpoon, hands down.

[Phantom Hoover]

It's really a weird comparison, of course the newer weapon's going to be better.

[CT27]

Either the Harpoon or Trebuchet I would say.

Harpoons are fairly good for anti-fighter/bomber work and you can carry a decent amount of them.  Trebs are good for neutering most capital ships from a distance.