I hope it's okay to throw in some comments on this as I believe Chapter 2 isn't out.
I just completed Chapter 1, within the last 10 minutes or so.
What's missing
-------------------
Voice acting, voice acting, voice acting. This is the only issue I ever have with FM's. It's next to impossible in a good firefight to keep reading. I don't know how much of a pain in the neck this is to do as I've never constructed diddly squat in FRED.
That's it, in my opinion. This campaign is easily on par with anything created by Volition.
What was enjoyable
--------------------------
The whole thing. Plain and simple. I was on the edge of my seat through most of the campaign. I love the ship designs and general perfomance of them. The first mission to the Sol gate was...daunting. All these huge ships and not a single dent in performance. Most impressive!
I particularly like the new weaponry, especially the Mace. I found the Flail and the Morning Star indispensable in the original Freespace campaigns. Go figure. If you want a true tactical advantage, learn to use the weapons everyone hates. I used to take great delight in really antagonizing other players online with the kinetic weapons. The mace improves on that tenfold.
The Hastor (hope I have that right) was my favorite to use. Complimented with the Hurricane dumbfire.
What wasn't
----------------
The Cyone fighter. Awesome design, but a bit short on cannons.
The Prometheus, even in the distant future, still has a lousy firing rate. A grand gun when up close though.
Strange Bugs
-----------------
Earth looks, well, seriously whacked on my system. The textures are all smeared and look like mirrors. Of course, I'm using an old Voodoo 3 for a video card so it's probably my problem.
This was a blast to play and I look forward to Chapter 2. Thank you very much for designing this
