NO.
Freespace series lacks
A) drama ("ZOMG Alpha 1 is going to do stuff all by himself, whoa!")
B) interesting characters ("Hey I am an anecdotal dude with no identity!")
C) original plot ("The ancient prophecies are true. The Great Darkness comes, and we're all GOING TO DIE.")
D) Depth. ("ZOMG, huge insects killing us all, let's develop some überfighters! Oh, and we had a 14-year war, guess it's OK to just drop it, right guys?")
Really, there's movies and there's computer games. You could make a decent movie out of Beneath a Steel Sky, but Freespace?
No. And this does not mean that I'm not a fan, just that I think the game lacks most of aspects of a good game. Now, let it be more political plot, with focus on commanders, well, maybe then.
See, Wing Commander The Movie for reference. Then think if you would like to see your favourite movie raped into unconsciouness.