Uhoh...don't make me write a long post comparing XWA and FS. It would get messy...

Alright, howabout a short version.
XWA-
Good:Virtual cockpit, big battles, better flight model(turn rate is proportional to speed) and personalized story.
Bad:Lack of weapon/loadout options, too few ships, more bugs, personalized story(I like the impersonal better.

)
FS2
Good: Beautiful graphics, best sound, rock-solid game, better capships, storyline is very involved, lots of ships and weapons to fight with and against.
Bad: Ships fly too slow(See my sig

), can't have as big of battles, very basic cockpit, simplistic flight model.
Alright...that satisfies my review/critic urge.
------------------
Sushi- the OTHER white meat!
Accelerate your game-
Velocity Mod