Originally posted by vyper
Thing is, they would've never had the popular support had the issue of representation not been so strong.
The popular support for the American Revolution isn't as high as the history books make it out to be.
If Britain was a little bit smarter in management of their colonies and was more serious about "The British Empire" they could have held onto the territories.
Of course probably each provence would have grown its own effective government over time, and world war one would have led to something closer to independent states in a British Commonwealth.
The US was insular enough until the 20th century that a British-dominated US wouldn't have changed history too much until that point.