[Snail]

FOW1 only had 1 vote? That campaign was great...

[TrashMan]

It got 2 votes.. (3 if you count my own...which I havn't posted for fairness sake)

I'm a bit surprised that Cardinal Spear got that high..it was good campaign with plenty of action, but it has so many plot holes and conficted canon on several levels...

[diceman111]

1. Derelict
2. Revenge
3. ITDoH
4. Flames Of War Ch. 1 (ThrashMan said he would kill me if I didnt vote for it ;-))
5. Raider Wars (For The Babylon Project)
6. Inferno R1
7. INFA
8. Sol A History
9. Just Another Day
10. PI

Ok just want to say that these are just campaigns for FS:SCP (except raider wars) but if we also count TC then Wing Commander Saga , Beyond the red line and The Babylon project would be at the top of the list I think

[TrashMan]

That is a LIE!!!    I said I would....erm....HEAL you...yeah, that's it

that makes 4 votes

[Horus]

you are gonna pay me for voteing for it aye? (woops should i have said that outloud)

[TrashMan]

PESANT! One doesn't pay you to vote for perfection! You got your due reward when the campaign was released!

[Horus]

Whens next reward coming then?

[Ace]

It got 2 votes.. (3 if you count my own...which I havn't posted for fairness sake)

I'm a bit surprised that Cardinal Spear got that high..it was good campaign with plenty of action, but it has so many plot holes and conficted canon on several levels...

It did come out before FreeSpace 2, and there wasn't a lot of (and still isn't) canon on the period.

But yes, I'm a bit surprised it's still enjoyed considering how hokey it is in hindsight at times.

[Dark Hunter]

I enjoy it mainly for the final mission in the "Vega" campaign. The one with Deathclaw. Whoever made that mission was a genious...

[TrashMan]

Whens next reward coming then?

soon... I'd reckon I got 6 more missions to go before Part 1 can be released.

[TrashMan]

It did come out before FreeSpace 2, and there wasn't a lot of (and still isn't) canon on the period.

True...some of the things that do spring to mind is the number of only 2 Typhons destroyed. Just in the campaign you destroy 3 and capture 1.

And the weapons...while cool, they make no sense since they are better than the weapons the GTVA uses afterwards.

It was stil la nice campaign...what bugged was the vasudan Athena..

[colecampbell666]

The Athena looked cool, though.

[Wobble73]

Why does nearly everyone on this thread keep calling Transcend, Transcendant!!!!

[colecampbell666]

Dunno. Probably because it centered around the transcendant, and since that was similar to the campaign name, people got it confused.

[jr2]

Umm, no one mentioned BtRL demo???  The best demo out?

OK: (Slightly out of order, but approximately) :

1. FSPort + ST
2. INFR1 & Solar Wars
3. Derelict
4. BtRL
5. TBP
6. WCS
7. DEM
8. JAD 1, 2, & 3
9. Homesick
10. Sync + Transcend  (Yeah, I hate Herc IIs also )

[hip63]

WOW! what responses!

a little FYI for everyone, I have played TBP's EMW & RW and I have downloaded the WCS demo and BtRL demo.

The TBP stuff is great, the WCS show great promise and the BtRL rocks but there's not much to play with yet. I know that there are some mission out there for BtRL but still with limited numbers fo models in the demo, there's not enough for anyone to put together a "real campaign to sink your teeth into" unless there something I missed.

But let's keep the thread going, I wanna see more Top Tens!

hip63

[nubbles526]

Just updated the ranking!


First place is STILL...DERELICT!!! Who got 15 votes!
Second place is:Procyon Insurgency With 12 votes!
Third place is tied with: Transcendent Inferno Release 1, Just Another Day Who got 8 votes!

4th place: Sync (7 votes)
5th place: Homesick, The Babylon Project, (6 votes)
6th place: Into the depths of hell, Cardinal spear, FSPort,Deux Ex Machina (5 votes)
7th place: Flames of War 1, Inferno: Alliance (4 votes)
8th place: Destiny of peace, Sol: A history  (3 votes)
9th place: Rain on Ribos 4, Fall of Epsilon Pegasi, Into the halls of Valhalla, Awakenings, Warzone, Phantoms, Echo Gate(2 votes)
10th place: Desperation, Faces of Treason, The black Hand, Revenge, Journey to Epsilon Pegasi, Ross128, Wing Command Saga, Aeous Affairs, Renegade Reassurgence, Pandora's Box, Shrouding the Light, Solar Wars (1 vote)

This time there were some votes that were not counted (Didn't know some of the initials from jr2... )

[jr2]

Umm, no one mentioned BtRL demo???  The best demo out?

OK: (Slightly out of order, but approximately) :

1. FSPort + ST = FreeSpace Port (FS1) + Silent Threat
2. INFR1 = Inferno Rel 1 & Solar Wars
3. Derelict
4. BtRL = BSG Beyond the Red Line
5. TBP = The Babylon Project
6. WCS = Wing Commander Saga
7. DEM = Deus Ex Machina
8. JAD 1, 2, & 3 = Just Another Day
9. Homesick
10. Sync + Transcend  (Yeah, I hate Herc IIs also )

[Game_Master64]

In no particular order

Inferno R1
Into the Depths of Hell (any chapter)
PI
Homesick
Derelict
Desperation (both chapters)
Sync
Transcend (play with headphones and the lights off )
Revenge: Final Confilct (long as hell, but fun to play. Needs some tweaking to make it work right though....)
Main FS2

NOTICE: I didn't include JAD 1-3 or DEM, although they were funny as hell and i did enjoy them, simply because they focus around the jokes and not the actual game play or campaign story.