Author Topic: Caprica 1x08 "Ghosts in The Machine" [Spoilers]  (Read 8257 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline NGTM-1R

  • I reject your reality and substitute my own
  • 213
  • Syndral Active. 0410.
Re: Caprica 1x08 "Ghosts in The Machine" [Spoilers]
There is no way that the "Centurion part" could have known the gun held blanks - the weight difference could have been down to different types of ammunition or simply having less than a full magazine.

To keep a weapon's performance characteristics as consistant as possible you will find that different ammunition types, even from different manufacturers, will have near-identical weights. A bullet is nearly all of a cartridge's weight and the reason you can tell the difference with blanks is because there's no bullets. The gun will feel almost unloaded. Any sort of ammunition that weighed remotely the same amount as a blank round would alter the performance characteristics of the weapon severely, to the point it would basically seem like firing a different gun. It would also cause an extreme reduction in the weapon's stopping power. No one is going to produce and sell such a cartridge.

As to having a less than full clip: Again, the bullets are the main source of weight in a cartridge. The powder doesn't add enough to be noticible even if all the cartridges don't have any and all the cartridge casings together probably add up to a single bullet. If Zoe had any possible way of knowing there was more than one round in the magazine, she would have been able to deduce they were blanks. (And beyond a certain number of non-blank rounds there would be a perceptible change in balance.)
"Load sabot. Target Zaku, direct front!"

A Feddie Story

 

Offline Snagger

  • 27
Re: Caprica 1x08 "Ghosts in The Machine" [Spoilers]
There is no way that the "Centurion part" could have known the gun held blanks - the weight difference could have been down to different types of ammunition or simply having less than a full magazine.

To keep a weapon's performance characteristics as consistant as possible you will find that different ammunition types, even from different manufacturers, will have near-identical weights. A bullet is nearly all of a cartridge's weight and the reason you can tell the difference with blanks is because there's no bullets. The gun will feel almost unloaded. Any sort of ammunition that weighed remotely the same amount as a blank round would alter the performance characteristics of the weapon severely, to the point it would basically seem like firing a different gun. It would also cause an extreme reduction in the weapon's stopping power. No one is going to produce and sell such a cartridge.

As to having a less than full clip: Again, the bullets are the main source of weight in a cartridge. The powder doesn't add enough to be noticible even if all the cartridges don't have any and all the cartridge casings together probably add up to a single bullet. If Zoe had any possible way of knowing there was more than one round in the magazine, she would have been able to deduce they were blanks. (And beyond a certain number of non-blank rounds there would be a perceptible change in balance.)
I am ex-forces, so I'm quite familiar with the differences between blanks and different types of ammunition.  Blanks are much lighter, but the bullet does not constitute most of the mass of the round.  The difference in mass between hollow-point (dum-dum) and plain parabellum rounds would also be significant, as would the different between standard rounds and magnum rounds, armour piercing and so on.  It's a plot device that has no grounding in reality.

 
Re: Caprica 1x08 "Ghosts in The Machine" [Spoilers]
Well, it is a sophisticated military robot. It could probably identify the amount and types of rounds based on the most subtle facets of the gun's weight and balance.