Honestly I don't think I'd trust Yahtzee's videos too much in terms of a blanket judgement on a particular game. I haven't watched his stuff for a long time, but I know there were multiple reviews in the past where I felt like he was laser-focused on one negative aspect of a game in lieu of other positive ones, or was viewing a whole game in a much harsher light than it deserved. At the end of the day he's a comedy writer, and his shtick is to go balls-in and bash the hell out of a game for humorous purposes. It's fun, but I don't put much stock in him beyond that.