Author Topic: The Shivan Manifesto, Version 2.0  (Read 23869 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Antares

  • 28
  • Author of The Shivan Manifesto
The Shivan Manifesto, Version 2.0
Here it is, folks.

I spent most of today poring through the original release of the Shivan Manifesto, looking over commentary from you and editing in my own responses.  Most of this was cut-and-paste work, but it still took several hours to accomplish.

I believe I've addressed every conceivable topic that could ever arise from this essay, but if I've left something out, be sure to let me know, so I can make changes.  Some minor errors still exist--lots of italicizing needs to be done for purposes of style and emphasis, and there are probably a few errors, but by and large, everything is in good shape.  Some ideas may be out of order--i.e., you may read mention to something that hasn't been discussed yet--due to the lengthy editing process.  Apologies in advance.

Setekh, you once mentioned making up some illustrations for this monstrous thing.  I'm too nice of a guy to ask you for any directly, but if you feel like making some renders or something, be my guest. :D

EXTREME LENGTH WARNING.  The Shivan Manifesto is approximately thirty pages in length as a Microsoft Word file.  Do not begin reading unless you plan to finish.



Since the initial Freespace title, the question of the Shivans' origin has remained largely a mystery.  While the subject of much conjecture and guesswork, the relatively scant canon material provided in-game makes it difficult to formulate any elaborate hypothesis concerning just who--or what-- the Shivans are, and what their purpose in Freespace is.

Here, I shall set forth my own theory as relates to the Shivan mystery, attempting to unravel Freespace's greatest standing enigma.  Be forewarned that this discussion is quite lengthy, as I have done what I can to work out each point in detail, with as much information as I can recall after several playthroughs of both FS titles.  In places where I lack direct proof, I am forced to make assumptions--some of them far-fetched--a tactic I hope will not offend those of you who are Freespace purists.

Comments and constructive criticisms are always welcome.  Please enjoy the reading.


[glow=red]The Shivan Manifesto[/glow]

I.  Who or what are the Shivans?

The most obvious answer to this question is that the Shivans are a violently xenocidal alien race, possessing advanced offensive and defensive technologies.  They have exhibited virtually no interest in diplomatic contact (a point we will discuss shortly), and strangely, have given higher priority to the possession of subspace jump nodes rather than habitable planets.  We know the Shivan fleet is vast, as evidenced by their innumerable fighter squadrons and--in their greatest display of brute force to date--their ominous armada of over eighty Sathanas-class juggernauts.  However, there is no evidence of a Shivan homeworld, nor any habitable Shivan space installations.  The Shivans are known to have a high degree of expertise in the field of subspace, able to navigate uncharted jump nodes or nodes too unstable for Terran/Vasudan engines, and also able to generate strange subspace energy pulses from their larger vessels.

The supplemental material that follows is the Freespace 2 database entry on the Shivans, taken (with apologies) from Tech Freespace:

"32 years after the Great War, we still know almost nothing about the Shivans. Physically, the Shivans have multiple compound eyes and five legs with claw-like manipulators. Their insect like carapace does not appear original to the creature's physiognomy, suggesting the Shivans are a cybernetic fusion of biology an technology. The integrated plasma weapon also exhibits properties of an organic artificial fusion. The weapon may be a kind of focusing device powered by the energy of the being itself, though this point is the subject of heated cotroversy. These details are cited as evidence that the Shivans could not have evolved as the Terran or Vasudan species had, but that they were likely constructed by another entity.

Only a handful of Shivans have ever been captured, and all research on live specimens ended with the GTI's Hades rebellion in 2335. The results of these studies remain highly classified. Though the Shivans are onviously xenocidal, their motives and origins have yet to be determined. According to Ancient artifacts, the Shivans seem to possess some kind of sensitivity to subspace disturbances. We do not know if the Shivans returned to this corner of the galaxy by chance, by cycle, by pattern, or by their detection of Terran-Vasudan subspace tarvel. Xenobiologists know very little about Shivan society. A leading hypothesis is the hive mind theory, arguing that Shivan society is broken down in specialized functions driven by a collective intelligence. The most convincing evidence supporting this theory is the behavior of Shivan forces following the destruction of the Lucifer, the turning point of the Great War. Other experts cauton against attributing insectoid properties to the Shivans, regardless of their appearance and behavior. Shivan communication seems to occur in the electromagnetic spectrum, though efforts to decode their transmissions have yielded no meaningful results to date."

a. Where do the Shivans come from?

As stated, the Shivans have no apparent home planet, nor any space stations from which to deploy their forces.  If such a location exists, it would naturally be believed to be located somewhere deep inside their territory, beyond the binary star system where SOC forces encountered the three Shivan Communication Nodes ("Into the Lion's Den").  This notion is given credence by the existence of the third Knossos portal in that same system, which the Ancients would not have constructed had Shivan forces already been present.  In-game dialogue suggests the region beyond the portal is the area of space in which the Ancients were first confronted by the Shivans, but we have no way to confirm this supposition.

The best clues we have to the Shivans' origins come directly from Volition.  One comment reveals that the Shivans' bodies, as seen in-game, are not artificial suits, but their true bodies.  The highly versatile nature of the Shivan body, able to move through outer space itself without protection (as evidenced in the Freespace Reference Bible) suggests that the Shivans either evolved entirely in the void of deep space, or that their bodies were created with the specific intent of being able to operate in that environment.

A second, more crucial comment from Volition indicates that as terrifying as the Shivans are, they should be viewed as "a symptom of a bigger problem".  More on this revelation will be discussed later.

b.  What is the extent of the Shivans' offensive and defensive capabilities?

Weaponry appears to be one of the Shivans' most specialized fields of expertise; the Shivans possess a wide array of destructive armaments, many of which are more potent than any comparable equipment in the GTVA.  Shivan offense is wide-ranging, able to neutralize individual fighters, bombers, and capital craft, commence thorough and sustained planetary bombardment, and even destroy entire solar systems via induced supernova.  Whether the Shivans possess any more powerful weapons of annihilation--as inconceivable as the notion may seem--is, as of this writing, unknown.

Strangely, in contrast to their immensely powerful arsenal, Shivan armor plating appears to be relatively weak.  The Shivans' primary defensive advantage is their possession of a versatile energy shielding system, a technology which the GTVA has subsequently reverse-engineered and applied to its own fighter squadrons.  The Shivans appear to lack the expertise needed to shield a capital-class vessel, with one notable exception: the heavily-armed superdestroyer Lucifer was protected by an impenetrable energy shield, likely energized by the ship's five reactors.  Allied craft were never able to penetrate the shield directly, and were forced to circumvent the mechanism entirely by ambushing the Lucifer during subspace transit, a time in which its shields would not function.

The Lucifer-class vessel destroyed at the close of the Great War was the only known craft of its type to exist in the entire Shivan armada.  After 32 years, the design may now be obsolete, or the superdestroyers themselves might only be manufactured in minimal numbers.  We have no way of confirming either hypothesis.

c. Why are the Shivans so destructive?

The Shivans' motives are as much a mystery as their very existence.  They kill with frightening indiscrimination, firing upon any non-Shivan craft, regardless of its intentions.  The Hammer of Light, for example, sought to ally with the Shivans, but several HOL craft and at least one major HOL base were destroyed by Shivan forces ("The Darkness and the Light").

The Ancients, in their FS1 monologues, believed themselves to be trespassers into subspace, and that they had somehow "sinned" against the cosmic order by intruding there.  To the Ancients, the Shivans were, in a sense, a sort of divine punishment meant to extract the universe's revenge upon their race.  In one of Admiral Bosch's own monologues, he echoes this notion, stating that the Ancients " believed their voyage across the sea of stars awakened the dragon that slept beneath the waves, that the Shivans were birthed in the flux of subspace and their destruction was the revenge of an angry cosmos."  This point is central to the theory of the Shivans' true origins, to be discussed shortly.

c.  If the Shivans are truly xenocidal, why did they respond to Admiral Bosch?  What happened to him?

Exactly why Bosch believed an alliance with a race so incredibly destructive was even possible is unknown.  In his monologues, Bosch simply states that he believes the human race "has no future with the Vasudans", and that humanity's destiny "lies elsewhere".  What we know for sure is that Bosch initiated contact with at least three Shivan vessels through the use of ETAK, his communication technology which transmitted modified quantum pulses.  The first vessel, the Shivan cruiser Rephaim, was apparently destroyed before significant progress by Bosch could be made; the second and third cruisers, the Sammael and the Azmedaj, were also destroyed, but not before the Azrael-class transport carrying Bosch and his command crew had managed to escape ("Return to Babel").

The Shivans could have reacted to Bosch's olive branch for any number of reasons.  It is possible that they were genuinely interested in his peaceful overtures, but given the Shivans' history of wanton annihilation, this theory is highly unlikely, to say the least; it is further undermined by the events in "Return to Babel", in which the encounter between the NTF and the Shivans onboard the Iceni is revealed to have been very violent, with a body count in the thousands, and casualties on both sides.  Bosch's subordinate onboard the Iceni states that the Shivans "took" Bosch with a dozen of his lieutenants, suggesting his meeting with the Shivans was not a friendly one ("Return to Babel").  In his monologues, Bosch claims the alliance with the Shivans is intended for the good of all humanity; it seems unlikely, therefore, that he would ask the Shivans to kill members of his own loyal crew.

The most plausible explanation is that the Shivans were more intrigued by the nature of Bosch's transmissions, rather than their actual content.  Bosch himself states that the first contact was "rudimentary and crude", meaning that the content of his message may very well have been different than what he'd initially believed--something nonsensical like "cheese is ambitious except on Sunday in winter" as opposed to "we come in peace".  The Shivans, in turn, would have been puzzled by what they encountered: a Shivan transmission emanating from a Terran vessel.  When they investigated, perhaps expecting to find captured Shivans, but instead discovered an overly-idealistic Aken Bosch, it is reasonable to assume that they were none-too-pleased.

To conclude the point, Admiral Bosch is probably dead, or wishes he was.  He and the Shivans probably weren't playing an amiable game of chess aboard that transport.

d.  Is it possible that the Shivans captured Bosch in order to interrogate him?

Unlikely.  The Shivans have never previously been interested in talking to either Terrans or Vasudans, and have never taken prisoners (with the exception of Bosch and his command crew). We are granted very few glimpses of Shivan/Terran personal interaction: once in the "Hall Fight" cutscene, and again with the apperance of the Lucifer at Tombaugh Station (described in the Freespace Reference Bible). We may or may not wish to include the boarding of the Iceni as a third example. In each case, contact has been extremely violent, with no intent to discuss any sort of terms, or indeed, to ask questions of any sort.

Secondly is the problem of the language barrier itself. Humans aren't Shivan, as Commander Snipes so succintly points out to us, and we don't speak "quantum pulse" very well. So far as we know, the only ETAK prototype was aboard the Iceni; whether this device was destroyed along with the command frigate or not is unknown, but it can be assumed lost.  ETAK was a prototype device, and as the first of its kind, probably wouldn't have been very portable.  The first Earth computers were enormous, taking up entire rooms, and Bosch's ETAK may very well have existed on a similar scale.
Despite Bosch's rigorous study of the Shivans, he's no MacGyver, and it seems unlikely that he would be able to rebuild such a device completely from memory. Even if we accept that Bosch had the ETAK blueprints stored on his nifty little laptop, and that he took it with him when he was captured (something that is virtually guaranteed to be untrue; if the Alliance hadn't recovered Bosch's computer, then we probably wouldn't be reading his personal log), then he is still aboard a Shivan vessel, with no Terran tools or materials with which to assemble his device.


We are led back to the questions of what exactly the Shivans are.  To say they are possessed of a "hive mind", as the FS2 database suggests, is not enough; if it is true, it is merely an attribute of their kind, and does not explain their existence.  Were they simply aliens in the same vein as the Vasudans are aliens to Terrans, it seems strange that they would shun any and all diplomacy, as well as ignore any planetary resources while focusing entirely upon jump-nodes.  If the Shivans are artificial life-forms, some variety of cyborgs or robots, it begs the question as to who their creators are, and whether or not they are alive or dead.  Are the Shivans once-harmless environmental preservation constructs that have gone terribly awry?  Or are they doomsday weapons unleashed in a war that has been over for millennia?  Such questions are so far-removed from the immediacy presented by the events and scenarios of the FS universe itself, that I am led to believe they cannot be the case.

The preceding information leads me to believe that the Shivans are, in fact, subspace life-forms.  They originate from somewhere within subspace itself.  While it is mere conjecture on my part, I believe that the Shivans initially exist as pure, sentient, subspace energy, and that the insect-like bodies we observe are fashioned by the Shivans in order for them to effectively move about within our plane of existence.  Such bodies would have no use in subspace itself, where no matter exists to be handled or used. This theory would explain their skill with subspace manipulation, as well as provide a foundation for their motives in attacking other space-faring races.

e.  The idea of energy-based life-forms is stupid, and you have no proof that the Shivans come from subspace.

Is it?  Energy beings have been a staple of science fiction for years, and the idea of a soul--a form of life lacking any physical body--is important to many religions worldwide.  Legends of spirits and ghosts are as popular as they've ever been, yet their subjects are seldom encumbered by physical matter.

The Shivans' subspace origins are indeed uncertain, but it is an explanation that fits the facts at hand: the Shivans' total disinterest in planets or technology, the skill with which they manipulate subspace energy, and their bodies' adaptation for zero-gravity environments.

II.  What is the Shivans' primary goal?

On the surface, the Shivans' only apparent intention is to destroy.  The Ancients themselves gave the Shivans the label of "The Destroyers", a moniker Admiral Bosch frequently applied to them.  We must strive to narrow this rather broad focus, however, for the Shivans obviously do not wish to destroy everything; they disregard planets, resources, and technology entirely, and in a rare display of strategy, they chose to capture Admiral Bosch rather than kill him outright.  This indicates there is more complexity to the Shivans as a race, despite their apparent single-mindedness.

To begin my explanation, I turn again to the Volition comment that the Shivans are merely a "symptom of a bigger problem".  I ask you to think about that for a moment.  As dire a threat as the Shivans already are, Volition claims they are a sign or indication of an even more serious situation.

The Shivans, as they currently stand, are a virtually unstoppable race of butchers hell-bent on the annihilation of all life they come across.  In order to conceptualize something even worse, we are forced to broaden our outlook on the situation.  There are those who have proposed that the "bigger problem" is yet another alien race, one superior to even the Shivans, yet with this I must disagree.  This would suggest a race of unbelievable power, so much so that even the Shivans' monstrous weaponry and apparently-endless numbers would be unable to stand against them.  From a practical standpoint, this idea makes little sense, as it would not serve to flesh out the FS universe in any way.  The GTVA has already proven inferior, both in terms of technology and in size, to the Shivan forces... therefore, what would be the point in introducing another brand of aliens that simply drives this point home?  Such a scenario would prove so bleak and hopeless that it would serve to depress the gamer, and I doubt this is Volition's intention.

So we must ask ourselves, barring bigger, badder aliens, what could be worse than the Shivans' methodical destruction of spacefaring life-forms?

The answer is damage to space itself.

a. Theoretical Subspace Physics

Think of the fabric of space as being like the skin of a living creature.  Also, think of a subspace jump as being like making a tiny wound or incision into said skin.  Given time, the skin will heal, but with repeated cuts and gashes, scars are formed, and the possibility of infection--or, in severe cases, amputation--develops.

We know that subspace is relatively "fickle".  The FS database tells us that most nodes open and close within milliseconds.  We also know that larger nodes can be collapsed by way of large explosions, such as the sealing-off of the Sol-Delta Serpentis node by the destruction of the Lucifer, or the collapse of all nodes leading off Capella by Orion-class destroyers loaded with Meson warheads ("Clash of the Titans II").  Therefore, I feel it is not unreasonable to speculate that subspace damage is also incurred, on some level, by the use of subspace travel.  It is entirely possible that traffic through subspace corridors will accelerate node collapse more quickly than the natural passage of time.

If we make the logical assumption that subspace--literally meaning "under space" or "beneath space"--acts as the physical support for normal space, and accept for the purposes of argument that subspace travel does incur gradual damage to the subspace fabric in the long-term, then what will happen when--eventually--subspace as a whole comes to collapse entirely?

The terrifying answer is that, left without structural support, normal space will collapse upon itself in turn.  The end result might be like the formation of a black hole, a literal gap in space that is devoid of anything, even of the theoretical surface that holds the fabric of space and time together.  Indeed, the apperance of new black holes in isolated places might be interpreted as a sign of the weakening or collapse of the subspace dimension in given locations.  Of course, even black holes shrink over long periods of time, meaning that presumably, the subspace fabric is capable of "healing", provided it is left undisturbed.

b.  Subspace Fights Back

Nature, in terms of the structure of natural objects, enjoys static things.  Depleted resources (gradually, sometimes over long periods of time) renew themselves.  Plants and animals grow in accordance to blueprints set down in DNA patterns.  Water--unless subjected to temperature extremes--remains water, no matter what container it is placed in.  And, of course, injuries inflicted to the body heal over time, with the help of the immune system.  If we look at outer space from such a medical standpoint as has been put forth, however, then what--if anything--serves as the immune system for the cosmos?

None other than the Shivans.  If humanity is the disease, then the Shivans are literally the cure.

Volition's comment on the nature of the Shivans leads me to look at the problem in question as being more of an internal one (in the sense of a wounded body) than an external one (in the sense of Super-Death-Aliens).  While the FS games certainly provide no hard evidence for such a theory, it nonetheless makes sense.  We know that the Shivans have appeared on three distinct occasions:

1. To the Ancients, following their discovery of subspace and their rampant expansionism across our galaxy; the Ancients themselves believed their new empire would "surely know no boundaries".
2.  To the GTA and PVE during the T-V War, a period of time during which subspace travel would have undoubtedly been heightened, and only 22 years after Terrans discovered subspace itself.
3.  To the GTVA in Gamma Draconis, following Bosch's activation of the first Knossos portal... a device that literally warps and twists the subspace fabric in order to form new jump nodes.

I feel it important to mention that I do not believe that subspace travel in itself was enough to attract the Shivans' attention.  If that was the case, the Shivans probably would have appeared long before the Ancients had cause to build Knossos portals to expand their control of the galaxy, or would not have waited over two decades to come in search of the Terrans and Vasudans (it is reasonable to assume, though by no means certain, that Vasudans discovered subspace travel at roughly the same time as Terrans).  During these periods mentioned, heavy subspace traffic would have caused more extensive damage to subspace, coaxing the Shivans out of the ether to perform their roles as "galactic antibodies".  The destruction of the Ancients over 8,000 years ago is the earliest Shivan intervention of which we are aware, but there is no telling how many subspace-faring civilizations the Destroyers wiped out prior to that time.

Yet we must also be careful not to characterize the Shivans exclusively as little more than what the galaxy uses to rid itself of an ailment.  The human immune sytem of white blood cells can be broken down into roughly half a dozen divisions (T-cells, NK cells, and so on), but the Shivans possess a wide array of fighters and bombers, to say nothing of their capital vessels,  and the Shivan pilots themselves.  As Dr. Mina Hargrove said, the Shivans display "considerable diversity as a species".  Therefore, I believe we should view the Shivans as just that: a species, something more than a natural reaction on behalf of the cosmos.  We must also remember that the Shivans are capable of developing strategy, able to set traps (as in "Pandora's Box"), indicating that they are not driven by a lone impulse to kill and destroy.  They are, on some level, thinking creatures, with as much at stake in their conflict with the GTVA as anyone else.  If the fabric of space/time is torn asunder, then the Shivans will surely die along with everyone else.

The "immune system" depiction is not without flaw.  Such a theory would suggest that the Shivans are spawned from subspace in overwhelming numbers, in the same manner as immune cells are within the body.  While there can be no argument that the Shivans are numerous, their legions cannot be infinite; this would stack the odds in such a way as to automatically doom both Terrans and Vasudans to extinction.  So colossally unfair an advantage would be against the trend of balance in nature--not to mention the programmers at Volition, who would probably want to make a gamer feel somewhat less-worthless than this.

It stands to reason, then, that the Shivans' numbers are finite, giving credence to the idea that they must originate from a "home base" of one sort or another.  We will discuss that notion in-depth later in the essay.

Above all, we are called to recognize that this theory illustrates the true meaning of the Shivans' roles as the "Great Preservers", not only of single, as-of-yet undeveloped races, but of the entire universe.  It is supremely ironic that they have been perceived as merciless Destroyers for so long, when in reality, they have been striving to save us all.

c.  The Shivans make subspace jumps, too.  Doesn't that defeat their own purpose?

Not necessarily.  As schooled as they are in the workings of subspace, the Shivans are probably capable of designing engines for their craft which avoid causing damage to the subspace dimension.  We know for a fact that their engines are able to traverse unstable jump nodes that Terran/Vasudan engines can not.  If this is not the case, then the Shivans are likely to view subspace travel as a "necessary evil", in their case; inflicting moderate damage upon the subspace fabric for the sake of preserving subspace as a whole.  In fact, as well-versed in matters of subspace as the Shivans are, they may very well be able to effect repairs to the subspace fabric, provided they don't have to deal with mounting damage resulting from node travel.

d.  By using nodes too unstable for travel by the Alliance, aren't the Shivans causing needless subspace damage?

Consider this:

1. If the Shivans do possess highly-advanced subspace technology, we hypothesize that their use of subspace nodes causes little or no damage, whether the Alliance has knowledge of those nodes or not.
2. If the above statement is half-true or not true at all (i.e., the Shivans can use unstable nodes, but still cause subspace damage nonetheless), then their use of "secret" nodes is, in fact, relevant in terms of strategy. We've stated several times that the Shivans aren't dumb; if it were absolutely necessary for them to make use of subspace travel for the sake of waging war, then they would do so. However, they would seek to do so in the most efficient way possible, a way which would quickly end the conflict at hand, and minimize the damage sustained by the subspace dimension. We should also factor in the reasonable assumption that the Shivans will want to minimize the losses to their own forces.

In FS1, for example, the Shivan armada levels Tombaugh Station in the Ribos system while gathering their forces there for a strike upon Vasuda Prime. In response, the GTA sets up a blockade in the adjacent Antares system, which is the only "stable" route to reach Vasuda. To reduce the hassle to themselves, the Shivans jump through a "hidden" node directly to Deneb, which is also one jump away from Vasuda. This allows the Shivans to circumvent the Allied blockade and destroy Vasuda Prime more quickly, hence shortening the duration of the war itself. Admiral Petrarch also clearly states that the Shivans made inter-system jumps without the use of recognized jump nodes during the Great War, so the question is not if the Shivans make such jumps, but why.

e.  If heightened subspace activity attracts Shivans, then wouldn't they have investigated the collapse of the Delta Serpentis-Sol jump node, or the outbreak of the NTF rebellion?

We know that subspace nodes, as a natural phenomenon, form and collapse of their own accord.  The Shivans, being unable to communicate with the Lucifer (for reasons I will explain), probably would have regarded the collapse of the Sol node with indifference, regarding it as a natural collapse--or, at most, a direct result of the Shivan attack against the Alliance.  The reduced subspace traffic following the destruction of the node--due to the great depletion of Allied forces--would have been an indication to the Shivans that their enemies had been destroyed, and that no further investigation was necessary.

To the best of our knowledge, the NTF rebellion had been in progress for a mere eighteen months prior to the arrival of the Shivans.  This figure pales in comparison to the Ancients' decades of rampant expansion, or the fourteen years of the Terran-Vasudan War.  The activation of the Knossos involved subspace disruption on a larger scale, and would have merited the Shivans' more immediate attention.

f.  Immune systems have a limited amount of defensive cells.  These numbers can be depleted, or even eliminated.  Wouldn't that make Shivan forces finite, meaning that particular explanation is valid?

While it is true that the immune system within a body works within a set scope of numbers, it is important to remember the scale on which we are speaking.  When a human body's immune system is depleted, the body either fights off an infection and regenerates its numbers, or succumbs to the infection and dies.  Since the "body" the Shivans would be protecting would be all of subspace, we are left with two possibilities:

1.  Deplete Shivan numbers, only to have them replenished because subspace still exists--a theory we regard as improbable, because this would make Shivan forces infinite, or
2.  Eradicate Shivans by destroying subspace completely--and, by proxy, destroying the entire physical universe, something we'd like to avoid.

For these reasons, the Shivans must have some base of operations from which their forces originate.  More on this later.

g.  If the Shivans are attracted by the subspace-warping effects of the Knossos devices, then why don't they destroy them?  Don't Shivans themselves use the portals?

The Shivans do not "use" Knossos portals, per se. The portals exist in Shivan-controlled areas, but so far as we know, the Shivans do not know for certain how to activate them, or precisely what they are used for. It was Admiral Bosch who drew the Shivans' ire with his activation of the first Knossos; we cannot know for certain if the Shivans, on their side of the node, were even aware of its existence. In their monologues, the Ancients state that the Destroyers did not seek "territory, technology, or resources". The Shivans appear to concern themselves primarily with their own technological advancement (if they advance--see earlier comments on stagnation), and in all likelihood, they are more interested in the jump node created by the Knossos portal than in the workings of the device itself. This, however, is an uncertain point; much of our theory centers around the Shivans having a great deal of subspace expertise, so it is logical to assume that they would know a device capable of manipulating subspace when they saw one.

We do not know for certain if the Shivans are even capable of destroying the portals. The briefing for "A Flaming Sword" states that the Alliance chooses to destroy the first device via Meson bomb deployment as opposed to main gun barrage for "strategic and scientific reasons". This presents us with three possibilities:

1. The material of which the Knossos is made will react in a strange manner when directly exposed to beam energy. We can only guess as to what this reaction might be, or why it would even matter, since the Alliance's goal is to destroy the portal anyway.
2. The portal is either partially or totally resistant to beam energy, making Meson bombs a more efficient method of its destruction.
3. Beam cannons can damage the device, but Allied scientists would rather use the opportunity to test the Meson bombs.

The player and various other vessels can fire on the Knossos in-game with no visible effect. We know for a fact that the portal is a sturdy structure, simply because the detonation of the first Meson bomb--despite wiping out all small craft within some three kilometers--caused no apparent damage. Whether or not the Knossos could withstand assault by a Sathanas is another question entirely, but since the largest Shivan vessels to enter Gamma Draconis prior to the destruction of the portal were of cruiser-class, then the point becomes moot.  We can assume that the Shivans could probably destroy the portals by detonating nearby stars, but would they really go to all that trouble when it would be easier to eliminate traffic through the node?

h.  Isn't it inaccurate to call the Shivans "Preservers" when they are so bent upon destruction?

The title of "The Preservers" is truly an ironic one to apply to the Shivans. In Freespace's final monologue, the narrator--presumably the pilot you've been playing--pretty clearly illustrates the meaning of this phrase. Here is the actual wording from the Freespace Reference Bible:

"I know why the Ancient Ones were destroyed. And I know what they knew.
I know that if not for the Shivans they would have been conquered long before.
Without the Shivans, someone would have discovered them long before, in their infancy. And destroyed them, just as surely as they destroyed countless billions of others.
I believe it is only the destroyers who are destroyed. The Shivans are the great destroyers, but they are also the great preservers. That is why there was no one to destroy us.
Long had we been the destroyer. Our turn had nearly come.
In the Vasudan war we learned how to adapt.
We learned how to study our enemy.
We learned how to overcome.
We learned how to survive.
And so we did."

The narrator explains, in simple terms, that the Shivans exterminate older, advanced races to ensure the survival of younger, undeveloped ones. The predecessors to the Ancients, whoever they were, were destroyed by the Shivans so that the Ancients might thrive; the Ancients, in turn, were themselves destroyed so that humanity, and presumably Vasudans (although there is evidence that the Vasudans themselves may in fact be descendants of the scattered Ancient population) could survive. As the narrator mentions, humanity--having assumed its own mantle as conqueror of the cosmos, rampantly colonizing, exploring, and waging war upon the Vasudans--had nearly reached the time of its own destruction.

Is it the fate of all space-faring races to be annihilated once they stumble upon the secrets of subspace travel?  In one of the few uplifting points of the entire Manifesto, I can say with some confidence that the answer to this question is "no".

In one of his own monologues, Admiral Bosch provides us with the following question to ponder:

"Thirty-two years ago in the Altair system, Vasudan scientists discovered the remnants of an extinct civilisation we now call the Ancients. Here, we found the secret to defeat the Shivans. How close did we come to being a footnote in the history of a future species that would happen upon our ruins ten thousand years from now? Would they indulge in the fiction of their own immortality until the Shivans came for them, and how long had this gone on?
Did the Ancients stumble upon the monoliths and the tombs of their predecessors in this distant corner of space, dismissing the warnings carved into the walls of the sepulchre? And when the Destroyers came at last, what did the Ancients think as they sifted the cremation of dust and bones, staring into the mute remains for a key, some solution to their plight?
What if there had been countless races, stretching back into infinity, and like the nine cities of Troy, each civilization had been built on the rubble of the one that came before, each annihilated by the Shivans?"

Bosch suspects that the cycle of destruction perpetuated by the Shivans has continued for a very long time--longer, perhaps, than any of us can estimate. If the Ancients did indeed uncover ruins of the races that came before them, ruins providing some clue or hint as to how the wrath of the Destroyers might be stayed, then that warning was either ignored, or understood too late for it to have any meaning. The Ancients fell just as the innumerable races that came before them did, their empire turning to ash.

In the case of the Alliance, however, something has changed.

At the end of the First Great War, the Shivans failed to complete their objective of xenocide--quite possibly the first time they had ever failed to accomplish their monstrous task. Unlike the Ancients before them, the Terrans and Vasudans were able to heed the age-old cautions they discovered, able to learn from them, able to adapt them for their races' own purposes. As the narrator of the final FS1 monologue so eloquently states, the Terrans learned how to study their enemy, how to adapt, and how to survive. Thus, the cycle of wanton destruction that has continued without end for countless millennia has at last been broken. The GTVA is not simple prey, like the other fallen empires, but a sophisticated enemy, one the Shivans will require more than brute force to extinguish from the universe.

In a fashion, this in itself may be the answer to the question of the "Great Preservers". Perhaps the rise of the Alliance, a force that, like the Shivans themselves, "did not die", is something the Shivans--maybe without realizing it--have been fostering for centuries. It was inevitable that eventually, there would come a race that would learn from the mistakes of those that came before, one that would not so easily knuckle under to the Destroyers. Unlike the dead and buried societies of the past, the GTVA has potential, potential to learn and adapt, potential to discover a final, permanent solution to the conflict with which they are faced. It is possible that, in the distant future, Terrans and Vasudans may stumble upon a means of travel superior even to that of the subspace corridor, allowing them to maintain their integrity as a society without incurring the hateful, desperate rage of the Shivans.

The question which this poses, however--one we are, at this time, unable to answer--is whether one or both sides of the Great War will perish in the hellfire of battle before that time should arrive.

III.  Capella

The destruction of the Capella star at the hands of the Shivans has long puzzled Freespace players.  It is an enigma with which we are provided very little evidence to examine--only the final cutscenes of the game, and the last few missions leading up to them.  In this section, we will submit a theory as to why the Shivans took it upon themselves to kill a sun.


As we are told in the endgame of Freespace 2, an imposing fleet of 80+ Sathanas-class Shivan juggernauts gather in formation around the Capella star, generating a subspace field that grows in intensity over the course of 72 hours.  During the final phase of Capella's evacuation, the star itself abruptly supernovas, destroying all the planets in the system, as well as the remaining Terran, Vasudan, and Shivan craft.

Our first clue as to the purpose behind this mind-boggling act of devastation comes from Admiral Petrarch in the course of his endgame monologue.  It is presented here in its entirety.

"To the officers and crew of the GTD Aquitaine. We have halted the Shivan advance. The battle of Capella is over. We sealed off the system and our people are safe, maybe forever. No one can fathom how or why the Shivans destroyed the Capella star. Though we know our enemy better now than we did 32 years ago, their motives remain a mystery. Perhaps they are exiles like we are, nomads wandering the universe, searching for a way back home. The explosion of a star might be a bridge between this universe and their own. As the old poet once said, 'There are more things in Heaven and Earth than are dreamt of in your philosophy.'
From our odyssey into Hell we have returned with a gift: the Ancient technology to build a portal between Delta Serpentis and Sol. To restore the link to our blue planet. To return home after all these years.
This is Admiral Petrach, signing off."

At first, Petrarch's words seem like little more than simple rhetoric.  The war has just ended, after all, and now is undoubtedly the time for speeches of victory and remembrance.  The tone of Petrarch's monologue is strange, however; it almost seems to lament the plight of the Shivans, rather than condemn or gloat over them.  It is very odd for the Admiral to feel sympathy for the Shivans when one considers the damage they caused during their relatively short-lived incursion into GTVA space.  When observing the speech from this standpoint, we are left to wonder if perhaps there is a hint of literal truth in Petrarch's words... if perhaps the Shivans really were attempting to return to whatever they call home.

For a moment, let us look at the situation from the strategic point of view.  The Shivans have amassed a juggernaut armada in-system, and are poised to launch a full-scale strike upon Allied space, a spearhead which the fatigued GTVA is not likely to survive.  Yet, instead of invading Allied territory, the Shivans choose instead to destroy the star, killing the mere handful of refugees in the system at the time, and losing several juggernauts in the process, perhaps a substantial portion of their fleet (though an accurate figure is impossible to determine, since we are provided with only one camera angle in the cutscene to observe).  In addition, those juggernauts that are not destroyed enter subspace, but to the best of our knowledge, there are no inter-system nodes other than those leading to Vega and Epsilon Pegasi.  The juggernauts could not make an in-system jump without being caught by the supernova blast, so just what was their destination?

We must ask: what practical purpose did the destruction of Capella serve?

b.  "Whatever those things were, the Shivans have got less of them now."

For the answer, we look not to Capella itself, but to the SOC reconaissance mission into Shivan space conducted a few days prior.  During that sortie, SOC forces destroyed three strange-looking Shivan devices composed of a large red crystal and exterior "blades".  The shock wave created by these devices was unusually large for objects of their size ("In the Lion's Den").  In the FS database, these objects are referred to as "Comm Nodes", suggesting that they serve as relay stations for the quantum pulses used in Shivan communication.  When observed up-close, the objects can be heard emitting the same "buzz" Allied fighters heard when they received transmissions from the cruiser Rephaim.

At the time of the SOC mission, only nine juggernauts had jumped into the unidentified binary system.  Days later, when the armada gathered around Capella, that number had increased ninefold.  This, of course, could be mere coincidence, but it could also be an indication that the objects destroyed by the SOC had more value than mere radio relay stations.

If the Shivans are indeed subspace-born creatures, then they would find normal space a much different place from their natural environment.  This much can be gathered from the bodies they construct to harness their essences, if we accept the other points in this treatise as being true.  It is quite possible that Shivan shielding systems were originally developed not for combat deployment, but as a way to allow them to retain their coherence in our material universe.

Perhaps, then, the Shivan Comm Nodes are much more than just that.  They may very well be like lifelines, of a sort, providing the Shivans--far separated from their subspace domain--with the inherent subspace energy they need to survive in normal space.  I believe the crystals in these devices, due to their highly volatile nature, to be some kind of subspace battery, a shell for pure subspace energy to inhabit.  On a larger scale, I believe this crystalline substance to be the base component in all Shivan construction, crafted in their own subspace dimension, but then heavily modified via electronics in order to function properly in standard space.  The distinct red hue of all Shivan craft suggests this crystal--or some like material--is an integral component; even their weaponry and engines seem based around the same substance, suggesting its extreme importance to their functionality.

If true, it would mean that the SOC destroyed something far more vital than simple communications equipment.  It would mean they destroyed installations absolutely vital to the Shivans' continued existence, and quite possibly killing an untold number of them by suddenly and abruptly severing their life support.

c. Apocalypse

This would serve to explain the sudden increase in the numbers of the juggernaut fleet, but it still does not give us the answer as to why the Shivans destroyed Capella instead of attacking the GTVA directly.

To understand the solution, we must observe the problem from the Shivan standpoint.  Throughout their incursion, the Shivans gained very little ground against the GTVA.  The furthest-encroaching Shivan vessel was the original Sathanas, and it was destroyed in Capella--merely one jump from Gamma Draconis--by the GTVA Colossus.  It is likely that the Shivans, in all their destructive fury, had never previously lost a vessel of that magnitude to an enemy.  Since they were never able to advance any further than Capella (with the exception of a Shivan force that attacked the Vega-Capella node in the endgame), the Shivans could not know for certain just how many Colossus-class vessels the GTVA had in their ranks.  For all they knew, a fleet of the mammoth vessels could have been waiting deep within GTVA territory, waiting to spring a trap on the advancing Shivan fleet.  Faced with such uncertain opposition, the Shivans took the only course of action open to them:

They ran away.  The Shivans were not attacking the GTVA, but retreating from it.

The FS database tells us that subspace jumps require the presence of intense gravitational fields.  If we look closely at the Capella supernova cutscene, we can see a strange black "aura" surrounding the star after the juggernauts release their subspace charges.  This odd field extends for a wide area around the sun, blocking out the glimmer of stars behind it... and it is into this area of darkness that the escaping juggernauts jump.  This darkness cannot be a black hole, for if it were, we would not be able to see the light emanating from Capella itself.  Therefore, this ebony field must be the outer rim of a tremendously large jump node, one the juggernauts have opened using the gravity field of the star as a springboard (this theory is strengthened, albeit not much, by the fact that Capella turns green in hue.  Yellow star + blue subspace node = green :D).  Their destination within subspace, wherever it is, requires an exceptionally strong gravitational field in order to make the subspace jump, one that can only be provided by the force of a star.

Unfortunately for us, the Shivans' methodology has a disastrous side-effect.  A stellar supernova is triggered when a star of substantial size runs out of light elements to burn; when this happens, the heavier elements are condensed into iron, which the star cannot use for fuel.  Unable to "explode" outward any longer, the star collapses inward, crushing the iron core so tightly that its subatomic structure changes.  In less than a second, the iron core shrinks to a neutron core, which is in turn crushed by the star's outer layers as they too collapse.  The core heats up to a few billion degrees, and explodes in a supernova.  Mind you, this takes place naturally over the course of several billion years; when the Shivans disrupt the process with a few minutes of subspace tinkering, their gravimetric distortions causing Capella's core to fuse before the sun has even finished depleting its remaining elements, then a supernova is the inevitable outcome.

d.  Couldn't the juggernauts have been using inter-system jump nodes near the Capella star that the Alliance didn't know about?

I had always visualized system-to-system nodes as lying along the "edges" of any given star system, not smack in the middle. It seems unlikely that each juggernaut was jumping through a separate node--this would indicate that a large number of such nodes were bunched very closely together, something we have never seen--meaning that if such a jump point existed, it would be one very large node. In all the time that the GTVA has been studying subspace, we have never heard anything to suggest that "supernodes" exist in close proximity to stars. Therefore, I feel my theory that the Sathanas fleet creates its own node is more credible, in this respect.

Carefully observe the "End Game" FS2 cutscene. You will see that some juggernauts continue to activate their subspace "charges" while the other ships depart, even after the Capella star has already turned green--and, we assume, already been affected by whatever the armada did to it. When the main body of the fleet has departed, the charges on the ships left behind dissipate entirely, and the juggernauts themselves "go dark", their characteristically red glows fading to simple black.

Why do the stranded juggernauts power down? Do they know it is futile to try and attempt the explosion of Capella, and therefore make no effort to do so? Have the Shivans on-board these ships somehow been evacuated to those that escaped by means of a teleportation technology? We have seen no evidence of such capability on behalf of the Shivans (in fact, the Freespace Reference Bible provides a graphic description of Shivans physically leaping from ship-to-ship in the course of a battle), so this seems unlikely. Therefore, what conclusion are we to reach?

It is my own belief that the "marooned" juggernauts were using the full extent of their energies to sustain the artificial jump node while the other craft in the Shivan fleet made their escape. If we accept, for the moment, that the juggernauts are "alive" as some evidence suggests, then we could interpret the dimming of their surface lights as a form of "death". We know for certain that their subspace charges took some time to energize--at least three full days--and that by the same token, they were likely to be very intense. Left with no remaining energy, the Sathani--dead or dying--could only drift, derelicts in space, waiting for the supernova to overtake them. It sounds cliche, to be sure, but the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

e.  If the Shivans needed a star, why didn't they use Gamma Draconis, the star seen through the nebular clouds, or the binary stars in the system with the Comm Nodes?

FS briefings tell us that Gamma Draconis is a remote system lacking in either planets or viable resources.  Having no planets at all suggests that the Gamma Draconis star is probably small, and lacked the gravitational field necessary to pull together matter to create planets during its initial formation.  Such a field would have been too weak for the Shivans to adapt to their own purposes.  Similarly, the star seen in the Shivan nebula--a nebula which is, as Admiral Bosch tells us, the remnants of whatever star had lived and died there previously--must have been young and/or small, or it would have already consumed the nebular gases themselves.  Lastly, the gravitational fields created by two stars feeding off one another are likely to be unpredictable, and thus unsuited for the Shivans' needs.

f.  But in Real Life, Gamma Draconis is a huge star.  Surely it would be big enough for the Shivans to use.

This is an excellent point, one I am hesistant to even address. As much as I hate to shun reliable sources, I am afraid we must be forced to ignore some real-life astronomical statistics when dealing with the Freespace universe.

The folks at Volition are, by profession, game designers--and damn good ones at that, or I wouldn't have poured so much time into Freespace as I have. So far as we know, none of them are physicists who have any more basic knowledge of astronomy than you, me, or anyone we would meet on the street. I remember reading in an interview that an author was hired to create the main plotline for FS2, and we can safely assume that he, too, was just another average guy looking to get his paycheck. I find it very likely that rather than pick and choose star names to assign to various systems in accordance with their specific needs--a process that would have taken a tremendous amount of time--the Volition staffers simply randomly chose the names of popular stars, or stars that they happened to be fond of.

This supposition is not without some supporting evidence. Take Capella, as it is depicted in FS2: a system with one star, densely-populated, a center of industry, and the headquarters of the GTVA's 3rd Fleet. This would lead us to assume that either the planets in this system are suitable for habitation, or that the system itself is legion with installations fit for both residential and mining/production purposes.

In reality, Capella is a rather inhospitable place to be. The system itself contains at least ten stars, including the G-type giants Capella A and Capella B, which are generally those most-associated with the system. We never see any of these sister suns in FS2.  Capella A and B are large stars, and have a narrow orbit around one another (about the distance from Earth to Venus), and the potential for a stable planetary orbit around either star is small.  Even if planets were orbiting around Capella, those worlds would be severely irradiated by both stars, and would also be tidally locked, meaning that the same side of the planet would always face the sun (in the same way as the same side of the Moon always faces the Earth--hence, the "dark side of the Moon" is the side we never see).  This eliminates the potential for planet-based life as we know it, leaving us to rely upon life existing upon heavily-trafficked space stations... something I view as being more than a little difficult with almost a dozen stars crowding the immediate vicinity.

The point I'm making is that for the purposes of our discussion, we should try to regard astronomical details as they are presented within Freespace itself, without turning to outside sources.  I don't fault Volition in the least for randomly naming their star systems; it's a time-saving measure, and some games, like the Master of Orion series, provide random names to every star in the galaxy (with the exception of the homeworld, which has a pre-set name determined by species, a value the player can change) as selected from a set list of some 300 stars. It may not be the most realistic approach to take, but then again, the designers of these games hardly expect the vast majority of their fans to look into the titles with as much depth as we have.

g.  Why would the Shivans worry about a Colossus fleet?  Wouldn't they already know about Allied fleet strength from experience during the Great War?

This is not feasible for two reasons.  The first is the theory that Shivan forces in normal space cannot communicate with forces residing at their subspace "home", but we will discuss this idea in a later section.  The second, simpler reason is the simple fact that unlike the Shivans, Terran and Vasudan fleets actually make progress.  So far as anyone knows, the Shivan species has remained essentially the same--if not stagnant--for the last eight thousand years, using the same kind of weaponry (as per the discoveries of the Vasudan scientists in Altair), and presumably, the same kinds of spacecraft. While there are notable additions to the Shivan fleet between the First and Second Great Wars, such as the Mara, the Astaroth, the Moloch, and the Ravana, just to name a few, there are also numerous "older" craft, such as the Basilisk, the Manticore, the Nephilim, the Seraphim, and several capital ships. The folks over in the Inferno camp would even have us believe that the Scorpion is still in use.  In contrast, the GTVA is nearing completion of its switchover from the old "Great War relics", opting to incorporate faster, more capable, more destructive war machines.

Humanity's potential for adaptation should not be underestimated. We went from having no existing space program to landing on the moon in less than twenty years. In "The Great Hunt" (FS2), you'll even hear one of your wingmen muse about what a "miracle" it was the Alliance won the Great War, due to the lack of present-day technological advantages: shields (a slight continuity error, as Terrans and Vasudans only lacked energy shielding for a relatively short portion of the Great War, before using them throughout the remainder of the conflict), flak guns, and beam cannons.

h.  You're full of it, buddy.  The Shivans would never back down from a fight.

This is an understandable sentiment, but one disproven by the facts.  Consider the following:

Firstly, if we accept that the Shivans operate with a hive mentality (something we will accept as true for the purposes of the essay), then we need not necessarily conclude that their reaction at Capella was one of "fear", per se. It would be in error to confuse the notion of "fear" with that of "self-preservation".

If there is any dominant principle in the animal kingdom, it is to stay alive. This is commonly observed in the "fight or flight" principle, which even humans possess; we either confront an enemy, or run away so that we might live to fight another day. This principle is more complex when applied to a hive society, as generally, there are no individuals; all drones or workers strive for the good of the colony, and may very well be willing to sacrifice their own lives for the sake of that goal. However, this should not lead us to conclude that mass suicide is acceptable by default; if all the drones in a hive society are killed, who will be left to support the hive itself? In Robert Heinlein's classic Starship Troopers, a group of the grotesque "Bugs" (also called Arachnids, the book's main "bad guys") have surrounded a space marine who is shielding himself behind a bulbous "brain bug" which serves as the controlling influence for the hive's workers. The "warrior" Bugs screech in protest and frustration, unable to attack the hiding marine; if they do, they risk killing the brain bug itself, destroying the hive hierarchy and silencing the source of their own commands. In effect, the Bugs would be comitting suicide.

For that reason, you Shivan fans out there should not think of the Shivans as being "afraid" of the GTVA. Rather, you should think of them as regrouping and marshalling their forces instead of risking complete decimation at the hands of a Colossus fleet. They are merely exercising good judgment in the face of the unknown. To paraphrase Heinlein himself, any race that possesses enough skill to construct spacecraft is not stupid.

Although the Shivans themselves are not the sort to often make retreat, they have done so on more than one occasion, when the situation calls for it. In "First Strike", the Shivan cruiser Taranis--low on supplies--attempts to retreat through the Beta Cygni jump node. Shivan cruiser group "Hellfire" tries to rejoin the primary Shivan fleet in Delta Serpentis, rather than lingering to do battle with the attacking GTA fighters, in a show of simple strategy. Even the Demon-class destroyer Beleth gives priority to making the jump to Capella instead of powering down its engines to combat the Vasudan corvette Thebes and the player's remaining bomber wings. This is either because the Beleth does not believe it can survive a bomber attack, or is more focused upon providing reinforcement to the Sathanas. In either case, the destroyer's first concern cannot be the engagement of the nearby GTVA forces, or it would not bother making such a run for the jump node. This is just one more indicator of the Shivan strategic mindset: self-preservation and accomplishing orders take priority over enaging every target of opportunity. This is further evidenced with the first Sathanas, which breezes through to Capella without remaining to mop up the surviving bombers, and by the juggernaut fleet itself, which proceeds on course straight to the Capella star without engaging nearby GTVA warships.

But then, why do the Shivans throw swarms of fighters and bombers at the Alliance with such apparent abandon? The simple answer is that this in itself is not a bad strategy; overwhelming numbers have determined the outcome of many a battle in the course of history. However, we should also take note of the benefits vs. costs standpoint. In the briefing preceding "Their Finest Hour", Admiral Petrarch informs us that the GTVA has suffered over one hundred thousand casualties, a figure which probably includes all military craft and civilian transports. Given the Shivans' military superiority, we will arbitrarily assign them one-tenth the casualties at a figure of 10,000 in terms of fighters and bombers for the purposes of this discussion. This figure in itself is admittedly optimistic, for not every pilot in the GTVA can be a Triple Ace and mop up some 400 Shivans over the course of his or her career. If we include all capital ship classes ranging from crusiers and up, we can probably double this number to 20,000, perhaps 25,000; if we assume the Sathanas has at least the same crew capacity as the Colossus (the actual figure is probably smaller, for we can assume the Shivans are more efficient in terms of space than either Terrans or Vasudans, and are able to operate their ships with smaller crews), then the number balloons to around 50,000 or 60,000.

If we accept a static figure of 30,000 for a Sathanas crew (acknowledging our uncertainty), and multiply that number by 85 (as we are told there are "more than eighty" juggernauts, but apparently less than ninety), and add this product to our previous figure of 60,000, we are left with a rough estimate of what the Shivans would view as their potential losses in a full-blown shootout with the GTVA: a staggering 2.6 million Shivans, more than twenty times the casualties of the GTVA, even when taking into account the destruction of the Colossus. This is a considerably larger investment than the dozens of "throwaway" Shivans in any given fighter or bomber squadron. Faced with such tremendous losses to their active forces, it is not difficult to imagine why the Shivans would choose to make a strategic retreat.

As for the notion of the theoretical "Colossus fleet" itself, remember that GTVA space is pretty big; not large, perhaps in a galactic sense, but still consisting of some 23 star systems, excluding Sol and Capella. If the GTVA did possess a Colossus armada, it would make sense for them to evenly distribute these vessels throughout their borders, rather than lumping them all together in one particular system. As anyone will tell you, capital ships are relatively slow-moving; even the vaunted Sathanas only has a top speed of 25m/s, with the Colossus matching this velocity. If a Colossus were stationed on the fringes of GTVA territory, in Alphard or even Altair, it would take quite a while to make the complex system of subspace jumps needed to reach Vega. You can rest assured that the Shivans weren't able to round up their own armada in a matter of hours, either. Being intelligent creatures, they would have known a small window of time existed for them to act before the GTVA would have been fully prepared for a confrontation. With this in mind, discretion was "the better part of valor", so to speak, permitting the Shivans to retreat and lick their wounds.

Think of the matter in this fashion.  The massing of the juggernaut fleet to destroy Capella must have one of two purposes: either as an offensive or defensive action.  If we assume that the Shivans are efficient creatures, then the first option stands upon
« Last Edit: March 20, 2004, 07:40:15 pm by 1461 »
We have returned to continue our purification of this galaxy. It is again your turn to be crushed beneath the great force that is the Antaran army. All your petty squabbling with the other beings in this galaxy is meaningless. The Antaran fleet will destroy you all, one by one. You may not surrender. You cannot win. Your only option is death.


Offline Taristin

  • Snipes
  • 213
  • BlueScalie
    • Skelkwank Shipyards
Well, let me be the first to say:


I forgot the warmup procedure, but who cares? :p

Also let me be the first to put off reading this for a day or two, and wait for other people to quote and paraphrase it for me. :D
Freelance Modeler | Amateur Artist


Offline Unknown Target

  • Get off my lawn!
  • Global Moderator
  • 212
  • Push.Pull?

oh, and



Offline Falcon

  • 29
Then I'm the first one to read it then?

Awsome job!
[as stated with the facial looks]


Offline Taristin

  • Snipes
  • 213
  • BlueScalie
    • Skelkwank Shipyards
I read the first and last paragraph...
Freelance Modeler | Amateur Artist


Offline Falcon

  • 29
That doesn't count you read the middle too. :D
Though it takes a long time. [starts to fall asleep]


Offline Knight Templar

  • Stealth
  • 212
  • I'm a magic man, I've got magic hands.
bah, it's only a 10 minute read guys...

And that said, I like a lot of your ideas/observations. A few things seem a bit strange though, like the Shivans running from the GTVA. I think I missed your exact reasoning on that, but I doubt the Shivans would guess that there were more Colossus's or run away from them.

Other than that. :yes:
Copyright ©1976, 2003, KT Enterprises. All rights reserved

"I don't want to get laid right now. I want to get drunk."- Mars

Too Long, Didn't Read


Offline Sybiene

  • 21
All of you guys are going to make me look bad.

I spent like two hours poking holes in this thing on ICQ before Antares submitted it. I'll lose face if you agree with it too much. :p

Possibly because this is my least favorite of the three or so theories that he's come up with in the last year :doubt:. I think I want the engineered weapon-Shivans back.

Any reasoning, intelligent race would probably figure out that it's easier and cheaper to just give a civilization the tech needed to not damage subspace. (Which the jump-happy Shivans must have) Of course, we don't see the Shivans doing that. We have the psychotic and xenocidal deathbugs that we all know and love.

Death and destruction is the order of the day with them. I doubt antibody-Shivans would have saving subspace as their secondary goal, behind killing everything. Not to mention they use Knossos devices, instead of destroying them whenever they can, so nobody else can get their grubby hands on 'em.

Shivans being a little worried about Colossus(i) fleets is possible, if unlikely. In FS2, the little game of tug-of-war in Capella, Gamma Draconis and the Nebula was going back and forth for a while. And who's to say they knew that the GTVA didn't totally smash the Lucy fleet, but instead barely got by at the last second. The Shivans might actually have thought they had a closely-matched enemy. Problem is that Shivans aren't exactly the cautious type.

Have got to get Antares something though, he got me out of my extended lurk-mode on this forum.


Offline Bobboau

  • Just a MODern kinda guy
    Just MODerately cool
    And MODest too
  • 213
overall a nice theory, you didn't fall into any of the clasic clices, though I don't particularly like the shivans origonating from subspace, as it isn't realy a place, and I'd prefer to keep it 'some other mysterios place', though for a game we would need a singular place to atack.
Bobboau, bringing you products that work... in theory
learn to use PCS
creator of the ProXimus Procedural Texture and Effect Generator
My latest build of PCS2, get it while it's hot!
PCS 2.0.3

Thou shalt not wear a garment of diverse sorts, [as] of woollen and linen together

To begin my explanation, I turn again to the Volition comment that the Shivans are merely a "symptom of a
bigger problem".

    While I find (and actually anticipated) your space-damaging theory interesting I don't entirely agree with your hypothesis in general. First of all, on the assumption that Volition chose their words carefully I would not equate "symptom" with the function of the immune system. I believe that as a symptom they are merely a sign that there is a bigger problem, they would not be the principle driving-force behind a cure. Does the bigger problem therefore equate to be a second, more-powerful race? I wouldn't necessarily agree with that either. One thing is that the problem is not necessarily something that can be defined through a specific overlapping occurence which affects everything. The bigger problem could be something as simple as a cycle, the problem of the mighty destroying the weak, the powerful and the advanced against the not-so-powerful and advanced.

     The thing is I don't buy the idea of the Shivans as the "Great Preservers" either. One does not preserve life through destroying it. If that is the way that they preserve order then does every species only have a finite amount of time in this universe? Once they become advanced enough to discover subspace they _must_ be destroyed? There's no indication of preservation on the part of the Shivans and all such information is based upon FS1 monologues which essentially say that the mighty have fallen, and little else.

Not necessarily. As schooled as they are in the workings of subspace, the Shivans are probably capable of
designing engines for their craft which avoid causing damage to the subspace dimension. We know for a fact that
their engines are able to traverse unstable jump nodes that Terran/Vasudan engines can not. If this is not the
case, then the Shivans are likely to view subspace travel as a "necessary evil", in their case; inflicting moderate
damage upon the subspace fabric for the sake of preserving subspace as a whole.

    I frankly don't buy this statement. To say that the Shivans have more advanced jump technology is perfectly believable and supported by each game, particularly Freespace1. However, if the Shivans are intent on not damaging subspace why would they then in effect open new wounds? Why use a node which their intended victims could not travel and therefore cause damage to subspace which said victims would not have normally caused? Strategic advantage? Given the overwhelming firepower demonstrated by the Shivans in even the hull of a single ship I find it unlikely that such an advantage is required.

In addition, those juggernauts that are not destroyed enter subspace, but to the best of our knowledge, there are no inter-system nodes other than those leading to Vega and Epsilon Pegasi. The juggernauts could not make an in-system jump without being caught by the supernova blast, so just what was their destination?

   Given the aforementioned advanced subspace jump technology I find it contradictory to assume that the Shivans were unable to make an inter-system subspace jump with their fleet. Just because the GTVA knows of no such node does not mean that the Shivans do not know as well.

At the time of the SOC mission, only nine juggernauts had jumped into the unidentified binary system. Days later,
when the armada gathered around Capella, that number had increased ninefold. This, of course, could be mere
coincidence, but it could also be an indication that the objects destroyed by the SOC had more value than mere radio relay stations.

    I saw no apparent correlation between the influx of additional Juggernauts and the destruction of the Comm Nodes. My impression gleamed from the mission "The Lion's Den" suggests to me that the Juggernaut fleet was quickly amassing. In the space of 15 minutes six juggernauts jump into the binary system. Lt. Snipes himself states something to the effect that 'at this rate, we'll have over a hundred juggernauts in a few hours'. I don't believe there is any basing for the idea of the destruction of the Comm Nodes further angering the Shivans.

Perhaps, then, the Shivan Comm Nodes are much more than just that. They may very well be like lifelines, of a
sort, providing the Shivans--far separated from their subspace domain--with the inherent subspace energy they need . . .

If true, it would mean that the SOC destroyed something far more vital than simple communications equipment. It
would mean they destroyed installations absolutely vital to the Shivans' continued existence, and quite possibly
killing an untold number of them by suddenly and abruptly severing their life support.

     The above statement seems to be pure speculation. Speculation to which I can find no basis. The Comm Node have no adverse affects on any known Shivan forces within or without of GTVA space. They do not slow the progress of the Juggernaut fleet. They do not deter the agressive, unrelenting advance of the Shivan armada as a whole. Give the correlation between the communication which took place amongst Admiral Bosch and the Shivans, and the transmissions detected from the Comm Node I believe that the device serves no other purpose than communication. If the device is vital to the lives of countless Shivans why would it not be better protected by fixed installations?

The binary system itself seemed to be little more than a transition point between adjacent systems, an inter-system junction if you will. Such a system would be an ideal place to co-ordinate and relay communications between the Shivan forces. Just as the system serves as a central hub in subspace to branch off to several destinations so would it too serve as a centre of a communication network.

To understand the solution, we must observe the problem from the Shivan standpoint. Throughout their incursion,
the Shivans gained very little ground against the GTVA. The furthest-encroaching Shivan vessel was the original
Sathanas, and it was destroyed in Capella--merely one jump from Gamma Draconis--by the GTVA Colossus. It is likely that the Shivans, in all their destructive fury, had never previously lost a vessel of that magnitude to an enemy. Since they were never able to advance any further than Capella (with the exception of a Shivan force that attacked the Vega-Capella node in the endgame), the Shivans could not know for certain just how many
Colossus-class vessels the GTVA had in their ranks. For all they knew, a fleet of the mammoth vessels could have  been waiting deep within GTVA territory, waiting to spring a trap on the advancing Shivan fleet. Faced with such  uncertain opposition, the Shivans took the only course of action open to them:

They ran away. The Shivans were not attacking the GTVA, but retreating from it.

    This statement is perhaps the most difficult to believe.
    First of all, assuming a competent level of intelligence within the Shivan forces one can also assume that they realise one does not run _towards_ an opponent in order to escape it. Whether or not the Shivans believed there was more than one Colossus is irrelevant, given their knowledge of subspace they would also realise that subspace nodes can be collapsed as in the case of the Lucifer. On the assumption that the Shivans do not know this fact, they would have been witness to it through the mission "Clash of the Titans". And if the Shivans did also assume that there was a Colossus fleet, it would be ludicrous to assume for the Shivans to assume that the GTVA would hold it outside of Capella rather than moving to engage. If anything the GTVA has shown itself to be overzealous, as evidenced to the Shivans through the GTVA's attempted conquest of the nebula and subsequent full retreat into Gamma Draconis and Capella.

Why the Shivans destroyed Capella is a question for which I do not have an answer. But the most obvious, simple and supported conclusion is resources. The Shivans were shown to harvest gases from in the nebula, and as the cutscene seems to indicate the creation of the second nebula one can assume that the Shivans will be harvesting those gases as well.

Specifics on Shivan construction have been a matter of some debate. There are those who despise the  suggestion that the Shivans might "grow" their vessels, but with a crystalline base material, it is the most likely conclusion. Specific subsystems such as sensors and weaponry are probably added later, after the initial crystal mold has fully matured. This lends credence to the idea that at least some Shivan craft are "alive", as evidenced
by the unusual dexterity shown by the juggernaut armada shortly before the destruction of Capella.

     I am one of those people who despises that premise and believe that it is little more than ideas influenced from such shows as Babylon 5 where ancient races like the Vorlons and Shadows posses living ships. The dextirity of the main Shivan arms can be equated to more advanced technology. One need to look only at our own artificial limbs which have evolved from a wooden pole attached at the knee to intricate and advanced constructs in which people can dance professionally. If the manipulation of the four arms is neccesary for the function the ship was performing then integrating technology to perform that motion would be perfectly understandable. Just as GTVA vessels use rotating parts on their Gas Miners, warships and AWACS vessels.

If Cocytus existed within a standard subspace corridor, then surely the Shivans would have preserved their juggernauts and simply used the correct node to return home instead of
making such a sacrifice and destroying an entire star. Therefore, it is likely that Cocytus exists in a place "set apart" from regular subspace, on a level that is more difficult to reach. If subspace is water in a large fish tank, then Cocytus is a bubble resting in the middle.

    Given the apparent lack of concern for their own lives as evidenced through the unrelenting attack of the Shivans I do not believe that the loss of a few Juggernauts and ships insystem would be considered a "sacrifice". I believe that the Shivans hold as much regard for their own lives as they do for those which they destroy, which is very little. Either that or the Shivans are so devoted to their cause that the loss of thousands of Shivans has little consequence on their species as a whole.

However, I do not believe the entire subspace theory makes sense. I do not see how you can equate the following points and continue to follow some pattern of logic:

-Subspace contains no matter, and therefore as subspace beings the Shivans are ancestrally pure energy.
-Somehow, the Shivans who would have no knowledge of matter have gained the knowledge of matter from interacting with our own universe (which isn't mentioned at all) and fashioned bodies for themselves in this existence.
-Shivans need Comm Nodes to help them survive in this existence as acting as subspace batteries ; even though subspace energy would assumably be gainable by simply entering subspace which would be far easier than relying on a destroyable, unprotected device in this dimension. And furthermore, that the Shivans cannot communicate through subspace into other systems yet these devices which hold subspace energy apparently sustain Shivan life in different systems? (as that system appeared to be a junction point rather than a home or even a staging area)
-The transition of matter in the form of space-faring vessels through subspace has a damaging effect on the fabric of subspace, and space as a whole. However the Shivans have decided to permanently add a central hub of matter to subspace and furthermore that this hub is accesible by the Shivans through theoretically destroying a star, an event which under current scientific understanding can result in the creation of a black hole? Which would also be a serious wound against space.

Firstly, we have established that Shivan activity is proportional to the amount of subspace activity produced by
a spacefaring race.

    There is no evidence supporting this point. Shivan activity is not proportional to subspace activity, the only supportable point is that Shivan activity is created (essentially) by subspace activity. Or that is to say, that a subspace-capable race will attract the fury of the Shivans. But it is _not_ to say that a race which uses subspace more will attract more Shivans. If anything given a lower population base the GTVA would produce less subspace activity during and before the second encounter, while at the same time the shivan attack force was exponentially larger.

Secondly, for reasons unknown, the Shivans do not seem capable of sending messages from normal space into
subspace. If they were able to do so, they most certainly would have called for reinforcements following the destruction of the Lucifer during the Great War, or would have sent for larger, more destructuve vessels as opposed to evacuating their armada of juggernauts.

This point assumes two things:
-that Shivan reinforcements were nearby to call upon during the Great War; which by the way also contradicts cannon text stating that the Lucifer invasion was a "scouting force".
-the Shivan Juggernauts were fleeing the GTVA, a point which I believe I've disproven. The Juggernauts were at best fleeing the explosion of a star, with good reason. One thing I failed to mention is the fact that if the Shivans were fleeing the GTVA, why did only the Juggernauts leave? Clearly the Shivans have more ships in their arsenal than Juggernauts yet we did not see any other class of vessel entering subspace during the explosion of the star.
-this point also assumes that Shivan Comm Nodes, are not infact Comm Nodes but something else and Volition is trying to mislead us. When in fact the Comm Node appeared to be located within a planet-less system which if inter-system communication was not possible would be a very odd place to put Comm Nodes. Furthermore, it also assumes that Shivans cannot communicate through the very dimension they originated from (as your theory states) while less-advanced races can. An assumption which I find in no way justifiable. And, for the conclusion:

2. The GTVA has had little success combining Shivan technology with their own systems. Upon the first capture
of a Shivan fighter in "Playing Judas", Terran technicians couldn't get the weapons or afterburners to work, and  the jump drive frequently malfunctioned.

   This point ignores the principle of Occam's Razor which states something to the effect of 'the most simple answer is often the correct one'. Or to translate, the GTA could not get the afterburners to work because they simply did not know how they worked. The technology is more advanced, consequently the GTA or GTVA understanding of said technology would be in some way limited. A factor, by the way, which seems to be decreasing from FS1 to FS2 where we move from a partly-function Shivan fighter to a near-fully functioning Shivan fighter in FS2 which is in many ways superior to its predecessor.

In conclusion, overall I found your hypothesis an interesting read but overall I find it flawed in many regards. Though the idea of damaging the fabric of space through subspace jumps (someone's been watching Star Trek:TNG I see??) is something worth hanging on to as a possible piece of the puzzle though not necessarily one that the Shivans are aware of (and therefore the principle motivating force behind their actions)
« Last Edit: October 13, 2003, 12:26:15 am by 1332 »


Offline Krackers87

  • 158 crew
  • 29
Wooaahhh... talk about a grand entrance...

Important info newcomer:

Exits are to the sides and rear. Personal flamethrowers are located beneath your seat in case of emergency or naughty disposition. If you run into any Shivans while crawling through the ductwork, it's probably just Carl. Give him your lunch, back away slowly, and you'll be fine.
Put this in your profile if you know someone who is fighting, has survived, or has died from an awp no scope.

just like seventies goofballs
he's waiting on last calls
well listen method man
'cause if you leave on the last line
don't leave on the ground kind
born just a little too slow


Offline Krackers87

  • 158 crew
  • 29
Perhaps from capella they could take a direct route to wherever they were going.

If other systems disrupt subspace travel then perhaps they could travel from capella to their destination without passing through any other systems.

I also beleive that the shivans originated from a planet but were somehow expelled into subspace away from their home. Living in subspace they adapted to the conditions around them essentialy losing all of their former characteristics.

The shivans probably consider subspace as their home now so when we travel through it we are now invaders of their territory explaning why they are so relentles on killing us. Everytime we use subspace we are invading them.
Put this in your profile if you know someone who is fighting, has survived, or has died from an awp no scope.

just like seventies goofballs
he's waiting on last calls
well listen method man
'cause if you leave on the last line
don't leave on the ground kind
born just a little too slow


Offline Kazan

  • PCS2 Wizard
  • 212
  • Soul lives in the Mountains
the jumps-damage-subspace is a blatant contradiction to canon - as set down by volition [somewhere] in FS2 'the more a node is used, the more stable it becomes'

(not exact quote, it's in there _somewhere_)

However on the Capella-sun-incident being a jump i'm very much in agreement, and on the possibility that the shivans "blinked" and were worried that perhaps we could blow away their sathanas fleet I believe that may be plausable.

The shivans were quite likely used to being virtually unopposed.  The loss of the lucifer fleet would have set them aback, not to mention how quickly we stole their shield technology

Then 32 years later we show up with beam weapons, and heavy anti-matter warheads, stealth fighters the shivans can hardly detect - and we have a ship larger than their juggernauts and we destroy one of their juggernauts after it barely enters our space.

The "Comm Nodes" could have been major installations of somepoint, and that our destroying them triggered the anger of the shivans - but their worry that we may have had more of the Colossus-class worships may have send them spinning - from the collective shock of losses they have never before expirienced they may have decided to run-home whereever that was, in another galaxy perhaps.

Maybe they were not destroyers-of-all but destroyers-of-the-weak and when we were able to stand up to them the returned home - to another galaxy - a more "mature" galaxy, ie older species.

who knows.
PCS2 2.0.3 | POF CS2 wiki page | Important PCS2 Threads | PCS2 Mantis

"The Mountains are calling, and I must go" - John Muir


Offline aldo_14

  • Gunnery Control
  • 213
I agree with a lot of that - albeit not the bits that contradict the Reci storline ;)

Oh, Kazan - what is written in the techrooms (which I think is your source-  correct me if i'm wrong) isn't necessarily true.  It's just the human / GTVA view.  So what GTVA scientists see as a node becoming more stable could actually be a rip or rift enlarging in subspace, like a screw through wood.

The Shivans scared-of-Sathanas thing i'm not too sure of.  Mainly because they would have been able to assess the technological capabilities of the entire GTVA in FS1, and would have probably had a decent idea of the amount of materials they had.  That's arguably more debatable, of course, but it's a thought.  We also don't know what they may have learned from Bosch.

My opinion has always been that the Shivans sealed up Capella as 'cautery' - to prevent fighting a war on several fronts.  Also, i think the shivans physical form and evolution in space is a direct result of them being forced to leave their home planet, rather than through choice.... ;7

If you’re working off the hive mind theory, it brings the fact that shivans do not experience fear, or a sense of preservation.

The damaging subspace thing is plausible, but unlikely. Subspace seems to be a natural element in the fs universe. Say subspace is the fabric that binds all space; the nodes are just temporary distortion between normal space, and subspace. Which can be used to spacecrafts advantage.

As for the destruction of the capela star, the shivans could have a different motive. The destruction caused the nodes to gamma draconis and connecting systems to be sealed off. If you look at the subspace node map u would see that they can’t go anywhere else other than there already know systems. The shivans may have fixed the problem of terrans spreading across the galaxy destroying any who appose them. It also forced terrans and vasudans to stop fighting each other and find peace.

Also as part of the mystery and intrigue of the shivans is that they are in no way human, they are beyond our understanding. .........and what is it with the human race'es desire to know everything.



Offline TrashMan

  • T-tower Avenger. srsly.
  • 213
  • God-Emperor of your kind!
    • Minecraft
1. Energy beings are not possible.. that's the stupides idea I ever seen (and one thing I rellay dislike about ST, alltough I like the series). How can energy be alive?

*Don't use batterys - you might kill a Shivan!*

2. If Shivans have engines that don't damage subspace, why don't they just help other races to develop them, rather than destroy them?
Nobody dies as a virgin - the life ****s us all!

You're a wrongularity from which no right can escape!


Offline Setekh

  • Jar of Clay
  • 215
    • Hard Light Productions

Indeed, welcome. To be sure, I agree with most of what you say, but I have a very different interpretation of the critical "a symptom of a bigger problem" statement. ;)
- Eddie Kent Woo, Setekh, Steak (of Steaks), AWACS. Seriously, just pick one.
HARD LIGHT PRODUCTIONS, now V3.0. Bringing Modders Together since January 2001.
THE HARD LIGHT ARRAY. Always makes you say wow.


Offline karajorma

  • King Louie - Jungle VIP
  • Administrator
  • 214
    • Karajorma's Freespace FAQ
Certainly an interesting document.

I wouldn't say that it's THE explaination of what the Shivans were up to but it is certainly AN explaination.

But just to make a few points

1. There is a good possibility that Bosch was interrogated after his capture. If he told the Shivans that the GTVA had a fleet of 200 Colossus Class Juggernauts waiting they may have believed him (They don't know the signs a human shows when he is lying after all).

2. Gamma Draconis is a very big star. It is infact bigger than Capella A & B put together. (Use the Internet Stellar Database next time if you want to check the details for a star. I'm sure it has all the real FS2 ones.)
Karajorma's Freespace FAQ. It's almost like asking me yourself.

[ Diaspora ] - [ Seeds Of Rebellion ] - [ Mind Games ]


Offline Gloriano

  • silver dracon
  • 210
  • Machina terra
You must have chaos within you to give birth to a dancing star.- Nietzsche

When in despair I remember that all through history the way of truth and love has always won; there have been tyrants and murderers, and for a time they can seem invincible, but in the end they always fall.- Mahatma Gandhi