Originally posted by karajorma
Birmingham is bigger but Manchester is more important to anyone in England apart from brummies so it probably would be Manchester.
Capital cities aren't always chosen just on size.
I live near Birmingham and I've been there plenty of times, great night life. Been to Manchester a fair few times too and I hate the place, just does not agree with me at all. I'm not particularly keen on Birmingham either though to be fair (apart from the aforementioned night life).
I think I have a problem with cities, I tend to notice that everybody seems to be really tense and uptight in a city and theres this feeling of unease that's always about. I guess city folk don't really notice it after a while though.