I remember that the Tomcat was quite popular. Something that the F-16 Falcon hasn't lived up to.
Wait,
what? The F-16
Viper (pilots are not fond of the 'Fighting Falcon' nickname) is one of the most popular fighters in the world, and far more popular than the F-14.
The Tomcat never sold nearly as many. Nor was it as powerful a platform for force projection; it was a specialized heavy fighter with expensive ordinance. It was very good at its job -- carrier defense and air superiority -- but not particularly versatile.
The F-16 is not really good for comparison to the F-14 anyway. One's a land-based multirole light fighter with fantastic maneuverability and ACM ability, the other's a carrier-based heavy fighter meant to haul missiles and go fast while attacking at BVR.